Very busy even on a Monday. Go early or expect to wait, but if you are not in a rush, it is worth…read moreit. The service is very friendly and accommodating. The setting is casual and the food is excellent! Fresh and well made and with many menu options. A must stop in the east end!

Went to try a hot lobster roll and also sampled the calamari. The calamari was perfect - crispy,…read morenot too heavy of a batter, well salted, and piping hot. The tartar sauce and marinara paired well too. The lobster meat was chunked rather than shredded (which I prefer) and really piled on generously. It was disappointed that the meat was super dry and not tender. Kind of disappointing for a $36 lobster roll when you expect the chunks to melt in your mouth and be succulent. We did ask for a side of butter to dip the pieces in and it did improve it slightly. I needed to also salt the meat since it was cooked in unsalted butter. Bun was a tad too toasted but otherwise held up well and was both crispy and fluffy. Side of fries were well crisped and salted. Service was great - our waitress was attentive and quick to address our needs while managing a very busy bar. Food came out fast. Had no wait when opting to sit at the bar (2 people) though a table wait would have been about 15 minutes.

Food was amazing as always, service and ambiance impeccable. Bostwicks is always a guaranteed…read moreawesome dinner!

Fran and Susan are the best bartenders you could ever want! This place is right on the water and…read morehas amazing sunset views but they don't take reservations so make sure to get here early. They always have changing specials and fresh seafood. They did open up a new location and that menu is a little bit different. We ended up doing the macadamia crusted halibut and the sauce that it came in will live rent free in my head forever! The parking is an open rock lot so sometimes it is full and it expands into the road on the harbor.

It was fabulous! We got 2 lobster dinners 2 lb each. It came everything! And it was delicious…read more All of the fish looked awesome. We will be back for sure.

The Hamptons are a challenging place to run a business. Seasonal, workers shortages etc . This…read morestore was run so well for a long , long time. Now it has lost its charm and sense of what good quality is. I don't know who bought it but it is no longer clean and delivering what a high quality fish store could. The service is below past standard and just the presentation is less appealing. Please up your game. I miss the old Stuart's.

Still one of my Hamptons favorites. Classy atmosphere and still feels "under the radar"…read moreconsidering this is a historic venue. Food always has a very fresh farm to table vibe.

One of the worst dining experiences I have ever had…read more My partner became ill and was unable to join me for dinner. We called the restaurant to either move our reservation to another day or cancel it, and were told that only the manager could assist us. However, we were told the manager was unavailable because he was busy speaking with regulars at a table. I asked if we could simply be placed on hold until he was available so we could find a solution. We were told no. Instead, the employee said they would "leave a note" and that someone would call us back if they were able to help. Meanwhile, we were told that if the reservation was canceled, we would be charged a $135 cancellation fee -- despite the fact that we were actively trying to work with the restaurant to either reschedule or resolve the situation. The experience became even more unacceptable when the employee eventually hung up on us and then stopped answering our calls. The restaurant only answered after American Express contacted them on our behalf. To be clear, I have no issue with a restaurant having a cancellation policy. What I have an issue with is the way this situation was handled: being told the manager was "too busy" to speak with us, being refused the simple courtesy of being placed on hold, having our calls screened, and ultimately being hung up on. That is an embarrassing level of customer service for an establishment of this caliber. I genuinely hope someone in management -- above the person working the restaurant that evening -- takes this seriously and addresses this behavior. A cancellation policy is one thing; treating a customer with this level of disrespect is another.

Every thing we ate was incredible. The food was great. Ambience perfect. Everyone friendly and…read moreeverything on time. Highly recommended.

This place makes some top tier sauce! I won some of their sauce in a raffle and had a $100 gift…read morecertificate to try them. I was trying to find a way to go there without having to drive so far just for food. I live an hour away from them, so the travel time is what makes going there a deal breaker consistently. It's worth going to East Hampton generally, but it should be a day thing. Not just to go eat. The person who helped us was very knowledgable and asked good questions in terms of what you'd like for your platter. The food was top quality. Our platters were worth every bit of that gift certificate and I'd love to come around this place again! I also had to buy their sauce on the way back home because we use it for some dinners. My only critiques is regarding the mac and cheese. I wish it was more of a homemade baked mac and cheese with the toasted top. But definitely good mac and cheese nonetheless. The mashed sweet potatoes were definitely too seasoned with all spice. It gave it too much of a kick than I was expecting. I liked the seating inside and outside. If we didn't have bad allergies, would've probably sat outside and enjoyed our meal. Also, this place has their own parking area. So that's definitely a plus!

Single best fish market experience I've ever had. Birthday tequila shots with the owner while our…read moreoysters were prepared. Anyone who doesn't appreciate that kind of service is likely a chode and sucks the life out of whatever room they enter. Scallop ceviche was fantastic and the oysters were super fresh and a few were down right huge!

Great food; Great owner! Our favourite place for seafood. Amazing lobster salad, scallop ceviche,…read moresea bass and blue fish paté!

We came here with my in laws during a recent trip over the summer and had a blast! We were able to…read morefinagle a 6:45pm reservation which was perfect. Our server was a lovely woman who chatted up the table and had everyone feeling welcome. Service was efficient and very kind. We ordered the biscuits to share and the spinach and artichoke dip. Husband, FIL, and I had the burger and my MIL ordered the French dip. Fries were great, wine list and drinks were delicious. I loved when they refreshed our martini glass. Burger was huge and delicious, MIL raved about her french dip and they sent over the ribs complimentary because our server was adamant we try them! They were actually so delicious and better than the burger I think! Vibe is great, felt like an updated country club and it seemed like the patrons were friendly with each other/knew who was dining /got up and chatted with friends which made for a lovely atmosphere. Would definitely be back, this Hillstone location is a win!

We went here for the first time, and unfortunately, it wasn't a great experience. First of all,…read moreparking was a nightmare, and it took us quite a while to find a spot. We were a group of four, but there were no tables available when we arrived. We were initially told to sit at the bar, then another person came and told us that a table was available, only to come back and say there was no table after all. In the end, they separated us into two groups and had us sit at different sections of the bar. I ordered the chicken sandwich and asked for coleslaw on the side, but I received fries instead. I didn't bother sending it back and just ate the meal. The sandwich was decent, but it wasn't anything special. The chips and spinach dip, however, were very good. The waiter was nice and seemed to be working hard the entire time. Overall, I don't think I'll be coming back to this restaurant.

So I needed a 4lb salmon to make gravlax and The Seafood Shop was amazing. We picked out the lucky…read moresalmon, I examined it closely, it was fresh and organic and a good price. The young man who trimmed it gave me a piece exactly 4lbs and packaged it in a heavy duty disposable tray that I will be able to cook in and throw away. So, in summation: service treats you like a valued new friend; checkout staff are knowledgeable and helpful; store doesn't smell of seafood, truly a testament to the freshness of their products. It is a sham that they have removed the fresh vegetables from the store, but I understand. In addition, all customers were given a big slice of their homemade jalapeño cheese cornbread. Not to be missed. I'll be back.

Absolutely terrible customer service. They did not pick up the phone, hung up once we finally…read moreestablished contact, and failed to meet a delivery time by 3 hours.

We walked in at 845. No one was there, they close at 900. The place was empty and the woman said…read morethey were closing. I asked if they would mine giving us an espresso. The woman at the counter said no problem. When I asked how much she said it is on us. The next day we went back for breakfast. It was great. My wife got eggs Benedict and I had a fried egg sandwich. The food was great the service was awesome.

FIX YOUR TAP WATER PLEASE!…read more It tastes like metal and sewage. God how have they not fixed this by now.

The prepared foods are absolutely delicious! I only wish I got there earlier to have more choices!…read moreWill visit again for sure

Overrated to say the least. I was so excited to stop by Round Swamp Farm with the number of…read moreinfluencers that fave about it. I tried the chicken salad and it was honestly pretty bland. My friend had the turkey sandwich and it was nothing special. Someone else had an Asian chicken salad which they said was pretty flavorful. We all split the chicken tenders and I will just say- not worth the price. The workers were great and I loved the vibes of the place. A lot of great options for prepared foods. Overall just did not live up to my expectations!