Literally everything about this place is the best. The staff? Outstanding, and they want to be…read morethere. The pizza? Best in town. This particular location should be given a key to the city for all the philanthropy they're always involved with. Cheers, Papa's, may you live forever.

This place takes me back to my childhood. I can remember going here as a kid. The food isn't…read morehorrible but it's not great. The value is a reasonable price. I remember it being better as a kid. The staff are very polite. The customer service is good. The restaurant is clean. The BBQ chicken was probably the best pizza.

Very friendly, great prices, open table seating- a perfect pizza place…read more The salad and pizza was worth waiting for.

Come here for the nostalgia, leave here with new memories and a full belly (and a full heart). My…read morehusband and I have been getting a heart-shaped pizza for Valentine's Day for years and years. Our kids have now become a part of our tradition and they love it. We love their crust too!

Both pizzas were delicious, lots of flavor, not greasy, very tasty dough!!…read more Good customer service!

How does this place stay in business?!…read more Have you seen their prices!? A small pizza nearly costs $25, a medium over $30, and a large $40-$50. This is more expensive than California! They're even selling slices for $8-$10! I travel a lot and often go get pizza from Chris Bianco in Los Angeles and Phoenix. His pizzas are only around $18-$25 for some of the highest rated neopolitan style pizzas in the nation. Save yourself the financial stress and drive over to Southpaw Pizza. It's much better than PizzAmore. That's what I did and I was able to get two small pizzas and a side of tots for only $25.

Ordered pizzas for a work event! Delivery was a little late but communicated with us…read more Pizza was great with flavorful crust. One of the better pizza spots in Corvallis!!

Today was my second time. I love their gluten free pizza. It's so delicious. I've decided it's…read morethe sauce that makes this place so special. It's divine with such bold and beautiful flavors. They also have real green olives many places no longer offer them and they are the best on pizza. Inside is small and cozy but warm and fuzzy. You can play Ms Pac-Man and they actually have 3 arcade games to indulge. Cute booths for date night. Even beer on tap and real sugar Mexican Coke. Everyone here is so kind and friendly. It's worth paying a little extra for the fresh toppings and most authentic and flavorful sauce. Plus the cheese blend is on point. They even have a stamp card that will reward you after 12 with a free pizza. What are y'all waiting for, get in here.

Super interesting flavor combos! The loaded potato is amazing and a family favorite. The folks are…read moreattentive and great service.

Wow! This is my first time ordering here did have a little problems with trying to order online so…read moreI just had to call there. They were very friendly and patient with me since I didn't really know the menu. But I got half meat meteor. Something like that and half CBR and I added mushrooms to the CBR site. So good and I'll leave a picture I will definitely be ordering again. And really good prices too for what you get. It's more expensive than little Caesars, but the amount of toppings they put on is crazy.!!!

Food was great Like aways service was awesome. Great place…read moreto eat alone or with friend or family

The salad bar is delicious! They have real Ranch dressing. We go in quite often to eat the salad…read morebar for lunch. It's a very fair price at $5.50 for a one-time- through salad. We order pizza for dinner and get sausage with extra pineapple- perfect every time! Highly recommend this place. They have a party room, beer and a gambling room if you're interested.

Now I don't know why this place has reviews below 4, but I consider this the best pizza in town…read more We come here everytime we're in Corvallis. Now I have not had any of the other places, but looking at pictures online. They don't look like my style. Pizza here is always great, the staff is always friendly, it's within walking distance of our hotel, and they have great pies and always plenty of toppings. I am a sucker for the bent which has plenty of veggies and meat. American dream pizza is a staple for our yearly visits to Corvallis. I know I'm getting pizza at least once that weekend if not twice!

My daughter wrestled in McMinnville and my ex-in-laws recommended American Dream Pizza in Corvallis…read moreon the way back to Roseburg. They got there before us an ordered. I had looked at the menu on-line and went with the Dream Special. I love tomatoes and thought it was a different experience to have whole slices on top. I got the mini size. We got to the restaurant and appreciated that there was so much parking available. The inside is quirky. It was bright and open and inviting. It was pretty busy when we got there at 5:30. When I got my pizza, I ended up eating the tomato slices on their own (I sprinkled on a little salt). The toppings underneath were good - Italian Sausage, American Bacon, Mushroom, Black Olive, Fresh Tomato. The crust was so boring. If I'm going to eat carbs, I want them to be worthwhile. This crust would have been a waste of calories so I scraped off the toppings and left the crust. My pizza was a thinner crust, so I took a bite of my daughter's thick crust and I had to drink water to help get it down. Super disappointing because it looked so good! Maybe the intent is to dip it in a sauce? I don't know. Part of their claim to fame is that President Obama stopped in for a slice of pie several years ago. The picture is cool to see. I'm not in Oregon much, but I will definitely not be back to eat here again.

Food as amazing. We just walked in shortly after they all opened and bought a sausage square and…read moreanother one that had corn that looked very interesting. Both were excellent. They had four different varieties to pick from plus they had whole pizzas that you could buy. It worked to be extremely clean. Three people that were working had-smiles on their faces, which I think makes a difference when you enter into a place. They acknowledged you as you walk through the door. Only $12 for two lrg square pieces. Will go again Rumor is there also opening one in Corvallis

Thin Crust, Thick Attitude! 0 stars for customer service…read more 4 stars for the pizza. Let's get the important part out of the way: this crust is thin. We're talking very thin, could-probably-read-a-newspaper-through-it thin. The dough itself tastes like someone actually cared, slightly chewy at the edge, not crisp in the middle, none of that cardboard-cracker nonsense some "artisan" spots try to pass off as minimalism. It's the pizza equivalent of a well-tailored blazer: simple, but you can tell it's good. Very yummy. Menu's takeout only, thin crust only today, two options on the day we went. No square slices, no thick crust for us. This place said "here's our thing, we do it well, deal with it," and the thing is genuinely delicious. We went with the margherita and it delivered! Bright sauce, good cheese-to-crust ratio. I WISH IT HAD JUST A TAD MORE mozzarella. Now, the vibes. There was a whole crowd of people outside like it was a pop-up sneaker drop, but somehow zero line inside, we just walked up. The woman at the counter was deep in conversation with the pizza-makers behind her, which, fine, workplace camaraderie, no crime there. But the energy shifted the second we started asked a question. A Simple one, too..."any square slices?" Got a flat "no, sold out, this is what you have." Fair enough, but the delivery had a little edge to it. Not a good edge. Asking to heat up our slices seemed to be an inconvenience. And the sense of urgency to get us out the door felt a bit performative given there was, again, no one behind us. I saw the drinks after we paid, but there was no way I was going to bother her with ordering a self serve drink. Could be an off day? Could be a personality thing? Could be a hundred things we don't know about, maybe she'd been fielding the same square slice question for six hours straight? Hard to say, and I'm not going to pretend I know why. What I do know is the pizza was good enough that we're already plotting a return trip, service vibes notwithstanding. Sometimes the crust redeems the counter. Brace yourself for a slightly chilly welcome. Worth it.