The service was excellent and pickup was actually earlier than the time they gave. Workers are polite and the inside is clean. Always love coming here, very good pizza place for everyday eats! read more

Too bad condone now!! What happened to the $5-$6 pies? $21 for a pie with barely enough cheese or sauce?? $20 in delivery fees and tips. Not what it used to be will order from Real Deal fro here out. read more

Love this place! been going here for years! New manager Eric is a super nice guy and always takes such great care me! they have added some new stuff to the menu and even have ice cream inside now! Keep up the good work Comella's... I WILL be back!! read more

I'm giving them a 3 because overall the food is good. But I did have a bad experience with them regarding uber eats because my food was not in tamper-evident packaging! My uber driver ate all my French fries, left me like 10 and who knows what else he touched from my order! I called and they apologized, but when people order from third parties, you need to make sure everything is sealed to perfection! I wasted $45 on touched food and uber eats won't even refund me! read more

The worst cheese pizza I have ever eaten. Will never go here again. Tastes like cardboard and very salty. read more

Comella's - a half eaten pizza in a box - Italian Near Me - Boston, Massachusetts

As a vegetarian and an Italian food lover, I am deeply disappointed. Today, I was starving and decided to order the Ma's pasta dish, which claims to be vegetarian. On my second serving, I see a piece of what looks to be a meatball. I also regretfully decided to get a cheese pizza as well, which was mediocre and burnt. I will never be buying from you Italian frauds again. Don't buy please, your tastebuds will thank me later. read more

Third week in a row of getting the wrong order! I've tried using English to communicate there? Next time maybe sign language? I don't know but, this is the last time for me cause my wrong order was horrible! Hopefully the person who received my order had better luck! read more

This was the worst pizza I've ever had in my life. I could barely gagg down one slice read more

I am giving 3 stars but really 2.5. Their prices have been rising and while the food is usually pretty good I expect better. This trip was a disappointment. When I fork over $85+ for a couple of pizzas and 3 meals I would hope to get what I ordered. read more

Comella's - Steak and cheese pizza? Not much shaved steak in my opinion. - Italian Near Me - Boston, Massachusetts

See all

Great pizza, entrees and subs! They also have great entrees. It's very delicious. The desserts are really good as well.

Delicious and very fast serviced Italian American food. They do a good job with their pasta dishes with excellent red sauce and just recently, I tried the olive oil butter garlic sauce with sweet peppers, chicken and broccoli. This is the neighborhood favorite take out and there hasn't been a time when they were not busy. They have excellent wine and beer selections while you wait you can dine inside or have take out. I am frequent client and my husband is completely in love with this place. They also have excellent pizzas even though I really don't go there for that but everybody else seems to love them. read more

Comella's - Simply delicious. - Italian Near Me - Boston, Massachusetts

Surprised at how flavorful my chicken brocolli alfredo was- I've found that this dish can be pretty bland and mushy and just not very good, especially from a take out kind of place, so I was not expecting much, but it really hit the spot and was rich and comforting. Friends enjoyed their pizza as well- so overall they're pretty solid. read more

The eggplant used to be the best but the last 2 times it's been all bread crumbs and minimal eggplant. I was so disappointed and won't likely return. read more

as you can see in the trash. My order was cold pizza was hard as a rock ...taking a break from here for a while read more

Comella's - As you can see in the trash. My order was cold pizza was hard as a rock ...taking a break from here for a while - Italian Near Me - Boston, Massachusetts

Just ordered 2 delicious pizzas and an appetizer of calamari The pizzas were cooked perfectly and the side order of calamari was oh so good. The delivery person was truly professional and courteous. She made the delivery well worth the wait. Definitely worth the time and will definitely order from here again read more

Just picked up two pizzas here. Told me 20 minutes. A plain and a pepperoni. 45 minutes later got one over cooked and one half done. Three teenagers are running this shop on a Saturday night??? C'mon! I can't get two simple pizzas cooked and on time?? read more

Comella's - Over cooked pepperoni - Italian Near Me - Boston, Massachusetts

See all

I'm never going back here. My family of 5 went there for end of week pizza and were told 30 minutes. Sure thing. We bought chips and chocolate milk for the kids and prepared to wait for our 3 pizzas. They brought one out after about 10 minutes, and the other 2 didn't come for nearly a half hour AFTER that. No communication, we had to ask twice and when I asked the first time, she said "well I moved one up to being you that one." Great, so half my family is done eating and ready to leave, and the other half is starving and cranky. One of the pizzas that came late was wrong when they brought it. Not to mention the feeing of exclusivity in the place if you're not a white family from one of the private schools in W Rox. For the price we paid ($67 including a tip) suffice it to say I can go somewhere else where my family is treated more respectfully. read more

The only reason why I went here was because I got a $5 off coupon. They could've gave me $20 off and it still wasn't worth it. Steak and cheese - there was more foil wrapping covering the sandwich than steak in it. Veal parm sub - no cheese on it. Clearly says it comes with mozzarella but no. I guess they don't understand the concept of "parmigiana." Never again read more

Ordered six meatballs from there yesterday. Put them in the microwave to heat them up and thought they smelled weird. My boyfriend and I both took one bite and could tell they were old and sour! Absolutely gross! We did bring them back and got a refund. Won't be returning ever! read more

Lasagna is an Italian Dish, and always made with Ground Meat, "plenty" of Tomato Sauce, Mozzarella & Parmesan Cheese. So please put in your menú Ricotta Lasagna so customer will know in advance that is your own recipe. Weeks waiting to eat a real Lasagna Dish and I was disappointed. Veal Parmigiana was delicious, but needed much more Sauce. But, thanks for being on the frontline in this hard times, it was a blessing to be able to order food at least one day. read more

A clean, snappy little Italian comfort food joint with a huge menu (see reviews for the Newton location - there's also one in Wellesley) and as you'd expect, generous (though not insanely so) portions. They're known for their "mess" which they describe as an Italian goulash. It's basically sauce, pasta, cheese, and total goodness - you select one of their 20+ variations of meats and veggies. Their veal parmigiana seemed a bit over-breaded but other than that all the food has a great fresh flavor - very tomatoey and more emphasis on oregano than garlic (a plus in my book). I can't wait to go back to try some of their fresh ravioli - with fillings like asparagus, goat cheese, and sweet potato, in addition to standard cheese, meat, and seafood - it sounds so good! read more

Mess = Italian Goulash is about right. Imagine if a tray of lasagna and a tray of mixed pasta got into a knife fight and disemboweled each other onto your plate. Then various yummy meats swung by to hear what the racket was, slipped in the red sauce gore and joined the pile. That's mess. Looks horrible, tastes fantastic. This place is a great to-go option for parties and entertaining. The mess scales perfectly.. just tell 'em how many people you've got, how hungry they are, and they can recommends how many trays to get. The other menu options are more hit or mess, but nothing has been downright awful. While it's clear most of this place's business is takeout, but it does have some seats and tables if you want to eat in. read more

Stopped by on a whim this afternoon, and picked up a frozen takeout "seafood ravioli" for way too much $$. But, I thought, I have had a good experience in the past eating in... It was just short of disgusting, as the "seafood" was mushy and tasted old and fishy. I threw out about half the order (hey, I was starved and washing it down with an OK Bordeaux). Bottom line - I won't buy their takeout for anything. But eating in.... read more

REALLY GOOD ITALIAN CUISINE!!!! It's hard to find legit Italian food in this city, but Comella's is the place to go! You can order meatballs & sausages & pastas to go, or dine in and relax. Simple, clean atmosphere, always with the game of the day/night on TV's. If you love authentic, fresh Italian food.....check this place out! You'll be glad you did. . read more

Comella's compelled me to make my first review of a place on Yelp... My roommates and I frequent Comella's for our dose of homemade Italian food (don't expect gourmet, expect homemade). My roommates would get the messes (trust me when I say that calling the meal a 'mess' is a term of endearment for the dish) and I would go the meals (chicken parm, calamari parm, chicken broc and ziti). We always hoot-and-holler about how good the food is after we eat it, but two weeks ago everything changed at Comellas...for the BETTER. They had free samples of the new pizza they were implementing into their menu and my roommates and I literally ate the whole 'free sample' pie (we kind of abused the whole "free sample" mentality). Now afterwards we chalked the immense appeal of the pizza to us being ravenous as it was 8:30 PM, but the next day we ordered the pizza and were absolutely AMAZED. I am serious when I say that Comella's pizza is easily in my top 5 pizzas I have ever had (and I've had my fair share). The best part is that a large cheese pizza is $5!!!! The Upper Crust is down the road and the prices are about 60% higher there for an inferior pizza. We have had the cheese, buffalo chicken, sausage and garlic, and pepperoni pizza and have loved all of them. I would love to hear if anyone else out there agrees with me. Tell me if you find this helpful. read more

I've been a customer of Comella's for over 8 years. I recently bought 3 pizzas....and was very disappointed. It's still a relatively fair price at $8.25 for a cheese pizza, however the pizza is really suffering in quality. Pizza dough was almost unrisen... a very flat pizza. Had enough cheese, but not enough sauce. Also, two of the pizzas were on the smaller side and failed to fill the pizza box. For a while, Comella's was a good place for a consistently decent pizza at a good price. Pizza price is going up and quality is going down. read more

People told me to give it another chance, I did, here is what I think: If legendary Italian Christopher Columbus awoke from the dead and this was his first meal, he would crawl back into his grave and rebury himself with his own hands; but not before changing the name on his stone to read "O'Neil" out of embarrassment for the food he ate which was called 'Italian'. This is not Italian food. read more

Was craving eggplant parmesan, which I probably should have gotten with their infamous "mess" but just got ziti on the side. $6.99 for a good two meals, pretty tasty altho the sauce was a little on the sweet side. It did hit the spot and I'd be there more often (so many things to try) if West Rox. was a little more in my hood. read more

They have an awesome deal on plain cheese pizzas. Add toppings and it climbs in price but still worth it. I'd give them 5 stars but a lot of their food (ex. pasta/lasanga plate) is pricey - worth the money by and large but not cheap. Also, their phone system is a little screwy during peak order hours. You won't be disapointed if you eat or order out from here. Staff is super friendly too. read more

This is Italian homemade cuisine to it's finest! We've ordered a tray (they have different sizes of containers for takeout) of rigatoni with chicken and sausage. My God, delicious! We finished the whole platter. The combination of the meats with the pasta, sauce and cheese was to die for! I would seriously go there every week, if I could.... Perfect food to share with family and friends.... read more

I've had the pleasure of eating Comella's food twice. The first time was at the Wellesley location, and I got a "MESS." It was delicious. This NEXT time went above and BEYOND my expectations of delicious Italian Food... The theater I do a lot of work at, The Newton Country Players, just finished their show, "The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee," and my friends Chrissy and Nathan were hosting our cast party!!! When Chrissy said she was ordering food from Comella's, I knew it was good...BUT THIS GOOD?!?!?!?! WOW! They are super nice, too. Our show got out at 10pm, which was past closing time. The owner told Chrissy to text her when she was done with the show. The owner lives down the street from the restaurant and was nice enough to go BACK to the restaurant when it was closed to get our order!!!! That's a COMMITMENT to WONDERFUL service!!! EXCELLENT Customer Service and EXCELLENT Food!!!!!! read more

Comella's has become my post COVID19 go to. They provide delicious Italian comfort food with fantastic service. The menu has a great range as well including salads, appetizers, pizza, entrees. My personal favorites are the antipasta salad (at least two meals), chicken Parmesan, and meatballs. I love, love their red sauce! Also, I find their pizza to be the most delicious for the price. Customer service and delivery is great. Keep your local businesses in business. Comella's is fantastic! read more

Not bad. Pizza is at a fair price. Pizza isnt the greatest but certainly not the worst. My family loves to go in for a quick bite and cheap pizza when in a pinch! read more

I have been coming here since they had $5 large cheese pizza. The price has gone up to $8.50 (I can't recall the exact price but it was 8 something) but I still find Comella's pizza to be one of the best bang for the buck. You get a perfectly thin yet soft crust with the perfect amount of tomato sauce topped with just the right amount of mozzarella on top. The pizza is always fresh, consistent, and tastes amazing. I no longer live nearby but whenever I have my pizza cravings, it is totally worth driving 30 min to get my fav Comella's cheese pizza. read more

I joined Yelp just to rate this place. I've been looking for a place like this since I started going to school here 7 years ago. Usually in Boston, in terms of Italian fare, it's either pizza on the low end of the spectrum or a classy joint on the high end. Dropping $20-25 on two people for an actual meal doesn't happen. I can cook Italian food pretty well, but sometimes you just want some quality takeout. A lot of the pizza places in the area have food, but that doesn't mean its necessarily good. The food here, on the other hand, is top notch. I went here with my father, who is a sauce snob and he loved it. That never happens. I had the sweet potato ravioli, which was out of control. My father had the beef ravioli, which was also really good. Portions were good. I'll be able to get at least two meals from my serving. The dining room is a little weird, but I won't fault them for it because it works- its not sure if its a formal restaurant or a take-out place with a dining room. I've been living up the street for 6 months now and have overlooked this place for some reason, but I'll be going back. Often. read more

Whenever I have a craving for some gnocchi, I go to Comella's. I really like their spinach gnocchi. Gnocchi is not the easiest thing to do well. Their sauce is just okay - it has a consistency that I just can't put my finger on. Maybe it's a little greasy almost? It's not bad, just not my favorite. They have a pretty big menu, with a billion types of the "mess" which is Comella's specialty, which is a mix of all sorts of things. Anyway, one of the reasons I don't eat here too often is that it's not cheap. A single serving of spinach gnocchi is $10. Granted I get a meal and a half out of this, but I still don't like spending that much on lunch on a regular basis. Come on, people, we're in a recession here! I've also only had takeout from here, so I can't comment on how it is to actually eat here. Whenever I'm craving tasty Italian food though, I will definitely go to Comella's! If they ever drop their prices (which never happens... anywhere) then maybe they'd earn 4 stars from me. Until then, they're a solid 3 stars. read more

Waited 90 minutes (after website said 60) for SUPER dry chicken fingers, and a sandwich with burned chicken and soggy bread. They also forgot part of my order. Did not eat more than a bite of anything. Got full refund. read more

The $5 cheese pizza is the best deal in town and it's really good. I don't consider pizza a meal, it's more of a snack food and this is rightly priced for snacking. It's the most consistent pizza - crust is light & thin, sauce is slightly sweet, and a great combination of cheese. If you want to make it a meal try a side of eggplant parm. I'm not a fan of the highly touted "mess" combinations but I have had the shrimp scampi is a large order and that was great. Beware the wait time on pizza is long during peak hours so plan ahead for takeout. read more

Our go to place for cheese pizza. At $5 a piece, you can't go wrong. We are trying the Mess next time we visit.

WTF is a MESS plate? the menu is VERY confusing and makes no sense. My head was spinning and eventually just randomly picked something called a MESS plate (FYI they are ALL called MESS plate) Shrimp is overcooked, pasta is mushy and overcooked, the calamari is ABYSMAL and shameful. The only reason why I haven't given this a one star is because i haven't tried the pizza. That better be some BOMB pizza mate. read more