A little out of the way, but this place was great! Parking got a little tight, but the views were amazing. Docking is available, too bad I don't have a boat. The place is nice and spacious with an extensive outdoor seating area that extends to the water. The gracious and friendly staff greeted and led us to a great spot outside, right at the edge of the patio under the big tent. This gave us a great view of Mill Creek and the Peconic Bay We started off with some zucchini chips, and were given some olive tapenade with breadsticks and flatbread. These were very good. The Halibut and Surf n Turf specials we had were fantastic and perfectly prepared. The halibut was nice and chunky, and the filet+lobster tail were done just right. Every little bit of it was devoured, and left us no room for dessert. This wasn't too tragic since dinner was fantastic. This was a little far for us to drive for dinner, but we were heading to the Custer Institute afterwards despite the predicted cloudy skies and this made up for that. read more

See all

Great food, great views excellent service. We look forward to coming back for another wonderful meal. It is then when hidden gem! read more

Waypoint Restaurant - Seafood Near Me - Southold, New York

We had a great experience at Wayfair on Fathers Day. Our waitress Jeanine was very attentive. We were told on arrival that there would be a slight delay on the food which was greatly appreciated. We sat at the edge of the patio on a beautiful day. We ordered drinks and in a short time we were able to order our food. Everything was delicious. We not only enjoyed our food but THE VIEW is amazing. We came with our son and daughter in law for their first time and they loved it too! Can't wait to go back! read more

The best spot to eat on the water in Southold, and it pulls a perfect 5 stars for the service, entertainment, environment, and food. The weather was gorgeous, they had live music by the water with a very talented musician singing covers too. The drinks were well made and the server was very attentive, checking on us all the time if we needed anything, always refilling water and to be of service. The oysters were fresh and delicious, the Fish and Chips was also good, not too deeply fried. The Tuna Sandwhich was really good too, fresh fish and filling. Wonderful spot for the summer, 5 stars! read more

Waypoint Restaurant - Fresh Oysters - Seafood Near Me - Southold, New York

The food was horrible. My fluke was not seared - it was mushy. The puree on the plate was ice cold and the parsley puree was disgusting. My 3 stalks of roasted broccolini was the high point. Not going back. read more

If you drive by quickly, you will miss waypoint restaurant,from the corner of my eye while driving I saw people sitting out on the point by the water, so i turned around and gave it a shot, from the quality of the cars in the parking lot I could tell off the bat, It was a high-end restaurant walked in got a table and we're surrounded by water, wealthy patrons and plenty of boats from the Hamptons even got a glimpse of the celebrity. Brooke shields was having lunch. We sat for 15 minutes and no one came to our table. Finally, an owner or a manager asked if we were being helped and I said no , a waitress came over took our order and the food was mid. The octopus was served cold and tiny little pieces mixed with salad I've never seen a grilled lemon That was ice cold on top of the salad before ,the food almost came out too quickly as if the dishes were premade in the fridge, the crowd is pretentious, even though the restaurant is pretty I thought it would be a lot better, but I don't think I will be coming back read more

See all

What a gem. Still a little early in the season so it was fairly easy to get a reservation at our preferred time. The food was spectacular so we decided to share a few appetizers and the main. The blackfish was a special and not being a huge fan of fish I was so excited to realize how great it tasted. Pricey but all the restaurants "out East" are comparable with nyc prices. The view compensates and so does the lovely atmosphere and I'm definitely a fan. read more

See all

Bitter sweet review. I always thought highly of this hidden gem. Just want to submit a current review. Beautiful location on the water. The service lacked. My party of three waited at a table for quite some time. We had to go sit at the bar for service. Complicated menus. There is a pre 4 0'clock lunch menu. A four to five menu and an after five dinner menu. We were there at 3:50 thus ordering was a bit complicated. One would expect to have higher prices on an upscale waterside restaurant. The food did not live up to the price. We all had the pasta seafood dish. Told it would be served with linguine bucatini came out instead. The pasta was properly al dented but did not seemed married to the watery sauce. No black cracked pepper was available. It was a minor ordeal to get grated cheese. . I had an empty glass sitting in front of me for most of my time. They missed out of a couple more drinks on my bill. Twenty dollar drinks and forty five dollar plates. They have the nerve to charge a credit card processing fee on the bill. The music was suitable for the background. Disco Techno garbage. Played too loud. Doubtful that I will return anytime soon. read more

Waypoint Restaurant - Seafood Near Me - Southold, New York

See all

A wonderful dinner by the water at Waypoint Restaurant. After cocktails, we started with tuna crudo, a roast artichoke salad, and a grilled octopus salad, followed by the catch of the day, striped bass. For dessert, almond tiramisu and a pistachio cake. Everything was absolutely delicious! read more

See all

We rolled up on our boat like we've been doing for years, and it's been such a joy watching Waypoint grow in popularity. The food has always been amazing fresh, creative, and consistently delicious. But this year, something else stood out even more: our server, William. From the very beginning, he made us feel like family. He carried himself with the kind of ease and expertise you'd expect from someone who's trained at a top restaurant (I can't remember if he said Eleven Madison Park or another Michelin-star spot, but either way, it showed!). William guided us through the menu. He suggested the perfect wine pairings for each course he knew the highlights of the menu inside and out, and truly elevated the entire dining experience. Every recommendation hit the mark. We've had many great nights here over the years, but this one stands out as the best yet not just for the incredible food and music, but for the outstanding service William provided. Waypoint is lucky to have him on their team, and we can't wait to come back for another evening like this! We only have a few more weeks left until we have to put the boat in for the season but we will make sure to stop back! read more

Pros The Halibut special was delicious ($55)! The hostess was patient and very helpful. Our reservation was for 7pm. When we arrived early, she was able to seat us right away. We had to change tables 3x because of how chilly & windy it was. We sat by a window which was very nice. Cons Our waiter seemed checked out. We felt rushed whenever he came around which made it difficult to relax. One of the dishes was well below what other reviews have stated. The desert was dry and cold. The sides were just okay. Summary I recommend Waypoint because it is a beautiful setting and the Halibut was so good ($55). The hostess and manager (Chris) were terrific. The waiter did come around towards the end of the meal. Too little too late? Perhaps. Hopefully this will be received with the intent it is being written- to help enable decision makers to implement strategies to make a very good restaurant even better. The secret (sauce) is in the details, every detail. read more

Waypoint has some undeniable strengths--the drinks are excellent, and the food is well-prepared. But let's be honest: $600 for a meal for four people is pretty hard to justify, especially when you're being told the red snapper is locally caught in Long Island Sound (which it absolutely isn't--red snapper doesn't live anywhere near here). For that price, you'd expect not only top-quality ingredients but also complete transparency about where your food comes from. The atmosphere and service were solid, but nothing about the experience warranted such an inflated bill. If you don't mind splurging--and don't mind a little creative storytelling about seafood sourcing--you might still enjoy it. Otherwise, you can find better value elsewhere. read more

Waypoint Restaurant - A drunk lady and a espresso - Seafood Near Me - Southold, New York

The food is delicious. The ambience is absolutely beautiful, sit outside under the canopy and watch the million dollar boats pull into this gorgeous spot. The branzino is always fabulous. The New England clam chowder is excellent . The mussels are the best , and the charred octopus with artichokes hits the spot every time. The wait staff are very accommodating. For the reviewers who are complaining of the cost, you saw the menu before coming, you see the prices, why post a negative review about the prices? You can sit here and enjoy a 3 million dollar view for a price of a $27 fish and chips. read more

The ambience was wonderful. Sunset on the water - beautiful. The service was a bit lacking. The waiter made it seem like we were imposing on him by being there. Most of the mask was good. But, I had the tuna crude which was fairly tasteless and overpowered by the chipotle aioli and the filet mignon special. For $70, I expected it to be cooked properly (med rare) and the vegetables to be more than lukewarm. I had to add salt to everything to get it to taste okay and left half the steak uneaten. When we received the check, there was a $10 credit card fee added. They never said that we needed to be prepared with $400+ cash for the meal to avoid the charge. For a restaurant with these prices it I'd ludicrous to charge a fee for using a credit card. It's only ten bucks but absolutely makes certain we will never return and won't be recommending to our friends. read more

What a great spot-we loved our meal-phenomenal service and atmosphere were also top notch! We will be back!

Atmosphere by the bay makes this place a try BUT sorry once and done for me...here for lunch...food very marginal, expensive ...$40 lobster roll...and slow service. You must use better beef for your $28 burger ...$28 tuna appetizer had 4 thin slices of tuna over wontons...see ya! read more

The star is for the service and atmosphere. We almost turned around after pulling up to a very unassuming restaurant exterior. I was pleasantly surprised to be walked though a beautiful dining room. This restaurant transports you to the Florida Keys. A lot of the crowd hopping off a boat for lunch, it's very scenic. Our server was welcoming, attentive and kept a smile. The food however was borderline disrespectful. The fish and chips I had was awful. I couldn't eat it. Imagine a flavorless cod, coated in a funnel cake batter, underdone, without a sprinkle of salt. The moment I saw the color of the fish as the server brought it out, I knew it would bad. To make matters worse, it was served with cold, stale fries. The lobster roll was skimp, burnt, and also served with cold, stale fries. It's a shame because everything BUT the food were makings of a great restaurant experience. read more

Waypoint Restaurant - Lobster roll - Seafood Near Me - Southold, New York

See all

One of the best spots on Southold Bay for the view alone. it's quite pricey though $25 for a Makers Mark and club soda?! Really? $24 for meatball appetizer (Delicious, but very expensive). They are obviously catering to the very wealthy boaters who pull up to the dock. Service was very good, wish I could afford to return, but, nope. read more

A friend recommended the spot. 25 min drive from Aquebogue home, not bad. So worth the the lil drive. Restaurant is on the water, beautiful view. We had Janine as our waitress and she was a sweetheart. The espresso martinis were delicious and they let me substitute it with Casa Migos ! So I was very pleased! Meatballs are the bomb!!! Clam chowder flavorful. The special are delicious and lobster ravioli is yummy! We'll coming back for more and bringing loved ones as well. read more

See all

We went for a July 4th early dinner. The service was fantastic, the food was delicious, the drinks were yummy, the atmosphere to die for. There was live music, which was nice. We had a wonderful time. We will definitely be back. We had the octopus appetizer, the gemelli pasta, the shrimp with buccatini, the caprese appetizer and fries. For drinks we had the watermelon martini, watermelon margarita, and spicy margarita. So so yummy!!!! read more

Atmosphere is great, beautiful view but the service was pretty terrible. Took a half hour just to get a check and when it arrived most of it was wrong. Really sad considering how beautiful the location was. read more

Beautiful restaurant, gorgeous view. Ate before the rush on Thursday of 4th of July weekend, because we are smart, lol. Ate at outside bar, bartender and barback gave great service. Drinks were perfect. Oysters great, raw clams could have been better, plumper , fresher. Mussels appetizer was delicious. Burger was just right and husband liked the clam chowder. Would recommend, don't go tonight, lol read more

I had a lovely birthday lunch here last week. Unfortunately it may have been a one off. My husband had lunch there today and he ordered me the Octopus salad to bring home. I was not happy to see there was maybe three tiny slices of Octopus total. I believe in notifying a business if something is less than satisfactory. I spoke to the manager who was too busy & really unconcerned about what I had to say. "I will look into it" was all she could muster and just barely. Nice views and top prices. Don't bother. read more

What an incredible restaurant!!! More like a whole experience!!! The atmosphere is phenomenal !! Coupled with a view second to none, amazing live music, absolutely delicious food - I can't even find words to describe!!! The owner truly aims to please!! We came for our mom's 80th birthday and we honestly can't wait to come back!! THANK YOU for e truly memorable experience we will never forget!! read more

Delightful, if pricey, place!!! Fresh seafood, dietary restriction met with ease. Could not have been a better meal for our family!

We came here for a wedding brunch. The food was good, but the view was even better! It was right on the water! There was drinks and a breakfast buffet ready for the wedding guests. What a fun way to end a wedding celebration! read more

Waypoint Restaurant - Seafood Near Me - Southold, New York

food was good. service was the worst i've ever experienced. my boyfriend ordered a tito's and coke and the waiter laughed at him. the dude all around was just being an ass. then i hear him saying to another waitress that he chases people down when he doesn't get a good tip. read more

Steer clear of this restaurant. The staff ruins the experience of a beautiful view and decent food. They are catty, talk poorly and mock customers in their clear view. Fortunately wasn't done to me. There are not enough poor things to be said about the staff and the service. It was as if they have nothing better to do the try to ruin people's day. read more

$24 for a 3 meatball appetizer? $36 for half roasted chicken? In the words of our bumbling leader: "Come on man!"

Phenomenal evening here with friends. The location is really quite remarkable. So close to the water that at high tide it nearly kisses your toes. The views of Jennings Point & Kissing Rock, on Shelter Island, were spectacular. The restaurant looks recently updated, well kept & clean. The service was lovely; attentive and friendly. Nothing snooty about this place. There's a great outdoor bar area & plenty of indoor and outdoor seating. We sat at a table by the water and the food was really very good. Not sure why I was surprised, but seriously, this chef, Matt, is excellent. Pasta dishes were perfectly seasoned & not over-sauced. Who makes a light bucatini dish? This place :) My friends were delighted by the Halibut & chicken as well. I'll be going back again soon & I will post more pictures of the restaurant itself. Go check it out! You will not be disappointed. Update: went back with my husband & son tonight. Blown away again! Excellent. Made resi for Tuesday night. Hopefully Hurricane Henri is kind to NoFo & everyone survives largely unscathed. read more

See all

Although the food is decent, it's overpriced and service is borderline awful, the only thing going for it is the view. Manager Therese is unbelievably rude, un accommodating and totally foreign to the concept of customer service let alone care. So many lovely places on the North Fork to go to, this is not worth your time and money. read more

Nice outdoor area, service is slow and due to that the food came out barely warm. Saturday evening, no specials at all, Limited menu and quite pricey for the food. Disappointing and certainly not worth the cost. read more

So we truly love a lot about this place HOWEVER, I don't think I can go back there again if they continue to hire a DJ! I have nothing against DJ's but he clearly doesn't have a mix that is suitable for the NOFO dinner crowd. Way tooooooo loud and way too much bass. From our seats we can tell he was having fun but I personally witnessed people asking the staff to have the music lowered. Nothing changed during our 1.5 hour visit. What a shame because the food is decent and the view is amazing. Not a cheap place to eat I only wish I could have a conversation during dinner. read more

Our meal was delicious at waypoint, our server was friendly and attentive. The only downside was that we were sitting in an enclosed "outdoor " area and it was very loud and hard to talk to table mates, it was also a bit chilly because it was so windy outside... but it was our choice to sit there so no fault of the restaurant. Not a cheap night by any means but the food and drinks were great. read more

A little pricey but good food. Service was mediocre. Nice view and location. Good drinks.

While the food is a little pricey the view is priceless. Tasty offerings, mostly seafood, but a good variety. Service was good as well. Would return especially on a nice summer night when we can sit on the covered deck and enjoy the view. read more

See all

One of the pleasures of Long Island is being able to stop and enjoy fabulous cuisine wherever you go. Waypoint did not disappoint. From the moment we walked in, we were greated by a courteous maitre-a-dee and immediately introduced to the manager, Chris Campbell. We were a little early for our reservation so he offered to sit us at the outside bar. Our bartender, Adam, made us very tasty margaritas. The view from our table was so picturesque which was in sync with a crystal clear afternoon. Our smiling server, Kathy, readily took our orders for appetizers and the main meals and were delivered within minutes. I can't talk enough about the food which was beautifully presented and unbelievably delicious followed by equally fabulous dessert. Overall a truly pleasant and enjoyable afternoon and evening which ended with sitting around the fire pit enjoying after dinner drinks and a cigar. A must stop if you're in Southold. read more

See all

A wonderful day trip was made assume at our stop for lunch at the Waypoint. Great location, nice water views and a staff that was spectacular. The moment we came felt like old friends. My wife had a beet salad and I had the fish and chips. Now let me stop there. This was the best fish and chips I have ever tasted. The batter on the cod was so light and crunchy I just have to rave about it. My orders came with French Frys that were were also over the top. You can tell that the kitchen staff is right on their game. Had post and suggest that if you are near this place stop in and enjoy read more

Beautiful location and the food tho pricey was delicious. Service attentive tho a bit slow but the place was packed on a gorgeous Saturday eve. The fire pit tables were a nice touch after dark. They did have the biggest American flag Ive ever seen at a restaurant lol. read more

The setting is quintessential North Fork with outside dining on the water. We have been here three times in the past 6 weeks. The staff are pleasant and hard working, and have gotten our orders correct every time. The octopus in the appetizer was not especially tender. The mussels however were superb. We have gotten the peach caprese salad twice. It is delicious but the peaches were a little underripe the second time we ordered it. The poached fluke was really delicious--moist and tender with a flavorful sauce. The non fish-eater in our group loved the roast chicken. The halibut special was disappointing. The portion was generously sized but the fish was tough and disappointing. The $45 price made this especially (pun intended) hard to swallow. Prices have been heading up on the North Fork. Ultimately I am not sure this restaurant is worth the expense for dinner. Maybe we will try again for lunch. Pros: setting, some excellent dishes Cons: price, some mediocre dishes read more