Step aside, I'm from New York! Stopped here with boyfriend on my way to Boston. Diners, Drive-ins and Dives on the Food Network featured this place last month and they had me salivating over their sandwiches. Imagine my surprise when on a Friday afternoon I discovered a sandwich I really wanted to try was only served on Saturdays. Instead, I had the roast beef 1000, which I have to say was somewhat worth the trip. "Somewhat" because it was small, it didn't have enough meat ("That's what SHE said!") Sandwiches are over priced here. Felt like I was having finger foods. Also, they should try different breads on this sandwich. The onion bread is delicious but not sure it is best option for this sandwich. I'm just sayin! Anyone up for pizza? read more

Yes, they have great tasting food, but WHAT A TOTAL RIP-OFF! are you kidding me??? $8.25 for a "Large" sandwich the size of a post-it note???! Where do they get off! I hope they go under and something REASONABLE goes in there!! NEVER AGAIN! read more

Insane sandwiches every. single. time. The roast beef 1000 is extraordinary with delicious rich, buttery brioche that melts in your mouth and it's Iggys so no surprise why it's other worldly. It's then topped with a very generous portion of high quality house-made roast beef and a thick slice of sharp cheddar that cuts through the layers upon layers of meat, topped with quick-fried crispy shallots that nicely breaks up the meat and cheese while adding that superb garlicky-onion flavor and is topped off with house-made 1000 island dressing for the win. Next up was the Ham Pimiento that comes on a toasty baguette that serves as an excellent vessel. It's stacked high with ham, slightly sweet pickles that add a nice acidic finish and loads of creamy house-made pimiento spread that's finger lick'n good. You will want to buy a small tub of this stuff to-go to address impulse cravings. Loved the flavor but the bread was a bit too crunchy for my liking. Service is friendly and sammies are up in no time. There isn't a lot of seating until they finish their construction so be prepared to get it to go. Prices are on point and they have a mini market that offers a fantastic variety of take-home items. read more

Holy shit. May be the first time of come to tears of joy from eating a roast beef sandwich. The roast beef 1000 is one of the greatest sandwiches ever conceived. It's what cows hope to become when they die. I would fight through at least 3 ninjas, 2 wild dogs and a street panther to get into this place for lunch each day. read more

the service is SOOOOO SLOOOOOOOW. I love their food, but really. they are taking 'slow food' too literally. particularly unnerving when you see not less than six people working in the kitchen, and your breakfast sandwich takes 15 min to make. come on. read more

A lot of strollers. If that doesn't bother you, keep reading. It seems like one of those harmless boring sandwich places, but the sandwiches are pretty darn good. they grate their cheese, so it can look a bit weird. but the cheese is meltier because of that. otherwise, the sandwiches are good and non-offensive and family-friendly just like how things should be in this neighborhood. now you know my enthusiasm for sandwiches. read more

I got Cutty's for take-out and was shocked at how huge the sandwiches are! They're not cheap at around $9 or $10, but worth it given the quality and the size. My boyfriend and I shared the Spuckie and the daily special (something with Thai sausage). He was crazy about both of them, but I was not as big of a fan; I would have preferred the Roast Beef 1000, which seems to be the most popular choice. Once I go back to try the Roast Beef 1000, I'll decide whether or not I'll boost my 3-star rating to 4 or 5 stars. read more

Cutty's - Half of the Spuckie and half of the daily special (Thai Sausage) - $22 for both full sandwiches (twice the size of what's on the plate) - Sandwiches Near Me - Brookline, Massachusetts

I went there for CRAZY Sunday fried chicken sandwich. They were indeed deep super FRIED. The line was long and we were pretty excited for its famous fried chicken. The first two bites were good before I realized they put tons of mayo on it. I had to use napkins to take some dressing off. Their home-made chip were disappointing. Too dry and no flavor. After half sandwich done, I was debating if I should finish it but I don't think their fried chicken mayo leftover gonna stay good. The lady who sit next to me was staring at me since she got her half one wrapped to go. But then I felt okay once finished this guilty pleasure fried chicken. The next day, NOT SO GOOD!!! MY body was sick with all oily fried chicken. It took me three days to recover it. I might try their normal deli sandwich someday , cerntainly not their crazy fried chicken, that's for sure!!! read more

I love a nice local sandwich place and this place had some good reviews so I thought I'd give it a try. I got the Turkey 1000 and some tomato soup. My sandwich, on brioche bun, was quite tasty but I wish it had a bit more sauce and maybe something else? It was 4 star for sure but nothing like WOW this is the best thing I've ever eaten. I did try my friends pimento ham sandwich and that was closer to a 5/5. read more

Listen, the food here is delicious. I love the well thought out ingredients in the meal selection. But like everyone prior me listed... DISAPPOINTING SMALL PORTIONS! My WHOLE sandwich was served on a coffee mug saucer... WHAT?!?! I left just as hungry as I entered. Granted the food tasted great but a little pricey for an appetizer serving IMO. The menu is small but will grow in time. The chips were visually unappealing & too salty but they were surprisingly moist. I would go again because the food is tasty... but might pack my own salad for accompaniment. read more

The sandwiches at this place are sooooo gooooood! I've only tried the roast beef repeatedly, not willing to branch out yet, but I've heard the other sandwiches on baguette are pretty tasty as well. My only complaint is that for the price I would think at least a little side of chips or a house salad could be included, but alas, nada! Also, the girl working the register, Jemma, is pretty f'ing fantastic as well. read more

Roast Beef! I think I tried another sandwich once at Cutty's. Their roast beef sandwich is the best sandwich I've had in greater Boston in 20 years living here. That may sound like hyperbole, but I'm serious. I've had the roast beef 5 or 6 times now and I keep going back! The sandwich is an artful combination of flavors. The roll yeasty and soft, but dense enough for the sandwiches ingredients. the meat and the provolone are both high quality and sliced very thin. The Russian dressing is delicious and the crispy shallots are so dark, I nearly mistook them for bacon pieces. (The shallots may be my favorite single ingredient on this masterpiece.) The staff is friendly and helpful. My first time in, I was impressed at the coffee knowledge and passion of the man who took my order. (They serve Terroir coffee.) Some reviewers have commented on the prices being high. However, taking into account the high quality of the ingredients, I say you get what you pay for. read more

Off the bat...i wish i could give cutty's 4.5 stars. i was walking around the neighborhood and saw pretty much every other person go into this place. being pretty hungry myself, I decided to try this place out. I ordered the roast beef and homemade chips.....my god....this was the best sandwich i've had in boston. ever. the only fault was not actually with the sandwich itself but rather the chips which were beyond salty. i do wish that cutty's were open later so i could grab a sandwich after work everyday but i guess i'll have to settle for the weekends. read more

Fantastic sandwiches. Love the road beef and pork but have had pretty much everything on the menu and would recommend. In a town with great delis (Mahmela's, Michael's, Zaftigs), Cutty's stands with the best of them. read more

Absolutely love Cutty's! One of my go-to's is the half spuckie which is beyond delicious and very filling! You definitely get your money's worth in both size and quality. Today, however, I stopped by for breakfast and tried a "basic breakfast sandwich" (egg and cheese on an everything bagel with red eye mayo). I was not disappointed at all! Though there was a bit too much sauce on it for my liking that is something that is easily fixable. Definitely recommend stopping by Cutty's for a bite to eat if you're in the Brookline village area! read more

Cutty's - Egg and cheese on an everything bagel with red-eye mayo - Sandwiches Near Me - Brookline, Massachusetts

Just awesome. I'm all about a good sandwich shop and considering that one of my favorite sandwich shops in Boston is right around the corner from Cutty's, I was a little hesitant to spread the love. But they earned it. I placed an order for eight Roast Beef 1000 sandwiches and eight hand-squeezed limeades and have to be honest that I had more than my fair share of the bounty. The sandwiches are simple but spot on with flavors, the staff was incredibly friendly and the space is well-lit and inviting. I do have to say that the prices are a bit high but you are getting good quality and inventive sandwiches. Considering I could spend the same amount for a (yes, massive) sub sandwich that I wouldn't finish or prefer to the Roast Beef 1000 - well, it's not really a contest, is it? read more

Food: Super delicious, I do wish that some of the sandwich servings were bigger on the baguette's, but I probably don't need the extra carbs anyway. I'd like to see more variety in the sandwiches as well. Service: I've realized calling my order in ahead of time is the best way to survive, especially if your in a rush. I have yet to come in here and there not be a line! Overall a delicious place in town for a gourmet sandwich! read more

I can't say enough good things about this place. I have had nothing but excellent experiences here. Both spuckies are wonderful, the greens shallot is a revelation, and the pork... oh, holy crap, the pork... Do yourself a favor... get both. Eat half of each. Now you've experienced porky perfection two ways, and can selfishly gorge yourself again later on the same piggly goodness. The staff are really friendly and always smiling, so I'll just assume this place is just as much of a joy to work at as it is to eat at. read more

The spuckie was a really interesting combination of flavors with the olive-carrot salad. I'm not a big fan of olives and the taste was a little overpowering, but I still think it was a solid sandwich. I had my sandwich pressed so that it would be warm and the cheese would melt. The roast beef 1000 needed to be warmed up a little bit. The brioche was slightly warm but the middle was really cold. The homemade chips are very thin and slightly burnt which my friends like it that way whereas I prefer chips that are golden. Portions aren't huge and it can be a little pricey for a meal but it's definitely worth a try. Their brown sugar cookies were also soft and delicious. read more

Cutty's is a 16-seat sandwich shop in the heart of Brookline. A small spot that has deservedly garnered fame for its care, detail, and attention to lovingly prepared high-quality sandwiches. Sourcing ingredients locally when possible, but always using the best of the best, Cutty's manages to take basic sandwiches to the next level with its quality. This past Sunday was Cutty's fried chicken day, only selling fried chicken from 10am until they ran out, regular menu sandwiches were not available. Good thing I went Saturday then...to get to try the best selling sandwich, the roast beef 1000 (but with turkey instead). Consisting of slow-roasted beef (or turkey), crispy fried shallots, house-made 1000 island dressing, sharp cheddar, and a peppered Iggy's brioche bun, there is no question as to why this is their best-selling gem. Perfectly balanced with the best ratios, no single ingredient out-shines the other. Pure tastiness in one sandwich! Also of note are their housemade potato chips, cream-less tomato soup, and anything else really. Next stop in will be for a ham pimento, a ham dijon, and a pork rabe. Okay...maybe I should share some of those. Now accepting applications for 2 friends with great taste in food to split 3 mouth-wateringly amazing sandwiches ASAP! read more

Boy does this place get crowded at lunch. Got the Pork Rabe, which was super delicious and perfectly toasted. Definitely want to come back earlier for breakfast when I get the chance to wake up and take the green line. Anyways, friendly service and hey, Guy Fieri has been here! This place has a small eating area so it's not too big on crowds! read more

Cutty's is delicious! Their fennel and peanut salad is over the top! I highly recommend!!

Terrible: Their hours - BUT order on Sat they'll deconstruct salads/sandwiches for you to assemble on Sunday! Bad: Parking OK: Atmosphere, prices, Pork Fennel, Carrot & Chickpea salad, Rice Krispie Good: Neighborhood, limeade, Wheatberry & beet salad, Ham Dijon, Brownie, Cookies Very good: Spuckie, Pork Rabe Excellent: Their people & service, Greens Shallot, Eggplant Spuckie, Mozzerella Rabe Outstanding: Greens Bacon Orgasmatastic: Roast Beef 1000, Fennel & Peanut Salad read more

High quality healthy sandwiches! My favourite is "spuckie" (mozzarella + olive-carrot salad, ciabatta), both of the vegetarian (eggplant) and non-vegetarian (salami) versions are great. The sandwich isn't that big though, I get hungry in a few hours but that could be just me. Clean kitchen and friend staff. read more

Tried Cutty's for lunch today, it was delicious! There was a big line but it moved relatively quickly. The cashier was very nice and the owner was there as well. The source of their ingredients is on a large chalkboard next to the menu, which is always cool. We got the roast beef 1000, the spuckie, and a limeade. Both sandwiches were awesome. This is a great sandwich shop that is minutes from Brighton. And yes, Guy's head is spray painted on the wall but without DDD, I never would have went to Cutty's in the first place. Docked a star simply for the price; 2 sandwiches and a drink was almost $22. If it came with chips or something, I wouldn't mind. But for a place that's just open for breakfast and lunch, it's a bit pricey. read more

Overpriced, but yummy! I had the pressed spuckie, which was fantastic. Okay, it was super greasy... But who doesn't need a little bit of that in their life? The ingredients were simple, yet combined in a way that was interesting! The olive/carrot mix just worked, and I don't even like olives! While I didn't expect a little sandwich to cost $11, it was a great little spot to visit. The place is tiny... Maybe seats 10-12? I just got my food to go and enjoyed it in my car. I noticed that they sell their pimento cheese, so I'll likely go back to grab a container of that! I wanted to taste their food before purchasing things for home. Overall, it's a win! read more

Cutty's - Not the prettiest looking thing, but it sure was tasty! #Spuckie - Sandwiches Near Me - Brookline, Massachusetts

Good S**t! Seriously, great concepts, great execution... ! This is good stuff and I've been lucky with parking which is definitely a challenge in that hood! read more

On Saturday I made plans to order the special egg sandwich: pork/potato pancake, sharp cheddar, bacon on a xl english muffin. The sandwich did not disappoint my taste buds. The added curry ketchup was so unique and savory even a bit of heat. The science behind each crafted sandwich and the high level of taste is worth the wait. Be patient as the expansion continues to allow more room for seating even ordering. I find that if I go before 11:30 am or after 2 pm the wait time is cut in half. The chalkboard of 'where our products come from' is an added value for me. Plus the house made condiments and sides motivates me to build my own crafted sandwich. read more

Slightly overrated! Sandwiches were good but very small for the price? We got the Saturday pork and fennel and a roast beef 1,000. The home made chips are delicious. I ordered an iced coffee and it nearly had 2 ice chips in it. Not iced enough. read more

9, 2 person tables in the back. Sandwiches are very unique, some ingredients I wasn't aware of. Ended up getting the spicy chicken sandwich, large size lots of flavor but very greasy. Coffee was good, staff was friendly, very Brookline. No wifi, various outlets. read more

Cutty's - Spicy chicken sandwich- special - Sandwiches Near Me - Brookline, Massachusetts

I used to live in the brook house and would come whenever I have time! This is literally the best sandwiches in town! Place is small but you don't come for the ambience. Actually there is a nice park nearby where you can sit and enjoy the outside if you have a decent lunch break! I'd recommend it to anyone who's ever in the area read more

In the words of Roald Dahl, "scrumdiddlyumptious". This place is my Saturday's delight. my top 3 picks sammies: Ham pimento Roast beef 1000 Pork Rabe Oh yeah...make sure to get yourselves a bag of homemade chips. Food is good but the service is slow. With no one in line and you are the only one waiting it should not take 25 mins for sandwiches. read more

Brookline has only a few spots that serve breakfast sandwiches. Out of those few spots that do, most are chain restaurants. Then, like a beacon of breakfast sandwich hope piercing through the fog of prepackaged egg patties, there is Cutty's. And when it comes to breakfast sandwiches, Cutty's stands alone. From the chorizo to the red flannel hash, these are breakfast sandwiches like none you have had. They are creative, they are exciting, and most important, they are delicious. read more

Cutty's - Next Super Cluckin' Sunday, September 13th. - Sandwiches Near Me - Brookline, Massachusetts

Been here many times and it never disappoints! Just be sure to go before it gets crazy on the weekends - but every time I had to wait a bit, it was worth it! I wish the place was larger so there was more seating, but overall - can't complain! Update: I just saw they've expanded, so I'll have to visit again when I get back to MA! read more

Yes! Yes! Yes! As part of Day 2 of the 'enjoy every sandwich' road trip, my boyfriend and I stopped at Cutty's for lunch. With the dog in tow, we opted for take out and ate al fresco nearby. We made Cutty's a destination as it is, supposedly, the one of the 'top 50 sandwiches' in the US right now, making it the best in MA. And boy do I believe it. We shared a Spuckie and a RB1000. One was more delicious than the next. The thinly shaved meats, the salty-sweetness of the carrot/olive salad on the Spuckie... divine! If I lived in this town I'd be here at least once a week. Interesting twists on classic sandwiches, constructed with incredible ingredients and care. Five stars all the way. read more

It's good enough, but I don't get the hype. The sandwiches are good, and the portions are generous, but this place closes early and has high prices and a small dining area. You'd think they were serving ambrosia. Maybe I'm being too critical, but nothing here really does it for me. All the items are as I expect, but nothing is memorable. Nothing interesting, nothing worth the wait entailed in going during the lunch rush. Good to stop in once if you're in the area, but don't go out of your way. read more

Hands down the best roast beef sandwich I have ever had!! This sandwich shop is the perfect example of the amazing and delicious food a 'farm to table' shop can bring, and more restaurants should take their approach! Can't wait to come back and try a fried chicken Sunday!! .. And everything else on the menu ;) read more

Cutty's - Roast Beef Goodness - Sandwiches Near Me - Brookline, Massachusetts

Came here for super clunkin sunday. Pluses: - Was a REALLY cold day, so they did an online pre-order system. I appreciated not needing to stand in line in the cold. - Provided hot chocolate. - Chicken sandwich was crispy and BIG. Iced shaved onion layer was amazing. Bun was buttery and nicely toasted. Minuses: - Chicken didn't seem to be brined well, so taste and juice was lacking. Possibly because of volume of orders on this single sandwich day. Overall, I don't regret trying this, but would not return unless I'm convinced the lack of salt was an anomaly. read more

Best sandwich in town. We have been wanting to go to the cutty's for so long but they close early during weekdays. Finally had the chance to try this Saturday. The roasted beef 1000 is too good to even find a word to describe. I got the pork rabe (Saturday special). Feel like I can have a second one right away. read more

Cutty's - Pork rabe and roasted beef 1000 - Sandwiches Near Me - Brookline, Massachusetts

03/15/2016 - They have renovated! Cutty's is now much larger with more seating! More seating = more friends for lunch! Food is still fantastic! :) read more