We just happened to get a paper delivered to the Airbnb we rented in Marathon and I read through it and spotted this pizza place that was woman and veteran owned with pizza available by the slice and it was lunch time and we wanted a quick option. This was it! We walked in and were greeted right away while the delicious aroma hit right as you opened the door. They have a lunch special which is two slices of pizza and a drink. That's what we got. You just pick your slices and then they warm them up. The crust is perfectly crispy. The toppings are plentiful and the flavor is great and different on each variety. Loved the various crust options and sauce flavors. This is definitely a great stop. Wish we would have found it sooner bc I would have been back more than once. We also ordered the cannolis. Chocolate chip was the flavor they had. When I saw him grab a bag and a box from the fridge I wasn't expecting much from them but I was wrong, they were delicious! It's a small shop with a quaint little dine in area but it's big on flavor and personality. read more

See all

Great lunch spot for pizza with kiddos. Stopped for some lunch on the way to Key West with the fam. Service was great, pizza was made fresh, and drinks for cold. The place is small, but luckily we had a table without issues. Pizza - nice selection and ways to enjoy (by the slice, whole pizza [multiple configurations]. Glad we stopped. read more

Took this to go to our hotel. Dave Portnoy said this is the best pizza in the Florida Keys and I have to agree. Got the margarita and it was delicious. Crust was fluffy and crisp and pizza was not too greasy. Service was friendly but it did take a bit to get our order. The key lime pie was to die for! read more

Coast to Coast Pizza - Key lime - Pizza Near Me - Marathon, Florida

See all

Great pizza, salad and garlic knots! Really fast too. Their pizzas have a ton of toppings - no skimping! We were impressed!

Don't understand the good reviews for this place. Pizza is way overpriced; almost $30 for a large two-topping with virtually zero sauce and little flavor is ridiculous. A Domino's or Papa John's pizza at half the cost would've been better. And then wanting $3 for a can of Coke is just wrong; a can they bought for under $1. The young lady working the counter was okay but not too friendly. Inside has a few tables but it's tight. We were told it would take 45 minutes to make our pizza, but upon returning after 35 minutes it was already done and sitting in the warmer. I'm not a local, but even if I were, I wouldn't be returning to this place for overpriced and sauceless pizza. read more

Perfect Pizzeria in every way. Firstly the pizza, we ordered a split on a 16" NY style with half pepperoni and half sausage & mushroom! I must say that the sausage is outstanding! Actually it was the best I'd had on any in NYC. The mushrooms weren't huge so that was a plus (not heavy & wet weighing down on the pie). Next is the sauce, glorious on every bite. Finally the fact they had Mexican Cokes was a perfect finish for me. The best pizza in Florida, hands-down (coming from a real jersey girl who loves New York City pizza). If you've had Joe's pizza on Carmine St., New York City you won't be disappointed, I promise. read more

Coast to Coast Pizza - Pepperoni, pizza, half, sausage and mushroom pizza, and Mexican Coke - Pizza Near Me - Marathon, Florida

We got a pepperoni pizza and garlic knots. The pizza was excellent. The price was reasonable. Next time we are in Marathon we'll will definitely be getting pizza from here. read more

Super yummy pizza and great gluten free crust! (I'm picky) great flavor and sauce. Would go again read more

Coast to Coast Pizza - Gluten free pizza - YUM - Pizza Near Me - Marathon, Florida

UNBELIEVABLE! We went with a party of 10. Ordered 4 pizzas and salad. Service was excellent and very personable. All of the pizzas were delicious and cooked to perfection. White pizza, Sicilian style, was the hit of the night until we tried the key lime pie. If you are looking for pizza, this is the place to eat! read more

I wanted to like this place, but the customer service really took away from the experience. When I mentioned that the address listed on Apple Maps appears to be incorrect and could confuse customers, the man at the counter was unnecessarily rude and dismissive instead of simply acknowledging the issue. On the positive side, the pizza was actually pretty decent--fresh, flavorful, and worth trying. Unfortunately, the poor interaction at the counter left a much stronger impression than the food. I hope they update their location information and work on being more courteous to customers who are just trying to be helpful. read more

My family ordered a pizza and a salad for pick up from Coast to Coast while vacationing in Marathon. We did a margherita pizza and greek salad- both were delicious! I would very much recommend Coast to Coast Pizza Company if you're in the Marathon area. We didn't dine in so I can't speak to that experience but the pick up/carry out was great! read more

Coast to Coast Pizza - margherita pizza & greek salad - Pizza Near Me - Marathon, Florida

Great Pizza! Prices aren't out of the norm for a really good pie. Crust, sauce and toppings are all quality. Would definitely come back!

Driving down the keys and had to make a stop after El Presidente proclaimed this the best pizza in the keys. He was not exaggerating. It's awesome. We got the pepperoni with house pickles jalapeños , hot honey, and basil pizza. Absolutely amazing. I wish I had taken a picture but it didn't last long. I STRONGLY suggest you hit this place up. read more

I'm giving one star here, we were on our way out of the keys and hungry. Took 45 minutes to get the pie and upon picking up my second slice I found a FOUND A HAIR... a light wavy one. GROSS. We got the Hawaiian under the name of Jackson.... It was 38$ for one 16" large, very pricy. NEVER AGAIN AND COMPLETELY UNACCEPTABLE. CONSIDERING A Chargeback - we threw the pizza away. read more

Coast to Coast Pizza - Hawaiian - Pizza Near Me - Marathon, Florida

Horrible service took an hour to make my order. Stood in the shop surrounded by angry customers all upset with their orders. I don't know how they have such good reviews? Pizza was ok. Never would go back read more

I am from the Northeast; rather than get into a discussion about the state of Florida's pizza production and who has better pizza... let's just say if you want quality, delicious pizza - Coast to Coast should be your go-to pizza place. They have a water filtration system in place that mimics New York water. Water is the essential ingredient when making pizza dough. Enough said. If they're that dedicated to having the "right" water then they are that dedicated to making perfect pizza. We will patronize Coast to Coast whenever we visit the Keys. My advice: call ahead about an hour before you're hungry. The service is as fast as possible; their popularity demands a certain wait time. And they are worth the wait. We get takeout, but if you want to eat there, there's a small section where you can eat-in. Nothing fancy, just a place to sit and eat. read more

Coast to Coast Pizza - Plain cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Marathon, Florida

See all

Good quality pizza here and believe it or not, solid Key Lime pie. Who knew? A nice thick slice, not too limey, and with real whipped cream. Nice touch. I'm honestly sick of Key Lime pie having lived down here and eaten so much of it everyway from Sunday whenever we had houseguests move in for the week, weekend, or summer. Shhh ....so much so, I used to keep cheap single slices from the Dollar General stocked in my freezer to dole out to unknowing guests. It's Kismets, Kismets, I'd say. lol! Anyway, this isn't that. And I appreciated Key Lime pie for once in a very long time. read more

Coast to Coast Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Marathon, Florida

Ordered the Hawaiian and white pizzas as well as a couple slices of key lime pie. Pizza was alright, kind of dry honestly, would order with extra sauce. Key lime pie was good. Service was solid. Nuff said read more

pizza looks good in the box. For us, the pizza was basic. cardboard like crust, chewy and the sauce tasted like tin. we had 7 others in our group and they all had the same opinion. meh. read more

It was amazing best non-flop, good pizza and Marathon that had in a long time. Great quality, good pizza and I'm thankful it catch my cravings for a good football day and I enjoyed the pizza read more

This was a quality pizza. It was loaded with toppings and had a delicious crust. We ordered a specialty New York style called The Road Trip. We also ordered the garlic knots, and they are made from that same delicious dough, so those were a hit as well. We ordered at the counter and after a bit of a wait, we took our pizza to go. There are a few tables and a counter by the window where you can sit. It seemed like most people called in their order and picked it up to go. read more

Coast to Coast Pizza - The Road trip + black olives; garlic knots - Pizza Near Me - Marathon, Florida

Their pepperoni taste like hot dogs.... When I called to rectify the problem, and young man answered said he was the person to talk to, and then told me "you're the only person that's ever complained " So, I got news for you, I don't complain EVER so if you're getting a bad review from me.... You need to do better. read more

Tomato sauce is very sweet with sugar taste. we Bought 2 pizzas and eat One small Slice each. I won't be back. Unfortunately a trow away money read more

After a long day of eating and drinking on marathon key I was of course exhausted and needed a large pie. I found Coast to Coast pizza, which being on the key is like 1 mile from coast to coast, but I went with a large cheese. They advertise a process that makes their water like New York water. However that works, I guess I believe it. Nobody who lives in Florida hates anyone more than a person from the north east that always talks about their water and pizza. It'd actually be best if the people from the north east stayed there...unless you're here to make pizza...just don't complain about Fl pizza anyway..end of rant. The pie was okay, but extremely floppy with no char. Other photos made it seem like it had a good undercarriage with a bit of char, but my pie was way too flaccid. Few things in life are at their best flaccid, and that includes pizza. You can see all the flop from the photo. The taste was okay. Strong on the parm which is fine, just depends on the cheese you like. read more

Coast to Coast Pizza - Floppy pie - Pizza Near Me - Marathon, Florida

See all

Ordered from here for pick up. I ordered the pepperoni pizza and the taco pizza after seeing such great reviews of the place. Like someone else mentioned, I too am a pizza snob (I'm Italian so it's warranted). The woman on the phone was so kind and took my order and said it would be about 30 minutes. When I arrived I walked into the little spot and it's very unassuming. Just a simple pizza shop. I paid for my pizzas and saw... the boxes!! They were big !! I didn't even realize what size pizzas I ordered but if this is their standard, know that it is big!!! I took them home and finally got to dig in. These pizzas were so, so good! The pepperoni pizza was delicious and the taco pizza was so unique and also so yummy. To pick between the two is hard, I love a traditional pepperoni but the taco pizza was a taco and pizza together -- ground beef (choice or ground beef or chicken), salsa, lettuce, tomatoes, cheese, sour cream! What a perfect combination!! If you're in the area or nearby at least, I would suggest coming here for a pizza night in! Just know it's 2 days later and I'm finally finishing up my leftover slices! I will certainly be back here. read more

Coast to Coast Pizza - Pepperoni Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Marathon, Florida

See all

Do yourself a favor and go eat this right now! I don't even like deep dish pizza normally, but this specific Detroit pizza here is everything!!! So freaking good, just the perfect amount of crispy bottom, fluffy bread and do yourself another favor, order it light cheese with extra sauce. We ordered both to go and delivery here and it was perfect every time. Super quick, done just right! We ordered from a few other pizza spots in the area while staying down there for around a month and can confidently say don't waste your time ordering anywhere else! read more

Coast to Coast Pizza - Detroit style - Pizza Near Me - Marathon, Florida

Ordered pizza and garden salad from our resort. The pizza didn't have enough cheese and was overcooked. We did not get a garden salad, instead a Greek salad arrived. Delivery was timely. read more

Coast to Coast Pizza - Over cooked pizza and not enough cheese. - Pizza Near Me - Marathon, Florida

See all

Lets start with service, over 2 hours for my pizza on June 20th. I ordered on line at 6:30 and said would be an hour, got there at 7:30 and told 15-20 minutes more and got my pizza at 8:45 went home. The pizza had NO flavor and bland. Here comes the good part, my wife and I were throwing up 20 minutes after eating it and throw up ALL night long with diarrhea. STAY AWAY AT ALL COST !!! read more

I was craving pizza on our trip to the keys and Ragz picked up takeout from here. Given there are very few pizza options in Marathon, I honestly wasn't expending much. We settled on the New York California pie. Took off the broccoli, added chicken and pineapple ( it's my Roman Empire). Also ordered the garlic knots. The order was ready when Ragz got there - ordering in advance on their website was quick and easy. The pizza is 16 inches, we had it for 2 meals between the 2 of us. The pizza crust had the right chew to it and I really liked how well the toppings went together. The ricotta cheese was absolutely yummy on the pizza and I'm glad we went with that option. We still ended up leaving the pizza crust ends, but it was a very tasty pizza regardless. The garlic knots were pretty basic by themselves, tbh. However coupled with the marinara sauce they came with, made them super delicious. I'm not a fan of marinara at all, but honestly this was delicious. They should bottle it and sell it! Overall good experience - the pizza tasted yummy cold the next day too! If I wanted pizza again and was in the area, I'd likely order from them again. read more

Placed ordered on phone and were told 15 minutes so we showed up and then waited another 1.5 hrs for 2 orders of garlic knots and 3 salads . As they said our order was not ready .For a pretty simple order . Girl behind the counter should probably not be there very classless and a simpleton . Place could use a good cleaning as well very disappointed in their attitudes and service. Went to Driftwood down the road walked into place ordered at the counter and food was ready in 15 minutes and the staff was very pleasant. read more

just tried the New York 7.7 it was fantastic I'd rate it a solid 8.1. If I had one tiny suggestion, it would be to cook it a bit more well done and maybe go a little lighter on the oil. But those are minor points the flavor was absolutely delicious and I'd definitely order it again." read more

I had maybe too high of hopes considering it's one of the only non seafood restaurants in the area. We got there about an hour before it closed for dine in and it was absolutely packed. First thing to note is it was Saturday night and this place closed at 9pm which is a little crazy if you ask me. The service was absolutely crazy, I wouldn't say it was bad because the young man was very nice but they could not pump out pizzas the way they needed to. Maybe they were understaffed or not expecting such a crowd but it was intense. We sat there watching people come in for take out that had to wait 30+ minutes. We were also waiting for 1 salad and 2 pizzas for dine in. Both pizzas came, the salad never did. We went up and asked 3 times for the salad, finally when we asked the last time for a refund because we were done with our pizza and it was boxed up, they gave it to us to go. So although kind, it was hectic and slow. The pizza flavor was okay, nothing crazy and it was incredibly greasy which is okay sometimes. I would maybe try it again next time we visit. read more

Coast to Coast Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Marathon, Florida

See all

Some of the best pizza I've had in a while. Great sauce and crust. Mostly a pick up spot - only has 3-4 tables. Garlic knots are tasty too.

Pizza was great. Detroit style was very well done. We lived there for 11 years, right up there in taste, texture, crispness and more. Good value, nice people. On time. Did takeout. read more

Had delivery and best pizza ever. Price was awesome highly recommend. The sandwich was ok but pizza fantastic

I have ordered in the past however had stopped going since I had not found that the pizza crust and ingredients lived up to my expectations. I gave them another try this week and they definitely improved. We had the meat lovers which had a perfect crust, flavorful sauce and abundantly topped. And never forget to grab their key lime pie. I rate it top 5 in the Florida keys! This place mostly does takeout, but they do have a small dining area which is nice. The staff have always been attentive and friendly. read more

We ordered the meatball appetizer and a pepperoni pizza. There was so much salt in the sauce of both meatballs and pizza we couldn't even eat it. I contacted the restaurant and got no response. We will NOT be back and will not recommend !! read more

Garden salad was extremely fresh!!! Yummy homemade dressing. Plump RED tomatoes. Got the pizza knots!! They are to-die-for!! Highly recommend!!! :) would definitely be back. We wanted subway and then we kept commenting that subway would have been soo inferior compared to this place!! Also my mom left her card in the card reader and the lady at the desk came running out ... :) 10/10 read more

See all

Came here last evening on our last day in the keys. The keys strip has very few veg options so the safest bet was to look for a pizza place . I read about this one and decided to give it a go . The first visit here was disappointing as we were told they were sold out , it was dinner time !! We decided to give it another try and came here the next afternoon. We ordered ahead just to make sure and ate at the restaurant. We ordered the New York style margherita pizza . It was really good . Freshly made , thin and delicious crust and also tried the key lime pie which was yumm! The lady behind the counter was very nice and welcoming and we were glad we got to try this spot which had some awesome reviews . read more

Went here because Portnoy said it was good and he was correct! Pizza was awesome, the two girls up front could not have been less engaged - they could have cared less that we were there. Regardless, got a slice to go the next day! read more