After all these years still amazing and high quality. Was a little sad to see they didn't have any indoor seating anymore but we were able to take our food to a nearby park. You still order at the counter and they tell you when your food is ready. Ours took about 10 min to come out. I got the greens bacon (Swiss chard, bacon, spicy mayo, ciabatta). Even though you'd expect the bacon to be the main flavor, the Swiss Chard flavor is actually what came through the most and I was delicious and well cooked/seasoned. The bacon was a thicker cut but didn't add too much flavor, more saltiness. The mayo was almostttt a little too much. But good flavor and spice. Bread was perfectly soft and held up well. My partner got the turkey 1000 without cheese (All-natural turkey, crispy shallots, 1000 island, brioche). He said everything tasted high quality but the crispy shallots made it. read more

Cutty's - Inside of greens bacon - Sandwiches Near Me - Brookline, Massachusetts

I got the beef 1000 sandwich - TASTE: 4/5 - classic slow-roasted beef w thousand island dressing. Would come back to try more of the menu! TEXTURE: 5/5 - wasn't expecting the crispy shallots -- game changer! Enjoyed the soft brioche too PRICE: 4/5 - paid $14 SERVING SIZE: 4/5 - a much smaller sandwich than I thought, guess I'm too used to North Shore portions lol SERVICE: 4/5 - walked in at 12pm on a Saturday to no line. Employee at the register was friendly, and my sandwich was ready in 5min ATMOSPHERE: 3/5 - bright, small space w standing room at the counter for a quick bite PARKING: 4/5 - got a metered street spot near the library on Washington St read more

Cutty's - Beef 1000 - Sandwiches Near Me - Brookline, Massachusetts

See all

Delicious lunch place! We were lucky enough to be able to have their fork n knife grilled cheese which really celebrates local vendors (clear flour bread, allendale farm tomatoes) and was EXCELLENT. It is definitely rich, but the tomatoes are highlighted in a special way. Also had the rabe tj which was a little lighter (though still very filling) and had a great balance with the broccoli and cheese and jam. We did order in person and had to wait a fair amount of time, seems like much of their business is takeout. read more

Cutty's - Fork n knife grilled cheese - Sandwiches Near Me - Brookline, Massachusetts

Local takeout spot Where each sandwich delivers Fresh ingredients No shortcuts taken Crunch, flavor, food to share Or enjoy solo Everything with love For all Cutty customers New and old foodies Or someone that needs A sandwich to satisfy Cravings and hunger I ordered the Rabe T.J and I was a little nervous the broccoli rabe would be too hard or soggy but it was perfect and not messy to eat. You could get a clean bite every time. Other sandwich ordered was a warm, pressed ham Dijon. A simple sandwich yet perfect and flavorful. Not something to pass on or overlook. Both sandwiches blessed by chef kisses. So good read more

See all

Genuinely so good. The turkey 1000. You won't regret it. The perfect amount of crunch, flavor, and textures going on. Big fan of the bread and the portion of turkey too. Not too much, not too little. This place is poppin!! Looks like a lot of people know to order ahead of time and drop in to pick up their order. My friend and I ordered two Turkey 1000's at the counter and waited probably 15 minutes. read more

Cutty's - Turkey 1000 - Sandwiches Near Me - Brookline, Massachusetts

3.5 Stars. Nice, modern sandwich shop. The Beef 1000 looked small at first glance, but actually contained a good amount of meat and was filling. The fried shallots added a nice textural component. Though I feel it would have been significantly better hot (with the cheese melted and the buns toasted). Wait time was pretty short even though there was a constant stream of takeout orders read more

Cutty's - Menu as of 11/22/25 - Sandwiches Near Me - Brookline, Massachusetts

Clean restaurant, cool colors and interior, fast service. Beef 1000 is a cold roast beef sandwich with a lot of beef see picture nice taste. Don't expect any sides with any of the items. The food comes in a paper bag with the logo on it. Moderate pricing. read more

See all

Great sandwiches and limeades. Very tasty and great ingredients. Sandwiches are on the smaller side. The rice crispy treat was a nice little sweet treat. read more

Dig the store vibe; but the sandwich was small, overpriced and bread was burnt. I might give it another shot next time I'm in the neighborhood read more

I don't know why everyone goes crazy over this place. The sandwiches are ok, sure, but I feel like they really don't want customers--no seating (the dining table area is holding all their junk), they NEVER update the menu except to REMOVE things, they were over the top no contact during and well after covid, they are barely open.... Just, why? I've never had a bad experience there, I just feel like they are reluctant restauranteurs who want NO contact with their customers. Like they would prefer a return to pushing bags of food through a small hole to people who ordered online. That's ok though because Mahaniyom is just around the corner and they want customers. read more

Window service only but you can order online and service is quick. Tried out the Ham Dijon sandwich. I was expecting it to be a lot bigger based on the photo on the online menu. The ham was prosciutto rather than a deli ham, and there could have been a lot more of it. However, the flavors of the pickles/butter/dijon was very well balanced. I would try other sandwiches, but wouldn't get this one again. read more

Cutty's - Ham Dijon - Sandwiches Near Me - Brookline, Massachusetts

Came for their Super Cluckin Sunday honey mustard chicken sandwich. It was really tasty and tender. The edges of the bun were buttery and perfect. The sauce was a bit too sweet for me and a wish it was a tad crispier. read more

Cutty's - Sandwiches Near Me - Brookline, Massachusetts

See all

Biting into a roast beef 1000 is the definition of a slice of heaven. Soft pillowy bun, piles of flavorful fatty sliced beef, and a zesty thousand island sauce that is a party in your mouth. What more could you want in a sandwich? This online order only, walk up window operation that operates only a few days a week during lunch hours can be a bit annoying but maybe the scarcity is what makes it even more special when you do happen to get a sandwich on a blue moon. read more

Cutty's - Roast Beef 1000 - Sandwiches Near Me - Brookline, Massachusetts

Simply delish! This place has become a new addiction. Great quality and reasonable priced, too. They were also featured on America's Test Kitchen!!' read more

I love Cutty's! Simple, friendly consistent goodness what's not to love. Take home a bag of granola too! So delicious!

The sandwich was ok overall, but it was not more competitive in any particular aspect compared to some of the better shops around, in terms of quality, quantity, or price. The sauces were an exception, which were very good and left an impression. read more

Roast beef/ cheese and sauce sandwich on a cute bun... very good Tomato soup excellent ( and a nice kick) Grilled cheese sandwich I liked, but some would say it's a bit greasy Ambiance is; it's 100% take out I hope they can survive and make money for an unusual protocol such as take out only. read more

Cutty's is a sandwich shop in Brookline Village. Their menu is minimal and to the point. They make only a handful of artisanal sandwiches and a couple of soups. They sell pickles and various spreads too. Theirs only one thing to get for me. It's the Beef 1000. It's slow-roasted beef, crispy shallots, 1000 island dressing + sharp cheddar on Iggy's black pepper brioche bun. My goodness it's good. Tender, sliced so thin yould read through them. Sweet shallots and tart dressing. Salty creamy tangy cheese is balanced beautifully with the soft peppery airy brioche bun. Truly a must try samich. read more

Cutty's - Sandwiches Near Me - Brookline, Massachusetts

See all

I've only had their Roast Beef 1000 but it is delicious and very fairly priced. I have never tried North Shore Roast Beef sandwiches so I cannot compare but I think Cutty's RB is great. read more

Pros: -Super Cluckin' Sunday chicken sandwich. I've only had the BBQ ranch so far but will be sure to try the Honey Mustard ASAP. Order ahead on the Monday before (instructions on their website) because it sells out and pick up is a breeze The BBQ ranch chicken sandwich is delicious. The chicken is tender, sauces are tasty and overall it is a delightful experience that I can't wait to repeat! read more

Cutty's - Super cluckin Sunday bbq ranch chicken sandwich - Sandwiches Near Me - Brookline, Massachusetts

Awesome high quality food. Dedicated hardworking staff. Great atmosphere. Great value too.

The roast beef was completely underwhelming. It was small and not worth the price. Just seems like generic grocery store roast beef.

Great egg sandwich this morning, with bacon. Plus I had the turkey for lunch this week too. Lucky me! Incredible food, with a nice online ordering experience. Food ready as promised. read more

Cutty's - Incredible egg sandwich today! - Sandwiches Near Me - Brookline, Massachusetts

First off the woman who is behind the counter is the nicest person. So sweet and accommodating. I look so forward to Brookline market on Thursday so I can get a sandwich from Cutty's. I don't know anyone who has better sandwiches. read more

Roast beef sandwich was rather small and pretty underwhelming overall, especially for the high price tag

I am so in love with Cutty's. I had this twice during my stay in Brookline and if I had more time, I would have it again. I sampled the following: -Pork Rabe -Tomato Soup -Honey Mustard Fried Chicken Sandwich (+ Spicy Goo for $1.50) -Tandem Coffee All items were delicious and well-priced for portion size and taste. You can taste the quality of ingredients and the food comes out quickly with a friendly smile, which is a plus! What makes these sandwiches great is the ratio of ingredients to a perfectly toasted bun. I really fell in love with the Chicken Sandwich they offer on their Super Cluckin' Sunday once a month. The crispiness and meatiness of the chicken sandwich was perfect against the sauce and lettuce. The spicy goo wasn't too spicy-- there was a pleasant amount of heat. It was well-worth the wait. I am just sad I don't know when the next time I'll have this again! read more

See all

Amazing sandwiches located on Washington St. Perfect, small, hole-in-the-wall sandwich shop. I ordered the TJ Rabe with ham and it was delectable. Pick-up is super easy since they have a pick-up counter as their door. These sandwiches are packed with flavor. I really enjoyed the blend of cheese (provolone & fresh mozzarella) that mixed in well with the broccoli rabe. The tomato jam was a great compliment spread to the sandwich and I wouldn't have ever thought of it. Of course, the panini-style press makes any sandwich so much better with the crispy toastiness. I will definitely be back to try out the other sandwiches one day! read more

Cutty's - TJ Rabe w/ ham - Sandwiches Near Me - Brookline, Massachusetts

Went here for the Super Cluckin Sunday which occurs once a month. The line wasn't too bad and it took about half an hour before I was able to order and got the sandwich soon after. It is priced about $13. The fried chicken was great and definitely worth the wait and price! This is probably the best fried chicken around Boston and it is worth the hype. read more

Cutty's - BBQ Ranch - Sandwiches Near Me - Brookline, Massachusetts

Make sure you order ahead to ensure you're able to beat them selling out! So the ambiance of this place will be whatever you choose lol. Chicken sandwich was a very solid treat. Highly recommend! read more

Got the Italian sandwich ( a special for the 4th) and it was great! Ordered online and easy pickup read more

Cutty's - Italian sandwich - Sandwiches Near Me - Brookline, Massachusetts

After hearing about this place in Boston Magazine, I had to try their roast beef sandwich, Beef 1000. During the pandemic, you can only order the sandwiches online or via the Toast app. The shop definitely followed good social distancing guidelines since they didn't allow anyone inside and they just handed you your order via an open window in the front door. The Beef 1000 sandwich consisted of roast beef, crispy shallots, sharp cheddar cheese, and thousand island dressing on a brioche bun. I literally digged into the sandwich within 2 minutes after I picked it up. However, my first impression was that the meat in the sandwich was cold. Is it supposed to be like that? Don't get me wrong.. the sandwich was very delicious but I was expecting the roast beef be at least warm similar to Kelly's . It is a small sandwich for $12 but the tastiness wins over the price. Might be I will try it again once they open back up and customers can dine in again... read more

So after hearing good things about cuttys I decided to check out for lunch. I went in, got their 1000 island beef special which looked like their best meat option. I asked for hot sauce on it and they said hot sauce you have to buy the hot pickles for 1.50...you can't just add any sauces. After waiting for a bunch I got the sandwich. Portion it was ok....I think I was still hungry afterwards. The sandwich itself was ok as well, seemed like any standard roast beef sandwich but this one was $12... overall it wasn't bad but not worth the price imo. read more

This place doesn't look like much when you walk by. There's no seating, and you just see a counter by the sidewalk to place orders. However, it's usually hard to miss, especially considering the line of people outside waiting to place orders or pickup their food. The menu is simple and small, but satisfying. The sandwiches are simply amazing!! All the ingredients feel very fresh. I had the Roast Beef 1000 and it was awesome. The meat was thinly sliced, fresh and very soft. Each bite has a satisfying blast of flavor from the dressing. I added some extra pickles which perfectly paired with the flavor. The rest of the group had the Greens Shallot and the Turkey 1000, and they had similar feedback. The one word we kept repeating was "fresh". We'll definitely be back at Cutty's next time we're in the neighborhood. read more

Take-out only, so order ahead online. We got the Greens Shallot with turkey and the Rabe T.J. with turkey. Both were improved with the addition of turkey, but the Rabe T.J. I think would have been a great sandwich without it. The Greens Shallot, though, was a similar texture throughout with a lot of swiss chard (which adds a lot of moisture), so the turkey (or some protein) felt necessary. The bread was really nice on both. read more

Drove out to this small mom and pop roast beef sandwich place. Lady was nice but abrupt and looked tired. Hopefully they don't stay short staffed for long. Had to order at their front door. The roast beef sandwich paired with a tomato soup was good. Unfortunately they didn't have inside seating but it was a nice day anyway for sitting at the nearby park. read more

Cutty's - Beef 1000 and tomato soup - Sandwiches Near Me - Brookline, Massachusetts

Came for the Sunday chicken sandwich - honey mustard. Did not disappoint. Highly highly recommend. Also got pimento cheese - best you can find around this area. read more

Cutty's - Friend Chicken Sandwich - Sandwiches Near Me - Brookline, Massachusetts

Wow. I've never left a review. I just ate the beef sandwich. Straight up that was one of the best sandwiches I've ever had. So good. Perfect size. Very neat. Nothing spilled out of the sandwich. Not a single drip or crumb. The beef was soft, not chewy at all. Generous portion of meat. The crispy onions or whatever. Fire. Thousand island is my favorite. I added the pickled hots and it was the perfect amount of heat. The bread was soft but wasn't soggy at all. I wasn't given any napkins but I didn't need one. Whole thing just went down so easy. Holyyy. Right down to the last bite I was happy and it is lingering. The place is take out only so I sat by a little pond and ate the sandwich on a beautiful fall day. Best sandwich experience ever. Hahaha. read more

Tasty beef specialy if you are a good taster and service is good specially the ambiance there are good

It's that time of month again!! Cuttys chicken sandwich! We got the famous chicken sandwich again and this time it was the bbq. Still a fantastic sandwich but the honey mustard is better. read more

Cutty's - bbq chicken sandwich - Sandwiches Near Me - Brookline, Massachusetts

See all

Had the once month BBQ chicken sandwich today. A big portion of Crunchy and very juicy chicken. The sauce was very flavorful and the roll it was on was high quality as well. I would eat the sandwich immediately as I can see the heavy sauce making the breading soggy pretty quick. I'd say the sandwich was worth the hype and will be getting it again next month read more