My cafe con leche was served at almost room temperature so i questioned why it wasn't hot and i was told it was hot. When i mentioned it was room temp they said thats how it's supposed to be. Customer service is lacking. We got plenty of side eye and attitude from the cashier. Maybe it's me? The food was fine... it's ice cream, hard to mess up. read more

Paradise Flavors - Storefront - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Marathon, Florida

See all

Cute little shop, nothing fancy from the outside but boy it did not disappoint. Hundreds of popsicle flavors to choose from! Fresh fruit chunks in them. Fresh tropical fruit juices and several flavors of ice cream. Service was very friendly and super quick! If you are passing by Marathon, definitely stop and get yourself a treat! We settled for the Mamey, pineapple popsicles, horchata juice and key lime pie ice cream. read more

Paradise Flavors - Key lime pie ice cream, horchata and popsicles - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Marathon, Florida

Everything I've tried from this place is amazing. I stop with the family on every return trip from the keys. Super delicious fruit pops, fruit cups, smoothies and candies. The chamoy they use is delicious. There are Latin candies and snacks unique to the regions they come from. They have more flavors of paletas (fruit pops) than any other place I've seen. Unique savory and sweet combinations. A typical island vibe on the outside but when you step inside they welcome you like you are home. Every worker there including the owner is absolutely amazing. I usually spend 10-15 minutes just talking about anything and everything. To me it is a 5 star experience without fail, each and every visit! read more

Paradise Flavors - Fruit cup with chamoy. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Marathon, Florida

Amazing mangonada! I enjoyed passing by this place and having this, plan to return. My favorite thing here is the mangonada read more

See all

We visited Paradise Flavors a couple of times while we were on Marathon. They have about 75 flavors of popsicles, as well as ice cream and other refreshing treats. The first popsicle I had was a pineapple, and it was beyond delicious. It was made with fresh fruit and had such a concentrated flavor. It was my favorite item we tried. The next day I got the mango popsicle, which was also very good with small chunks of mango in it. I tried but could not finish the orange sorbet popsicle. It was a very bitter taste like the rind of an orange. I do not recommend this one. My husband had a smoothie one time and a banana split the next time. Both were good, but not the best he has had. This place is definitely worth a visit for a refreshing treat. Try the pineapple popsicle! read more

See all

Small little shop with so much personality! We stopped here for a little ice cream break and the variety of ice cream bars they have will knock you on your butt. My kiddos had mango, I had chunky mango, and hubs had watermelon. We all loved all our respective flavors - and now writing this I'm just thinking I want to go snag another one for dessert tonight. Yums! read more

Great spot for homemade ice cream! I was overwhelmed with the variety of popsicles, these flavors took me back to childhood! Yum yum yum! Had the coconut and took an assortment to go read more

Tried the key lime pie and it was very good. So many flavors to choose from! We plan on stopping back in to try some other flavors! read more

Paradise Flavors - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Marathon, Florida

Oh my word! During the hot summer days in Florida you need a safe cool delicious drink, smoothie or ice cream this place is my go to whenever I'm heading to the Keys. Thank you Paradise for all the delicious homemade treats read more

See all

Visiting the Keys from Pacific Northwest on a mission to find the best Key Lime Pie. As it turned out, the award was in the form of Ice Cream from Paradise Flavors. Highly recommended!! read more

We were next door getting our caffeine fix and saw a little girl come in with her mom who had one of these popsicles so my husband wanted to come take a look. We spoke to the friendly owner who walked us through her process, all items made in-house by her, with fresh fruits and ingredients, and tons of available flavors. She told us she's originally from Mexico and had been in the Keys for about two years. So friendly and sweet. We wanted to try tons of things from here but it was still pretty early in the AM and we'd already had breakfast and coffee so we only had room to try one. I chose the key lime pie on a stick which was super cute. It was fresh but lacked the citrus tartness I was expecting. read more

See all

A not so simple popsicle stand with what looks like hundreds of flavors. Pick from the freezer and all reasonably priced. This is not one of those fancy places where to get the paleta rolled in sauce and stuff. The fun is in browsing the selection and choosing the one. They also have sundaes and other things, but I didn't try them. read more

So happy these place was in the corner of our house. Stopped by 3 times and loaded on paletas. Staff was very nice and attentive. Very inexpensive and homemade. My favorite is to put them inside a glass of Prosecco read more

Paradise Flavors - Sangria was amazing! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Marathon, Florida

See all

We stopped in for some fruit and ice cream. It looks like the ice cream pops go on for miles and seems like there's an infinite number of flavors. The fruit cup we got tasted good, but it was 50/50 for fruit that were and weren't ripe. Also, they have a tip option on the tablet when it's not a sit-down service, which is annoying. read more

See all

Cute ice cream shop. Had the mamey with condensed milk popsicle - highly recommend - brought back childhood memories of having the same flavor as a milkshake. Husband had the cookies and cream ice cream and said it was delicious. The staff was friendly and helpful. Popsicles were well organized. The only trouble you'll have is making the decision of which popsicles to choose. Lots of great options. We loved this place so much, we went back the next day. We bought two - coconut and arroz con leche to eat there, and 5 more bars (2 arroz con leche, coconut, mamey with condensed milk, and guava strip) to take back to our hotel. Never have I ever purchased 9 popsicles in less than 24 hours. read more

See all

Stop by tonight. Tried their ice cream and it was amazing. Very friendly and outgoing too. If you are traveling through or staying in Marathon worth the stop. So many flavors of Popsicles and they are all freshly made. Going back tomorrow to try them out. read more

Qué sabores tan exquisitos y excelente atención....me encantó!!! La textura de las paletas son únicas read more

Friendly service, an unbelievable selection of ice cream and yogurt bars. A must-visit stop when in Marathon. read more

Paradise Flavors - Yummy - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Marathon, Florida

See all

Hands down the best ice cream shop in the Keys and in my opinion all of Florida. Fresh hand-made flavors. I haven't had one I didn't like here. Tons of choices. read more

Paradise Flavors - Orange Creamsicle Icecream Bar with real orange pieces in it! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Marathon, Florida

JUST WOW! Highly recommend. Was leaving key west and looking for an ice cream spot and found this spot on Maps. And wow. We first ordered the Capuchino Paleta and the Key Lime Pie (5/5) amazing, we had to go in for more we order the Pico De Gallo and the Mamey Paleta and omg these were even better especially the Pico. GET IT! Pico de Gallo - pineapple, cucumber, watermelon, mango, Tajín, lime and salt. And the worker - Ceasar is super nice and friendly. Definitely making a spot here every time we come to the keys. read more

Paradise Flavors - Pico de Gallo - pineapple, cucumber, watermelon, mango, Tajín, lime and salt. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Marathon, Florida

See all

I can't say enough good things about this place. It was seriously the highlight of my family's recent trip to the keys. The first visit I tried the Pico de Gallo based on other reviews and I immediately went back in for a second one. We went back daily after that. I also tried Cucumber Tajin (also got two in a row), mango sorbet, and others in my family had the blueberry cheesecake, chocolate, cotton Candy, sangria, and I can't even remember then all. We probably bought 20 desserts from here within the few days we had left after we found it. The first gentleman we had was delightful, the second gentleman was also very kind, and the woman was also very nice. Great family business. Will be the first place I stop when I go back!! The cons were only that it wasn't well lit, so finding it and feeling comfortable approaching the first time was a little difficult. But then we kept going back! read more

Paradise Flavors - Pico de Gallo! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Marathon, Florida

Highly recommend! This was my first time here and I'd definitely come again. The prices are very fair and there's a huge variety of flavors of paletas. The owner was very friendly, and even offered us free samples of all the juices. Very cute interior and a few benches/tables outside overlooking the airport. read more

Rare these days to find great ice cream at a reasonable price that isn't overly sweet. Family tried 3 flavors and all were great, we couldn't agree who's was the best. read more

This is a must have in Marathon. Locally owned and made popsicles, ice cream etc... unique flavors such as avocado, cucumber/tajin, watermelon/chamoy, tamarind, all sorts of coconut, piña colada and tropical flavors. All made with fresh fruit from their separate fresh fruit stand. Great prices. The owners and workers are really friendly and helpful. Kids and adults love this place. read more

Paradise Flavors - Popsicle dipped in chamoy - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Marathon, Florida

See all

first .... most of all.... AMAZING BEST ICE CREAM EVER!!! service is great and super nice! read more

One of the best paletas I've ever had! The owner was very friendly and offered us some free samples of all the juices. Huge variety of flavors as well. I highly recommend this place and I'll come again. read more

Excellent and unique! The server was super enthusiastic and happy to show us the whole list of offerings, even though we arrived close to their closing time. read more

Our fave spot for sweets heading home from key west! Delicious and affordable! $3 any ice cream. read more

Paradise Flavors - Mango sorbet - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Marathon, Florida

Excellent ice cream. Good flavor selection of homemade ice cream. Lots of ice pops (Mexican ice pops/paletas -- we didn't get these but were impressed with the selection). Definitely worth a visit. read more

We had popsicles that were incredible! Coconut was the best I've ever tasted. My husband had Mango and was thrilled. Definitely stop in. They have so many flavors it's almost impossible to choose. read more

Best mamey smoothie and the pineapple passion fruit juice was delicious! They have several ice cream flavors and so many popsicle choices all homemade. The guy working there was awesome as well! read more

Paradise Flavors - The best mamey smoothie! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Marathon, Florida

Cute place with terrific ice cream and friendly service. Had a scoop of lovely mint chocolate chip and also an unusual one of Mexican chocolate - not overly sweet with a hint of cayenne to perk it up. read more

Delicious ice cream pops! They also have fresh juices, normal ice cream and smoothies. Everything is made fresh and in house. Family owned business. Price very affordable. Plenty of unique flavors. A definite must try when down in Marathon!! read more

See all

I ordered 100 popsicles from Paradise Flavors for my wedding party in April. I had posted previously about Cesar ghosting me for weeks prior to the wedding and being unable to place my order. However, I was actually able to place the order. The order was delivered on-time. I was so excited for this "cool" treat to serve to my guests. A visit to the Keys isn't complete without a Paradise Flavors pop treat for me. I have noticed over the months of buying multiple pops at a time that the pops made with a creamy/milk base do not hold their consistency in the freezer and MELT. I have had this happen when we would buy a few at a time and try to freeze for a couple of days. I thought it was a fluke with the freezer at the hotel we were staying at, but no. There must be a problem with the recipe for these cream/milk-based pops because all of them got soft and were melted in the freezer overnight. The freezer was turned up as cold as it would go, and the pops were all soft. This softening did not happen to the pops which were not the cream/milk base. The icy-type pops held their consistency and did not melt. I tried to explain this to the man who picked up the freezer - I think Oscar - but he didn't seem to understand, or just didn't act like he cared or wasn't interested. I hope Cesar at Paradise Flavors figures out this issue with the recipe, because when they are frozen, they are really delicious and unique. I want this small business to listen to this post and to succeed!! read more

So good! I got the Arroz con Leche paleta and my husband got a cone with pistachio and butter pecan ice cream, both were delicious! We will definitely stop by here the next time we're in the Keys! read more

Paradise Flavors - I got the Arroz con Leche paleta and my husband got a cone with pistachio and butter pecan. Everything was delicious! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Marathon, Florida

Fruit bars/popsicles are so good. Highly recommend the mango and passion fruit flavor. They have real fruit pieces in it. My daughter asked to go back and was happy to find the bars as a dessert option at a restaurant one night. read more

Very good tropical fruit ice creams. Coconut is my favorite with Mamey a close 2nd. Lots of flavors to choose from.

We were driving through from Key West, and my husband and son wanted ice cream. It was delicious, and the service was wonderful! They have ice cream, and also these amazing ice cream bars made with homemade ice cream and fabulous things like fruit and chocolate inside. My 14-year-old said it's the best ice cream he's ever had! We will definitely be stopping every time we're visiting the Keys! We live in Orlando, so we visit a few times a year. read more

Paradise Flavors - Hubby and son loving their ice cream! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Marathon, Florida

Service with a smile not to mention incredible ice cream and Cuban coffee. Our family loved it!!

You will love this local ice cream stop! Local honey, amazing ice cream bars and cones. Fresh fruit, beer ect! The owner is friendly and helpful! You will love this place! read more