We had a meatball sub and a calzone with pepperoni and artichoke hearts last night. $17.50 total plus tip, which I thought was a good value. I was super impressed, but kind of sad that I've lived here here for this long without trying them out! I can't wait to try more of their items. I was excited to find a place in town that has good calzones with ricotta. read more

Rude and terrible service. Mediocre pizza. Not worth the hour over said time pizza would be ready.

Never ordering from here again. Said pizza would be ready in 45 minutes. Went to pick it up 45 minutes later and it wasn't ready. Then said pizza would be a 30 minute wait and ended up being 45 minutes. An hour half to make a pizza. Multiple customers experiencing the same problem. Hopefully they choose not to go back as well! read more

Tried this one again, had not been back since last year. Was ok then but no fireworks. Glad I did . Making a good pizza should not be difficult , and lots of filks do an acceptable job. But i wanted better than sauce and cheap topping on marginal dough. This is pretty good , topping did not overwhelm, spicy sausage . Actually looked like sausage. Sauce good not fantastic but was a good start. Sauce matters! The dough crispy , but not burnt. The crust held up despite asking for thin crust. The staff were attentive and i think customers may feel like it is a neighborhood pizza place. Needs cosmetics! Pretty dingy and salad bar showed it. Beer selection good for this area ... no so many you lose a good one! So better cosmetics, lightening, improved red sauce , would go a long way. And guys keep saying hi ! My ole neighborhood had a local pizza place and everyone knew most of the regulars read more

My favorite pizza - hands down! I've loved Cirello's since I was a kid, over 30 years :) It's the dough/crust and sauce that sets them apart -- other places in town I have to get a side of pesto sauce just to eat their crust! The staff are great and it must be a fun place to work because I see the same happy people working every time I'm there :) read more

Fun to eat in at Cirello's. Always have a good time, even if we don't always like the music they're playing, we like the eclectic mix. Two big screen TVs, delicious crust, terrific pepperoni, fabulous sauce, fun photos on the wall, as well as funky art, big windows. It is NOT a fast food joint. Good pizza take time, so don't be in a hurry. read more

Cirello's Pizza - Pretty Pepperoni Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Corvallis, Oregon

The pizza toppings taste fresh. Cirello's Pizza knows how to make a real Italian pizza. My rating of only 3/5 is for some other (rather important) reasons: 1. If you say you deliver--keep a set time. Many times we've called and it is before the delivery stop time. They have all the excuses. We're closing early. Nope, the delivery person just left. Sorry, we don't deliver on X days. And the list goes on. 2. If you get delivery often they don't recognize that you are a regular -- although they know you are. And then you can hear them laughing in the background on the phone that "they're calling again." Let me in on the joke and you'd be 4/5. Maybe. 3. If your menu says you have pasta. Then keep the pasta. OR just get someone to change your menu online. Please keep your menu up to date! 4. If you've once had one restaurant go under because of e coli, wouldn't you try your hardest to do nothing more than be the friendliest, go-out-of-your-way to rule the pizza in Corvallis? The pizza is that good. Make your customer service match and you'll be great. read more

(Not the) Best pizza in the Willamette Valley!! Go for the sausage and onions!! Update: I picked up a pizza the other day...and something has changed. The cheese was not top grade, the crust was bad, and the sauce was as bad as Little Caesars sauce. Not sure what happened, but I wrote them a letter with a pictrure of the pizza and my feedback, and I got zero response. Unacceptable. I've had there pizza 50 times and ordered it for a company meeting once. It is not good pizza anymore, they went cheap. read more

This used to be the best place in town, but their prices have increased steadily while their service has declined. Lately, on a couple of occasions, I've called trying to place an order more than 30 minutes before their listed closing time, but they say they won't deliver anymore because they're closing early. I'm not surprised their sister business Marzini's went out of business, and now that Market of Choice offers up decent pizza for a reasonable price, I'd be surprised if Cirello's stays in business for much longer. A real shame, because they used to have the BEST pizza in town. read more

A college town, Corvallis has a lot of good pizza. Cirello's is my personal favorite, however, bc of its delicious, fluffy crust. The Mediterranean--with feta, red onions, and broccoli--is my pizza of choice, and The Sicilian is my husband's. He adds pepperoni as well. The staff is very accommodating and will take requests and make pizzas no longer on the menu (such as the Mediterranean). We prefer to order over the phone and then pick up the pizza ourselves (usually 20 minutes after placing the order) and take it home or eat in the restaurant bc we have found that when the pizza arrives via delivery service, it is often soggy, perhaps from having to sit around while other orders were delivered first. So the 5-star rating is for pizza picked up or eaten at the restaurant, NOT for delivered pizza. read more

OOOOOKAY I've waited and waited to write this because I have a conflict of interest. I worked here for six years, But, now that I have moved on I think it's fair and time that I give Cirello's an excellent review. I have been going to Cirello's since I was a little kid and it's always been one of my favorites. The crust and sauce beat the pants off any other pizza in town. There is a vast selection of toppings and take it from me, most are prepared in-house. The sausage is really something special. And of course, the people who work there are amazing and they enjoy their jobs. It's a good place to work and now it feels like my second home. The clientele mostly consists of townies-- that's how you know it's good. The location kind of sucks but it's worth the travel. Eat here. You'll be back. :) read more

Cirello's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Corvallis, Oregon

I'm giving them a below average rating because of the lack of consistency and quality in their pizza. The first pepperoni pizza I ordered for delivery arrived in a reasonable time and smelled great. That's where the experience ended. It was so greasy and tasted like one of those "chef Boyardee" pizzas in a box that you made as a kid. It was a complete disappointment. It did taste slightly better as leftovers the next day, but still wasn't that great. My second experience with Cirello's was a little tastier, but as one reviewer pointed out, the crust becomes soggy very quickly. By the time it arrived, it was a very limp pizza. In addition, it took longer than usual because they burned the first one. I think your best bet is to order and eat thier pizza in the restaurant. Any time letting it sit and it will go to... well, let's just say it won't be great. read more

The pizza wasn't bad, but it wasn't something I would remember. The crust was very soggy when we got it home to eat and that made it hard to eat. read more

Delicious, fresh and filling pizza! The best gluten free crust in Corvallis! The staff is great! I can't get enough of this delicious pizza! read more

Alright, Cirello's, I've had a good slices from you, but also a couple mediocre ones. The lunch special mini-pizza's are the best way to go imo, I love provolone on my little pie, and they have so far come out perfectly baked fairly consistently. 50cent soda on Tuesdays is pretty sweet too. The regular pies have been hit or miss, though they do seem to be pretty close to NY style pizza. Up the consistency a bit and it'd be a solid 4-star. read more

Cirellos is a comfortable little pizza joint near the HP campus. It offers good pizza, sandwiches and brews. It has a small salad bar as well. I liked the pizza well enough, but it wasn't anything special to me. I stopped ordering it. I should note, though, they offer a whole-wheat crusted pizza that seems to very popular. I've never tried it, though. I order the meatball sandwich now. I LOVE this thing. The meatballs don't taste like they were store-bought, but they are (I asked). The sandwich is assembled without sauce, and thrown in the pizza oven to melt the cheese and make the bread crusty and good. Its served with chips or potato salad and a bowl of marinara sauce to dip it in. Thats the part I like best - the dipping. I like being able to control how much sauce I'm getting - I find I like it best with just a little! Overall, this is a good lunch place. I enjoy it, always get good service, and haven't found anything to complain about. read more

Great pizza. The regular crust is so good that I'm reluctant to try another. I remember someone in school liked a plain old cheese pizza. I thought that was disgusting. But try the Foghorn here. It's very good. The margarita is too. Neither is on the menu online. But they'll gladly fix them. That's the other thing. The people are very nice. read more

Spent a couple nights in Corvallis and had them deliver a pizza, turned out they make a fantastic pizza!

We have been fans for years...I went in tonight with a loyalty card full of stamps to redeem for a free pizza. Unfortunately, tonight, I waited an hour and a half for my order. I called it in and was told it would be 40-45 minutes. When I went in to pay, 45 minutes later, I was told my pizzas would be made next and would be 8 minutes in the oven. So I sat down...and waited for 45 minutes longer. I was very disappointed in the extended wait and in the misleading information (both on the phone and in person). Up until tonight, I would have given then 5 stars based on years of experience. Until they get their system better organized, I can't give them more than 3. read more

I love this pizza place. My family eats there at least once a week. The pizza and salad bar are excellent. The crust is always perfect, the ingredients fresh, and the sauce just perfect. What really makes Cirello's specials is the staff. Our child has special needs and eating out is sometimes a challenge. The staff is so kind and always makes us feel like every spill or disruption is no big deal...for parents of a child with special needs, I can assure readers this kind of acceptance and genuine hospitality is, sadly, more rare than one might expect. read more

Best New York Style Pizza in Corvallis, hands down. Excellent selection of local beers on tap -- which you also can get as take-out in growlers with your meal. Cozy dine-in experience with comfortable booths, warm lighting and sound. Everyone on the staff has been friendly and seem to be having fun while still doing a great job. read more

OMG, delicious and an atmosphere you just feel comfortable in. Our pizza was loaded with toppings and they were extremely fresh and tasty. Would recommend this place to anyone looking for great actual pizza without the portentous pricing of Corvallis. read more

I love pizza and this place isn't bad. It's a bit expensive but it's kind of a fun atmosphere. We sometimes go here for little celebrations which is probably why I like it so much :) read more

This is the best pizza in Corvallis. I have tried every other pizza place, and this one always comes out on top. I usually order for pickup, they aren't super quick, usually 25-40 min, but it's great quality. read more

Best, the best, pizza in Corvallis. The crust is top notch (try the whole wheat!) and they are loaded with good toppings. This ain't your regular chain. In the years I've gotten their pizza maybe once or twice they've been a bit (15 min?) off schedule of when they said it would be ready, but that's to be expected with a small operation like this. Friendly staff and nice atmosphere. read more

Our family orders pizza every friday night. Recently younger members had lobbied for a new pizza supplier, so we had been trying out Cirellos. The first week, we ordered the pizza, it came in less than 45 minutes and was really good. The next week, things did not go as well. I called, ordered the pizza, the nice kid on the phone advised it would be delivered in "45 minutes to an hour." I hung up at 5:43. By 7:03, the kids were starting to bounce off the walls and I figured I would check on the pizza, maybe the driver got lost. This is essentially how that conversation went: me; Hi, I was calling to check on our pizza. her: Oh,we are really busy tonight, I am sure its on the way. me: Could you check anyway. her: just a minute. (a few minutes later) it should be there in an hour to an hour in a half. me: are you kidding? thats 2 and an half hours for delivery! her: well, we are *really* busy tonight. me: but when i called the guy said it would be here in 45 minutes to an hour. her: well, i don't know what to tell you, he shouldn't have said that. (direct quote) me: i'd like to speak with the manager. her: just a minute (a few minutes later) oh the delivery driver just came back. he will deliver your pizza soon. me: I'd still like to talk to the manager. her: hold on. (another few minutes later) he's really busy. he will call you back later. well, the pizza showed up about 15 minutes later around 7:40. the manager never called back. My take on this: Cirrellos has great pizza and seems to have plenty of customers. They made it clear they don't need me, so I will be buying my pizza elsewhere. read more

If you want pizza in Corvallis that doesn't involve weird crust, Cirello's is the only game in town. (Pizza Hut, Little Caesar's, and Domino's don't count.) They also have excellent pasta choices, and free wi-fi. read more

These are special pies. I would never have expected my favorite to include broccoli, but it does. Be daring and try something new! The crust here is truly worth eating all by itself. They take awhile to bake but always worth the wait. read more

My favorite pizza in town. Why just four instead of five stars, then? Too limited in hours, and sometimes impossible to get ahold of on the phone. Also, though the toppings are perfectly good, American Dream and Woodstocks have more topping options. That said, it's still the best pizza in Corvallis. Also, you can buy their dough to make your own pizza, and unlike a lot of other pre-prepared doughs, it comes out great, even in a crappy normal apartment oven without a pizza stone. read more

Decent crust but its ALWAYS soggy in the center out. Topping slide off. Its ok. My husband likes it so it say ok...meh...

Better off just getting a frozen pizza. Go to the Dream or Woodstocks for a good slice of pizza.

Our favorite pizza place in Corvallis! Excellent pizza and even better service. They always go above and beyond to be friendly with our young kids and enjoy showing them how to toss pizzas! On Tuesdays they have happy hour all night, which means super cheap pints of delicious microbrew beer. Highly recommend them! read more

The "other" pizza joint which is there when you are sick of everywhere else in town. The pizza is good but just don't plan on taking any home, as the crust will be soggy before you leave the restaurant. I'm generally pleased when I eat here but occasionally the staff is a bit too busy passing the time to properly make a pizza to order and it has to be remade. read more

I heart Cirellos. The pizza is the best in Corvallis. The crust is ten times better than American Dream, and they have so many toppings to choose from. Great beer on tap!.. and Kirsten Studley is a pimp. ;) read more

I am updating my earlier review; as a gluten-free gal, I have given Cirello's several chances and it's a done-deal; they make the worst, most bitter, texture-repulsive crust in town. read more

My favorite lunch spot....the nicest people work there and the food is always great. Try the lunch special...$8.50 for a pizza square with 2 toppings and a trip thru the salad bar and a drink. Amazing! .....two toppings not counting the cheese.... and you get to make your own salad the way you like it. Anywhere else a drink will cost you another $2.00+. read more

Best pizza in town. I don't know when they started doing delivery but we are a fan of food that comes to to our door! American Dream changed their menu about the same time I realised that Cirellos delivers and we have really started to get Cirellos much more. The pizza toppings selection is big and they do have linguisa, one of my favourites. The crust is the best in town. I do not care for red sauce on pizza and they have some options that are delightful! The foghorn with Linguica added is one of my favourites. Also The Rinz with its salt crusted edge is fantastic. My wife is usually not a big crust fan but on The Rinz she enjoys it, she says the salted crust remands her of the warm pretzels. The service is friendly but slow. It has been slow both eating in and delivery. When I ordered delivery last time he did not give me a specific time but implied a time MUCH sooner that it arrived. It is one thing to have a long delivery time like AD but to imply a sooner time and then not be within 1/2 hr of that is frustrating. If he had told me it was going to be an hour right off the bat I would have been ok with that. The food is great you just have to not be in a rush. The service is friendly and selection good. Prices are about the same as the rest of the independent pizza places in town. read more

Good pizza but the wait is horrific. This is the third time and it was not a charm. We waited for over 1 and 20 minutes for our pizza

Geez this stuff is a gut bomb. Ive only ordered cheese and pepperoni, but I ordered it light pepperoni. There was still so much grease on the thing it was dripping off the pizza and running down my arm. I do have to give them credit for having a product that tastes different from all the other places around town, but just too much grease for me. read more

Cirello's reminds me of the place that I worked at when I was in high school. It has delicious thin crust pizza and a few other menu items as well like pasta and I think a few sandwiches. They have good beers on tap, and the place has a very mellow, laid back vibe to it. Small salad bar, get your own plates, grab your own foil to wrap up your leftovers...great pizza and a relaxing time to be had at Cirello's! read more