Food was good - not great this time. Great service. That's why the 4th star. This was my first time at this location. I had dinner here with my daughter recently and I was a little disappointed this time. My daughter got the House side salad and I got the Candied Walnut Grape. Unfortunately, my salad had a ton of black pepper in it. I love black pepper so it was a lot for it to be overwhelming for me. I'm familiar with the salad, as I order it every time I eat at Dewey's. I have no idea why this salad had been doused in black pepper. We order a large pizza (wanting to have leftovers to take home). We did half Ryan's Inferno and the other half was Socrate's Revenge. The Ryan's Inferno side was a bit dry and had several dry dough bubbles. The Socrate's Revenge side was much better. The service was great, as usual at most Dewey's. Also, they have both types of high chairs - the wooden type for upright sitting and the sling type for car seats. read more

See all

When you say pick up at 5:27 and Don't have the pizza ready at 5:47 that's a problem. I went in to pick it up and they said that it would be out in 5 minutes, 20 minutes ago. Top notch customer service right there! Cherry on top it was cold when it came out. read more

Ordered to take home. $25.00 for what ?? Verry bad. Shocked. Really!!! Usually eat in so no worries. I thought.... Pizza was out to the car rapidly!!! Opened at home. Paper thin. No sauce no nothing. Comparing to how it was in the past. Don't know what to say except Won't go to that location ever again And they should be ashamed!! read more

I haven't had Dewey's in a while but they got my attention with the Skyline Dip pizza. Sadly this thing barely had anything on it except an abundance of onion. Super thin layer of cheese with some parts of the pizza cheese/less. Couldn't taste or see the chili dip. It had a few beans and maybe 7 small diced tomatoes. What a waste of money. read more

We received a gift card for Door dash from a neighbor and decided to use it tonight. I've heard great things about Dewey's as we just moved to the area. We were going to order two different pizzas because I'm vegetarian but it would have come to almost $60. So we chose calzones instead. They were awful! Flat, chewy, greasy, hardly any toppings inside and sauce was way too spicy. It's a hard never again. read more

Great food and service. The Caprice pizza was fresh, hot, and felt healthy to eat. Not overly greasy or laden with cheese. The Salads and Helles Beers were great as well. Would definitely swing by if I am in Cincy again. Worth the visit. read more

See all

It's been awhile since I've had Dewey's Pizza. I'm a huge fan and used to go to the Oakley location. Since we moved, the Anderson Township is closer to us. There's a slight change in the menu. I was bummed that they no longer have the wild mushroom. That was my fave. But I was able to try something new. But for the most part, they kept it the same. Especially their salads! They are all so good and my fave is the peppercorn ranch. We dined in on a Saturday night. It was only a 15 minute wait. We ordered: -Peppercorn Ranch salad: Romaine, bacon, tomatoes, shaved parmesan, red onions, peppercorn ranch dressing -Half and Half 17" pizza: Caprice Olive oil, minced garlic, fontina, fresh basil, fresh mozzarella, roasted cherry tomatoes. Dr Dre: Olive oil, mozzarella, green bell peppers, red onions, all-natural chicken, bacon, house-pickled jalapeños, with tomatoes and ranch added after the bake) Drinks: Great Lakes Eliot Ness Caparzo Sangiovese Everthing was perfect! The salad tasted epic since I last had it 7 years ago. The crust on my pizza was amazing! Fresh tomatoes, cheese well balanced and you can taste that garlic! My only complaint was not enough basil (smiley face). My Mr. loved his pizza. We had leftovers but that's quite alright. And our drinks paired so well with the meals! Service was great and restaurant was definitely clean. What a great experience and a I'll return for sure. Dewey's never disappoints! read more

See all

We love Dewey's pizza, specialty pizzas. We always loved coming here when our daughter was little and watching them make pizzas through the windows. They would always put on a show for the kids. It's kind of small so I'm busy nights. It's a little bit hard to get in, but the pizza is worth the wait. read more

Dewey's Pizza - Anderson - Pizza Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

See all

Pizza was really bad. We split the veggie pizza. Tomatoes were unripe. They were red, but hard as a rock. It had no taste at all! They went downhill. read more

Ordered a side salad and a calzone via DoorDash. The salad was fine but the calzone was inedible. I cut it open and a ton of liquid poured out. Maybe the mushrooms? The bottom was completely gooey and gross. Pepperoni tasted suspiciously like sausage..... so disappointed bc everything I've had to date from Dewey's was delicious. read more

I'm surprised it's taken me this long to check out this location in Anderson Township. I know this area very well and it has a lot to offer. Plus I usually enjoy Dewey's anytime I've gone and this visit is no exception. Great service and excellent pizza that anyone enjoy. I talked my boss and co-worker into going, and of course, it didn't take too much persuasion for them to say yes. Who says no to pizza, right? It wasn't too busy for a noon lunch. The inside looks just like you expect for a Dewey's, about the same as other locations, featuring the usual menu of salads and pizzas. I still like how they keep the kitchen visible via windows. One of the cooks was entertaining some kids by tossing the dough and playing up to them. They really liked it. As for us, we decided to do a 1/2 and 1/2 pizza, half killer veggie and half Don Corleone. We definitely didn't wait long at all before the pizza was ready. The combination turned out really good too. I was a big fan of the veggie especially with the fresh tomatoes after added after the pizza was cooked. We were all satisfied by what we got and by the service. I can't say Dewey's is the best pizza ever, but I can absolutely say they are consistently good. You get a great deal for the money, quality pizza and salads, and really good service. Dewey's does it good! read more

See all

Put in an order online and sent my husband to pick up. Online ordering wasn't working well for me at the time, finally went through and never gave a time for pick up. Sent my husband to pick up and he had to wait for over 45 for our calzone. He finally got home with the calzone and it was very MID. Barely filled with anything! We hadn't been here in awhile due to poor customer service last time we dined in. We just won't be back. So sad Dewey's used to be so good, I think this location has some issues that need to be worked out at an owner level. read more

We have enjoyed Dewey's pizza many times. However last night we didn't. Our pizza was undercooked with very little cheese and generally not good. Very sorry to have to report this because this was not our typical experience. read more

We have always enjoyed the pizza at Dewey's Pizza. We usually split the pizza and order our favorite for our side. All of the salads are fresh and very tasty. read more

Dewey's Pizza - Anderson - House salad - Pizza Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

Great unique pizzas with fresh modern toppings, some good goat cheese, etc. choices. Friendly and efficient staff

If I am perfectly honest, the pizza is good but their salads are the reason I crave this place. My son and I recently shared a Don Corleone and he ordered a Caesar Salad. I have have the House Salad. Anderson Dewey, It's the goat cheese for me. Anyway, Dewey's is the nicest neighborhood spot and we prefer to dine in the dining room. The neighborhood shows up and you have to be comfortable "seeing and being seen". Dress up and smile. read more

I started my night here by joining an online waitlist because no reservations are accepted here. However, after waiting in the car for a bit, I get a text from them saying my spot is lost "due to unforeseen circumstances." I had other reservations scheduled later in the evening, so I went inside and settled for a spot at the bar to eat at. I ordered the gluten free crust which comes in 12 inches and it was more than enough for one meal plus a second meal of leftovers - definitely shareable. Dewey's crust has always seemed on the thin side for me, however it was filling nonetheless. For my three toppings, I chose mushrooms, olives, and spinach. The toppings weren't fully baked into the cheese and the spinach was a little tough. While the cheese was slippery and messy, it had a delicious rich flavor. I would love to see dairy free cheese come to this location. Overall, it was a delicious gluten free pizza but this location is a bit disorganized. read more

Dewey's Pizza - Anderson - 12- Gluten-Free Crust - Pizza Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

Great experience! Great pizza and salad! Great servers and management! Love the Green Lantern pizza, calzones, Don Corleoni pizza and meatball pizza was very garlicky soo good! read more

Pretty disappointed in this particular Dewey's Pizza franchise (Anderson). Ordered a full sized salad and it was 1/2 size compared to what we usually get which is enough to split for $11.25! This manager was not willing to adjust stating "it was full -sized." We eat at a Dewey's often and have had a few bad experiences...always in Anderson. We won't be visiting them again. Sad. read more

Good pizza and good salads. Pricey pizzas but good. I like the don corlean pizza lots of pepperoni. The bronx bomber or deluxe is always light on toppings. Carryout is often 90 minutes to 2 hours because they leave capacity for inside diners. read more

Dewey's is such a great place to check out! Best pizzas in the city and many different and creative options.

It's Dewey's!! Always perfect in every way. Good, servers, ambiance- everything is always excellent at Dewey's! And of course, so delicious!! read more

I stopped in here one day and had a sweet tea. It's a nice atmosphere. Tvs for the sports fans. A nice clean dining room. The restrooms are well kept. I didn't have time to try the food yet but if someone has left me know if it's good. If you drink more than you should call a taxi. I don't wanna hear about ya on the news!!! Good job!!! read more

Dewey's is a Cincy favorite and it really is good. It's never blown my mind but it has fluffy crust and full of toppings. I do like whatever oil mix they use on the edges, it's subtle but tasty! Service is awesome all around. On a Friday night, we were quoted 5-15min wait, enough time for our toddler to watch the guys in the back build pizzas from almost scratch. Hubs ordered the gluten free pizza with a $3 upcharge for GF. He didn't love it. Gluten free is so hit or miss, we've had a really hard time finding one he loves but Dewey's definitely doesn't take the top spot for best gf crust. Toddler and I split an 11in cheese pizza for $9. For a little kid, she killed three pieces! We were very impressed! Dewey's is a yes for her but not so much for mom... although the food is good, there's nothing to entertain the kiddos. Usually a piece of paper and crayons are offered but I saw almost every mom with a little one in a bit of distress. We were all either holding our kid or giving them our phone to watch videos. So for dining in, I would not say this is a "toddler friendly" experience. read more

2 New Yorkers paying through to West Virginia then DC. Google maps directed us here. Pics of outstanding. Service is extremely friendly. Pizza arrived quickly. Price are affordable. Since food is so good you may experience a wait time for table. It's well worth the wait. Highly recommend this pizzeria. read more

Dewey's Pizza - Anderson - Socrates revenge - Pizza Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

Always creative pizza offerings are available. High quality pizza and excellent salad options. Good beer selection too.

I love Dewey's but this location loves to get your order wrong when you order takeout - if you eat here eat inside or else they don't care.

Good quality pizza with a great crunch to the crust. For people seeking simple options it was a little more difficult for my wife. As petty as it might be my only complaint was I believe our pizza should have come with the pizza spatula instead of balancing it on my fork to plate. In saying that I would revisit if we had one in our area. read more

While Deweys still has a robust takeout menu they took off the most popular salad and salad dressing that made them So unique! We came to cincy from LA to visit and craved that distinct Greek salad and dressing that made them so special. What a disappointment to be told it's off the menu because of the cost. The real cost is having your loyal customers go somewhere else..... read more

See all

Peppy staff Unique pizza topping offerings Varied quality beers A bit rushed sometimes. read more

Let me say I have not had Dewey's pizza in many years. The crust is very good the sauce is flavorful with a little bite. I would suggest extra sauce when getting red sauce. Worth a try, they have many special.. One great thing they use local bakeries for deserts. read more

See all

I has a craving for pizza while in town. I got this rec from my brother in law who said it's legit. Being from Chicago we have our favorite pizza and I trust his tastes. (Chicago has more than just deep dish). Quick order on the phone, we had the largest size they had - southwest style which had some corn and bean salsa with chicken and a chipotle sauce. I'd say the crust was exactly what I was looking for that day. Chewy on the inside and decent crisp on the outside. Quality bread. The toppings were just right and looked absolutely splendid. Good looking pizza just needs to be gobbled up. My young daughter liked the pizza at first, but then started complaining about a tad bit of spice. I didn't taste spiciness myself but something to note for younger eaters for the southwest style pizza. The pizza was cut into slices - which was fine for this craving, I'm more a fan of squares since the slices were cut uneven. I'm a fan of Dewey's. I don't see a reason to try another place when I'm in Cincy...unless other yelpers could convince me to. Btw, the pizza is wonderful as a cold breakfast the next morning. ;) read more

This pizza is sooooo good! My favorite place for pizza in Anderson. I also like dining in, service is fast read more

Since MY order was messed up, my friend gave me some of her Hawaiian.... As you can see, the bacon on it is nothing but flubbery. Maybe if you actually eat in, you can request CRISP bacon. read more

Dewey's Pizza - Anderson - Flubby bacon that Dewey's uses on their Hawaiian - Pizza Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

They have amazing pizza and the staff and management were so sweet. They go above and beyond to make sure that everything is perfect! We stopped in after some Christmas shopping and it was a wonderful break. I also appreciate that they have vegan options for my daughter! 10/10 read more

A good Dewey's location. We ordered food for a party. The pickup time was much sooner that we were expecting. Food was in fact ready on time. One of my favorite things about Dewey's is their toppings. Not only are they fresh, but they liberally apply them to the pizzas. As a girl who loves her pizza to be loaded with vegetables this is a very good thing. Socrates Revenge continues to be one of our favorites. All the flavors work well together. The flavors are similar to those found on a Greek salad. Hence being named after Socrates. Ryan's Inferno takes two classics and combines them into one. It is a buffalo chicken pizza with creamy blue cheese crumbles, red onions, and a sprinkling of celery after baking. Celery on a pizza may sound a bit odd, but just as it goes with buffalo wings it goes with the pizza. Cheese pizza was a cheese pizza. Nothing special, but the younger children at the party were happy. Crust on all the pizzas was tougher than I have enjoyed at other locations. We also ordered a Greek salad to go with the pizzas. Salad dressing on the Greek is still quite unique. It is a thick, orangey red sauce, that is on the acidic side. read more

See all

Pizza was very hot and fresh. It was delicious! My friend and I split a half and half pizza. When they brought the pizza out to the table they told us they had made a small error on one side and a new pizza was already in the oven. They let us keep the pizza and brought the new pizza in a matter of minutes. The staff was all very polite and paid close attention to detail. I highly recommend. read more

Dewey's Pizza - Anderson - Pizza Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

Best fresh dough pizza in the area. All toppings are super tasty (we like pepperoni and sausage.) Their salads are also exceptional. And their staff is always very friendly and helpful. ONLY bummer is it's usually 30+ minutes for pizzas = a good sign of how busy they are. (??). Also a bit pricey, but worth it. read more

Pizza is great, Revelup online ordering app is atrocious. Second time I've ordered online though all the steps and confirmed payment with my thumb, only to show up after a 40 minute drive to find that the app didn't submit the order. Apparently if the pickup time changes between when you start ordering and when you finish, you have to confirm and do the payment again? I don't understand it, but I won't use it again. I'm furious. read more

Enjoy the friendly atmosphere and helpful staff. Always coming around to keep drinks full and attend to customer needs.