I came here last wk for my friends early birthday dinner and we absolutely loved the food. I only gave a 4 star only bc the space is a bit tight and they make you wait outside until your table is ready. we ordered the following: costicine di maiale ( pork) crostini di pulpo ( octopus) costicine di agnello ( lamb chops) read more

Great local spot on a tree-lined West Village block has outside seating. Great pasta with seafood. Friendly staff knows their wine and there's lots of it! read more

Craving Italian food, Basque-owned bar provided the best meal/ experience of the day. I have to say I walked in hungry, yet I don't think that has me exaggerating the quality of the experience, knowing it could. The space is small yet not crowded with tables and spacious tiled, bar space. The owner greeted me with a warm hello as I walked through the door and encouraged me to take a seat at the bar. He tells everyone who approaches a table, "that's your seat" in the most welcoming tone. The special of lasagna was what I was craving. I also eyed the loaf of bread on the counter and enjoyed a lightly toasted piece to finish off the sauce. The lasagna was creamy and savory, and with a lovely ring of tomato sauce and basil drops. I like lots of sauce so the owner brought me a side dish. Around me were many pleasant conversations, none of which were overpowering in the small space. I'm.l not sure how the sound would be during the dinner hour. I'll def visit again for another weekend adventure. Delicious! read more

See all

Came here for dinner with a friend, very small high quality Italian restaurant in Fidi. I liked that considerably it was cheaper than most Italian places in NYC. I got the lobster ravioli which was delicious but there was a lot of other stuff that also looked yummy on the menu. Friend and I shared the burrata which was also very good. Pinning this as a great Italian spot, service was good and prices were good. read more

Cotenna - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

Cotenna is now offering pizza nextdoor and it's called Briciola. We ordered for our group today and unfortunately, no one was pleased with it. The dough was undercooked, they forgot to add parmesan on top and for the bresaola topping - they give you 3 small 1/4th slices (exactly 3) for the entire pizza so the majority of the pizza doesn't have the topping. So, not only was the dough not cooked properly (you can see in the pics that it's under which is why it didn't puff up) and it wa a lack of toppings, but when we called, we didn't get any follow up. We wanted to love their new pizza offerings but unfortunately, it's a no go. read more

See all

Cruising the streets at 6pm and found this restaurant, luckily they had two seats at the window, looking out to the street. My son and I had the dinner special, shrimp and crab pasta and a bottle of Gavi. Amazing fresh hand made food, highly recommend this restaurant. read more

See all

The best meal we had in New York City. Based on prior reviews, we ordered: - the octopus salad: grilled octopus in well balanced salad with nice flavours - lamb chops: absolutely bomb. Perfectly cooked with flavours that seep through - the best lamb I've had in a while - truffle gnocchi: decadent, a bit heavy for one person but perfect for sharing - tagliatelle bolognese: excellent complexity and depth of flavour to the sauce Overall everything was absolutely delicious. It's a cute and cozy spot, good for a date or intimate gathering with friends. Service was very good. Will happily return next time I'm in NYC! read more

Cotenna - Truffle gnocchi, Grilled Octopus Salad, Tagliatelle Bolognese, lamb chops - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

I went here for dinner to catch up with a friend. It's a cute small vibe with incredible food and service. The waiters checked in on us regularly, and knew what to recommend. We got burrata to start with. It was one of the creamiest burrata I've had. I got the bolognese and my friend got the gnocchi. I am definitely coming back! read more

Cotenna - Burrata - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Better than most pasta. These dishes as takeout were better than half the sit down dine in pasta I've had in this city, if that alone doesn't deserve a high rating I don't know what does. The bolognese and the broccoli rabe n sausage orchiette were both stellar. I will definitely be in to experience the restaurant soon. read more

Cotenna - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Small, hole in the wall restaurant. I love the octopus salad dressing and the mounds of microgreens were fresh. Well deserving of a Michelin bib gourmand read more

Cotenna - Grilled Octopus Salad - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

I had a great time dining alone at the bar. I thought the food was excellent and I appreciated the wine selection. Fine service and it definitely started to get busy as I left and it's quite a small space read more

Cotenna - BIETOLE e CAPRINO - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Disclaimer: This review is all about the Aperol Spritz which was perfectly made! Five stars spritz and a quick glance at a menu that didn't seem to contain a single plant-based option. I kept thinking this is the perfect spot for an aperitivo but even the snacky section of the menu is very meat and cheese-focused. I've been to Italy many times and I'm always able to find something at aperitivo time, so it is a little disappointing, I cannot lie. While I doubt I'd return to eat, I can't help but think I'd gladly duck in again for a spritz. It's a lovely rustic space and sitting at the window with (or without) a good friend while looking out at a West Village street is sometimes all you need in life. read more

Small place in west village Had reservations but asked if we wanted to sit at the bar Hostess started the meal in negative fashion since restaurant was pretty empty Ordered tagliatelle octopus salad and tuna tartare All pretty good 8/10 considering price Just felt a bit rushed through it all No bread service - kind of odd If on a budget decent place but much better Italian restaurants in the city read more

See all

One of hidden gems of west village side of things. I only discovered spot from my co-worker when we had our offices around the corner. The lunch specials were spot on; pasta was always on point. Staff amazingly generous and nice. Always good place to go for dinner/lunch. Highly recommend read more

Cotenna - Garlic shrimp - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Great little Italian wine bar and Italian spot in the West Village! We got in as a walk in on the Sat after V-Day but got the corner seats at the bar, which we didn't mind. But probably best to make a reservation. We each got our own quartino of wine (glass and a half) and shared the kale and pecorino salad and the tagliatelle bolognese. Both delicious and definitely recommend. I think you're supposed to get bread but they must have missed us. We didn't need it anyway. Great spot for a date or a more intimate spot to get together with a friend. read more

Cotenna - Tagliatelle Bolognese - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

I discovered this place last night on Bedford after going to Film Forum. I never think to look at what's around the corner from the theatre, but several great options open late-ish on a Saturday night. We sat near the doorway: the tables were otherwise pretty crowded together inside. There's seating outside as well. My friend and I shared the goat cheese and beet salad. It was very good: lots of beets. My friend ordered the Bolognese and enjoyed that. I had the hand-rolled gnocchi. I thought the tomato sauce could have used some kick. I added ground pepper to give the dish a little more flavour. Good service and a pretty large menu for a relatively small place. I'll be back go try some other dishes. read more

Everything here was delicious! It is a very intimate restaurant. It seems like a really nice place to have a date night or a small girls night. The waitress was also really sweet and tentative to us especially since we were a larger party. All of us loved each dish that we got, including all of the appetizers and the dessert. The drinks were also really strong and tasted really delicious. I would come again if given the chance :) read more

Cotenna - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

Lovely corner spot! They have many different sister restaurants throughout the city but their pastas and pizzas are uncomplicated and delicious. You can always expect a warm comforting meal here. read more

Really this is a 4.5 because of affordability; for a WV pasta spot to all be sub $20 is fantastic. It's a small charming venture, usually you don't need a reservation but it isn't big so doesn't hurt to make one. The bruschetta was pretty simple but oh boy, that cheese was delicious. The pasta dishes we got were solid; not really wowing but I was pleased with the quality of a quick neighbourhood spot. I probably wouldn't itch to come back here, but it's just a convenient cheap nice going out meal so it can be added to the rotation! read more

Cotenna - BRUSCHETTA ai FUNGHI e MONTASIO - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

We had reservations and waited about 5 minutes before we were seated. The space is super tight but gives a cozy feel. Without hesitation we jumped right into it . For appetizers started with the crab cakes and the mushroom bruschetta. Both dishes were very tasty, and delicious. For our main, the lobster risotto and the truffle gnocchi which was their signature dish was sooo delicious!....very rich and flavorful Everything was bursting with flavor. The wine was also fantastic .the server knew the menu well and was very attentive. Had an excellent time ! Will definitely revisit! read more

See all

Probably acceptable as a wine bar but as an Italian restaurant this is pretty low on the proverbial neighborhood totem pole. Space is tiny and cramped. Branzino good for the price. Black truffle gnocchi uses jarred truffles or something, was not happy with it at all. read more

Cotenna - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Save yourself the food poisoning and terrible service. Mussels were overcooked and shouldn't be on the menu if they are going to be served cold or tough. Server misunderstood eggplant as lamb chops, and then insisted I ordered lamb. Not sure why this spot exists in NYC given all of the amazing food elsewhere. read more

Hands down the best black truffle gnocchi I've ever had - seriously creamy and cheesy, paired with wine it's perfect! The ambiance is small and intimate - so an ideal girls night spot! read more

Cotenna - Truffle gnocchi - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

There was a mixup with our reservation last night, but thankfully they were still able to accommodate us in their outdoor street-eatery. It's worth noting that tables both inside and outside are quite close to one another - but that's New York! Nothing on the regular on the menu was more than $16! Things on the specials board didn't have prices; the Gnocchi Tartufo ended up being $24 but the creamy truffle sauce was delicious! My husband's Orecchiette with Sausage and Broccoli Rabe was also very good. Portion sizes are decent - we could've had a starter and / or dessert as well, but we were headed to an event with more food afterwards. read more

Cotenna - Orecchiette with sausage and broccoli rabe - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Cotenna serves reliable Italian dishes and located at Bedford street near the sixth avenue. We came here during COVID when at the time NYC law restricted capacity to 50% indoor dining. They have many seating options here aside from their main tiny restaurant, they have outdoor dining on both sides of the street. Upon check in, we were lead to an annex restaurant across the street. We felt comfortable dining indoor since there were only four tables inside the unit. We started our dinner with gamberi e Aglio e olio; shrimp scampi on garlic and olive oil, it was so delicious to dip the homemade bread in olive oil with a piece of shrimp. We then had the costicine di Agnello; grilled lamb chops served with roasted potato. It blended well with our choice of a bottle of Montepulciano. For our entree, I chose spaghetti a polpette; spaghetti with meatballs and orecchiette salsiccia rapini; pasta served with Italian sausage, garlic, and broccoli rabe. We then concluded the dinner with ricotta cheesecake to share. The dishes from appetizer to dessert are simply delectable. We found that the service here was slow on Saturday night but we were happy that they were doing well that night. Do plan your visit especially if you have other pressing engagements after the dinner. Overall it was a lovely supper, we were not rushing and also not being rushed by the wait staff, we enjoyed every single dish that was served on our table. We are looking forward to dining here again soon! read more

See all

Food: delicious homemade noodles Drinks: fantastic, willing to provide drinks that are not on the menu Ambiance and service: very busy, but still reasonable timing and attentiveness. Cute space. read more

I had gnocchi alla sorrentina, which was tasty: garlicky with a strong fresh tomato flavor from the sauce. However, the portions are tiny for the price. You would probably need more than one dish per person. Though the flavor is very good, the price is just too high to really justify coming back. read more

The time I had at Cotenna was pleasant, but there were a few things that concerned me. For one, the dishes that were used to serve the food were visibly chipped and discolored. This was present on more than one plate, so I could only assume all of their dishes were like this and I don't think customers would enjoy seeing their food being presented in such a state. The food was decent, but it felt like meals that I could have made at my home. The meatballs especially were delicious, but not in an elevated sense where I need to come back to try them. I can see myself buying frozen meatballs and cooking them at home myself to replicate how it tasted at Cotenna. I chose to give this restaurant a 2 instead of a 1 because of the customer service which was very good. The server was super charming and tended to my every need- making sure that I was satisfied with my experience. The view was also positive since I had a seat by the open window where I can watch people walk by without being fully outside of the establishment. I don't think I would return to this place because their food tastes like it is store bought, not freshly cooked and the utensils were not at its best quality. But with a little polishing, I think this can be a lovely Italian place to visit with friends. read more

See all

Went a little after 12. Empty. Food within 15 min of ordering. Quick and simple service. Black Truffle gnocchi ($25)- Salty creamy sauce that is balanced by the chewy gnocchi with lingering truffle aftertaste. Linguine Vongole ($19) Light pasta with good slight acidic aftertaste. Wish there was more clam but otherwise simple and very easy to devour Hole in the wall vibe and size. Portion is not heavy. Quick good lunch grab. read more

The most reliable Italian restaurant I have found in the city. Looking for an intimate, affordable wine bar with memorable food? You've found it here. I am a longtime fan of the restaurant group that owns Cotenna, Aria, Briciola, etc. They all have different names so it's hard to notice that they are owned by the same group and serve similar items, but it is great to know that wherever you are in the city, one is close by! Cotenna has a simple and straightforward menu with all appetizers, pastas, and sides with the same prices. Waiters are very knowledgeable about wine recommendations. On my most recent visit, we shared 3 pasta dishes. The macaroni and cheese with truffle was not too overwhelmingly truffley, but our favorite dish was the pesto pasta with artichokes. A great pesto is hard to find! Bravo! read more

Cotenna - PENNE WITH PESTO AND ARTICHOKES SLOW BAKED MAC & CHEESE WITH SLICED TRUFFLE GARGANELLI WITH OSSO BUCO - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

Really small cute spot with awesome servers! We enjoyed all of our food, the goat cheese and mango salad was a really pleasant surprise, we didn't know what to expect with it, but the flavors came together nicely. The only thing I felt was not perfect was the amount of truffle oil on the gnocchi. I know it's their signature dish and maybe I'm just sensitive to the truffle oil, but I felt like they could've gone a bit lighter on it. The cheesecake was really great as well! read more

See all

It was horrendous, they told us they were out of bread but still serving other tables bread. The service was horrendous, our order was wrong. There was no water available. Terrible ambience and service. DO NOT GO HERE! read more

Really used to love the place so much that I would go out of my way to get a to go order whenever I was in the area. However, it really has gone downhill since I last came here back in December. Sad to say I won't be going out of my way to Cotenna anymore and I hope others are aware that not only are prices more now, but portions are less than half of the serving size. I gave the restaurant over a week to address it (called, e-mailed, fb messaged, etc.) and they've blatantly ignored me despite a server saying he took down my information and will pass it along to the manager. I ordered the rigatoni e gamberi to go and was beyond disappointed to find out the portion was literally less than half the tiny container. It was more of an appetizer than an entrée. Not only that, but the consistency of the dish was subpar as well. There were only a few pieces of shrimp, but half had the tails on and the other half had the tails remove. I was left starving after eating it and had to find another meal entirely. read more

Cotenna - disappointing / beyond mediocre portion of the rigatoni e gamberi - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

My expectations were not high, which is probably why I was so pleased. People are drawn to Cotenna by the prices, which still manage to be reasonable - no small feat in this city these days. That being said, you get what you pay for. This is no frills, inoffensive food and wine, but it won't knock your socks off. Polpette were delicious - tender, and swimming in a good sauce. But the orchiette with sausage and broccoli rabe had flabby pasta in a garlic-y sauce with a few pieces of flavorless sausage. We poked at it, but it really wasn't worth finishing. We sat at the bar and got bumped into every time someone passed. This works if you are dying for a drink/snack before or after Film Forum. read more

First the physical; - great location! - fast service and attentive staff - heated outdoor seating - indoor ambience was very charming Now the food; - nothing on the menu was over $16 but everything on the menu tasted like it was triple the price - the portions were a good size and it was very easy to order multiple dishes and share family style with friends - We decided to order everything family style. We each got a glass of wine, split two apps (fried calamari and Caesar salad), split 3 pastas (the special truffle gnocchi, the pesto penne and the truffle mac n cheese), and then had two desserts (the truffle and tiramisu). All in all, for 7 dishes and 3 glasses of wine the total was 63/pp with tax and tip. VERY reasonable considering the quality of the food and the location. One thing to note, is that Cotenna owns the restaurant across the street too, so don't be thrown off if they seat you at this location, it's the same menu! We went on a Saturday night and had a great time! Will definitely be returning! read more

Cotenna - the pesto penne, truffle gnocchi special and truffle mac n cheese - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

My friend and I decided to try Cotenna because of the $16 pasta options. That's a pretty good deal on pasta considering other places around charge much more. They had a sizable list of pasta options to choose from at $16. I got the Fettucine al Funghi and my friend got the Rigatoni e Gamberi. We were both really satisfied with our meals and they had a lot of flavors. I will definitely come back again because the food is amazing. The only downside about the place was that they doesn't have a sign that tells you it's Cotenna so it might be a bit difficult to find at first. I eventually found it by looking at one of the menus, but the outside is white and the door is red. I hope that gives you a better idea when you go! Tip: Get a reservation ahead of time because it is a small place and it does get very busy in the evenings! read more

Cotenna - Bottom: Fettucine al Funghi, Top: Rigatoni e Gamberi - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

The black truffle gnocchi special is incredible. We also really enjoyed the burrata and prosciutto special and the orecchiette pasta. I wanted to get the gnocchi again because it was the best I've ever had. Cloud puffs of creamy cheesy flavor. The restaurant is very small and seating is tight but the food is worth it. Waiters were on top of it. read more

See all

I was throwing up till 3 AM last night bc of their food! I had the special "black truffle gnocchi" and grilled octopus salad and some wine! I honestly have never been this sick from Food before so i absolutely can not recommend this place! read more

Pretty expansive and interesting menu of pastas, all the same price ($17). Price is decent considering quality and portion size, especially given the lack of mid-tier pasta places in the neighborhood. I ordered the truffle Mac and cheese which came piping hot (kudos considering the distance from my office) and cheesy/gooey with a strong truffle flavor. There was a large piece of shaved black truffle on the Mac as well. I found the noodles to be just a little too soft, but I like my pasta fairly al dente so this may be a matter of personal preference. I was looking for something decadent and heavy after a night of heavy drinking and Cotenna definitely supplied on that front. Wish the delivery fee were a little lower, but cest la vie. Will order again to try another of their pastas. read more

Cotenna - Maccheroni Al Tartufo - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

Very underwhelming. I'll state that everything should be taken with a grain of salt, as we did go on a Saturday night which is bound to be chaotic. Our individual waiter was excellent, if overworked, as were the men busing the tables. The other waiter and the hostess just stare at you blankly when asked questions. They brought everything - salad, appetizer, all the entrees, table bread, out at once. One dish we ordered never came out. Everything was tasty enough but not special enough to justify the prices or the chaos. If you're a talented cook or buy a quality sauce you could achieve the same effect since everything is meant to be very homey. Same goes for the drinks. read more

Cotenna - GNOCCHI WITH HOUSE TOMATO SAUCE - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all