Always clean and welcoming. Hands down the best meatball parm wedge I've had ! Lots of special pizzas to choose from too & single slices always fresh too . read more

The boneless buffalo chicken... BRUH! and the Reese's pie. Amazing! I loved the pizza too, but the Chicken...Bruh!

Pizza tastes amazing, but the atmosphere was super unprofessional and the things being talked about were inappropriate for customers to be listening to as they sit in the waiting room. read more

It's sad when there's more chicken on one slice of pizza then a whole chicken sub (when the sub is three times the price) I put the whole sub onto the one half it was cut into. I had half of just a sub roll with nothing on it on my plate and the waitress handed me aluminum foil to wrap it up. I said no thank you there barely anything on the sub so I just put it on all into one half. Instead of apologizing or even attempting to fix anything she just stood there laughed and walked away. I didn't try the pizza but everyone else was saying that wasn't even that great. read more

Pizza was so undercooked and it was probably the worst two slices of pizza I've ever had. They are not very nice either. I had to cook it in my own oven for another r20 minutes Ridiculous read more

We ordered 2 pizzas tonight and have to say they were the worst we have ever had! Save your money, sauce on it was absolutely terrible!

The pizza here is good but the service is bad ordered a slice of pizza and when we got there it was not even cooked plus they made us wait around 20 minutes for one slice of pizza over all 1 star read more

Bad stuff. Flies on the not so great reheated food. Terrible rude service. They refused to give us tap water. They said they only sold water. It's not free. One of us took three plastic cups for the water that they had to purchase. The waitress rushed over to say no plastic cups. Those are "special" for other drinks. She started to take it away. Then she changed her mind. Said she couldn't take it back as we had touched it. When one of us asked for utensils. Four of us had pizza. Two had eggplant parmigiana. She asked how many of us were eating before she gave us the cheap plastic. When it was time to pay there was an extra $0.75 on the tab. When asked she said it was for ranch dressing. None of us had ranch dressing. She apparently mistook the Parmesan cheese for dressing. The bill also included $1.75 for the 3 plastic cups. I said they only cost about five cents each and offered her 15 cents. She wouldn't budge. We asked for the owner and was told he'd be back Thursday What a nightmare. Was it because we had 3 children with us. Or because five of us were Asian We will never know. We left with a bad taste in our mouths. From the food. And the sourpuss way we were treated. read more

Cousin's has been a staple in Wingdale and Dover for many years. I have been a customer for 10+ years and it is always a great experience. Great food and great service. You can't go wrong ordering here. read more

I don't think I ever had anything I did not like here. One time we ordered a veggie pizza with artichokes - I was surprised at how good it was. The salads that come with dishes could be a little bigger/better. read more

I come here out of convenience bc it's close, but every time I get take out it takes way too long and some thing is usually missing and I have to wait even longer read more

My friends and I were looking for a local pizza place to have a quick dinner before 1.5 hour ride back to NYC. We came across Cousin's Pizza and dropped in. It has 3-4 booths for 4 people and 2 tables so I can't imagine having more 20 people in the restaurant with ample space for everyone. We ordered garlic bread with cheese, tomato basil soup, French onion soup, onion rings, chicken Parmesan, a slice of white pizza, and two bottles of Pepsi and root beer. I started getting excited because garlic bread with cheese was amazing as well as the soups. The portions are big as well. The server attended us frequently and I loved the entire experience. The reason why I'm giving 4 out of 5 stars is because of chicken Parmesan - I considered it to be too basic. I wish there was an option for 4.5 stars! read more

See all

We ordered a large pie fried clams that came with french fries which were burnt and the french fries were soggy and disgusting ordered a fried calzone which was nothing but go on the inside again disgusting when I returned to the store because this was a pickup to eat at home they refused to give me any type of refund or even acknowledge that the food wasn't cooked correctly are you still enjoy this place I will never go back it's disgusting read more

Still the best. I try to stop here every time I come to town. YELP wants me to keep writing so let me say this again,,, good, good,,,,,,,,

Calamari was actually not edible. Wings were literally the size of my thumb. Pizza was only ok. Very disappointing.

Besides one of the women who take orders, well there food is absolutely amazing and their delivery drivers are polite and very courteous. Rock solid food for the area!!! read more

WARNING This is not the coal fired pizza place! That is Cousin's Cafe! We got a speciality pie, BBQ chicken pie and 1/2 dozen garlic knots. Absolutely terrible! The knots came in like a soup and the pizza was gross! I asked for well done, I got a soggy mess. I don't know how this place is still open. Don't get, this is not how pizza should be. read more

Just moved here from Philadelphia and had pizzas that were great. Ordering meatball parm and veal parm platters tonight.

The place has become dirty. The staff doesn't wash their hands. Food is not temperature regulated well which is not good for bacteria growth. read more

Everything I've had there is always delicious. The soups are especially good. I like the meatballs a lot too.

if you ever get into a fight with the owner, fake him out with the left and give him a quick knee to the chest. the guy is a sucker. FUCK YOU GINO !!!- DB read more

Awfulllll pizza! Ordered a large buffalo chicken pizza got 13 small chucks of chicken and paid $24 for it!!!! So disappointing and it had no buffalo flavor. Huge waste of money read more

Stopped in yesterday after driving by then circling around to go back. Tried the bianco pizza with pepperoni. We will definitly go back. Even today's left over slices were good reheated. Crust thin and crispy, plenty of cheese and a nice garlicy olive oil underlay. Very friendly staff! read more

Love Doug and all the staff here!! Amazing honey BBQ wings (best I've ever had) and a killer grilled chicken salad :)

We have been going to Cousin's Pizza and bakery for several years, mostly for breakfast. We've always like the place for the very friendly service. Something has changed about the place. During our last few visits we weren't treated as friendly as before and the breakfast experience wasn't very good either. Today was definitely the worst. The breakfast wasn't done to our request, it simply sucked. That has happened before too. But the previous friendly treat at least helped to forget that. It seems like since Lori left, things are not the same! The stuff was very cold, impersonal , no care at all. We're very disappointed and won't be going back. To bad, we really liked that place! read more

We were just passing by and wanted a few slices to go. My husband got two eggplant slices with pepppers and onions. That was good. He chose for me two plain slices with "chicken". It was all different types of chicken and it all smelled weird. Some of the "chicken" i couldn't even chew. It was disgusting. For 4 slices he was charged $15 which is crazy. Will never go back. read more

This place is so cheap with their toppings, it's almost laughable. I've ordered many times from them and once got a salad pizza with small pieces of disgusting lettuce, a few olives, cooked with cheese. As for my Husbands favorite pizza - BBQ chicken - well their bbq pizza has such small pieces of chicken on it, you can barely tell it's chicken. The bread tastes like it's frozen and thawed out. I also met someone that used to work there as a cook recently and she said that their food is kept at unsafe temperatures, and that food is sometimes cooked / fried, and then unfrozen for quick access later on. It makes sense because their food tastes kinda reheated sometimes. Save yourself food poisoning and put your money to good use and go to COUSINS CAFE. They are the ONLY good pizza place in Wingdale / DP. read more

Good food, friendly service. We are repeat customers, one of the better places around.

FANTASTIC hot wings and pizza. The pizza actually has flavor compared to pizza express. Definitely go to cousins. And make sure it's cousins pizza in the plaza not the one down the road!!! read more

I had the chicken wings a couple of years ago and they were delicious, but the wings themselves were incredibly tiny. So recently I decided to try the JUMBO chicken wings and they were indeed much bigger. However, it was plain to see that they had premade these things who knows how long before and just warmed them up. What little sauce was there was only on the bottom, it had long dripped off the wings themselves. It had been stored so long the sauce had separated into half-sauce and half-grease. If they had bothered to open the container and look they would have seen that these wings were unfit to serve. Dry wings and nearly no (disgusting separated) sauce. When a restaurant has so little respect to serve something like this for nearly $10 I take it almost as a personal insult. I won't be back. read more

Definitely a better place than the Wingdale Deli Express. And not over-priced. Their pizza is great, their onion rings are not over-fried or greasy and the people there are a lot friendlier than at the Deli Express. I highly recommend this place if you don't want to spend a lot of money and you still want really good food. read more