Kinda surprised by the reviews for this location! I've been going to this one for about 6 years, the drive through pickup window is unmatched. But my pizzas are always perfect and I've never encountered anyone rude. And we order pretty often. Every once in a while, I'll have to wait a minute or two at the window, but I order well done bake so it's to be expected read more

Only one person there. I did my order on line but was not ready. So had to wait for the wings to be cooked. Clerk was friendly and did apologize for the delay. Very tasty and tender. Will try them again. read more

Donatos Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Amelia, Ohio

See all

This location does not honor Donatos pricing or coupons. Even after showing the website price and email conformation price, I was told I would need to pay the full menu price for the pizzas. read more

Donatos Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Amelia, Ohio

See all

07.23.2022 Second time in one week we've tried to dine here. Placed an order, Lg Hand Tossed Cut in squares and a salad. Seems simple enough..: First time, on Tuesday, it was cut incorrect and we left. Tonite, I'm here, placed the order as stated above. When the order is being handed to me, she states that it's in squares... guess what; ITS NOT! Why don't people listen?? Is it really this hard? People have a choice how and where they spend their money! Donato's used to be better than LaRosas's, now I'm not so sure. #DOBETTER read more

Chain pizza with franchise shipped frozen disc crust. They are generous with toppings and cheese but the sauce is nothing special. Customer service was good and the friendly service exceeded the food quality. read more

See all

Two stars because they make edible food. Do not let the two-stars deter you from eating at ANY other Donatos. This review is based on the Amelia location only. Full-disclosure: I worked for Donatos in HS and again in college. We've ordered from here at least an average of once per month since we relocated June of '18. Everytime we've ordered a pie, I request "thick" or "sweet" sauce. It's a lot more robust, thicker, and sweeter. It's just an all-around better tasting sauce. The thicker sauce truly adds a different dimension in the flavor department. There has been no less than 10x where our food has arrived with the thinner sauce. And sadly, after you've experienced the thick sauce, you will never want anything else. Additionally, you'll be disappointed on how truly bad the thin sauce is. To their credit, they've at least offered to remake our orders every time. This issue with that is, instead of having a proper amount of food, we then have double, and a lot of it goes to waste. I cannot for the life of me understand how our orders get messed up, every time. The lone exception is when I placed a delivery order and then called the store to verify they would use the proper sauce. Today, however, I called an order in and specified "thick" sauce, and it was STILL wrong! Bottom line is this store needs a major overhaul from the ground up. Steer clear of this location. read more

Donatos Pizza - Classic trio...edge to edge toppings, kinda. - Pizza Near Me - Amelia, Ohio

Reduced to carry out in these pandemic times. I ended up at Donatos on an unseasonably warm Saturday evening. Ordered a split cheese and pepperoni pizza and an order of barbecue wings. The pizza was typical Donatos...wall to wall pepperoni and decent cheese pizza. Nothing wrong here. Donatos is decent carry out pizza. The problem was the nasty wings. Heavy breading and equally heavy barbecue sauce couldn't hide the lack of meat. What little I found I gave to Jenks, our dog. Yuck. Avoid these like covid 19. All in all an all too typical fast food carry out experience. No problem here. There's a decent Larosa's around the corner. read more

Pizza was on time but cold . Don't think we will do that again. But we did because it is so good. The next one was hot so the odds are you are going to get a bad one occasionally. read more

I went to the store to get some explanation as to why my coupon wasn't working. I spoke with Tracy, a manager at this location, who informed me that there's nothing she can do she doesn't have time. She states she's not able to honor that coupon you'll have to do it online. I then told her I won't be back because I don't have time to waste an hour of my day trying to figure out their website. She decides to get an attitude with me slamming things telling me that basically she's not gonna be cussed at, when I never cussed at her personally. On top of that she's threw my food through the window at me, and slammed the window in my face. I get home with my food only to discover my pizza, my shareable meatballs, and bread sticks are undercooked/cold. My autistic son witnessed the whole thing. I decided to call the manager of the store, Mike. the next day to tell him about how his employee treated me. He stated to me he had already spoken to all the employees that worked last night and the district manager. The only thing he can offer me is an apology. He actually stated the only thing he can offer me is an apology which isn't an apology at all. I told him I will never be step foot in his business ever again. He basically acted like he could care less. So I will be contacting corporate and the district manager personally to tell them this store. I don't believe this manager did speak to anyone. I would like this investigate further. I will also be reporting this location to the food and health board due to them serving me undercooked food, which we didn't even attempt to eat. I would never recommend visiting this location for fear you may experience the same thing I did. Sincerely Dissatisfied, Joey D. read more

We love Donatos pizza, but this location is HORRIBLE. Our orders are NEVER, ever ready on time. We ALWAYS have to wait 30-60 minutes beyond the promised time to get our food. It's ridiculous. Not sure if it's a staffing issue or what. We live about 5 minutes from this location, but we'd rather drive 30 minutes to a different location instead... it's faster! Employees offer no explanation or apology or anything. After three tries, we are done. We will not be giving this location our business anymore. read more

Yea they lie and steal. I ordered a pizza and a 2 liter. It was for delivery so I received the pizza but no 2 liter. So I called the store and was told I could come get it or nothing. In my book that's theft by deception. They should have credited back my card but no they take my money give me no product. They are worthless. read more

Placed order told it would be 50 minutes. 90 min later called and was told it would be another 20 min before it would get here. If I had been told it was a 2 hour wait I would not have ordered. read more

Saturday night...one delivery driver on the weekend before the 4th of July. Pizza arrived cold. Normally I would just call and complain but the that poor delivery driver would be over worked. My pizza was 40 mins past the time window. I had tipped online but think about people who don't because of late deliveries! They will take it out on the worker for orders being late. Staff up on weekends if you can. Haven't ordered pizza in a while for delivery. I did end up calling and the manager gave me a credit because I didn't want a replacement or to stress out the driver. UPDATE! I'm giving 4 stars because the manager Steven/ Stephen (I dont know the spelling because I called) was EXTREMELY professional!!!! My pizza arrived cold and outside of the delivery window and he gave me an immediate credit and was very understanding. Give this manager a promotion and a raise! I can imagine calls like this to be very frustrating. This manager was a model employee and is by far the type of employee I would want to represent my business! Excellent management. Please make sure you are giving this manager the credit he deserves. I've never had such an easy resolution to a customer service issue. read more

It has been a few years since I been able to get food here. They did. It have it where I moved down south. So I really wanted to have there pizza and garlic cheese bread along with pizza from here. Ordered it online and everything was burnt. The thin crust wasn't bad but they remade the two items. The bread was plain chees they other way to much cheese. A half pep and chees pizza with more cheese then anything. Was told that I might have to wait for tossed crust pizza because it might be frozen. Thankfully it wasn't. The manager Erica kept making excuses saying it's one of those nights where nothing right. Did not seem that way the fifteen minutes I waited for them to remake things menwhile my other pizza got cold even after being under a light to try and keep it warm. Also they looked at my food did not tuck it but opened it up with no gloves to protect my food. While raining many of the employees where eating back there, droning around the food as it came out, playing on their phones and one with a Bluetooth earbud or air-pod In her ear. I do t mind having fun at work. But this was a little much. No one took it seriously about all the food that was coming out. Many just running around. So giving me an excuse that nothing is going right when I'm clearly their watching all this going on was not a valid excuse. Avoid this location because it still was a little burnt around the edges and my son who lives pizza would touch it. Thanks for easing $41 and change. Could have gotten better foo, faster service and more for my money at dominoes. read more

I understand there are issues with items not being available but, don't use that as an excuse to screw people over. You put tomatoes on my pizza but can't put them on my sub, which was over-cooked and drowning in Italian dressing. The girl even told me she gave me a 10% discount and that was a lie. read more

Placed an order for delivery. order arrived on time. However, one of the salads we ordered was missing! Delivery driver said he was Door Dash - not affiliated with the store & couldn't help. My wife has contacted the store twice. She was told both time her CC would be credited. It still hasn't happened. She will be going into the store in person. Last time ordering from this place. Buyer beware! read more

Horrible. If you have any other option, do NOT waste your money here. I have had the misfortune of dining here. I gave the Donatos corporate website a complaint and after a couple weeks finally got a response and got a credit for a brick street bread which is the item that was completely horrible. First of all, I arrived about 45 minutes before they closed and all the lights were off and no one was anywhere to be seen. The donatos light was off, the dining room lights, the open late sign. Everything. After paying for my order they decided to put my food in the oven, which was the time my food was supposed to be ready, ok, so I patiently wait for it. I get the food 15 minutes later and it is completely raw. And the guy who took it out of the oven knew it was, he went to pull it out, then pushed it back in for another second, then decided to just put it in the box and give it to me. I didn't look at it until I got home at which point they were closed. I paid over $16 for a pizza and brick street bread. You do realize I could go to LaRosa's which is RIGHT NEXT DOOR and get better quality food for less money. I am attaching photos to this location so you can see for yourself Do not go here. Save your money. Go to any other pizza place and have a better experience. read more

Donatos Pizza - The inside of the bread, completely raw dough. Unless you want food you can't eat, like this, do not eat here. - Pizza Near Me - Amelia, Ohio

See all

I was not please with there food I ordered a calzone it was the worst calzone that I ever had also the chicken wing bites were not what I had ordered as well for 35 dollars on Uber eats it was not worth the money or time I would never order from this place ever if I could give a half star I would read more

I ordered pizza from this location tonight. When it arrived it was smashed and stuck to the lid. Not a little like 50% of the pizza was stuck to the lid of the pizza. Not the way you want your pizza....come on guys.....this will be the last time I order from this location. read more

Donatos Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Amelia, Ohio

I've had food from here twice. First time was perfect. This time was nearly perfect, tho I did order extra sauce and I'm sure it wasn't extra because the sauce was barely covering the pizza. They were quick tho and quality was decent. Loose a star for the lack of sauce tho. read more

Donatos Pizza - Donatos pizza box Amelia Ohio, were I ordered. - Pizza Near Me - Amelia, Ohio

See all

Ordered at 5:46 told 20 min got there@ 6:06 & into the drive thru and sat for 4 minutes, 4 workers walked past the drive thru and NO ONE acknowledged us AT ALL. Had to pull out of the drive thru and go inside and was met with attitude from the workers. IF YOUR GONING TO HAVE A DRIVE THRU ON YOUR BUSINESS FOR CONVENIENCE, WORK THE DRIVE THRU!!! I will NOT be back or reccomend this location to any of my people. read more

I live 5 minutes from this location. I get an email at 7:30 that my order had left the building. I call the store at 7:50. While on the phone I get a call from the delivery guy who "got a flat tire". Ok I get it that happens. But why wait 15 minutes to call your manager to tell them what happen. Then they had the nerve to try and bring my order that would not have been fresh. The driver was rude so I called the store back and told them to refund me my 30+ dollars and cancel my order read more

Don't go to this Donatos worst service ever, will not have your food ready , this is my third time to be disappointed. Promised at 7:04 was not even in the oven. I hope this place go out business. read more

I ordered pizza at 5:45 today p.m. and asked that it be ready by 7:15 PM to be picked up. I just left it's now 745 and I had to wait for my order. I'm confused on why it took two hours to make pizzas when it was ordered two hours ago. They are either severely understaffed or severely unqualified or even a combination of both. Unless you have a lot extra time to spare I would avoid this place and go somewhere else. read more

I gave two stars, only because the pizza is outstanding. However, this is not to be confused with the customer service. At least acknowledge me at the front desk, rather than ignore for 10 minutes. read more

You can't go wrong for a pizza this good for around $10. The thin crust with what seems to be a couple hundred pepperonis on it, is an amazing choice. My wife and I find ourselves going to this location when we are on the east side of town and we haven't been disappointed yet! read more

Donatos Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Amelia, Ohio

Placed an online order tonight. Was supposed to be an hour wait. Received a confirmation email stating my order would arrive at 7:47 pm. The store closed at 9:00. No pizza and no notification. So glad I didn't pre-pay on my card. If they can't fulfill orders then they need say so. read more

Ordered online, they used DoorDash. I ordered at 5:15 at 7:30 I had called 6xs with no answer and disconnected at 10 minutes each call. 7:40 DoorDash calls thinking I'm the store wanting to know why the door is locked. Now I can't even get my money back since I paid online and no one answers the phone and no F%#*ing pizza either! read more

Not sure how this location manages to make their crust undercooked and chewy every single time. It's think crust! How hard is it? Also, how hard is it to make the cuts go all the way through said thin crust? You have one job! Jeez! read more

Donatos Pizza - They never, ever make the cuts go all the way through the crust. Resulting in a mess of a pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Amelia, Ohio

See all

Very bad service, and they lock the front door so you have to go through the drive-through. The drive-through is a complete mess and you have to wait behind people who showed up after you if they don't have your pizzas ready. I'll probably never get pizza from here again. read more

Was told that our pizza would arrive 30-40 minutes never arrived after an hour and a half. I called multiple times while home to ask about where our pizza was, no answer. I drove up to find that the store is drive thru only. So while in line I called the store again and asked a male employee how we had ordered a pizza and it was an hour and a half late, and he answered sarcastically, "Yeeeaahhh?..." I said, "I am waiting in the drive thru line and I was wondering if you could bring out our pizza and give us a refund?" The employee responded with " We'll see you when you get here." and hung up on me before I could answer. After addressing another employee at the window, he told me that our pizza had just been sent out for delivery. I still asked for a refund, to which he agreed to. After a few minutes he says that the driver didn't give him a copy of the receipt to do the refund so we had to wait more for the driver to come back to complete the refund. Probably will never order from here again. read more

Horrible service made a $35 order pre coupons for pick up. When I arrived they refused to take 2 coupons even though this was stated when ordering. That aside the manager Mike? had a definite attitude so we politely let them keep thier food over the extra $2 discount. Mike you win but Donatos definitely lost. read more

I ordered a large pizza, a asiago cheese bread and a cinnamon bread. I live about 25 minutes from the restaurant, I found all of my products burnt on th bottom. I called and spoke to the manager and she said she would give me credit for the entire $28.00 order. That was at the end of January. I called to get my replacement order, and even though the manager I spoke to knew when I ordered, and that it was my first time ordering, she had no credit on file, and seemed more interested in the name of the manager then my order. I used to live in Florence , my and enjoyed the Donotos there, I will never use this place again. She had no interest in my situation read more

This place is run terrible. Ordered a pizza and 30 min after it was supposed to be ready they said they didn't know when it would be ready. Bad management. read more

We will never order pizza from here again. We ordered online and paid in full from the app for delivery. We were promised our pizza delivery at 7:40 pm. After 3 phone calls we continued to be told that they were really busy and and didn't have enough drivers. We eventually drove there picked up our cold pizza at 8:45. No one cared one bit about the terrible service they provided. They gave us a 10% discount. Not even close to doing the right thing. They lost our business. read more

My only complaint is they don't deliver to my home area or my work area, otherwise I'd order more often. Love the founders favorite. Love the subs. Coupons are usually available online to save a few bucks. It's ready when they say. read more

Worst run pizza place EVER. I would never write this but my experience is the same every time I order pizza here. It took over an hour and a half for my pizza to arrive. They told me 45 mins. to an hour when I called, which was horrible to begin with. Whoever runs this does a horrible job. This kind of delivery time has been going on forever too! One time, for a couple days, they just quit answering their phone during business hours. I'm sure Larosas gets even busier than here, and their delivery is never like this. read more

Me and my family ordered a hot chicken pizza at 7:20 the thing said that it will be here at 7:45, it is now 8:30 and they still aren't here. We've called and called but they kept putting us on hold and the longest we were put on hold was about 10 to 15 mins so don't order from here if ur gonna get anything... Pick it up in person read more

Very slow service, service with a serious attitude. Really they should just close this place down. It's not that hard people.

Some of the worst pizza in the amelia area late and cold and they don't care when you tell them about it.