Cowfish

every year, a friend treats me to a different steakhouse. so this was my first time here. the…read morewaitress Tammy was very helpful in explaining and suggesting various options on the menu. my friend and I shared a wedge salad. the way it was presented, you would have thought that we ordered 2 separate salads. awesome! The pricing was very reasonable, considering the steak came with a choice of potato, vegetable, and a sauce on the side. The ambiance was great.

We came with a reservation on a Friday night. It wasn't too busy. I loved the outside with a nice…read moreseating area around colorful florals. The building looks like a mini lighthouse. Service was efficient and friendly. I got the truffle airline chicken and my partner got the strip steak. Overall the flavors were pretty good. The sweet potato fries came with a cinnamon sauce. The mushroom demi glace and the cauliflower puree were delicious. My partner's steak was unevenly cooked with half being medium and the other half being medium rare. For cocktails, we got the strawberry lemonade, which was more sweet than tart, and the bourbon cherry sour. For dessert we got the smores chocolate mousse, which came with toasted marshmallows, graham crackers, and Hershey's pieces. It was good but too sweet for me to finish everything. It also came in a narrow mason jar which was a little impractical.

Another great steak from the best steak house in town!!!!

Wagyu American Kobebetter then anything I have ever tasted

See all

ROSARIO S. CASSATA AND CAROLYN AT 1 NORTH STEAKHOUSE IN HAMPTONS LONG ISLAND NY.

Buckley's Inn Between

3.7(123 reviews)

1.6 mi

Best burgers around! Good atmosphere. A place you can bring the whole family. Servers are very…read morenice. Irish fare is good too. Men's room can use some love though.

I LOVE Buckley's Inn Between, an important part of the charm and heart of Hampton Bays! We've been…read morecoming here for years. We loved the food before but we quickly realized at this visit: something was different. The food is even BETTER. The wedge salad was extremely fresh, coated with a delicious dressing and the perfect amount of bacon bits. The Buckley's Burger was FANTASTIC & cooked exactly as requested. I got mine with an extra egg. Service was friendly & attentive. Looking forward to coming back again soon!

Burger Special

See all

Menu - August 2026

Good Ground Tavern

3.9(54 reviews)

0.1 mi

Very nice atmosphere although it's taken us almost 2 hours to get our dinner and we're sitting at…read morethe bar seems to be more young kids working here which kudos to them, but it's not the service that we're used to They finally brought out my dinner and then advised us that what my wife ordered wasn't available so I guess she's supposed to not eat as I eat mine. Again, I don't recommend this place.

I was shocked at how good the food is here, and how approachable our bartender was despite the…read moreextremely swanky atmosphere. I came in for happy hour during the week and ordered a bunch of the appetizers that were on special. The focaccia bread with whipped ricotta and honey was outstanding. The bread tastes freshly made and was so fluffy. The baked clams were hearty and delicious, served on a bed of Himalayan sea salt which made the dish feel elevated. The pizza we ordered had an extremely thin crust that was perfectly crunchy and had just the right amount of sauce and cheese on it. Trivia was about to start after happy hour which I wish I had time to stick around for -- it looked like the teams that were forming were some stiff competition. TL;DR - Don't let the fancy atmosphere put you off from trying this place, especially during happy hour!

Quiet on a Wednesday afternoon. #offseason

Whipped Ricotta with Hot Honey

See all

Brunching

The Watershed Kitchen and Bar

4.3(111 reviews)

5.2 mi

We were very impressed with the Watershed and have been back several times in the last few weeks…read more Each visit is better than the last. food has always been delicious and good portions. our server Cali was incredible, attentive, knowledgeable and friendly. Highly recommend

The Watershed Kitchen and Bar is a gem tucked away in The Hamptons!…read more Smart, attentive service, quiet ambiance in the indoor area with a lively party atmosphere outdoors, with a live band. The food here is very high level. The meatball appetizer knocks it out of the park. The short ribs are extremely tender, no knife needed. The skirt steak is rich in all the right ways, lean, soft & expertly seasoned. A fantastic meal & experience!

Lounge area

Bloody mary

See all

Smaller bar

Villa Paul Restaurant

3.6(99 reviews)

1.5 mi

Good overall, but not great. Perhaps my expectations were too high but at this price point and in…read morethe Hampton Bays area, I don't think my hopes were unreasonable. Old school style with lots of wood, quiet ambiance & very attentive service. The "Eggplant Tower" was ok. The Porterhouse Steak was very large, however the seasoning felt bland as did the grilled onions on top. The baked potato was comically small and way out of proportion to the large steak. The sparse serving of broccoli was equally meager. The bread pudding and other desserts were very good.

First let me start by saying I am a local resident of the area. I'm not sure why I never tried this…read morerestaurant. The ambience was lovely and cozy and very welcoming. I ordered one of their special cocktails that was delicious. I chose escargot which was very good. I ordered veal piccata for my main course. Our waitress told me that if I wanted capers on my veal piccata it was $4 EXTRA !!!!!! Now I am a home cook and have always used capers for this recipe. I came home and went on line and EVERY RECIPE HAD CAPERS. I HAVE NEVER EVER GOTTEN AND UP CHARGE FOR CAPERS!!!! Both in upscale restaurants and more moderate priced restaurants!!!! I COULD NOT BELIEVE THIS. We were a party of 4. We received bread that was enough for 2. Upon asking for some more bread we were told there was an up charge of $3. Our waitress told us " the restaurant pays a fortune for bread and had to pass this onto us". Again, never ever had we been charged for some additional bread!!! Food was good- experience fell way short!

Peanut Brickle Cheesecake! Awesome

Homemade Bread Pudding (seasonal flavors)

See all

Birthday Celebration .. Clams on the 1/2 Shell (Top Neck) + The Special Almond Crusted Striped Bass ... Super Yummy

Centro 336

3.9(31 reviews)

3.2 mi

Came here with my coworker and wow, I was blown away! Such a beautiful spot with plenty of parking…read moreand a great menu full of options for everyone abs lots of drink options too . This is my coworker's favorite restaurant, and it absolutely lived up to the hype. We started with the baked clams, which were delicious, followed by Nona's meatballs, amazing sauce and incredible flavor. For my entrée, I had the fluke fish, and wow, that was the cherry on top. We ended the night with a huge slice of chocolate cake that was pure indulgence. Overall, everything was fantastic! Definitely more of a special-occasion spot as the bill was on the higher side, but 100% worth checking out.

Great experience at dinner last night. Happy hour at the bar before heading to the table for…read moredinner. I ordered the 336 cosmo for only $10 and it was delicious. Perfect balance of ingredients. For an appetizer I had the whipped ricotta which was plentiful and light, and then the "house made paccheri" for dinner which was also delicious. The restaurant was pretty empty...but I imagine it'll get more full as the summer season comes into swing. Staff consistently came by and filled my water glass - which I loved. And they were friendly and didn't rush us out.

See all

Canal Cafe

3.9(306 reviews)

0.6 mi

Emily D. - Canal Cafe is awesome! In fact, I'm surprised that on such a busy day, they allowed you…read moreto sit at a table and eat your ToGo. Maybe it was because of the elderly woman with you. On the chalkboard in front of the host stand, it states, " high tops and picnic tables are for cocktails and waiting, ToGo's can be enjoyed off premises" - If asking you to pick up your garbage after eating your Togo meal is treating you with disdain, I would hate to see how you treat other people. Anyway...I enjoyed my outstanding meal. The little necks were fantastic, the lobster roll was over flowing and the spicy margarita rocked. Oh and the staff, on point and friendly. Only issue was some woman making a stink about not being able to eat her Togo and being mean to everyone to get her way. Other than that, great day at Canal!

This place has gone down hill. AVOID AT ALL COSTS. Though the location is marina-facing and lovely…read moreoutside, you can do way better than this place as there are many similar options in the area. The food was overly greasy, the bread is stale, the lobster meat smelled funky and not fresh. We had lobster rolls, french fries, chips and guac, and shrimp tacos. The shrimp tacos were flimsy and soggy. Additionally, the service was ABYSMAL. The hostess was snide and the waitress treated my 80 year-old parents with disdain. When I asked to speak with the manager and express these concerns, he nodded solemnly but did not offer any sincere words or apologies.

Outdoor view

Soft Shell Crab BLT

See all

Patio

Edgewater Restaurant

4.2(406 reviews)

0.7 mi

Best margarita in the Hamptons for sure !!!! Friendliest…read morestaff always, sweet water view Love Happy hour menu

The restaurant has beautiful views weather you sit inside or out. The food was delicious, I got the…read moreswordfish, which they made sure didn't contain any of my allergens. My wife got the salmon and said it was delicious. The staff was very kind, personable and attentive. Definitely recommend you try this place.

Interior Dining Space

Happiest of Happy Hours!!!

See all

Water view

Stone Creek Inn

4.0(157 reviews)

4.5 mi

I came here with a group of 8 on a Friday night. We made reservations so we had no problems getting…read morea table. We ordered some appetizers to share, including the crispy sushi rice with salmon, the Caesar salad, the octopus carpaccio, the duck meatballs, and a fig dish that was on the specials menu. For my meal, I had the soft shell crab, which was served with farro. The dishes were on the pricier side, but our food was delicious and the service was excellent. Everyone from the valet to our waitress were very nice and made sure we were well taken care of.

We had an amazing meal at the Stone Creek Inn. The staff were lovely and professional, starting…read morewith the parking valet. Our waitress was lovely and our busboy was a lot of fun to talk to. The space is beautiful. There were tablecloths, comfy chairs and plenty of room between tables. The bread was great. This restaurant is in the splurge range, but it offers a prix fixe menu a few nights per week. My wife had the watermelon and tomato salad and loved it. The escargot were great. Three of us had the monkfish. It was amazing. One of our group had chicken fricasee. He loved it. We finished with delicious Basque cheesecake and an affogato. This place is head and shoulders above anywhere else that I have eaten on the east end. It's a big splurge unless you go on a night when the prix fixe is offered. It's a perfect evening for a special occasion or when you want a compete dining experience.

Bar is happening!

Bolognese

See all

PineHampton

Sundays On The Bay

3.4(248 reviews)

3.2 mi

This place has such a nice ambiance that can't be beat (only if you sit outside though - honestly…read morewould not say it's worth it to sit inside), such a great cocktail menu, and yummy food! I would recommend the corn agnolotti, fish and chips, baked clams, and oysters Rockefeller. The tuna tartare was decently sized but lacking a bit in flavor. Service has not been great when I've been here. They have a young staff that seem frequently annoyed, and unfortunately our food took a very long time to come the last time I was here. I would still recommend it, just be prepared to have a chill, long dinner!

Located on scenic Dune Road, Sundays On The Bay is one of those restaurants I've always wanted to…read morego to but never had the time. Last night I was driving back to the city and decided to check it out. I drove down the long road flanked by sand dunes. The sunset was simply beautiful. There was very little traffic and I made it to the restaurant easily. Once there I was greeted by a friendly young girl at the door. The place was pretty packed but I was able to get a table by the water with a view of the bay and marina. The atmosphere was relaxed and friendly. The food arrived hot and nicely arranged. The main entree I selected was the "Long Island Monkfish" for 34$. The price was more than expected for the quantity of food and they should have included some bread - very much needed with the spicy vinaigrette. The monkfish was absolutely delicious! The leeks and gnocchi went perfectly with the fish. I read online that the Branzino is really good here. I really wanted to try the Branzino but they ran out of it. Before I left, I went to the restroom. They have two stalls so there was a bit of wait. The main area is open with sinks, soap and a Dyson dryer - no paper towels. The stalls are clean with ample space. While waiting, I chatted with the other people who had been to the Rose wine soirée earlier. They said it was great - unlimited rose wine plus appetizers at the beginning, including lobster rolls. Tickets were 60$ all inclusive. They had a DJ and small outdoor dance floor and it was almost all women. That's not a surprise - rose wine events tend to attract more women than men. I'm not sure why, maybe because rose wine is pink or the invite appeals more to a female audience.

See more unrecommended reviews

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

68 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Siobhan D.

202

10 years ago

Ok, so in all honesty I have not eaten at this establishment. The basis for this review is on their customer service when making a reservation for a very large party. I am planning a bachelorette party and I called back in June (three months before the party) to inquire about making a reservation for twenty people. The person I spoke to took down my name and said the manager would call me back. The manager did not call back. However, I did call back a few days later. The person I spoke to at that time proceeded to make the reservation for me. They confirmed the date, the number of people and the time. They took my name, e-mail address and cell phone number as well. About a month later, I called to confirm, because I was making sure all of the plans were set in stone. I also didn't quite trust the reservation had been made because the young woman I spoke to was definitely not a manager and based upon my first phone call with them, I wasn't sure she had the authority to make the reservation. I spoke to a gentleman this time and he confirmed the reservation for me again. I called again this afternoon because the party is two weeks away and I wanted to reconfirm all of my arrangements for the weekend (out of sheer desire for everything to go perfectly for the bride-to-be). I called and said I wanted to confirm a reservation, they asked for the information and I gave it to them. Imagine my surprise when the next words out of the young woman's mouth were "Oh we're closed that night for a wedding, we cannot honor your reservation." I was flabbergasted. I asked why they didn't think to reach out to me. There was a pause and then she responded "Someone tried to call but it said the number was out of service". My number has never been out of service, first of all. In the case that they did call, they should have tried again. Even if the phone number had been written down incorrectly, they had my e-mail address as well. They could have e-mailed me. What I suspect happened is they got an offer to host a bigger party or an offer to have the place rented out AFTER I had made my reservation. I know that they were happy to confirm the reservation a MONTH AFTER I MADE IT. Whatever happened between July and today, I don't know but it is very fishy and frankly it's poor form. I don't know if I believe that they ever tried to contact me but if they did they didn't try very hard. Can you imagine what would have happened if I hadn't called to reconfirm a second time and shown up with an entire bachelorette party? The night would have been ruined. What I do know is that I won't ever be dining at this establishment because they were completely blaze about my reservation, didn't try to contact me when they could no longer honor the reservation (they say they tried to call- but they could have e-mailed as well since I know they had that information too). I will also be letting my friends and family (who recommended this restaurant to me) know how poorly I was treated. None of us will be back. It's a shame that they 1) didn't bother to try to contact me via e-mail when my phone number supposedly didn't work and 2) that they took another party even though they made my reservation and then confirmed it a month later. All in all this is a very questionable and disturbing business practice. read more

Corey S.

1 year ago

Disappointing Dining Behind a Pretty Façade at Cowfish, Hampton Bays Cowfish may dazzle with its charming waterfront view and ambient coastal décor, but beyond the surface, the dining experience falls painfully short -- especially for the premium price point. We came in with high hopes, lured by the picturesque setting and refined atmosphere. Unfortunately, nearly every dish we ordered was an exercise in style over substance. The lobster-stuffed mushrooms ($18) arrived as four tiny mushroom caps, aggressively filled with breadcrumb-heavy stuffing that barely hinted at lobster -- more filler than flavor. This signature appetizers was a complete letdown. Despite the elaborate menu description, not a single bite truly delivered the taste of lobster. Any flavor that might have existed was drowned in an overabundance of sauces that masked rather than enhanced the seafood. We hoped to at least enjoy the half-dozen oysters, but they arrived disappointingly undersized, barely the diameter of a quarter. And the clam chowder -- more of a cold cup poured into a wide, shallow bowl -- barely had enough volume to coat the bottom. Served chilled (unintentionally, we presume), it lacked both depth and seasoning. Even our cocktails, which should've been a highlight in such a vibrant setting, tasted watered down -- one likely the victim of sitting too long over ice, and the other simply lacking punch. In the end, we paid $140 for what amounted to small portions of over-conceptualized, underwhelming dishes, dressed up in fancy language but lacking execution. It's clear Cowfish is banking on the view and vibe to justify their prices, not the food itself. A lovely setting can only carry an experience so far. Sadly, behind the beauty, Cowfish left us with nothing but disappointment and a lighter wallet. read more

Mayda D.

10 years ago

The scenery is gorgeous and that's why I gave two stars. I wish you could bring your own food and enjoy the scenery because take out food would definitely better than what they serve. The restaurant is very much bar oriented and it would be better to go there for drinks and a couple of simple appetizers. After an hour wait on a Thursday night my husband and I were seated at a bar area (even though we requested an outside table) with our backs to the nice scenery because we were seated in a booth. We were so hungry by then that we did not have the heart to object. The food was nothing special and our waitress ready to fall asleep on us. We ordered some sushi as an appetizer and it came without soy sauce and ginger. When we pointed that out to the sleepy waitress she just looked at us as if she didn't know what we were talking about. She finally understood and brought some ginger and soy sauce. We ordered the grilled halibut as an entrée which was pretty bland. Definitely not worth the wait. read more

Paul C.

6 years ago

Spectacular. Food and ambiance was on point. Tables indoors distanced perfectly. The food was a 12 out of 10 this restaurant deserves a Michelin Star. Ordered the Buffalo shrimp. Roasted garlic hummus. And roasted Brussel sprouts as starters for the table all exceeded expectations. Perfectly seasoned nicely balanced flavors super fresh. For Mains we tried the Specials of the Prime Rib, the Salmon of the day. And the diver scallops. When i say amazing i mean it the Scallops were HUGE and so tender. The salmon was fresh and flaky a nice belly portion not tail end inferior quality filet. And the Prime rib medium rare was so tender it could be cut with a spoon. For a finisher we ordered the Sorbet trio perfect for sharing. So delicious and creamy. The wine list and drink offerings were also definitely on par with some of the best. Overall Definitely reccomend going out of your way to visit this Hamptons gem!! read more

Laura Ann D.

11 months ago

We recently got married at Cowfish, and it was absolutely amazing! The venue hosted our outdoor ceremony, and everything from start to finish was handled with incredible care. Marinna and the entire staff were phenomenal -- their attention to detail during the setup, procession, cocktail hour, and dinner was truly five-star. My wife and I exchanged nearly 200 messages and had two in-person meetings with Marinna and the team, and through it all, they were patient, compassionate, and clearly dedicated to their work. We had an intimate wedding of about 70 guests, with a live guitarist and a photo booth, and everything went off without a hitch. Our guests couldn't stop raving about the beautiful location, the delicious food, and the friendly, capable staff. To all the Cowfish team -- thank you for making our wedding day so special. We can't wait to keep celebrating milestones with you in the years to come! read more

Mary V.

6 years ago

not even worth half a Star!!!! awful service.. waitress noooooo clue wtf she doing.. highly racist atmosphere!!!! Staff tried humiliate my black husband over his skin color. Deff a place where ALL CONFEDERATE FLAG FLYING WHITE SUPREMACISTS WELCOME!! I'm Anglo Saxon and it's not enough to be ashamed of my country and racial inequality but a paying Customer with plenty $$$,my husband was chased down over check as he tried use bathroom AND I WAS STILL at table full of food n drinks when they accused ONLY BLACK MAN IN SHITFISH of trying duck on piss ass check THAT WAS OVERCHARGING US FOR ITEMS WE NEVER ORDERED and had to send back!cowfish #BLM! .. anyone interested in peaceful protest against this joint?? read more

Nicole A.

9 years ago

SO Good! I have celiac disease and I rarely if ever eat out because I hate being "that person" always nit picking the menu options. But they are so helpful and don't make me feel bad for making changes to the order so I can feel safe about what I'm eating. Celiac or not, they have lots of options and every one is delicious! My husband and I love eating here. Even on nights I don't get back from work in time to cook dinner, we'll pick up dinner and it's always amazing. Definitely a must if you're looking for quality food in the area. SO glad I live right down the road :D -must try their Buffalo Shrimp appetizer! One of the best things on the menu. YUM! read more

Brad M.

8 years ago

I had dinner at Cowfish last night and I'd classify this place as an overpriced Applebee's. Service was amateurish, it was loud, tables are too small and seats are uncomfortable (think one step up from folding chairs). My biggest critique is about the "Feature Steak." I'm placing this steak as one of the bottom three steaks I've ever had in my life. It was supposed to be 16oz but realistically was about 12oz. It was one of the toughest, grizzly cuts of meat I've ever had. If I were the chef I'd be embarrassed to send this out especially at the Ruth Chris price tag of $58. If you go there stick to burgers and fries. read more

Foodie 7.

6 months ago

Ordered takeout from Cowfish in Hampton Bays after hearing a lot of great things. Unfortunately, it didn't live up to the hype. The food arrived in flimsy cardboard containers, portions were on the smaller side, and the overall quality was underwhelming. On top of that, a key item was missing from the order, which made the experience even more disappointing. Everything felt a bit careless and not worth the price point. Disappointing overall, likely my first and last time ordering. read more

Drew G.

9 years ago

The most unprofessional staff I have ever dealt with. The general manager was straight trash and should be replaced immediately. Will never go back to this establishment. Refused a 20 top that was reserved a month ago exactly, and made us wait almost 2 hours - just toying with us bc they didn't like the way we expressed our displeasure. The general manager is a miserable human being. No wonder he's a GM and making piss money. Clearly uneducated read more

Dee Y.

6 years ago

Good view and nice dining experience! Brought my toddler boy and my dad to this place in this new normal era. Cowfish tries everything to make the whole dining process easier and more sanitary. Reservation, large space between tables for social distancing, digital menu and all the staffs wear masks. It was a great pleasure to dine in there with nice view and warm service. Their food were okay, above average but not as good as what I expected. read more

Joe C.

9 years ago

This is a great spot. Came here with my kids and wife for dinner. They don't take reservations, so beware. But we still were able to get a table after about only 5 or 6 minutes. Rustic nautical vibe here and my wife loved the interior. The clam chowder was outrageous, would definitely recommend as well as the center cut filet. Location was really nice, my kids were taking their selfie photos by the water. read more

Bernadette M.

8 years ago

A few problems with reservations, but I have to admit we did make them last minute and invited an additional couple to join our party of four...or six! The food was varied and well presented. Our server knew her stuff, was overworked, but boy she had such a smile! Overall, a nice place to visit. It lacked a certain wow factor...but everyone at our table, was pleased with their choices! read more

Alex M.

11 years ago

The most beautiful place to have drink and food in hamptons. Even I have to wait for a long time to get a set in summer time, out door bar just giving us feel wonderful to hang out with friends. Also kids friendly and so cool to go their other restaurant Rumbar. I am so happy to leave in Hampton Bays and I can enjoy year round to go to great place. read more

Barbara M.

14 years ago

WE went here for dinner a few nights ago. What a delicious meal! The host and bartenders were gracious, the servers and bussers attentive. I had the cumin flavored mahi mahi and the fried oysters for an app. Perfectly seasoned and very nicely presented. Lots of outdoor seating available. Lovely view of the bay. read more

Jake B.

134

6 years ago

Service was great. Our food was out in under 10 minutes of ordering on a somewhat busy Friday night. The atmosphere is awesome as well. We ordered the Tuna and thought it was very good. The only thing I would recommend is having maybe more menu options. Overall I would return! read more

Kelly B.

Elite 21

366

1083

5 years ago

Such a beautiful restaurant can't beat the location and the view! Food is delicious and cocktails are a must. They have a great outside bar if your looking for a more layback area. Take a seat on the lawn and enjoy the view. Don't forget to visit the sister restaurant RUMBA! read more

Jessie F.

8 years ago

Very busy but the food was wellworth the wait. came here for brunch during my trip to hamptons. My husband and I both enjoyed it. Service wasn't as slow as I was expecting it to be given the number of people being served. I'll visit again next trip to the hamptons! read more

Erica S.

120

10 years ago

very nice and intimate atmosphere at night, has valet parking, the bar at night is very packed during the summer and takes a long time to get a drink, the bartenders tend to play favorites as well and only have one, or two at the most bartenders at a time read more

Charlie B.

8 years ago

Food OK, and service good, however the valet scratched my car, and the restaurant had the nerve to say that the valet is a hired company, baloney, you hired them, you are still responsible. Being a body and fender guy I fixed the scratch myself. read more

Cowfish - newamerican - Updated October 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of Hampton Bays, New York Restaurants near Cowfish

BEST of Hampton Bays, New York Cocktail Bars near Cowfish

BEST of Hampton Bays, New York Things to Do near Cowfish

BEST of Hampton Bays, New York Coffee near Cowfish

BEST of Hampton Bays, New York Desserts near Cowfish

BEST of Hampton Bays, New York Brunch near Cowfish

BEST of Hampton Bays, New York Breakfast near Cowfish

BEST of Hampton Bays, New York Shopping near Cowfish

BEST of Hampton Bays, New York Wineries near Cowfish

People found Cowfish by searching for…

Best of Hampton Bays

Things to do in Hampton Bays

Browse Brands

Brands by name

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed Cowfish also viewed

Sundays On The Bay

3.4

(248 reviews)

Waypoint Restaurant

3.7

(109 reviews)

A little out of the way, but this place was great!…read more Parking got a little tight, but the views were amazing. Docking is available, too bad I don't have a boat. The place is nice and spacious with an extensive outdoor seating area that extends to the water. The gracious and friendly staff greeted and led us to a great spot outside, right at the edge of the patio under the big tent. This gave us a great view of Mill Creek and the Peconic Bay We started off with some zucchini chips, and were given some olive tapenade with breadsticks and flatbread. These were very good. The Halibut and Surf n Turf specials we had were fantastic and perfectly prepared. The halibut was nice and chunky, and the filet+lobster tail were done just right. Every little bit of it was devoured, and left us no room for dessert. This wasn't too tragic since dinner was fantastic. This was a little far for us to drive for dinner, but we were heading to the Custer Institute afterwards despite the predicted cloudy skies and this made up for that.

Worth it for the on-the-water view where you can watch the boaters dock to eat here. But the food…read moreis good, too. And so are the imaginative summer cocktails. There's plenty of friendly staff and they are very attentive. We loved it.

Rumba

4.3

(950 reviews)

I been wanting to come here for years and I finally made it to Rumba! Was it worth the hype and was…read morethe food great? Absolutely yes, and the service and workers here are great. You walk in here and you feel like you're on an island. The food is cart bean inspired and just packing flavor and cooked with love. For appetizers we got the Dominican ribs and sriracha chicken wings! Both appetizers were out of this world. I got a variety of tacos that were awesome. My wife's sister's husband got a burger he loved and his wife got some type of a risotto dish. Everyone's food was great and the drinks were amazing as well. I really loved this place and look forward to coming back. Great place to play the bar and watch sports. They offer valet parking and it is located on shinecock bay with a beautiful view! Great place for summertime eats! I really loved this restaurant and look forward to coming back.

The ambience and the food was amazing The service was…read moreexcellent too. I would definitely recommend a spot.

The Halyard Greenport

3.3

(296 reviews)

Good food and service except for the awful french fries! How can a cook ruin such a simple item?…read more Pour an entire container of salt and pepper on them and expect people to try and eat them!

Beautiful view, friendly service and an excellent menu…read more Went for my birthday dinner. I had the Skate Shnitzel. Brilliant idea perfectly executed. My wife had the pasta, which was excellent. We skipped starters and ordered ALL of the side dishes. The sides stole the show. Every one, including the fries, could have severed as an entree for my vegetarian wife. (though I think there may be animal fat involved in cooking the fries. Dont tell her!) Definitely not the dreary, average place we remembered from years ago. The Halyard is a new instant favorite.

A Lure Restaurant Chowder House & Oysteria

3.6

(324 reviews)

A Lure provided a banquet dinner for a group of hungry sailors. Liz was patient and great to work…read morewith. Adam and his staff were efficient and the food was great! Thank you Nonsuch Rendezvous Committee

This place is fantastic. The best baked clams and seafood chowder…read more You have to try this place.

SALT Waterfront Bar & Grill

3.6

(223 reviews)

Food was decent. The biscuit with the fried chicken was exceptional. Service was spot on. Loved…read moreeating outside by the water.

Came here for lunch with my mom and 2 children. We had spicy margaritas and it was very good…read more The atmosphere was beautiful. Very cute and tucked away spot. The waitress was eh - she seemed to be in a bad mood. I ordered a cold lobster roll. There was no mayo. it seemed just like herbs and served cold. a lot of lobster but i wouldnt get it again. My moms warm lobster roll seemed to be the same thing as mine just heated up and not really any butter. I would go back to try something else or just for some drinks.

Southold Social

4.3

(59 reviews)

Awesome restaurant Farm fresh delicious food with superior…read moreservice we can't wait to go back

Had made a reservation for a nice dinner here and it's a great spot…read more We enjoyed the veggie options and the drinks. The atmosphere is elevated and a good crowd forms as the night rolls on. There's a lounge towards the back for music and dancing. Plenty of parking on site, great service, and great food! Happy we came!

Beacon

3.9

(130 reviews)

Talk about location!!! Beautiful view overlooking the harbor!…read more Went with my uncle and aunt for his birthday- what a great experience! Food was amazing- lobster rigatoni, mussels and fries, and an ice cream cookie for dessert! Waitstaff was helpful, prompt, and engaging. Met the owner David- he and his staff took wonderful care of us, and spent the time to chat up my uncle for his birthday! Can't wait to return to Sag Harbor and Beacon!

A room with a view, sensational food and superb service? I'll take it! Called for a rez…read more(recommended) and snagged a table on the same day for early dinner. Our server (sorry forgot his name) was genuinely friendly - a rarity in the Hamptons these days - and made great food recommendations. The restaurant is one flight up with indoor and outdoor seating, even our inside table offered fantastic water views. Shared an order of burrata (a special of the day) to start, thoroughly enjoyed the creamy globe of cheese resting on tricolor sauce with toast points. My bouillabaisse, comprised of a large lobster tail, clams, mussels, and white fish, was well spiced with a saffron-based broth and served up with butter-slathered toast to mop it all up. Yummy! Partner's lobster rigatoni was made with plenty of fresh lobster meat and a well flavored creamy sauce. He said it was filling and delicious. Excellent experience overall, would definitely return when in the area.

Minnow At The Galley Ho

3.7

(68 reviews)

Much of the value of this establishment is its peaceful and lovely setting and atmosphere…read more However the fresh caught big-eye tuna was excellent as was the horseradish infused mashed potato. The portion was substantial, so I didn't mind the high $$$. The service was also excellent. My only slight complaint was paying $8-9 for an iced coffee. It was excellent but even an expensive restaurant 8 bucks for coffee is a bit extreme! Highly recommended --- even if it it quite a bit off the beaten path.

I usually don't write reviews, but as a fellow hospitality worker, I was significantly disappointed…read morein our greeting and accommodation last night. My sisters and I, party of 3, were celebrating my sister's bachelorette weekend, did my research early July and was beyond excited to dine here. We had a 715 reservation on the patio, it was starting to drizzle around 615 when we left our house. We arrived at the restaurant at 705 and the host checked the weather and said it will stop shortly, we were fine even if we had to wait 20 mins + ;the weather was out of their control. Then she says, "yeah it's not stopping, you should go across the street our sister restaurant". And my sister, also industry and bride to be asked if there was a way to move inside even with a wait or accommodate and the host said, "no we're booked." Which was disheartening bc I don't think her or I have ever turned away a guest and encouraged them to leave- even since we were on time, early may I add, to a reservation we had for a month! When I asked what the cuisine was across the street her response, " oh burrata, fish, some of the same fish from here and you'll definitely be able to get in". So I asked if it was like Italian/American.. she didn't really give great feedback. I have been a chef for 13 years and I would have loved to support what they are doing and was eagerly anticipating this dining experience. I genuinely hope to dine here at some point in the future. But this did leave a negative impact

Page Sag Harbor

3.7

(267 reviews)