Beautiful restaurant in downtown Indy, very pretty decor and a nice special occasion spot. The menu is pricey overall but everything we ate was well done. The sides are large enough to share between 2-3 people as well. Very respectful wait staff and we were taken care of throughout the meal well. There is also a speakeasy below the restaurant! read more

Commission Row - Cauliflower Steak, steak, Potato Gratin, Charred Broccolini - Steakhouses Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Welcoming this fancy Cunningham restaurant to Indianapolis downtown! It's right by Gainbridge Field House and often a difficult place to find parking in, but they have valet service @ $15. Upon entering, you'll notice the grandeur of the restaurant and we were greeted by two friendly faces who checked us in and walked us to the table. I'd made an OpenTable reservation and mentioned about needing a high chair which they quickly grabbed for us. The tall windows, exquisite light fixtures and modern look impressed me in an instant. I loved that the staff is accommodating to kids - brought a cup of water with straw for my toddler, a dog-shaped balloon and made sure to not keep silverware around her. The menu is impressive - we tried raw oysters, Brussels sprouts, salmon and seabass, all being good in presentation and taste. The staff was accommodating to food allergies and requests. My only complaint was the speed of service - it took us 20 minutes to get raw oysters which don't require any prep. While we'd ordered everything upfront (as the server requested probably knowing that the kitchen is slow), the wait between finishing oysters and getting our entree was ~20 minutes. There is a lot of staff so I don't believe it to be the bottleneck. I'm hoping once their machine is well-oiled, they'll be sure to earn the fifth star. I'm definitely going back! read more

Commission Row - Crispy Brussels Sprouts - Steakhouses Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Wanted to love it but have to say the service ruined the experience for us. We had about a party of 10 so having worked in the food industry I always give grace with service but our experience was a little crazy. We were there for almost 4 hours. Took 30 minutes at one point to even flag down a waiter to get our waters filled up. Never came around to check on us, if we wanted for drinks, how our food was. Some of our table had to flag down for the check because it was getting so late and they needed to get home to relieve sitters. Our friends that had been before raved about some dishes so we followed their suggestions and I wasn't impressed. The Caesar had no flavor, I asked for more dressing but never got it. Had to mount it in salt but didn't do anything, the pork chop was cold but couldn't even send it back because there was no waiter to send it back to. Mac n cheese had no flavor. I got a martini down at Mel's before and it was absolutely perfect. Ordered it the same way at dinner and tasted off. I asked the waitress and instead of doing something about how it tasted she told me it was made correct, didn't offer to make a new one. Pros - would come back for the burger and crab cakes, they were absolutely phenomenal. And the chocolate Swiss cake. However would not come back with a bigger group, maybe would sit at the bar but truly 4 hours for dinner?! Took over an our for the appetizers to come out and then almost 2 for our dinner then another hour for dessert then tracking down checks, a refill on water, ordering another round of drinks. Just crazy for a restaurant that's supposed to be higher class. Price tag was not worth it in my opinion. A little disappointed for how much we love Cunningham. read more

See all

Service was top tier. Expresso martini was delicious. Food was good. I've had the oysters.Waygu burger, shrimp cocktail and bone marrow. Ambience was amazing from the speak easy Mel's to the dining room at Commission row. read more

See all

Went here for an anniversary dinner and it was a phenomenal experience. We have been to other area fine dining/steak restaurants and Commission Row is easily in the top tier. Can't wait to come back! read more

Great space, good food and excellent service! Sat at the bar after drinks at Mel's. Everything was excellent.

Wow - CRG has done it again! This was a amazing meal. The salmon was to die for - and yes, I will be back. Drinks were good. I would go just for the salmon. I will say that the Caesar salad was a little tasteless, even though it is one of their "dishes" but the salmon made up for it. Dessert was lovely. Service was lovely- even though it was a devour menu, never felt like anyone was looking down their noses at us other guests had the fillet, and they said they could cut it with a butter knife. It was so wonderful and cooked amazingly to perfection - I'm always amazed by the number of steakhouses that claimed to be great that don't know what medium rare is - this place does. Highly recommend - will be back - want to try out Mel's as wellthank you for a lovely evening commission Rob and Maliyah. read more

Our service and food were amazing! The atmosphere was great! We can't wait to go back! read more

See all

Another great dining experience at Commission Row! I held my birthday/retirement dinner party here and my guests are still raving about the customer service, delicious food, a beautiful atmosphere. We started with fabulous, crafted cocktails at Mel's (thank you Jay for the private room), followed by dinner upstairs in the semi-private dining room. From the moment I walked in, EVERYONE went above & beyond to make my party special! Shout outs to Stephanie Bevins (Sales Mgr), Michelle Lennis (Events Coordinator), Jay Leonard (Asst GM), Ian Sarayan (Exec GM), and last but certainly not least....my favorite server in Indianapolis...Ben! If you dine here, please request Ben...he goes above and beyond to make you feel special and to ensure that you & your guests have an extraordinary dining experience! read more

See all

Food was good. Atmosphere great! Def check out Mel's Soeakeasy within the building too! read more

See all

might be one of my new favorite restaurants in indy! went there for dinner for the first time last night and it was amazing. it was a super busy night downtown and the service was still efficient and everyone was so attentive. espresso martini - must get! one of the best i've had. we got the crab cakes to start and they were so light and delish. we got the sea bass and salmon - both were perfectly cooked and SO flavorful. can't wait to come back! read more

Commission Row - Ora King Salmon* - Steakhouses Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Highly recommend this restaurant! Love the ambience and vibes. Great food! Highly recommend.

Amazing experience for my first visit to commission row and I cannot wait to go back! We sat in the bar! Service was awesome food was tasty and ambience was top notch! read more

See all

Great atmosphere with knowledgeable servers. It's a little pricey but the experience is well worth the cost... read more

See all

Server was top notch. Atmosphere was really nice. Everything my wife ordered was fantastic. But how do you screw up one of your most expensive steaks 3 times in a row?! First time was basically well done. Second one came out blue. They tried to bring it to med rare but all the did was overcook the outside while the middle was still raw. If you're charging that much for a steak it should come out perfect every single time. Worst birthday experience ever... read more

My wife and I had dinner there for my birthday and it was wonderful. Our food was excellent from the first bite to our last. The service was exceptional. Issac was entertaining and knowledgeable along with everyone else we encountered. Highly recommend. read more

What a wonderful and delicious spot in the circle city! Commission Row mixes upscale swag with a delicious food menu. It was so good we are doing brunch the next day. The steak was prepared well as were the scallops and the sea bass. The cocktails (Paloma for me) were delicious and delightful. I will be back and will bring more people! Viva la Commission Row! Five stars too to our server Jack who killed it! read more

Commission Row - Lemon Yuzu Cheesecake - Steakhouses Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Extremely beautiful restaurant with three levels of dining. We arrived towards the end of the Pacers game crowd to celebrate my birthday. Definitely a great restaurant to celebrate special occasions. We got the wagyu burger (10/10), mac & cheese, seafood salad, and for dessert, the Brie fried cheesecake (might have been a little burnt). Our waiter kept disappearing for long moments at a time, but thankfully other employees were very kind and checking in on us. Parking is available at the Virginia Ave. garage and they also offer valet parking. Would love to come back in a couple of months, and also check out the speakeasy downstairs. read more

See all

Met some friends for dinner here. Had reservations for 7 but didn't get seated until 7:30. It was a busy night. No big deal - we sat at the bar and enjoyed drinks. The bar had a very cool atmosphere. Once we were seated, the waiter greeted us and was very knowledgeable. Unfortunately, he was very slow too. It took quite some time to get our drinks and food. Again, it was a busy night. The food was good, but for the price, I've had better. $68 for a steak is a bit much. I would go again, but probably just to sit at the bar. read more

Ambiance and service were top notch! Great spot for a birthday celebration. Filet was cooked perfectly. read more

Commission Row - Birthday dessert - Steakhouses Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Let me start by saying that this is a beautiful Restaurant. When you walk in, you certainly do feel like you are in for an upscale experience. Overall, I would say that the service was good but not great. There were long periods of time where we were unable to locate our server. We were a table of 4, and the overall bill for the 4 of us was about $800+tip. When dining somewhere that has these prices, I will say that my expectations are pretty high, and I think they should be. Apps came out and were pretty good, maybe the best part of the meal. The carpaccio was probably the best thing that I ate that night. Now this is where things went downhill. We had the tomahawk ($169) and 2 ribeyes ($69 and $110) at the table. Only one of the steaks was cooked to correctly. The tomahawk was WAY under and cut poorly, so impossible to send back to the grill. One of the ribeyes was fine, and the other was sent back. When we got the refired steak, they waited as it was cut into at the table. It was raw, and my friend was asked if it was okay. He told them it was fine, and decided to eat it because the rest of the table had already finished eating. Once the waitress came back to the table, she ended up taking it off the bill and offering free dessert. Obviously, that's really kind, but disappointing. We had 4 of the sides, all fine, but nothing special at all. Same that you would find anywhere. Steaks could be helped out by more seasoning. Desserts were good, but once again, nothing special. Overall, I wouldn't say that it wasn't good at all, I would just say that for $800 bucks, I was really hoping to get food that was more memorable than your run of the mill Texas Roadhouse or Longhorn. If you want to go to a big fancy expensive place, give it a shot. If you want a good steak, and food you might remember something other than the price, I might suggest you look elsewhere. read more

A beautiful experience with my wife. The lamb chops were very good . The special was yummy. It included various seafood selections. Desserts were excellent Service was amazing Atmosphere first class read more

A great steakhouse adjacent to Gainbridge Fieldhouse. Ambience was top notch, and second only to service. Staff was attentive and knowledgeable. The 14oz strip was flavorful and cooked to a perfect medium. The sides were a step above local competition and each had a unique spin to the presentation. A place to keep near the top of your list! read more

Excellent food and even better service! The lobster bisque and A5 is a must-get! Best food in downtown Indy!

Another CRG win. Beautiful space, and its size and decor remind me of a more urban city like NYC or Chicago. The food was great and the service was top notch. The bar downstairs was cute too! read more

Wow. Had dinner with girlfriends tonight at CR and was very impressed for opening weekend. Our waiter Jason was phenomenal and the sommelier's recommendations were delicious (plus he gave us a tour of the event space). We had a variety of dishes including the meatballs, ceasar salad, sea bass, filet, salmon, French fries and brussels. All delicious and perfectly cooked. The entire space from event rooms to the speak easy was very well done. Definitely will return. read more

Wow wow wow! What an amazing new restaurant from the Cunningham group! A very good date night or business dinner spot. Everything is delicious and we decided to get a lot of things and share. The popovers, salad, steak, au gratin potatoes and Brussels sprouts were all 10/10. Definitely recommend! Then after dinner make sure to check out the cocktail bar downstairs! read more

Beautifully prepared and presented food in a stunning setting. Desserts are beyond belief, so be sure to save room to experience the decadent magic. Bone marrow, wagyu meatballs, sea bass and potatoes gratin are also shining stars. Consider starting with a cocktail. The Gibson was our favorite. read more

See all

Commission Row has been on my list for some time now! The restaurant is absolutely beautiful! I had the Caesar salad and the Ora King salmon. Both were delicious. The texture of the shaved Brussel sprouts opposed to your typical Caesar salad was amazing. Also, salmon and grapefruit-so tasty! Salmon was cooked perfectly and all great portion sizes. I Will definitely be back! read more

Pretty underwhelming for the price. The wagyu steak I got and the broccolini was barely warm. I just expected more and was disappointed

Food was good, but the wait was not. Got there at 5pm for a 7pm Pacers game. Seated at 5:15. Ordered around 5:30-5:35. Didn't get food until 6:25. For the cost I would have loved to enjoy the food but that did not happen. Won't be going again read more

Dined here for the first time with some friends and generally enjoyed the experience. The service was good for Indiana, though slightly rushed in ordering at each stage (for a fine dining restaurant at that price point, I would expect a little more, but tempered expectations are important in this state). Food was incredibly well seasoned and very tasty -- from the salad to the mains to the sides. Drinks were good, though a little on the expensive side. Table touch by the manager or maitre d'hotel. The main downside was that my friend's steak was overcooked by two steps (came out medium well instead of medium rare). When a steak alone is $65, you'd expect them to get it right -- especially at a place that features its steaks. They offered to recook, but we didn't want to wait for him to get his food for another 15 minutes, and it was _all right_, so we declined. Follow up by maitre d', but nothing more than a half-hearted apology. No comped coffee or dessert or anything for a pretty big mistake, especially when they don't have to eat the cost of a second steak. That right there is a clear marker of middling service at a "fine dining" restaurant. Would that I had read the other reviews about the steak first -- I would have informed my dining companion so that we could avoid. Otherwise, would recommend with the caveat that things cost 10-20% more than you might expect at such a place. read more

Love it and can't wait to go back August 1 20024 food and service was excellent. A few of my associates Itold them about it and they loved it as well. read more

Amazing!! Visited during devour and it was incredible. Ordered the Ceasar, filet and crème brûlée. Ceasar was a little sub par but the filet couldn't of been any better. Cooked to perfection. Amazing berry mocktail! Service was fantastic. Highly recommend with any visit to Indy. read more

Lovely atmosphere Good food, staff was fine Perfect date night evening or for groups read more

Great food, great service, great atmosphere. We got complimentary champagne & dessert for our anniversary! We had the 14oz ribeye & pork chop, both amazing! For apps we had lobster bisque & popovers! The speakeasy (Mel's) downstairs is also grea read more

See all

As CRG fans we were excited to try this restaurant out and it did not disappoint. Beautiful decor as usual and service was attentive with a personal touch. We started with the popovers and the Waygu meatballs. I wanted to crawl inside the popover and take a nap it was so good. Waygu meatballs were also delicious, a little dense for me. Each couple split a steak (dry aged NY strip and ribeye) as well as a few shareable sides (Brussels sprouts and mashed potatoes). The sprouts were fantastic, the mashed potatoes for sure the most boring part of the meal. The absolute star and the reason the meatballs and the mashed potatoes don't bring it down to a 4 star were the steaks. A buttery flavor bomb, probably the best steak I've ever had and we are steak people. We then went downstairs to the speakeasy, the Blood and Guts cocktail (essentially a Negroni) was so, so good. Yes, this is a priceyyy establishment. But we are excited to return! read more

We had an incredible anniversary dinner here. Service was outstanding, and all of the food and drinks were excellent. We'd definitely go back for a nice family dinner or work event. Mel's Speakeasy was also worth a stop in. Great ambiance, drinks, and live music. read more

Great meal - beautiful atmosphere with upscale feel. Server was very attentive. Had the 10oz filet and it just melted in your mouth - also good cocktail and wine selections. read more

You cannot go wrong with anything you order here. We started with the popovers and meatballs. Both were delicious. I had the 7 oz filet and it was the perfect size and the crust on the steak was . We ordered sides to share which were the brussel sprouts and Mac n cheese and both were delicious. Highly recommend as a date night or girls night out. read more