My husband and I stopped here for lunch one Saturday. We were warmly greeted by all the staff and quickly received menus. I believe the owner was behind the bar, he was very friendly and eager to make our visit a good one. We got the white crab pizza and, seriously, it was one of the best pizzas I have ever had in my life. Everything was so well balanced, not too much or too little of anything. The crab was sweet and fresh, definitely an 11/10. We live in VA, so it's not a local spot to us, but we tell everyone we know to come here and if we get the chance, we will definitely be back! read more

Cosmos Pizza - Enjoying a Mighty Swell Watermelon Mint Hard Seltzer - Pizza Near Me - Corolla, North Carolina

See all

Excellent food We ordered pizza, garlic knots, fried pickles, Caesar salad and boneless wings. All of the fried foods were perfectly cooked and flavored. We usually order to much but ate it all. Definitely will be our new go to when in town. read more

Cosmos Pizza - Caesar Salad - Pizza Near Me - Corolla, North Carolina

See all

I was fed the nectar of a higher form of life. This place has the best pizza yet produced by mankind. I can't give this place 10/10, so 5/5 will have to do. Drinks were immaculate as well. Epic swag. read more

Great pizzas every time we visit! Easy walk from our condo in Corolla. Garrett our server was great! read more

Cosmos Pizza - Build Your Own Pie - Large Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Corolla, North Carolina

See all

We have had Cosmos several times over the years. It is good handmade pizza with good toppings and sauce. I think their crust tastes good and is cooked well to give a good crisp bite. We got the supreme with no green peppers, add jalapeño, and it was sooo good. Also ordered pepperoni and cheese pizzas and it was solid. Salads were very fresh and good (family Caesar and Traditional). Lettuce was crisp and had tons of good fresh toppings. 2 subs ordered by the girls looked good too. The bread looked fresh and well cooked. I really wanted a slice the next AM for breakfast but the boys tore it up in the late night... Given it's a pizza joint at a vacation destination, expect a long wait or time to get your order. We ordered 5 pizzas, 2 family size salads, and 2 subs on Friday night and it took 1.5 hours for carry-out. $187 for all that isn't too bad. Again, expect higher costs out here for everything but fresh seafood. We will go back and order again. Wanting to try the crab pizza next time! read more

Ordered 3 pizzas, one with sausage and onions $65.00 . They were just ok, but im kinda jaded living in New jersey. The front-end person called our name did not ask how we were or hi thanks very dry. I would pass up next time and try another place. read more

10 out of 10! Owner, Manager and our server were awesome!! Friendly vibes and clean location and they made you feel welcome. Went twice during my stay in Corolla! Very good pizza with fresh ingredients and good tasting wine!! Asked them to please come open a place in VA Beach!! read more

Cosmos Pizza - So good!!!! - Pizza Near Me - Corolla, North Carolina

See all

Love this little place! The pizza and beer were very good. Will definitely come back... read more

Cosmos Pizza - This pizza is sooo good! Hospitality is top notch. Bartender is awesome. - Pizza Near Me - Corolla, North Carolina

We ordered 5 pizza's on a Friday for a 8pm pick-up. Not only was it on time, it was delicious. We wish we didn't live 6.5hr away!!!! I highly recommend Cosmos for all of your OBX vacations!! Next time we go back- we are definitely going for pizza!!! Fun fact: you can pre-order ONLINE for the same day!!!! We placed our order 12pm for pickup at 8pm. It was perfect. read more

Not convinced this pizza dough was made from scratch , consistency was doughy and rubbery, not crisp at all . We ordered three pies and two drinks, bill was over $100 for takeout. As a pizza business owner, I was fooled into thinking this place might have something special, as there was a wood fired over parked out front. Pizza seemed pre fabricated, frozen add toppings and bake , dissatisfying read more

Ordered food for pickup and then we stepped away for a bit to walk around while they were preparing the order. We came back a little later and asked the cashier, Matthew, if they had called me (as in called my name). Matthew proceeded to pop an attitude and say "No we're not going to call you." Trying to figure out where the attitude was coming from, I realized he thought I was asking if they were going to call my phone. I tried to clarify what I meant the second time and he just repeated what he told me before. And it wasn't until I gave him the same attitude he was giving me back that he finally gave me the answer I was looking for; an eta of when it would be ready. Dude's anger was blinding his common sense. If he didn't have such a nasty attitude to begin with, it wouldn't have taken him 4 tries to answer my question. He wasn't the only worker in there that seemed to hate his job either, because I noticed a couple of instances of workers mumbling passive aggressive things under their breath about customers. Food was alright (only reason this is getting a 2 star instead of 1) but Mathew's petty attitude left a bad taste in my family and I's mouth. Would not recommend this place unless you're getting delivery. read more

Delicious and fast pizza!! Easy order online. Great crust (even for those who normally skip the crust).

Our family went on a Friday night. We waited about 20 minutes to be seated, which isn't bad. However, the food came out and was wrong and had hair in it. I don't ask for much...be friendly and try to get the food right. Every dish was wrong - and the kicker was hair in my son's ranch. Then when we checked out the minimum tip you could opt to give is 20%. I typically give at least 20%...but this upset me because the service and food was not 20% deserving. Disappointed and won't be back. read more

Pizza was mediocre at best. The dough was thick & under cooked on some pies & overcooked on others. The more toppings the better to help you not focus on the dough. I would NOT reccomend ! read more

Great pizza. Just frustrating during off season because you never know what their hours are.

Wonderful pizza, great pizza. Staff was super nice. All 3 pizzas I got were great. PB whiskey milkshake read more

Cosmos Pizza - Classic!! - Pizza Near Me - Corolla, North Carolina

Pizza, fries, and garlic knots were great and flavorful. We got a few pizzas, all of which were good! Prices inline for the beach (not remotely cheap, but a price expected in a vacation destination). The wait time was long, but it was checkin day (Saturday), so that was also expected. The customer service was spotty, hard to judge too critically due to the business and it being 8 at night, so I'm sure staff was drained. A couple of the workers just seemed tired so they were a little short in communications (yes I accounted for them being busy) but it's fine. The vibe of the building was cool with lots of different rooms with unique vibes. read more

We had lunch at Cosmos. Pizza was delicious. We also got fries which were [chef's kiss]. Excellent service. We are a family of five with three boys 7, 5, and 1 - and they were super family-friendly. 10/10 would recommend. read more

Beware the amateur food critic here that just aims for the "elite" status, and has little to do with the everyday restaurant experience. Everything about this place was awesome. A classic feel pizza joint with the absolute best supreme pizza I've ever had. Staff was amazing, atmosphere was too. What a hidden gem on the OBX! read more

Very decent salad was a bit unpleasant and the margarita pizza was alright. The pepperoni pizza was Bussin and the waitress couldn't understand much, but on the bright side it fulfilled my hunger and cleared my digestive tract. The ambiance was okay. Overall a 3.2/5 read more

best pizza ever , fig & pig ! a little expensive but the pizza tasted great , the garlic knots were a little overdone but overall a good meal read more

The service was stellar. We were greeted immediately and served right away. The Greek salad was very good and enough for two plus leftovers. The pepperoni pizza, which is our go-to choice for comparison purposes, was great. The ingredients were high quality. Our only wish would be for an improved crust. We prefer NY style that folds in half. This one was just slightly stiff. All-in-all we will definitely go back. read more

We called to order delivery (which is erroneously listed as an option when you search for delivery in the area, get that fixed Cosmo). Instead of owning up to the mistake, we were told we could've gotten it delivered 25 years ago, which, it was mansplained to us, was the last time they ever offered delivery (it's a quarter of a century later and the Internet says it's true so don't act like we're in the wrong here, pizza boy). But with no other option since Tomato Patch burned down (RIP), we placed an order...despite their confusion about what constitutes "buffalo wings" - but we'll get to that in a minute. We were told our order would be ready in 30 minutes, so our friend Susan graciously offered to pick up the pizza at exactly that time. She arrived and paid, and was told it'd be an additional 10 minutes for her order. Alright, fine, no problem...except another 30 minutes go by (we're over double the time they quoted us at this point), and instead of being apologetic, the men in this shop started loudly teasing her about the fact that she was still waiting (oh, Susie is mad at us! Look at how mad she is, LOLZ). Real funny, jerks who make mediocre pizza and don't understand what buffalo wings are (we literally just asked for wings with hot sauce on them, aka your normal buffalo wing, but an hour or so later the wings are still being held up because chef Cosmo doesn't understand how to make them). At this point the pizza (which finally came out after an hour) is getting cold in the car, Susan asks about the status of the wings - she's told that since this was a "specialty" order it's taking longer and they're still in the fryer. Not sure why you'd put that part of our order into the fryer while our 7 pizzas are getting colder and soggier by the minute in the car, but okay. *Spark notes version: This mediocre pizza and beyond basic wing selection is not worth the bad attitude you'll get at Cosmo's. Maybe they should think about reverting to the way they did business 25 years ago, when they'd literally go out of their way for customers instead of making fun of them to their face about their own crappy customer service. read more

As expected this time of year, the place was packed, but worth the wait. The homemade crust was phenomenal....Which means something coming from this Jersey Gal. Lol. Definitely stop in or take-out any of their pies. DELISH! read more

Best greek salad that we've had. We decided to order salad along with our pizza and we are glad we did. The pizza was tasty and did not disappoint. The bonus was we ordered a family size salad so we got to enjoy it multiple days which was great.. Definitely will order here again. Only complaint would be is the website is not up to date with hours they are open during the off season. We were hoping to get another pizza and salad while we in town over the holidays only to find out they were closed. read more

When we asked if this was a Stromboli the server talked bad about us to a different table. Don't recommend this place at all! My husband did enjoy his sandwich but service and food was just okay. read more

Cosmos Pizza - This is their Stromboli. - Pizza Near Me - Corolla, North Carolina

See all

I'm going to give this a solid 4.5 stars for our short experience when we were there after the horse tour The AWESOME - Oh my goodness.. the bread sticks are so good and i'm not usually a fan of those but I actually had 2! This was the best I've ever had, twisted, cooked just right, coated with I believe was olive oil, cheese and garlic (I could be wrong about the ingredients) served with marina sauce. Great size too!!! The good - The service was very friendly; the gentleman explained that due to COVID19 no indoor dining but we there was outside covered seating (which we took advantage of). They did allow us to wait indoors at booth for our food which I thought was weird. - The pizza was very good and as expected; I'm not a pizza consiouer but I enjoyed it and even the left overs... - Bottle beer selection (I already had an ice coffee from Dunks and way too much carbs for me as is... so I passed but the wife enjoyed a Needs improvement? - Nothing... ok wife wanted onion rings and they don't serve that here. NOTE: They look like they have a full bar too which would of been fun to sit indoors and chat more with the family but it is interesting times... read more

Best Margherita pizza on the island Fresh and lots of mozzarella and basil with perfect crust read more

Cosmo's Pizza is one of the best pizza places in town. The pizza is always fresh and delicious, and the staff is friendly and helpful. I highly recommend Cosmo's Pizza to anyone looking for a great pizza read more

Delicious food. Staff was great!!! Would definitely come back again. Spicy/hot pizza and chicken bbq were delicious.

The pizza is the best in Corolla. The service was great. Will definitely be going back.

Since I've never been advised by a server not to get a dish, I'll start with this. My entire party ordered dessert and after the server didn't know what one of the cakes was, she came back to tell us we shouldn't even order them. She told us that the restaurant has "really bad" desserts. I appreciated her honesty since I wouldn't want to pay for something horrible. However, I do not understand why they have such an extensive dessert menu on each table if they're not recommended. Now for dinner, everything the server did agree with was good. We had the breadsticks and the truffle fries. Then I got the veggie pizza, which had thickly cut fresh vegetables (instead of many veggie pizzas that have soggy tasteless peppers and mushrooms). They split half with the jahjah pie for us and all the ingredients stayed separated well. Their dough is pretty plain but I can't expect them to have as great of dough as New York. Besides missing out on dessert, my dinner was also dampened by the high level of noise in the place. Having the bar run parallel to all the booths, there is no buffer between people who are eating and drinkers who are screaming at the football game. read more

See all

French dip pizza was phenomenal best crust I've ever tasted the salad was a true authentic Italian vinaigrette dressing and was all fresh and lots of cheese on the salad. The staff was helpful and friendly and very busy at the opening time so it's obviously a forefront of the pizza industry. Prices were reasonable as well. read more

Came in on a Friday evening with a party of nine and we were seated quickly. Good vibe in the restaurant as they were a lot of patron, both dining in and taking out. Quickly ordered appetizers and drinks followed by entrées. For appetizers, we ordered the boneless wings with sweet Thai chili sauce and mozzarella sticks. The wings came out quickly and were quite flavorful with the sauce. The mozzarella sticks seem to get lost in the shuffle and did not appear until some of the entrées came out. They appear to be little coordination between the waiting staff and the kitchen staff as the food came out in dribs and drabs. Our second appetizer appeared with the entrées. Overall quality and taste of the food was good, problem was with timing and presentation as entrées started to come out before the first appetizer was done. I understand wanting to get food out to the patrons as quickly as possible and that is much appreciated but also is the time during meal to enjoy the food, the atmosphere and your friends and family read more

The atmosphere of the restaurant was great, the bar looked pretty cool. If we had more time we would have enjoyed sitting down for a drink. However, we ordered a pizza that was just mediocre at best. Very greasy, dough didn't seem fresh Dry, and semi rubbery. I'd say frozen pizza is a lot better. However the prices were reasonable. We were in a rush so the to go service was pretty speedy. read more

Have to say Haven't been here in quite a while Came in tonight. Sean delivered five stars! Pizza was on point! In fact best pizza on the island! If you need some NY style don't miss Cosmos! And say hi to Sean at the bar! read more

Great pizza. Ordered takeout and was ready when they said it would be. Highly recommend. You won't be disappointed

The first place we stop when we hit the Outer Banks. Best food & amazing staff! The menu is great and food is consistently outstanding.

I would love to rate this place but the arrogance of the staff prohibited that from happening. Friday afternoon we decided to order pickup pizza from Cosmos. Saw they had a way to order online so we placed our order at 4:00 for three of their regular pizzas. Website said we could pickup the pizza's at 5:15. We paid with Apple Pay and were all set, so we thought. Started getting ready at 4:45 to make my way up to the store. My daughter said let me call just to make sure they'll be ready. The lady on the phone said they tried to call us to let us know our order would be "pushed back a little". Since we didn't answer they canceled our order. I didn't realize I had to hang by my phone so if Cosmos called we could run to the phone to answer their call. The lady said it is now pushed back to 7:15 since we didn't answer the phone when they called. She said if we didn't like it then good luck getting pizza from another place since it was now 5:00. WOW! Classic case of having too many customers so who cares if you piss off a few. With only a 3.5 star rating I wouldn't declare myself as a top notch restaurant. We called back and talked to some young guy who said it is what it is. When I asked for the manager he hung up on me. My main question is why would you have online ordering that tells you can pickup your pizza at 5:15 when that is clearly not true. We called Big Slice pizza and they loved to hear the story about one of their competitors. They actually got our pizza order ready with 45 mins and it was actually really good. Good luck Cosmos, with customer service like that you'll need it. read more

This place has been in existence for 20 years or more That alone should speak for itself....Best Pizza in Corolla, NC read more