I cannot rate this place. We couldn't dine here. First, the one handicapped parking stall was blocked by the restaurants dumpster. We managed to nose our truck into the stall with a bit less room and walked around to the front entrance. Our disabled son has a service dog. She happens to be a standard Poodle that is clearly tagged, working-dog vested in hi-viz optic yellow with 'Service Dog' patches clearly worn and tethered to our son with a matching hi-viz short traffic lead. Imagine our surprise when walking into the restaurant we were told by the woman at the register that the dog was not allowed inside. We would have to put the dog outside on a hook. We politely countered, gesturing to the dog and explaining that as a service dog, she was legally allowed inside, to which the woman again stated that the dog would have to remain outside. On a hook... We chose rather than continue to waste time trying to get a seat or even place an order, to simply leave. We would spend our money elsewhere. FYI: California Vehicle Code - VEH § 22507.8 states that it is unlawful to block the access or use of the handicapped parking like that: https://codes.findlaw.com/ca/vehicle-code/veh-sect-22507-8/ And the ADA has clear direction about service animals and their permitted access in a restaurant setting: https://www.ada.gov/resources/service-animals-2010-requirements/ These are very real legal issues. And we feel that the staff member made a choice to discriminate against us. Rather than raise a complaint with Humboldt County, we just won't return to this place, nor will we recommend eating here. read more

Dutchy's Pizza - Handicapped stall blocked by the restaurants dumpster - Pizza Near Me - Arcata, California

Service was all good, nothing exceptional nor poor, I ordered for takeout. I got a large pepperoni and sausage on a cheese pizza; The bread/crust/dough was fine, about a 4-5/10. Not much flavor, texture was fine. Cheese was also okay, 5/10. Didn't stand out by any means but didn't taste inherently bad. Pepperoni and sausage was fine, 5/10. Definitely not great but not terrible. Overall very underwhelming, I'd prefer dominos for 1/3 the price, and definitely most other chains at the same price. Next day reheating via microwave after refrigeration; bread/dough was soggy, everything tasted similarly underwhelming but a bit more so. read more

Great pizza with a Mediterranean style. Fast service and super clean and friendly location.

Pizza was good, I liked the sauce and pepperoni a lot. Crust was meh. But order was ion time for pickup and price was very good for the size so I'd order from them again but partly because not a ton of options in Arcata. read more

This place has free street parking which usually isn't a problem. I love the pizza by the slice option, but I wish you could do pizza by the slice for any of the pizzas; it is limited to different pizzas each day and they don't post that anywhere online. Would be nice to know what by the slice options they have before going in. I have also found the people working there to be not be very friendly. But those things aside, the pizza is super good. It has thin crust but isn't too crispy or hard. Our favorite is the hot goat pizza. It is so so good - creamy, sweet, some spicy heat. It's an amazing pizza. read more

Dutchy's Pizza - Hot goat pizza (12 inch) - Pizza Near Me - Arcata, California

I love this place, I usually get the Trenton with added pepperoni and basil or the yeti. This has happened twice now where they've forgotten the basil, which is annoying since it costs $2..... they're not checking boxes before they get sent out? I always get takeout so I can't say much about ambience. read more

Dutchy's Pizza - Receipt showing I should have gotten basil - Pizza Near Me - Arcata, California

See all

So bomb, great local pizza. My current favorites are the Bigfoot and Hot Goat. Unique flavor combos and convenient location in the middle of town. I think they only offer take out currently, worth it. Pizza was so good I ate half of it before I could stop to take a photo read more

Dutchy's Pizza - Bigfoot Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Arcata, California

Good pizza! We had this doordashed and really enjoyed it. They have an unusually cool and eccentric menu for pizza!

Solid spot in Arcata! While staying in Arcata and exploring the area, we were always lookign for outdoor spots and ones that came recommended. I thought from the way one side of the building looked they should have more outdoor seating, but they just had two tables in front of the place. I hope more places can keep or expand their outdoor seating since the pandemic is stubbornly still here. The service was friendly - we ordered at the bar and then sat outside and they brought our pizzas out. I got a vegan pie and partner got a pizza w peppers and meat. Delicious and the vegan cheese was quite good. We enjoyed a sunny afternoon soaking up the rays with a brew and simple pizza - not really sure what else we needed! There was also a place to charge an e-vehicle nearby (we had a rental that happened to be electric hybrid) but it didn't get too charged during our hour or so there! read more

Dutchy's Pizza - Meat pizza on top; vegan on the bottom. - Pizza Near Me - Arcata, California

It was amazing good. When I looked at the photos people posted, I couldn't understand why the local pizza place has a good rating. However, since my kids love pizza and had been asking for the past few days, I didn't mind to give a try. The small restaurant offers local beers. The spinach salad caught my eyes as well, I ordered a 12 inches cheese pizza for my kids and 12 pieces buffalo wings I could snack. Ending up we finished all the food (yes, the 4 items I mentioned). plus 2 extra slices cheese pizza for my little ones after the 12 inches cheese pie. (Wow, they must like the cheese pizza super very much, and they are in their 4 and 6 years old, I was astonished). Food came out good, crust was perfect, dressing for spinach salad wasn't heavy at all, the pine beer during happy hours (4-5pm) was my reward after the whole day walking around the national park. If you are the tourist to Redwood National Park, I would recommend here. Just stop by with a big slice of pizza with a local beer, I bet the treat will make your day ends happily. read more

Yummo!!!!! I had the lamb kabab pizza. Outstanding!! The people i was with also loved their food.

We had just driven into Arcata and hungry but not sure what to eat. It was after 8pm and most places were already closed. Pizza was something we could agree on, so we ended up at Dutchy's. We pulled up to the storefront. It is nothing fancy and very much a pizza joint. The staff person greeted us and gave us a few minutes to browse the menu. We decided to go with a 12" Hot Goat. We sat on one of the two outdoor benches and waited about 10 minutes for the food to come out. Initially, I thought it might be too small, but since we were traveling, it was perfect to two adults (no leftovers). The flavors were tasty and you can definitely taste the honey. I probably could have done without the onion and might suggest subbing with garlic, but that's just me. I also found that the pizza suffered from a slight soggy bottom, so assistance from a fork was needed. Overall, I great experience for our short trip in Arcata! read more

Dutchy's Pizza - Hot goat - Pizza Near Me - Arcata, California

See all

Called ahead to order and was impressed with the order taker who was able to give me a pick up time to the minute. Good pizza at reasonable prices. Street parking can be challenging but I found many are in and out while picking up a pie to go, so I recommend circling the block once. read more

Stopped by on our way to Redwood National Park and got a pizza and a ceasar salad. The service was fast, everyone was very nice, our food was served in less than 10 minutes, which was great. The pizza was alright and the salad was really really delicious! read more

Dutchy's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Arcata, California

See all

This place is such a friendly neighborhood gem. Good priced brews, food and phenomenal Philly cheesesteak.

Awesome pizza!! Had the Yeti and it was delicious. The crust was thinner (not bulky) in the best way and it totally works with the pizza. Had just the right amount of crisp while also being chewy-super satisfying! The toppings were on-point, sauce was good and the pizza was really well baked. Fast, flawless order and nice staff. Would definitely order from here again! read more

Dutchy's Pizza - The Yeti - Pizza Near Me - Arcata, California

Incredible pizza, the crust was perfectly doughy as well as crisp. The wings were perfectly cooked & seasoned & the green salad was lush and so tasty. I'm just driving through, but have booked marked it for another trip! You're the best Dutchys! read more

Dutchy's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Arcata, California

See all

Great pizza, atmosphere and service with crazy low priced delicious pint options. The hot honey side is super good. Love this place.

Pizza was ready Fast and we received a warm welcome. Get the Goat- it's one of the best pizzas we've ever enjoyed.

Dutchy's pizza is my favorite pizza spot, but they have sold it to tandoori bites. They're closing in March, and I'm so bummed read more

Dutchy's Pizza - This is posted on Dutchy's window - Pizza Near Me - Arcata, California

Food ok, Service awful, Ambiance cold. Recommend career change for some staff. Won't be back.

Great pizza, decent service, waited way too long for our food to come out. We came here specifically for the Hot Goat pizza recommended by a co-worker. It's basically a cheese bread with goat cheese, ricotta, spinach, onions and some other stuff with a light honey drizzle on top. This pizza is as good as it sounds, not just hype. It took an hour for our food to come to our table after we placed our order. The cashier who took our order seemed to be in an irritated mood. There's television in the restaurant if you fancy sports. It's a clean restaurant with clean facilities, good for smaller groups. With the service and long wait time, I recommend ordering for pick up. Order the Hot Goat Pizza and pick up a bottle of your favorite white, you won't regret it. read more

Dutchy's Pizza - The hot goat - Pizza Near Me - Arcata, California

Nice place to get a slice of pizza and a salad. Quick and easy dinner, and friendly staff. Good sized house salad, nice to include black olives. The Margherita slice was good, as was the pepperoni one. read more

See all

When I first came here I had the hot goat which was amazing and probably the best thing they have. This time I made my own pizza and I was literally impressed by how thin the toppings were! I thought they forgot the sausage until the dood dug around to find it....I've never had to search for pizza toppings. I'm super curious how much sausage was actually used on my pizza. I ate one of the flakes solo, it was so thin it had the essence of salt (not even meat taste, not enough meat to taste). The best bite was the first bite on some slices because they made a small pile of like 6 flakes of sausage in the middle haha. The veggies were also thin sliced but had a decent amount of green bells, tons of olives, and a meh amount of thiiiin mushrooms. I legit thought the sausage flakes where just burnt cheese. I was the Assistant manager at Papa John's, way better pizza for half the cost. At PJs we don't put toppings in the small center of the pizza because it would be too heavy and cause them all to fall off. Here the toppings are so thin it doesn't matter, it would be impossible for it to be heavy enough to fall off. Like I said there was a pile of sausage flakes in the middle which was the best part. I would only come back for the Hot Goat, I make better pizzas for half the cost at home. Sad read more

Dutchy's Pizza - Literally a flake of sausage - Pizza Near Me - Arcata, California

UPDATE: I tried the Hot Goat pizza for the first time and it exceeded expectations! Warm, gooey, savory and slightly sweet. YUM! This is my new favorite type of pizza. read more

Dutchy's Pizza - Hot goat pizza - Pizza Near Me - Arcata, California

Very lively dining area. Lots of local decor as well. All food was hot and tasty. We finished all our food and left very full and satisfied. Great place read more

Excellent food , especially Pizza and friendly staff. A great spot to watch sports. A nice atmosphere and happy locals

BEST PIZZA IN TOWN. CHEAP BEER! Also, Jill is so delightful! We have been coming here for awhile and we are so happy to experience another great employee. The owners are great and community driven, we can talk with them for hours and come back the next day and talk some more.! It is exactly what I want and need from a local pizza joint. read more

I was delighted to find my kind of pizza in Arcata. The dining room was closed, so we got it to go to take back to our Airbnb. Friendly service at the pickup window...they even offered my dogs a treat. I'll be back for sure and use them if I need to order a pizza for my college kid. read more

Ordered The Yeti pizza and it was amazing! Probably best pizza we ever had. The side salad was a good size and definitely can share with someone else. We are from out of town and this place was recommended by Apple Maps for local pizza. Would highly recommend! You will not be disappointed. read more

One of the best pizzas I've had in a while. The crust was crispy and thin. Good amount of tomato sauce. The cheese melted perfectly. Nice edge crust with some garlic butter I think. A great pizza. I got a little flustered over the difference between a medium pizza and a 12-inch pizza. I learned there is no universal "small," "medium," "large" with pizza. A medium could be whatever-inch the restaurant makes it. My social skills have declined in the last decade and more rapidly in the last few years. Dutchy's has a 12-inch and then a larger size (18-inch?). It's great pizza. The staff are friendly and helpful. I got a half cheese and half pepperoni. read more

Dutchy's Pizza - half cheese and half pepperoni. 12 inch. Delicious. - Pizza Near Me - Arcata, California

See all

i go here a lot, when did the hours change? thought this was a great lunch spot but now it's not open till 3, and closes at 8:30? so it's not a late night spot either. love the food but not a fan of the new hours, very inconvenient read more

One of the worst pizzas I've ever had in my life. And I'm 63 years old. Whoever owns Dutchy's should be ashamed of themselves for charging $30.00 US for this garbage. Shame on you owner. We went here because it was ranked #1 on Yelp. If you are a connoisseur of good pizza, you won't like Dutchy's. BARF. read more

Dutchy's Pizza - Dutchy's $30.00 pizza - Pizza Near Me - Arcata, California

Cool little corner spot. Limited parking on street only. Pizza was pretty good. We ordered a combo and a cheese. The crust was crunchy. Topping were fresh. Price was reasonable and the service was good. No issues at all. read more

Nice atmosphere and delicious pizza. Especially the Hot Goat! It has goat cheese, ricotta, spinach and a drizzle of hot honey on top. I order that every time, now. read more

Stopped here for a quick bite to eat. Met the owner and he was a great guy. Gave us his recommendations. We did enjoy the food. The pizza was good and the crust was thin and light. Crispy as well. All in all we enjoyed the stop. read more

See all

Cool little corner drive up pizza shop, that can be packed during school sessions. Great pizza is why and the prices are good to cheap by comparison. They're Hot Goat with bacon is an awesome pie, loaded with goat cheese, hot honey and bacon and it's freakin great - if you like goat cheese and spicy sweet you'll like this one! They run lunch specials daily and it's always a good cheap meal. Also specials on pizzas every day, and now after 5 pm they will even deliver it to you within a certain distance, fortunately for me we're inside that circle! A great delivery service too we've called them a few times now and always delivered before promised time. The walk in dine in side opened not to long ago and now you can enjoy you pizza or slice right there. Good people with really tasty pizza and good service. 4 Stars a cool little corner pizza house 00510 read more

Pizza with a twist! Hot Goat for the win. Creamy goat cheese, spinach, honey drizzle, great crispy crust. The sign of a good pizza is how it tastes like the next day, and Dutchy's didn't disappoint. Pick up was easy and parking in back made for fast pick up. read more

Ordered on the phone, came to pick it up, was ready super fast, loved that they have a water bowl outside for the pups, and there was a very nice guy at the counter. The pizza itself though, wow so much oil. I couldn't eat more than about half a slice and my partner powered through at least three but then regretted it later and spent the evening suffering from it. Seemed really nice, hopefully we just came on the wrong night but I wouldn't want to try it again. read more

The way a pizza should be. Outstanding crust. Super, high quality toppings. Literally the best. read more