Ordered a large cheese pizza and breadsticks with pizza sauce for take out. The flavor on both of them was really good! The herbs on the breadsticks meld very well with the cheese you could eat them even without the sauce and enjoy them. The pizza was very good too. The sauce and the crust have a nice flavor to them so even though I got just cheese, the pizza was delicious. Even reheated or cold out of the fridge, the pizza and breadsticks both are great to have as leftovers! read more

Today was my second time. I love their gluten free pizza. It's so delicious. I've decided it's the sauce that makes this place so special. It's divine with such bold and beautiful flavors. They also have real green olives many places no longer offer them and they are the best on pizza. Inside is small and cozy but warm and fuzzy. You can play Ms Pac-Man and they actually have 3 arcade games to indulge. Cute booths for date night. Even beer on tap and real sugar Mexican Coke. Everyone here is so kind and friendly. It's worth paying a little extra for the fresh toppings and most authentic and flavorful sauce. Plus the cheese blend is on point. They even have a stamp card that will reward you after 12 with a free pizza. What are y'all waiting for, get in here. read more

Cirello's Pizza - Gluten-free crust, small pizza with the most amazing green olives. - Pizza Near Me - Corvallis, Oregon

The guy at the counter was nice...after that it was all downhill. Topping: too many. Red onions needed to be chopped, Canadian bacon was in big slices and sausage was is huge chunks. Work those ingredients more (smaller) and less amounts. The sauce was overwhelmed by too much cheese. Just not our style of pizza. read more

It is hard to ruin pizza. If you use reasonably good ingredients and avoid burning it or serving it raw, it is hard to miss. But they also don't excel. Cirellos does not miss. It is good but not great. Cirellos reminds me of the neighborhood pizzerias around New york and Boston. That adds some warmth and charm. It appears to not have had a remodel in decades. The ripped up booth benches add character but dirty tables at 3:30 when business is slow suggests lack of care. . The crust is fine. It lacks flavor that some more "artisan" places might have but fine for a neighborhood restaurant. The pizza is heavy on the cheese which was not spread to the edges. I had to bite carefully not to pull off the entire cheese slab with each bite. Some might find that desirable but not me. Last time here, 6 months ago, l asked them to go light on the cheese and got almost none. Next time perhaps I will try Woodstocks, somewhere I have not tried since long before the pandemic. Maybe some day the pizza renaissance in Portland will spread to Corvallis. read more

Best pizza in Corvallis! We're regular customers, who had given up on finding good pizza in the Valley until we found this place. The whole staff are super friendly, and the place is clean. read more

Cute little pizzeria with the best pizza in town! Always friendly service. Been a regular for the 20 plus years of living in Corvallis. Love the Meg's Meal pizza with sausage added. Occasionally I buy a large dough ball to make pizza at home. It always cooks up nicely in my own oven read more

First timer for me and my friend! Have been dying to try this place and finally got the chance to, I was not disappointed. For starters the ambiance of this restaurant really reminds me of being a kid at the "local pizza shop". The retro arcade games, pieces of Corvallis history on the wall, and the old school cooking oven really helps to provide a comforting experience. The guy behind the counter provided very friendly service and had a good understanding of their menu. The entire crew behind the counter had a very positive energy around them. What surprised us was the portions, that breadstick tray was huge! And the pizza was not very greasy. It had really good flavor and all of the ingredients were fresh. The only request i will make is please bring back the salad bar ): You will most definitely see me on a regular basis. read more

Cirello's Pizza - Half Veggie Special/Half Meg 's Meal - Pizza Near Me - Corvallis, Oregon

See all

Best pizza in town! The staff is very friendly and always helpful. The vibe is like old school pizza parlor. They aren't trying to do anything extra besides just make good food. The way pizza should be. Good beer too! read more

Ordered a pizza to go recently and was pleasantly surprised at how good the pizza was. My friend and I called in to place the order and my pizza was ready in 20 minutes. We ordered a 12 in. with half Pineapple Express and half Dirtbag BBQ ($24, no extra charge for half and half). Their bbq sauce is pretty good, not too sweet and not too salty. The pesto sauce on the other hand was a lot lighter in flavor and at times tasted like there was no sauce at all. Not sure if it was this batch of pesto that was more bland but I was a bit disappointed. Overall, the pizza was still good and I'd think about stopping here if I was craving pizza in the future. read more

Cirello's Pizza - a pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Corvallis, Oregon

Best pizza ever and cheese sticks are best I've ever had. Cheesy, well done and peppery. They have been making these to perfection for so many years! read more

Great pizza! Don't understand the reviews, the service was amazing and the guy who took our order was funny and friendly. Nice classic pizza shop feel inside! read more

Holy freaking smokes. I waited for 2 hours for my pizza and it had hairs on it. I don't know what kind of hairs. I am extremely unhappy. read more

Cirello's Pizza - I'm pissed - Pizza Near Me - Corvallis, Oregon

My friend called Dominos on the way to philomath after the Ducks spring game but I stepped in and found Cirellos. We were more than satisfied, it was delicious! We did take out and devoured it at the air b&b. Lots of toppings, great crust. Best decision of the weekend! read more

Pizza one of the best in Corvallis. Everyone behind the counter is super friendly and helpful.

We love Cirello's. When we moved here we tried all the pizza parlors in town. By far, this is our choice. The primary reason is that the pies have good sauce, a good crust and generous toppings. The atmosphere reminds me of NY pizza parlors that I grew up with. I appreciate their frequent buyer card too. I hope they stick around for a long time. read more

Super friendly owner and staff. Handtossed crust means the "thin" crust isn't that thin but it doesn't overwhelm the toppings. Very generous on toppings so you get a nice, heavy pizza. Calzone are also recommended. read more

I tried to order pasta from their menu at 8:30 pm and was told they weren't serving pasta even though they were open until 9:00 pm. So I ordered the meatball sandwich instead, but there was hardly any meatballs in it either. If you are open, serve what is on your menu. Stop being lazy. read more

Seriously great pizza! They get the crust just right, not too thick, not too thin, and it just plain tastes good! Delicious combinations, had the RDP and Meg's Meal, took home the leftovers and devoured it the next day. This will be our Corvallis pizza go-to place, forget about the others! Can't wait to try more menu items, Cirellos rules! read more

Incredibly good pizza! Glad I accidentally got to try it! Will definitely come to this place for all of my pizza cravings. Had the pineapple express and pepperoni. Three days later and it's still irrisistably good after a quick microwave!! Also, the customer service was great! The guy at check out was incredibly friendly. I ordered for pickup :) read more

Good pizza but they can't figure out their cook time. Double the wait time-at least. They know they're going to be busy but can't be accurate about the time to make and bake a pie. Just be upfront. I've waited there enough to know that they are not honest about their time. I ordered at 5. Its 6:10 and no pie ie site. This is not a first. Plus the guy thinks he's funny and he's not!! read more

Great staff and service. Pizza is great too! I ordered on line and my order was ready when I arrived. Everyone was so friendly. A fun place to go. read more

After a long exhausting day of volleyball tournaments we were in desperate need of FOOD for hungry teens and parents. Cirello's offered a coupon on the welcome map at our hotel so we decided to check them out. Heads up, delivery is only available until 8:30 on Saturday's despite their website advertising 'delivery all day' (they're open until 9). Thankfully they were only a quick 3 minute drive from us so it wasn't too bad but still a bummer. By the time we arrived they had already wrapped up the salad bar too which leads me to believe they don't get a lot of business in the late evenings. Cirello's has been serving Corvallis since the 80's and walking into this parlor, it really shows. Upon entering you step back in time, the decor is super dated and the walls are covered in what I can only assume are family and community portraits over the years giving it that mom and pop feel. The pizza was fantastic though. The crust was just the right amount of chewy without being an actual thin crust and the sauce was loaded with extra basil which made the flavor really pop. Happy teens means we'd gladly stop in again if the occasion ever presented itself. read more

See all

We went here on a whim and decided to eat in. We were told it would be about a half hour wait. We said okay and placed our order asking about the restaurant and what its specialties are. We usually ask for recommendations at new places and even mentioned it was our first visit. My husband and I sat at a table and waited.... and waited..... People who placed their order after us were getting their pizza. I ended up asking how long it would be after about an hour wait. They didn't even recognize me. Their only response was, "We sometimes get backed up. Sorry about that." I think it had to do with only having one oven. That being said, the pizzas were amazing. I had The Hawaiian, and my husband had The Dirtbag BBQ. We also ordered the breadsticks. The marinara and ranch tasted homemade. We will be returning but hopefully at a less busy time. This is the best pizza we have found in Corvallis. read more

Service was awful. Treated us like we were a burden for coming in to eat. Said it would be 40 min for dine in and took an hour and 20 min. No apology or anything just a "here's your pizza your lucky to get it." The crust is so floury I couldn't eat it it. The breadsticks and spaghetti were decent but after waiting so long I couldn't look past the long wait, bad service and bad pizza. read more

Cirello's has a really solid New York style hand tossed pizza, they really pile on the ingredients and have great beer on tap. Their slice is the perfect combination of doughy goodness and pizza sauce and cheese! read more

See all

Burnt pizza 35$ old tomatoes nasty u just lost my Business!!!! U really need to look at your pizza before u send out to People!!! read more

Cirello's Pizza - Just got 35$ pizza burnt to hell !!!! Nasty tomato's very sad u just lost my business!!! - Pizza Near Me - Corvallis, Oregon

This place is amazing. We chose it based on yelp ratings and we were not disappointed. Next time we are going this way, we are stopping here again. read more

I got pizza here and it was the worst I've ever had. It is not NY pizza by any stretch of the imagination.

This is the only good pizza we've had since we moved to Corvallis. Delicious crust, good sauce, yummy toppings, excellent salads, and fantastic ranch dressing! read more

Good pizza with a thick chewy build. Whoever said this is NY style doesn't understand the thin crunchiness of a NY pizza. We loved the fresh tomatoes on our (enormous) medium veggie pizza. The small salads were very nice. Good beer too. Soccer on the TV and a very eclectic soundtrack. read more

Just ordered. Customer service sucks. Lets see how delivery and pizza turn out. More to come read more

Best pizza I've had outside of New Jersey. Best in Corvallis. But we all have different taste in pizza. If you happen to come from NJ I bet you will love Cirello's. read more

Great pizza, excellent crust! First "non-greasy" pizza we've had in awhile. Toppings were fresh & tasty.

Very tasty pizza. We also liked quick delivery. My husband scarfed his calzone and marveled at the smoky yummy flavor. I was more than satisfied by the Pineapple Express pizza. Loved every bite. read more

Good pizza. Custom built with the Mr. C option. Enjoyed it...would come back again. Quiet place on a Wednesday night. read more

Cirello's Pizza - a pizza with shrimp and olives - Pizza Near Me - Corvallis, Oregon

Last Friday we celebrated my daughter's graduation here. They were super helpful and very personable. The pizza was superb. I appreciate everyone there that helped us to make our celebration a success. I will DEFINITELY be coming back! read more

Super yummy and really friendly staff! Great for groups! We've eaten at the restaurant and ordered to go several times and it's always been a great experience. read more

Pizza was fair. Service was terrible. Showed up 30 minutes after ordering, was told it would be a couple more minutes. Waited inside 10 minutes, then told them I'd be waiting outside. Twenty minutes later, went back in to check. They said it was done ten minutes ago. I said that I'd been enjoying Cirrelos pizza for years, but wouldn't be back. The manager said "Good. We're busy. Bye." read more

Excellent calzones but only average pizza. Definitely doesn't approach what anyone from NY would call a NY pizza. Like many places, it just doesn't seem to have the right dough for it. read more

Friends and I wanted to go get some pizza for a party we were having, ordered 2 pizzas. When arrived, they were not only cold, yet tasted like cardboard as well. Called the restaurant, got a snarky reply from the person working, saying we should have checked it at the door. Terrible business. Would avoid if you don't like added stress! sad! read more