Because I lived across the street from this restaurant for a year, I've frequented it many times, usually on the average to once or twice a week. Each dinner including a beer will only set you back between $10.00 and $15.00. With a dessert, make that $20.00. Do not let the initial size of the pasty fool you. You WILL be full upon receipt to your stomach, no matter which variety is chosen.
Carved out of what at first glace looks like a long, dark hallway stretching from the front business side, to the back receiving side of a strip mall at the corner of Hardy and University Drives, the Cornish Pasty Company prides itself on its filled pastry dinners that were inspired on the historical food that British coal miners' wives would make for their husbands.
The design and layout of the interior gives you the impression you are entering a dark corner pub. Small tables for couples adorn the right side and a bar overlooks the entirety of the food preparation area on the left. Larger seats are available in the back for groups. Make no mistake, this hallway of a restaurant can get packed and run out of adequate seating very quickly on any night of the week, unexpectedly.
Luckily there are at least a couple of outside tables for overflow, or if it happens to not be summer.
Believe me when I say this: Living within eye shot of this restaurant makes it extremely easy to become addicted to these delectable dinner pockets.
The Cornish Pasty serves you with a pastry dough shell, similar in construction to a very large Hot Pocket or Calzone using dough that is best described as crunchy and glazed on the outside, chewy and warm on the inside. It's worth coming for the quality of the baking process alone.
Inside the pasty you will find any number of assorted selections. Because I am vegetarian, I can't cover the meat options, which are numerous. However, many of the meat varieties are featured with a vegetarian option using "meatless" meat substitutes which, in every conceivable way, are very convincing. Each dish is served with a sauce that is specific to the type of cuisine at hand. The Mexican is served with salsa.
Highlights of my experiences include the Vegetarian Pesto Chicken and the Veggie Tikka Chicken Masala. Arguably the most ethnic items on the menu. The pesto is light and really lets the mushrooms accent the chicken (which is, by the way, the most convincing "meatless" chicken I have yet come across). The bright red curry in the Tikka is some of the most painfully spicy and delicious I have tried outside of traditional Indian Cuisine. It's kept fairly faithful including green peppers, onions, fennel and chili's in the mix. If you want the traditional pasty in a vegetarian form, try the Veggie Oggie. The assortment of potatoes, cheese, rutabagas and peppered beef is a flavor uniquely British.
The dessert selection is light, but doesn't disappoint in any way. Try the Banoffee Pie if you have any interest in combining the best elements of a banana split and a banana cream pie. The Strawberry Pavlova is a unique type of crunchy lime merengue topped with strawberries and whipped cream. It's sure to not disappoint those who are fans of fruit desserts.
The beer selection is adequate for a downtown Tempe spot, though if you are looking for a bar with it all, maybe try Casey Moore's Oyster house just down the street at University and Ash Ave.
The prices on beers are fair for a Tempe bar/restaurant, with a Bass costing in the area of $4.00. The selection is kept pretty close to brewers of Britain, Belgium and Scotland. Names like Smithwicks come about fairly often. There are a few California and German selections as well, such as IPA. Drafts are all European Ales, like Guinness and Newcastle. I think this keeps quite well to the British "pub in a cave" motif.
The Cornish Pasty Company is one of my favorite picks out of the Tempe area, and a great way to feed yourself before kicking off a night of hearty local partying, bicycle riding, barhopping, going to a show or whatever else the kids on Mill are doing these days. read more