Looked at pics on Yelp before going here, but pics don't do this place justice. The buffet is homemade salads, meats, potatoes, etc. AND there's a dessert buffet!! I'd estimate a dozen pies, plus cakes and cookies (including sugar free desserts). Everything was fresh, made from scratch, and delicious. It's no-frills with a friendly staff. Best part (aside from the dessert buffet) was the man restocking glasses and helping in the kitchen. He seemed to thoroughly enjoy his work and smiled at everyone. We pass thru Chouteau randomly and will definitely make stopping here a priority. read more

It was the best stuff since sliced bread! Our first time. Everything was just as they state "Real ingredients. Real food." Meatloaf, mashed potatoes, yummy rolls, creamed corn, sauerkraut, fish, green beans, a salad bar and plenty of desserts! The sweet tea was just right. The had whole pies, loaves of bread, jars of honey, sorghum and many other things for sale too! Great find for us! read more

If you want home cooked comfort food in this area then you've arrived at the right place. It's all you can eat buffet style. Simple, basic & serve your self. Every time we are in this area, my husband stops to eat here. He loves it. Food: Plain, tasty and filling. Meats selections change daily, but there is always Ham. There are always basic daily sides to choose from, green beans, navy beans, mashed potatoes & gravy. To me the homemade rolls with fresh Amish butter is the star! There is a dessert bar filled with cakes & pies. Cookies and soft serve ice cream are also available. Service: Serve yourself buffet style. Restaurant was clean & tables were bussed. Decor: Basic. Tables & chairs only. read more

See all

We stopped in for breakfast and WOW what a nice home-cooked buffet! Fresh made everything and the nicest staff. This meal felt as if we were dining along side extended family. What a nice treat to fatten us up on our road trip back home. We even took home a home-made Pecan Pie! Sorry no pics, but you won't be disappointed - just for the biscuits alone! read more

Good home cooking type comfort food. Tonight it was meatloaf, catfish, mashed potatoes, green beans, cornbread, and lots more. Several different kinds of pie for dessert. Come hungry, leave happy. read more

The food is excellent! Good home cooked just the way my mom and grandma cooked!! Loved the chocolate pie.

We came from ca on a ride trip , and had to stop and see this place , we were skeptical at first since it was so small and a little buffet compared to what we're used to, but we were satisfied and felt overly full and the food was great , I loved the creamed corn and rolls, the desserts were great and the food was perfect for a small town home cooked feel .The food was always stocked and the workers were on top of the cleanliness.overall I would definitely give this place a 5 star review and say made are trip well worth it! read more

Buffet is outstanding. Employees very friendly. Variety, quality, quantity & price are top notch.

Outstanding little buffett! Everything was cooked/seasoned to perfection. The desserts are to die for! I'll be back and so will you, c'mon!

Awesomeness is all I can say great food Bring assistance as you will need it to waddle out to the car when your done. Lol read more

The food was excellent. It was homestyle family cooking. The fried chicken was really really good as was the lima beans. It was all Buffay style. They were quite a few selections to choose from for dessert. My favorite was the blackberry cobbler and ice cream. Service including greeting was stoic. The decor inside was bland. But overall, there was enough good food that I would come back in this area. read more

This review is for the breakfast my wife and I had this morning. It doesn't take too long to drive from Tulsa to Chouteau. The Dutch Pantry has been a favorite for a long time but this is the first time that we have eaten breakfast here. I can briefly sum it up. It's all really good. read more

Terrific. If you like homemade food, this is the place. All one price: meal, drink, salad, and dessert. It's how we cooked in the south in the good O' days, before fast food and eating healthy. My family loved it. The desserts are plenty and delicious. My favorite desserts are pecan pie and bread pudding. The bread pudding is one of the best I had even without rum sauce. You'll spend the same amount of money on fast food so do yourself a favor and try the Dutch Pantry. read more

This Amish based buffet has very good home style food. There are many salad selections. The veggies are like grandma used to make, especially the creamed corn. Entrees vary each day but are always good. Don't miss the dessert bar. Scrumptious desserts! Clean, neat, everything is self serve. Don't miss this gem! read more

This has been one of the best restaurants in the area for years. Their desserts are to die for

If your in the area & want a hearty meal, this is your kind of place. Amish staff is kind but reserved. If you come in for breakfast your first question is going to be "how many eggs this morning & how would you like them cooked?" The rest of the spread is serve yourself buffet style, even beverages. Cozy little place at a very reasonable price! read more

Stopped on the way through Oklahoma, where I'm from we have a lot of Amish, so the food was good as it is at home.

The inside of this place doesn't match the outside. It was very uncomfortable to sit inside. It felt more like sitting in an abandoned nursing home than a restaurant. Don't get me wrong, the servers are very friendly but the atmosphere is just awful and boring. The prices are also very high for the food. 35 dollars for 2 plates and the food wasn't good at all. No flavor in anything and most of the food was liquids and only one option for a meat that had no flavor. It isn't very sanitary either. I wanted to like this place but left disappointed... read more

The reviews are correct... You pay the adult price if you only eat one helping, but how is that different from any buffet? The green beans are chock full of bacon and onions and "cooked down", southern style. Every thing we ate was fantastic. My daughters raved about the meatloaf. I had bbq beef and fried fish. Old diner chairs and Formica topped tables are run down, but very clean. If you don't want food, it's worth it just for the dessert buffet. I'm not joking. The desserts are to die for. Don't expect gourmet anything, but it IS all artisan quality. Update: We stopped here again yesterday on our way through town. They closed two minutes after we got there (New Years Eve). Although they didn't put anything new on the buffet, they didn't make us feel rushed or hurried. An elderly couple came in a good 20 minutes later, she with a walker, he with a cane, and the workers helped them get their food from the buffets, served them drinks and were so very, genuinely kind. They never rushed any of us feel rushed or as if we were in their way. They quietly began cleaning and putting things away. read more

Great home cooking and plenty of desserts that are wonderful. All you can eat. The dessert bar is great, and sometimes I'm tempted to only skim through the main course and jump straight to the dessert bar. You can take some of the desserts home as well, as I enjoyed some of their peanut butter (crunchy type) cookies at home later. They have a different main course each day. (from their menu): Monday: Turkey and Dressing, Tuesday: Chicken Fried Steak, Wednesday: Fried Chicken, Thursday: Roast Beef, Friday: Catfish and Meatloaf, and Saturday: BBQ Pork Ribs & Fried Chicken. read more

What a jewel! The real home cooked comfort food! A lot of locals are gathered after hard day of work to enjoy delicious food buffet style and wonderful homemade pies, cobblers, cookies, brownies and cakes! What a paradise for a sweet tooth! read more

Five stars is unusual for a rating from me, especially since I'd give the food about 3.5. But the desert bar I'd have to rate between a 6 and 7. It truly is an amazing collection of homemade pies, cobblers, and bread pudding. Pies Included coconut, lemon, peach, blackberry, blueberry, pumpkin, and who knows what else. All made fresh with simple ingredients. I make my own coconut pie at home and had yet to find one that could match it. Most are just too overpoweringly sweet. This had just the right flaky and buttery crust, a not too deep layer of sweet coconut custard, and a nice topping of whipped cream. I picked up a blackberry pie to take home and look forward to making the trek back out. Just remember, take it easy on the food bar and save room for a few deserts! read more

This unassuming place just off the highway in a small Oklahoma town is a perfect find for people on a road trip or for Tulsans looking for something different. It is run by the Amish, so it is a low-tech, no frills, no decorations, totally basic type of restaurant. It is great, home-made country cooking, served buffet style out of steam tables with no effort made at all to dress them up or camouflage them. One look around at a restaurant full of locals and regulars will assure you that you are in the right place though. I should also mention that people come from miles around to buy their pies. They make a ton of different pies (3 different types of rhubarb pie alone). Before holidays you will have to order them days in advance. We got 3 of them last Thanksgiving on our way out of town and I saw a glimpse of their back room in which there were hundreds and hundreds of pies waiting to be picked up. The Amish do know their pie. read more

We were hungry and wanting something more than fast food on our trek from TX to WI. We swung into this place not knowing what to expect and were pleasantly surprised by their small breakfast buffet. Typical offerings and eggs cooked to order. I didn't love everything, I found the gravy for the biscuits to be very very sweet and the hashbrowns were of a very gooey, strange texture. BUT, overall the offerings were tasty. Good breakfast meats, nice little waffles, cottage cheese with a variety of toppings. Very friendly, basic dining atmosphere. This place is buffet only. You can also buy canned jams, pickles, honey, homemade pies, cookies and cakes. Everything looked delicious. read more

Very unassuming appearance inside and out. Food is not presented well, and LOOKS two levels below high-school-cafeteria. LOOKS. It actually tasted like a home cooked thanksgiving meal, like you'd expect at your parents' or grandma's house. Verdict: don't judge a meal by its appearance. This was actually quite good. Three stars mostly not for the food (which rated at least 4) but for looking so run down and forgotten that I almost turned around and left. read more

What a great find! The previous reviewer was right - very unassuming and functional dining area full of locals coming in from a morning of hunting or work. And very friendly too! The food is very fresh with a good selection for the salad bar. The entrees and sides apparently change from day to day and is always like simple good home cooking. Then there is the dessert buffet...what a selection! All that we sampled, pies and cobblers, were just made, not too sweet and full of flavor. We bought two to take to family for Christmas (and snicker doodles too). We were told the owners were going to renovate in the next week or so and a little freshening and updating would be nice. All in all, definitely worth a stop by. I've already recommended it to family who will be driving through in the future. read more

It's buffet but it's home cooked food like my mom made. Very good food. We were in Muskogee for six weeks and it's about twenty four miles away but well worth the drive read more

You can't beat this buffet style food. And the desserts, oh my! Good for the entire family!

The restaurant is very simple, the food is also simple, but extremely comforting. The quantity is basically and all you can eat, which is a dying way of doing business. I liked their sign at the start of the food line which reads something like this "take all you want that you can eat, and you can go back for more" shows a very frugal way of looking at life, but one that I grew up with. I recommend this place highly. read more

It was nice not what I expected but still worth the trip. Various items and so much candy, nuts and cheeses

I have been going here to eat for over 10 years, but not as good now. I found unfixed flour in my gravy last weekend. The Chicken was not as good nor replace quick enough. I was very disappointed. read more

The best restaurant in Oklahoma. The people are great, the food is out of this world good. Cannot find better comfort food anywhere.

Luckily I stopped in this town on my way to Arkansas what a special delight if you want fancy and pretentious do not stop here if you want great home cooked food good selection great prices please don't miss this stop its delightful you can slow down and enjoy the country and the wonderful food that they cook don't hesitate to go there if I lived closer I would make it at least a once a week regular Susan read more

We ordered cinnamon rolls for a special event. I picked them up and had the opportunity to peruse the store. It has a wonderful selection. The food in the restaurant was amazing. Now the cinnamon rolls were heavenly. They were light and delicious. Even after a week they were yummy. I will definitely be back to the Dutch Pantry. read more

I eat here fairly frequently and was very disappointed this time! Fish was cold, beans were from a can and mashed potatoes were from a box! I asked the cashier if the restaurant had new owners and he said same owners. I probably won't eat there again! read more

Its a little pricey, but if you want something that feels like great-grandmas all you can eat home cooking... whoa boy!

If you're looking for a small, home cooked buffet, this is your place. Was expecting more options in their buffet (not a whole lot of sides/meat). The food was ok; however it was fresh. My favorite part about the restaurant was their desert bar. The desert choice was endless and was so delicious. Additionally, what's really neat about the restaurant is the baked goods and jams. You can grab some freshly baked bread, pies or jams to enjoy at home. read more

Great food..the best food I've ever had in Oklahoma by far..traditional amish food..I've had the opportunity too live in amish country..milersberg ohio too be exact...this food is side by side in comparison..great experience, friendly people...life is short, dont cheat yourself...treat yourself..worth the drive.. read more

Oh holy balls this place is amazing! It is the definition of comfort food!!!! This is not the place to go if you're on a strict diet...or any diet at all. Fried chicken, mashed potatoes and gravy and some wonderful green beans are just some of the wonderful unhealthy things they serve at this buffet! And let me just tell you a little something about their dessert table...it...is...amazing!!!! Everything is homemade and so full of fat and sugar it will have you crying in the gym for weeks afterwards panting the words "worth it!" While slowly passing out on the stair climber! I give this place two fat thumbs up! read more

The best homemade food I've maybe ever experienced. We make this a stop every trip through Oklahoma!