Fireside Pizza is absolutely worth checking out. It's located in a restored firehouse in Walnut…read moreHills, the atmosphere with its exposed brick, cozy lighting, and a laid-back neighborhood vibe feels both trendy and welcoming. The true standout here is the wood-fired pizza. The crust has that perfect balance of chewy and crisp with a slight char from the oven, and the toppings feel thoughtfully chosen instead of overloaded. Their specialty pies tend to stand out more than the basics. I've been here twice and came away pleased both times.

This is a place my family all agrees on - they consistently have great pizza and calzones with a…read morevariety of toppings, interesting specials, a broad selection of local beers, wines, and a good soda fountain. It's housed in a neat old fire station, and each time we dine in I catch a new detail I hadn't noticed before about the building or decor. They offer picnic tables outside, and every time I've been there I have commented that I hope to sit there when the weather is nicer. The place is small, the staff is small, and the food is good, so sometimes they get pretty crowded -- occasionally I've had a long wait both in line to order and then at a table waiting for our food -- but it's worth the wait.

I cannot rave enough about this establishment. I am not a sauce lover, I usually take half the…read moresauce off my pizza because I just don't care for it, but the sauce at Rosie's was outstanding. I even bought a bottle before we left. Portions are enough for two people. Pasta is made in house. Who doesn't love homemade pasta. I ordered the meatball appetizer and added pasta as my meal. My husband had the chicken parmesan. He stated this was the best meal he had ever eaten at a restauarant. That is a bold statement, as we go out to eat more than we should. Our server, Emma, was wonderful. If all servers could be like her, we would always have a great experience. So do I recommend, YES!!!!!!! The only thing I found odd was that to sit at the bar, which we love to do, you have to have a reservation. However, they could seat us at a table immediately. Just something I never heard of. Please try this place if you haven't yet, you will not be disappointed.

Honey pizza - crust and toppings were great, but could use a little more sauce!…read moreGarlic knots - so soft and garlicky, favorite dish of the night Chicken picatta - great crust to the chicken and side salad had a nice dressing Cannoli cookie - very unique and tasty! Nice ambience and staff as well

Delish! Best pizza I've had in a long time. Guy working was super nice and pizza was done within…read more$20 minutes. Vibe of the place is very small and quick. Would 100% recommend getting the Fancy white pizza. Comes with extra basil too. I ordered my crust to be extra well done. Pizzas come in one size only.

My fiancée and I dined in at the Oakley location and absolutely loved it and wanted more. We saw…read morethat this location did take out/online ordering. We called it in and it only took 30 minutes. Their pizza is New Haven-style. This location only does New York style pizza, not Chicago. It's limited. They only carry salads, beer and wine to go. Also they do not offer gluten free but vegetarian. The inside does not offer dine in and only pick up. We ordered build your own which is the 16 inch with mozzarella, red sauce, sausage and mushrooms. The pizza was amazing! I absolutely loved the flavor and crust. So good that I requested my fiancée order next weekend! One of top 5 fave pizzerias in Cincinnati! Love them!

The place is really nice. They got a couple of different areas you can eat in outside and inside…read more The bar was beautiful. It had over 100 types of different whiskeys. The pizza was delicious. Only thing I wish I would've asked for I don't even know if they would've done, it was to get it. Cut in squares, but everything was wonderful. It's a really nice place. The staff was extremely sweet as well.

Pizza can be excellent or just ok, depending on how long it has sat in the windows. The…read morebreadsticks are consistently good with a cheese cup (a Midwest tradition) and are huge. The really awesome part is the bourbon bar upstairs. This is one of the best selections around. Great bartenders as well, they seriously run a tight ship. A frequent stop for us when we are in OTR.

My new fave spot for New York style pizza. Grab a bite with friends recently and walking in the…read moreplace was really welcoming. The staff sat us immediately and grabbed our drink orders. We stayed with water but our server returned quickly to take our orders and was very attentive the entire time. My fiancé and I split a medium New York style hot honey and pepperoni pizza. It was perfection, thin and foldable the way I like. It was cut into 8 pieces so the perfect amount to get full and not feel completely stuffed. Now as a sweets lover the gelato really stole the show here. We tried the cookies and cream but the sweet cream base I could devour in gallons! It was perfectly sweet and rich in flavor. I will dream about this gelato for days to come. Overall, a cute and affordable place to stop and catch up with friends. Looking forward to coming back soon.

Finally got to try the lunch special at Taglio in OTR! For $15 you get a drink, a salad, and a…read morepersonal pizza. Upgrades are available if you want a signature style pizza. You can also choose between Detroit style and New York. The Detroit style pizza was so crunch and delicious. Our service was a little slow even though it wasn't very busy, but the waitresses we had were still very nice. Will absolutely be going back.

Il Gusto is not only one of THE best hole in the wall restaurants, it is also THE best Italian…read morewe've had in the area! Though spartan, the classic vibes and service are very welcoming! We had better service here than most "normal" sit down restaurants. And the food...not one item we have tried was bad, the vast majority have been the best in their category. Best mozzarella sticks: it's obvious it's a higher quality mozz than whatever everyone else uses. Crispy perfection! Best GF/cauliflower pizza: lots of toppings to choose from (though somehow chicken isn't an option on DD) and again, from the mushrooms to the sauce, you can taste the difference. They make the sauces in house! According to my husband, best Chicken Parm he has had since moving here! You get a healthy portion. And...best cannoli in the area! Growing up in a predominantly Italian and Polish area, I have been lucky to have REALLY good Italian pastries...and their cannoli was reminiscent of those times. This has been the ONLY cannoli in the greater Cincy area that is worth consuming, IMO. All in all, we would dine in at Il Gusto constantly, if we lived closer. Glad they're on DoorDash though! If you are in the Kenwood area, and want a break from the chaos and crowds, Il Gusto is close by!

Had a large Deluxe pizza from Il Gusto the other night and it was amazing. The crust was nice and…read morecrisp. The toppings were plentiful. It was tasty on day 2 warmed up in the oven. I have to say one of the best pizzas I have had in a long time. Only downside for me is that I don't live close. I will be back the next chance I get. Check this place out!

I absolutely loved the pizza , the atmosphere was awesome. The service was great . This was…read moresuperbowl Sunday and unfortunately my wife was sick in university hospital so I had to get it to go . We will be back soon as she's better

First time for a steak hoagie and was perfectly prepared with pizza sauce, cheese, onion and banana…read morepepper rings. Stayed hot until the last bite. Perfectly baked roll.

Okay, I understand the hype! Bourbon House Pizza does Chicago deep dish pizza perfectly. My husband…read moreand I split one of the supreme pizzas and got Italian sausage and mushrooms in it. It was honestly so delicious, and oddly enough was even better reheated the next day! (Reheated great in a toaster oven) It also came out quicker than I expected. (With it being Chicago deep dish, I was prepared to wait!) We also got their appetizer sampler. The items were good, but the pizza balls definitely stood out! The dough was so fantastic and clearly homemade. It was perfectly buttery and flaky, yet firm structural. The sauce was also delicious. A must: pairing everythingggg with their house made ranch. My brother got a steak hoagie and was pretty disappointed when a small sandwich with a meat patty and a side of potato chips is what came out. It just didn't match the caliber of the pizza at all. We also got to Italian sub style hoagies, and those were both small and underwhelming as well. The dining room had a bit of a disheveled feel but I couldn't quite put my finger on what was off. The servers were attentive and kind. We parked at the Levee and walked over. Overall synopsis: I actually can't wait to get pizza here again!!!

We stopped in before a show at Southgate House. It was a Friday and we made reservations for 5:30…read more Reservations at this time were not needed; it was not crowded. The restaurant was clean and comfortable. They have outside seating, which could be nice in the right weather, though the area is just feet from the main drag. Our server was fine. I have no real recollection of them. We ordered a deep dish, looking to find a pizza as good as Zachary's in California. Bourbon House Pizza is not as good as Zachary's, but it is the best deep dish pizza we've tried in the Cincinnati area since we've been back in Cincinnati since 2021. We made our own pizza in an attempt to match our favorite - spinach and mushrooms. It was good. I enjoyed the sauce on top. Under the sauce, the cheese was very thick making the overall taste of the pizza very cheesy. We had a similarly cheese deep dish in Chicago. Our pizza at Bourbon House was better. I will say the crust is thick. I would have eaten the crust if there had only been two pieces per person. Since I was faced with potentially eating four pieces, I opted to skip the crust. One of our group asked if she could order from the kid's menu. The server had no issue with the request. Oddly enough, her meal was huge! We were all surprised it was a kid's meal. Our fourth ordered a small pizza. It looked like it had pineapple on it. I didn't ask how it was, but he ate every bite. It must have been a small and it was the perfect single serving size. Oh... we ordered a medium deep dish. It was eight pieces and was too much for two people. Because we were going to a show after dinner, we didn't box up the leftover two pieces. This size pizza would be great for four people to share. We will continue to look for great deep dish pizza, but we definitely found a good one at Bourbon House Pizza.

If you're looking for a place that feels like home while serving food that rivals the best Italian…read morekitchens, this family-owned pizza restaurant is it. From the moment you walk in, you're greeted with warm hospitality that makes you feel like part of the family. The ambiance is cozy yet lively--perfect for a casual dinner, a family gathering, or even a date night. Their pizza is absolutely fantastic (especially the deep dish). The calzones are generously stuffed, baked to golden-brown excellence, and bursting with savory goodness. Don't miss the hoagie sandwiches--each bite is packed with hearty meats, fresh veggies, and just the right balance of seasoning. And the lasagna... wow. Layers of pasta, rich sauce, and melted cheese come together in a dish that feels like pure comfort food. What truly sets this restaurant apart is the combination of incredible food and genuine hospitality. The staff go above and beyond to make sure every guest feels welcome, and the atmosphere is warm, inviting, and full of charm. Overall, this is more than just a restaurant--it's a place where great food and great people come together. Highly recommended for anyone who loves authentic, delicious Italian fare served with passion.

This place doesn't disappoint. Deep dish pizza is my dad's favorite and this place meets his and my…read moreexpectations every single. The staff was nice and the decor is your typical dive bar or pizza place. The deep dish pizza took about 35 minutes but we were told ahead of time that that would be the case. The garlic knots were immaculate. The waitress said that they are made in house with their special homemade dough. I would come back here just for those!!!

Never having been there beige and being in the town next door, I was in the mood for pizza and…read morethought I'd try them. I wasn't disappointed. I was greeted quickly and while looking at the rotating menu board behind the counter and trying to decide. I was directed to the menu laminated on the counter. Duh! even though I was alone I got a small meat lovers pizza and sat out back. The back was like a fenced in backyard with tables and umbrellas. When the guy brought my (great tasting) pizza out he told me to turn on the fans and basically make myself at home (my words, I was the only one there). I enjoyed the food and atmosphere. Laid back, relaxed and they even have a bourbon bar upstairs. How can you beat that. When I'm in town next year, I'll have to check them out again. You should too!

Goodfellas after a night out is the best. Always hot and tastes so good, affordable too! Big shout…read moreout to Reese for making my friend and I the best pizza last night, I see him there all the time and he is always so nice!! Same for all the staff, it's always a friendly environment.