Have to say Haven't been here in quite a while Came in tonight. Sean delivered five stars! Pizza was on point! In fact best pizza on the island! If you need some NY style don't miss Cosmos! And say hi to Sean at the bar! read more

French dip pizza was phenomenal best crust I've ever tasted the salad was a true authentic Italian vinaigrette dressing and was all fresh and lots of cheese on the salad. The staff was helpful and friendly and very busy at the opening time so it's obviously a forefront of the pizza industry. Prices were reasonable as well. read more

I would love to rate this place but the arrogance of the staff prohibited that from happening. Friday afternoon we decided to order pickup pizza from Cosmos. Saw they had a way to order online so we placed our order at 4:00 for three of their regular pizzas. Website said we could pickup the pizza's at 5:15. We paid with Apple Pay and were all set, so we thought. Started getting ready at 4:45 to make my way up to the store. My daughter said let me call just to make sure they'll be ready. The lady on the phone said they tried to call us to let us know our order would be "pushed back a little". Since we didn't answer they canceled our order. I didn't realize I had to hang by my phone so if Cosmos called we could run to the phone to answer their call. The lady said it is now pushed back to 7:15 since we didn't answer the phone when they called. She said if we didn't like it then good luck getting pizza from another place since it was now 5:00. WOW! Classic case of having too many customers so who cares if you piss off a few. With only a 3.5 star rating I wouldn't declare myself as a top notch restaurant. We called back and talked to some young guy who said it is what it is. When I asked for the manager he hung up on me. My main question is why would you have online ordering that tells you can pickup your pizza at 5:15 when that is clearly not true. We called Big Slice pizza and they loved to hear the story about one of their competitors. They actually got our pizza order ready with 45 mins and it was actually really good. Good luck Cosmos, with customer service like that you'll need it. read more

First time in the outer banks, wasn't sure where to go for a quick bite, and Cosmos did not disappoint. The staff was awesome, pizza came out super fast, fries were really good. Definitely a safe and cool spot for pizza and a beer before battling the 4x4 beach for 40 minutes. read more

Let me begin by declaring I'm a pizza snob otherwise maybe this place gets a 4. Ok crust, good sauce, very good toppings. I LOOOOOOVE good crust, good sauce and good toppings. I've tried arguably the best pizza from Maui, Hawaii to downtown NYC at Grimaldi's under the Brooklyn bridge. If you're looking for pizza I think this is about as good as you will find at the Outer Banks. After a day at the beach and no wait, (unlike Uncle Ike's hour wait), we were excited. Crust could be crispier but good chew and was not greasy. SKIP THE FAMOUS crab pizza that costs $$$, not worth it. They skimp on the crab and it is very small shredded pieces. I thought it was just me, but my wife also agreed the flavor is not good. We had a group of 10 and they easily handled us. They messed up our order but gave us a free pizza and I thought did a great job of making things right. read more

This used to be our favorite pizza place when in Corolla. We hadn't been here in a couple of years and it has gone downhill. Pizza just isn't as good as it used to be. The gluten free pizza for our daughter tasted pretty good, but made her very sick that night after eating it. Cross contamination is a problem. Bummer. read more

We are from NJ and know what good pizza taste like. While down here on our family vacation we tried three of the local pizzerias during our stay. Our kids love pizza. First try was Lucky's, next was Corolla, three times was the charm. By far the best of the three, Cosmos, wasn't even close. Tasted like normal pizza we are used to. Not like frozen crust you get in the supermarket. From now on it is only Cosmo's for us. We had a plain cheese, a meat lovers, garlic knots, and a chicken Parm hero. All were great. Would buy again. read more

Reviews were all over the place about where to get the best pizza in the OBX. Pizzaz Pizza, Duck Pizza, Waves, blah, blah, blah. Which one is accurate? Go with the one source you can trust! The stoned Jeff Spicoli dude cleaning the pool at our vacation rental! Before long, we were "Learning about Cuba and having some food". I was going to call in our order, but saw on their website that they had a bar. Why not have my wife drive us up to the restaurant, order the pizza, and have a couple of beers? Glad I did. They had some reasonably priced craft beers that went down well while the pizza was being baked. The bartender was a great guy and we enjoyed talking with him. Two beers later, our hot delicious pepperoni and mushroom pie was ready. Stoner pool cleaner made an awesome recommendation. Give Cosmo's Pizza a try. Well worth the drive. Dude. read more

As a professional chef and New Yorker I was excited to try this place for dinner. Any pizza place during a busy season should be able to handle Friday night pizza orders. Guess not for Cosmos. Harris Teeter has a great Take-n-Bake pizza for $9.99 and you'll save 4 hours of your life. read more

Came in on a Friday evening with a party of nine and we were seated quickly. Good vibe in the restaurant as they were a lot of patron, both dining in and taking out. Quickly ordered appetizers and drinks followed by entrées. For appetizers, we ordered the boneless wings with sweet Thai chili sauce and mozzarella sticks. The wings came out quickly and were quite flavorful with the sauce. The mozzarella sticks seem to get lost in the shuffle and did not appear until some of the entrées came out. They appear to be little coordination between the waiting staff and the kitchen staff as the food came out in dribs and drabs. Our second appetizer appeared with the entrées. Overall quality and taste of the food was good, problem was with timing and presentation as entrées started to come out before the first appetizer was done. I understand wanting to get food out to the patrons as quickly as possible and that is much appreciated but also is the time during meal to enjoy the food, the atmosphere and your friends and family read more

Great pizza. Ordered takeout and was ready when they said it would be. Highly recommend. You won't be disappointed

This is some AMAZING pizza!!! It really is!!! We stopped in after some friends suggested we try it for pizza. They have all the typical toppings, including crab! Prices are slightly high, but service is decent. The taste of the crust and proportions of toppings, sauce, etc is great! Service was just OK, but wasn't bad. The place is clean and the AC worked well. Looking forward to eating here again! read more

Cosmos Pizza - Pepperoni with shrooms on half and jalapenos on the other half - Pizza Near Me - Corolla, North Carolina

The first place we stop when we hit the Outer Banks. Best food & amazing staff! The menu is great and food is consistently outstanding.

The Ohio State jersey on the wall should have told me this would be overrated pizza. The pizza was fine. Let me say the reason for the one star isn't because it's bad. It's that it's prices to be GREAT and it's just fine. It is the kind of pizza that has potential but doesn't live up to it's past reviews. read more

This place has been in existence for 20 years or more That alone should speak for itself....Best Pizza in Corolla, NC read more

Amazingggggggggg please never change the recipes. Our pizza came a little deformed but that didn't stop us! 10/10 read more

Cosmos Pizza - Peperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Corolla, North Carolina

The food was great and the service was fast and friendly - definitely recommend! We were visiting from Manteo and only wish we hadn't been making so many stops on the way back, it was hard leaving the leftovers behind! read more

Cosmos Pizza - White crab pizza was delicious, and the service was fast and friendly. Definitely recommend! - Pizza Near Me - Corolla, North Carolina

See all

Pretty nice looking place, but for the price I'm a little disappointed. We asked how big the large pizza was, if it would be a good size for two people. The guy said it would be perfect. We ended up only eating about half. A small would have been plenty. That said, it was okay pizza. Thickish crust was a bit doughy. All in all, it was just so-so. I didn't get an itemized reciept, but I thought $40 with tip was a bit much for a one topping pizza and two soft drinks. read more

2 large pizzas, appetizers, one sandwich, and 5 drinks later, it was over $100. It is good food. It's fast and fresh. The staff was extremely friendly. It's a good environment but the cost is pricy! read more

Ordered take-out from here, but I didn't actually go inside. We got plain pizza, pepperoni pizza, and mozzarella sticks. Loved the mozzarella sticks, maybe they were a little sweeter than I am used to, but delicious. The pizza was good. Nothing special, but maybe New York pizza has biased me. It's great if you just want a simple meal, I don't see it disappointing anyone. read more

Cosmos Pizza - Plain Large Pizza 16" - Pizza Near Me - Corolla, North Carolina

We had a large order was ready on time and everything was correct. Pizza was very good.

Really good, fresh pizza! Crust was crunchy, sauce delightful, toppings plentiful. Lots of televisions to watch and great bartender. read more

Cosmos Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Corolla, North Carolina

Fantastic. Faaaaaantastic. Visiting here in peak season and got a table right away. Pleasant server, amazing pizza. I got the gluten free pie and it was phenomenal. I ate it all by myself! Photo shows all that is left. Only here for a week, but we may be back! read more

Cosmos Pizza - Aftermath - Pizza Near Me - Corolla, North Carolina

Excellent food, friendly service! Highly recommend for a family-friendly dinner and good pizza.

Pizza was very good. Liked the white crab special also margarita and bbq chicken. Service was good and staff was friendly.

I called in for a pizza and when they answered they said there is an hour and 45 minutes wait for pick up. I said ok. Because I knew they where busy and then before I could think of what my wife wanted me to order. He interrupt me with a real firm voice and said, would you like to order sir! Or call back? I proceeded to say if you're going to be rude I don't want to order. I was going to be patient with his an hour and 45 minute wait time the least he could do is give me three seconds to say what I wanted to order. I come to this area all the time. But, I will never support people who talk to others like that. read more

We have ordered from here the past several summers while going to OBX. The food quality, particularly the pizza has gone downhill. The pizza was very greasy with a really odd aftertaste. The pricing is consistent with what you would expect in a resort town. They were pretty disorganized and I would recommend going elsewhere to find high quality pizza. read more

This is a fantastic place if your willing to get messy! As an appetizer I ordered the mozzarella sticks, they gave me 7 instead of 6 . I ordered the meatball parm sub for the main course, which was really good except that the bread was a tad soggy. It came with a bag of chips and pickle. The place itself was VERY busy and they gave us a 25 minute wait, which turned into none when they cleared a table for us. The service was fantastic! I wish I could come again but I only rented a beach house for a week. Again, overall it was fantastic and I'd love to go again read more

Cosmos Pizza - My meal (half eaten) - Pizza Near Me - Corolla, North Carolina

Grabbed lunch here on our second day at the beach based on the proximity and reviews. We tried two different pizzas including a plain and half pepperoni/half mushroom. I was a little surprised by the prices as the pizzas start at $14.99, which is frankly too much for these. The pizzas were decent, a little salty, with a sweet sauce. Sauce wasn't the main attraction as the pizza had a lot of dough and chewy crust. Not a bad lunch option, and I hear tell that aren't many pizza decent options in the Outer Banks. read more

There were a couple of things that were not great about my experience at Cosmos Pizza. First off, they got my online order wrong. Second, nobody inside of cosmos, including the employees, were wearing masks. I get that that is their right, but it's very uncomfortable. Third, there were multiple other customers who returned their orders because they were incorrect during the 15 minutes I was there. Lastly, the pizza was okay but definitely not worth the price. Don't think I will be returning:/ read more

We went there on a Sunday evening in October and the place was crowded as it was one of only a handful of places open. The pizza was truly delicious as were the garlic knots. Pricewise, it was what you would expect to pay at a normal pizzeria in a resort town. We got takeout (did not call in ahead) and it took about 30 to 40 minutes to get our food which was expected because of how busy they were while also short two staff members. My reason for three stars was there was no air conditioning to speak of inside the place. With an unseasonably warm night, I don't see how anyone could eat inside there as hot as my wife and I were. If that situation were resolved I would change my review to four or maybe five stars because of the food's quality and the service we got from the overworked staff. read more

Pizza was awesome, garlic knots were awesome, and they had a great system in place for social distanced pick up. All of the staff were wearing masks. read more

My husband and I had an amazing dinner. Sean was operating in a short staff and a full house. He made what could have been a disaster into a great dining experience. He and the kitchen staff made us crave for our next Corolla pizza night. Thank you Sean and the kitchen staff in 5/16! read more

Every time my family comes down to the OBX we get Cosmos at least once - usually carry out. It's always very good. Great place for beer drinkers, as they have a variety of craft options. On this occasion, we ate in and the staff was warm and attentive. Note that it is off season. We had the veggie pizza and the house Chardonnay & Cabernet. Would definitely eat in again! read more

Cosmos Pizza - Large veggie pizza - Pizza Near Me - Corolla, North Carolina

Great pizza, just rough around the edges; but this is to be expected with high employee turnover due to the seasonal nature of a beach business. It's been managed better in recent years (used to be that you could show up at lunchtime in summer and they'd be closed!@#!). Tip to owner: update hours on social media sites during spring break (Yelp and Facebook listed you as closed but we knew you were open). read more

We ordered online hours before they even opened and 10 minutes before the order was supposed to be ready the called us saying they canceled it. They went on to say if we wanted to re order it would take over two hours to be ready. They were also extremely rude and hung up on us when we asked why they canceled our order. I would suggest not going here or at least calling days in advance. read more

Very friendly, we were looking for some place to eat dinner but everything was close. It was about 10 minutes before they close but they still was nice enough to make us our order. They are a little more expensive than what I'm used to but very delicious pizza. My family also liked their wings. read more

In OBX for family vacation, and I'm a big fan of pizza so thought we would give this place a try. We ordered 6 pizzas a gluten free, the marg, the bbq chicken, the Corolla, the supreme, and a pepperoni. Preordered and went to pick up, arrived a little Earl and had a beer while we waited. Super friend staff, we chatted for while we waited, and enjoyed the brew! Highly recommend this place! read more

Well, based on the 'best in obx' statement and a few reviews, we gave this place a try. Not sure if we hit it on a bad night or since it was mid October, they weren't on-point but none of us liked the pizza. it had twice as much sauce as cheese and the sauce had spices too strong for pizza sauce. it was not very tasty at all. And we ordered boneless wings and they were fried too much, almost burnt. Don't think we will go there again. read more

Our group of 9 visited during Spring break, so we had to wait about 20 min. We didn't think it was that bad a wait considering it was packed. We ordered 3 pizzas and an Italian hoagie. It was the meaty, veggie and 1/2 plain and 1/2 pepperoni. We are from NJ/Philly and considering that, it was pretty good pizza. We have tried many places in OBX, and the dough is usually way too thick, but Cosmos was nice and thin, except the crust. We would definitely go back again. The pizza hit the spot and the people were really friendly. read more