The staff is friendly, and the ice cream is great. However, the wait time is unreasonable, mainly because of poor management. There are not enough employees working to handle both online and in-person orders. On a busy Friday night, there should be more than three people working. It creates an unpleasant experience for customers, and I'm sure the workers feel overwhelmed as well. read more

I love a good cold stone ice cream- some brownie pieces and whip mixed in is one of my favorites combos but the combinations are endless. They also have yummy caramel apples read more

Went in to order a Shake. 2 employees working and there were 4 people in front of me. Eventually a manager (I think) came out to help me. Ordered a Strawberry Shake with Chocolate jimmies no whip. Paid ~$10 for a small. It was the worst Shake I've ever had. Way too much milk, not enough jimmies, lack of strawberry flavor (due to these excessive milk. It also tasted as if the milk was either just expired or about to turn. Just order ice cream here... read more

My wife and I came here on date night after eating pizza next door. The first thing you notice when you walk in is the overwhelming smell of sweetness. Sort of like a Yankee Candle store, your senses are overloaded with fragrances of sugar and (artificial?) flavorings. The candy counters are in the front and the ice cream is in the back. Probably logical from a sales standpoint, but the long, thin store is arranged so that it almost seems the ice cream is secondary. Regardless, they had about 8-10 flavors of ice cream. They also had a display case full of things that could be mixed in like candy and cookies. My wife got the black cherry frozen yogurt. She chose to not have anything mixed in, and didn't want one of the special cones (which seems to me to be missing the whole point of this place, but oh well). I just had a piece of chocolate candy to go as I was full. The frozen yogurt was excellent. I loved the way it tasted, but I also love frozen yogurt probably more than ice cream. It is a shame I was too full to really get the full experience so hopefully I can come back sometime when I am hungrier and really do it up right. This place looks to be a lot of fun (and quite a bit of a sugar rush!) read more

I'm never going back. They charge almost $13 for 2 scoops in a burnt waffle bowl. This is the quality they find acceptable? The owner needs to sell to someone who knows what they're doing. The ice cream tastes incredible, but it doesn't justify this, and to my dismay, it did not overpower the burned waffle bowl taste. My addiction to this ice cream is conquered. read more

I haven't been to a Cold Stone in about a decade and just had a craving for some cookie dough something today. The staff was very friendly and helpful to me figuring out which order was mine. The place looked clean, other than the staff it was empty at the time I arrived. It was a pick up order. I ordered a quart of Cookie Doughn't You Want Some. I just the whole thing. Yes, I did. No, there is no shame. However my main disappointment was that there were exactly 4 pieces if cookie dough in the whole thing. End of the world no, but to me it was the whole point of that menu item and I had to actively look for the 4 pieces in a quart. Also, I live quite close (5min) and it was pretty soupy when I get home to eat it. Not sure if it had been in a freezer or just out on a counter waiting for me. The taste of the ice cream and other flavors were pretty good aside from the mostly missing ingredient. read more

It wasn't possible to give them negative stars or I would. 21 friggin dollars into small ice cream vines. On top of that they wouldn't let customers use the bathroom they said it's for employees only. Tgey said you can go to Starbucks and use their bathroom. This lousy business will never get a penny from me again! Wow just wow read more

I would rate Cold Stone 5 stars only if it wasn't so pricey. Otherwise, this place is heaven to go for ice cream.

I love Cold Stone but this one just sucks. I don't know if it's because they hire people who are incompetent or because the people there don't have an incentive to work correctly, but every time I go here I am let down. The first time I went to this location, they ran out of reese's pieces, the second time I went, they put in the wrong toppings when I asked, and the third time I went in, they were cash only but didn't tell us until after ordering and making my order. The person working then made a rude and sarcastic comment "didn't you hear us saying it's cash only?" as though I must've been listening to their own self-bickering. Very upsetting since Cold Stone is the only good ice cream. read more

Ice cream and toppings are good but staff is consistently rude and act like I'm inconveniencing them by entering the store.

Staff is friendly and the ice cream is great. BUT the wait is unreasonable. AND it's entirely due to poor management. There are not enough staff members working to complete online and in person orders.... Have more than 3 people working on a busy Friday night. It's unpleasant for the patrons and I'm sure the workers feel overwhelmed. read more

Only had one option for frozen yogurt black cherry . It was good but not for 7 dollars for the smallest size . The staff was nice and place was clean and nice atmosphere read more

Expensive but so worth it! The store itself is a little small so it's hard to maintain 6ft distance.

Unsanitary! No Universal Precautions practiced. If you look at the ceiling vents and walls in the areas where the food is, you will see mounds of dust. If the workers are actually using gloves, you will observe them using the same pair to work with the ice cream, cash out a customer on the touch screen POS system and handle money. Gloves are not changed between transactions or between customers. the ice cream scoopers are placed in water that has been used by multiple other workers and they are not cleaned or sanitized. Additionally, no social distancing. Workers are not wearing masks. In this age of Covid and the spread of the virus so easily. You would think they would do better read more

Cold Stone is one of my favorite Ice Cream places in this area. They have many varieties of different Ice Cream, Milkshakes and even signature creations. Today I tried a signature creation called All Lovin' No Oven. It has Cake Batter Ice Cream, Fudge, cookie dough and whipped cream. I would definitely recommend to try this ice cream. It's one of the best ones I've tried there. I would also recommend the milkshakes there. My personal favorite is the Cookies and Cream. If you're looking to try a new Ice Cream place, Cold Stone should be a good shot. read more

Cold Stone Creamery - All Lovin' No Oven - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Albany, New York

Great place to get some heavy creamy ice cream custom made. They dance for tips. Cloths stay on so it is still family friendly ;) They also sell cookies and other desserts like caramel turtles in their bakery section and provide ice cream cakes with certain themes like Wonder Woman and Batman. My wife's favorite are their vanilla ice cream sandwiches with sprinkles. I like their Oreo sandwiches with real Oreo cream flavored ice cream but they don't have it lately. Hopefully it'll make a comeback! read more

Cold Stone Creamery - The first ingredient. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Albany, New York

See all

I think the new manager needs to remember that she is in the service business. I was already frustrated with the length of time to get served, even when empty. Recently, I was informed that we would no longer be provided with gluten-free birthday cakes. We've been getting them for my daughter since they opened. No training and no community focus is a great way to lose customers. Probably time the new manger becomes the former manager. read more

This place needs a manager. One that actually knows how to train the employees. There is zero communication between these young girls. They all seem to be a little lost at times. Btw. We are there every week so this is not a one time appearance ! We enjoy the plaza and try to make sure they have customers !! read more

filled with people who clearly can't understand english and the difference between BANANA and VANILLA, made my first experience awful never coming here again read more

I went here at 8:45 on a Thursday night just to find out that they were closed after I checked the hours before. I walked up to the door to try to get in and the worker inside just shrugged their shoulders and then looked away. Why would they close over two hours early? Definitely won't be back here because of the lack of service. read more

Hate going to this Cold stone location because they're either too busy and the line is out the door or you're waiting forever because the service is so slow. I love the Ice cream but they need to hire more people and get ones that have a better attitude. read more

This cold stone ice cream is the same as any other place its not special really its kinda overpriced and this location is horrid maybe if I went somewhere else it would've been better but the wait is always 30 minutes just to place the order and they only have like two people working behind the counter so it goes very slow read more

I went into cold stone on saturday night with my 2 kids and as we walked in there was water all over the floor and there was no caution signs. Also it smelled terrible. All the workers look like they were under 18 years old. This is very unsaturated and disgusting as you are serving people icecream in these terrible conditions. read more

I absolutely love ice cream and Cold Stone Creamery in Stuyvesant Plaza is the best by far and I have literally been to every ice cream spot in the Capital Region. The service that I receive when I go in is excellent. The entire team is super! They are all extremely friendly and the fantastic service is what keeps me coming back for more. read more

When we visited here, all the employees were engaged in prolonged, personal chit-chat while blatantly ignoring customers. I had to finally interrupt them to ask if it was my turn to be helped yet.  The young man who begrudgingly served me was as nasty as could be. We ordered some of their chocolates to go.  We wanted to get out of there as soon as possible because, not only were customers being treated like crap, but the store itself reeked with a strong, foul-smelling odor.  The stench was so pervasive that it actually infused the chocolates in the display case.  We were forced to throw out the ones we bought, which, at $22 a pound, was totally unacceptable.  Instead of contacting the Health Department, however, I opted to simply fill out an online complaint form to Coldstone's main office later that night to alert them of these conditions. The worst of it, however, was when the owner contacted me the next day in response to my comments.  Rather than appreciating a customer's helpful feedback, he immediately launched into defense of his rude employees;  dismissed that overwhelming stink in the store as it being my imagination, and oddly accused me of "blackmailing" him - though all I suggested he do was to look into the situation before it starts affecting his business!  This paranoid individual became so abusive to me that I was forced to end the discussion by hanging up on him in mid-rant. I found lots of online reviews where others claimed they, too, were treated poorly by the nasty workers at this location.  Now, after speaking with their equally nasty boss - who ignorantly condones their bad behavior - I can certainly understand why.  In his bogus retort, below, "Brian" claims the "owner, crew, and management team" were all interviewed and investigated  "within 2 hours of receiving complaint". That's funny, because I sent my complaint form in after midnight that night. Did he wake them out of their beds at 2am?  He should be correcting the conditions at his store rather than making up stories to discredit a respected reviewer. read more

Cold Stone has decent ice cream, but nothing special. There is a lot of different flavors to choose from, but the ice cream is very heavy. Also they don't serve soft ice cream which is absurd for an Creamery. Also the wait time here is absurd. It took over 20 minutes to get a cup of ice cream. I don't know what the employees were doing. The price is outrageous, it costs almost $10 for a cup of ice cream. Overall, Cold Stone is not worth the wait and price. read more

It's hard to compete with the ice cream places in Albany because there are so many good places. It's been about a decade since I've been to a Cold Stone. Got the cheesecake ice cream with graham cracker crust and Oreo. Satisfied yes, wowed no. Pricey without the warm hometown feel of one of the local ice cream shops. read more

Cold Stone Creamery - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Albany, New York

Please, for the love of God, do not order a custom cake here. I wanted to put a photo on top, which they said they would gladly do. They gave me 4 wrong emails to send the photo to. I sent probably 10 emails over the course of 3 days trying to get this worked out. Really terrible experience. Many other places around have wonderful cakes with better service. They did nothing to make it right. read more

Always a favorite of mine! Great customer service from a young staff. So impressed even though it was ten minutes to close no one acted annoyed at the large group I walked in with. The ice cream is obviously good but nice to see the employees so friendly read more

I'm usually not an ice cream fan, but when the craving hits, I want sugar baby!! This is the place to go. I've done a lot of the mixing, and I usually just get a like it cause otherwise I'll get in a sugar coma after a few bites. It's really heavy but absolutely delicious ice cream. Their new sundaes are SO amazing, they put a nice light vanilla on it, and I had the brownie one that was so delicious. The service though was absolutely amazing. The girl who worked there clearly LOVED her job (or was great at faking it) she was friendly, fast, and asked us if we liked it afterwords. I love happy customer service! Honestly, I can get ice cream anywhere, I can make my own brownie sundae really...but if I can get service like that I'd absolutely end up going back. read more

Super friendly staff. Always accommodating to a sample (or 2!). Cake batter icecream is a go-to....and they have candy apples! read more

Cold Stone Creamery - Coffee peanut butter chocolate goodness! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Albany, New York

Great pumpkin ice cream. A cool place to hang out. Person behind the counter was incredibly friendly. Wide selection, but a little pricey. They will kneed in marshmallows until they crunch. Yum. read more

Cold Stone Creamery - The cakes. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Albany, New York

I've been craving cold stone for a while now and when I finally decide to get some it's complete garbage overall. I waited in line ,which by the way there were only 2 people in front of me, for a couple minutes listening to the coworkers discuss their plans for later tonight. They took the couple and then me after a minute or two. Like there's two of you. FIGURE IT OUT. One takes one couple the other one takes the other. Whatever. Then I order some ice cream and I get it and it's like soup. I didn't want soup. I wanted ice cream. Then they packed my to go pint and they took me at checkout before the people in front of me. Made no sense. They also didn't give me a top and I'm holding this toddler of mine and he's diving in like no big deal. Anyways I'll never crave this place again. Horrible service and horrible ice cream. read more

How can a national chain be called local flavor!? The ice cream is super sweet - way too much sugar and then they have more sugar for toppings. You are better of going to some of the local places that make their ice cream on don't mix in candy after the fact and call it a custom flavor. read more

Ice cream is delicious but way too expensive. I'd suggest going to one of the smaller, local ice cream shops. They're just as good and cheaper than this place. read more

This place is good but the menu is getting too complicated - I wish they would just stick to the basics. It's a good novelty for this kids.

I first had Cold Stone Creamery ice cream in Colorado. I thought it was a local thing, but then one appeared in a plaza in Albany. If Cold Stones aren't sprung up all over the nation by now, they should be soon. The appeal of making your own custom designed ice cream is great. As soon as you walk in, you will be bemused by a giant menu with names that make no sense. Are they sizes? Types of ice cream? Cakes? I couldn't read any of it. Don't bother. Just look at the counter displays of ice creams and "mix-ins." Mix-ins are the chocolate chips, coconut, graham crackers, candy bars, peppermint patties and other goodies you get to put in your creation. The mixing is done on a board, I assume this is the cold stone, and the soft ice cream looks like dough as they fold the goodies into it. My last result, chocolate ice cream with white chocolate chips and peppermint patties, was good. The problem is that the ice cream, since it's some variation on soft serve that's scoopable, it doesn't stand well on its own. You need those goodies. Cold Stone knows this and charges you up the wazoo for a simple cup with two mix-ins. But like I said, since the menu is impossible to decipher, you won't know the damage until you get to the register. Cold Stone *would* have four stars if they still had cake batter ice cream. I had the cake batter flavor in Colorado, and it was delicious. Some of the best ice cream, and definitely the best soft serve I've had. It's recently been taken back into the lab, I guess, for a change in the recipe. I don't know why Cold Stone would mess with perfection. There must've been an outcry from fans, because Cold Stone's website will let you sign up for updates so that you can know when cake batter makes its return. read more

Usually, I'm not a big ice cream fan. Cold Stone is one of the only places that gives me an occasional *craving* for the stuff, though! Terrifically varied flavors, the ability to make things as healthy or as fattening as you want, plenty of choices and combinations, (including smoothies!) and things like fresh fruit (that's ALWAYS perfect, btw,) and the nicest service I've ever had at an ice cream parlor. The prices are pretty decent, too; you won't get gypped on portion sizes, and it's just a sunny, nice place to go and satisfy a sweet tooth! Love it! read more

Let me start off by saying I've been lactose intollerant for the past 15 years, and just recently found a lactase supplement that will allow me to once again eat dairy products. So I haven't had real ice cream in 15 years. This weekend was my friend's birthday and she had ice cream cupcakes from cold stone. They were AMAZING! The next time I feel the need to indulge, Cold Stone is on the tip-top of my list! read more

Stopped here on a quick trip through town. Staff was super friendly and helpful with our choices and encouraged us to have tastes to try the different flavors out. Strawberry lemonade sorbet is delicious and so is mint ice cream! read more