Food was good after it was sent back because it came to the table cold. I had to send my salad back…read morebecause steak and fries were cold. The huge baked potato that was also served was not cooked thoroughly. On a positive note the food once returned was delicious. Cook needs to look at what goes out , and a plumber may need to look at the bathroom fixtures.

This is what I ordered: Seafood Stuffed Whitefish…read moreFlaky broiled whitefish filet filled with seafood stuffing topped with creamy Old Bay white sauce. Served over wild rice pilaf with choice of vegetable. What I got was a large portion of rice that was not cooked well. A large order of green beans that were good but cold. The fish was a very small very thin white fish filet that was overcooked with hard crispy edges. I could not identify what it was stuffed with but whatever it was it was MINIMAL. Would I order it again. No. Will I go back, absolutely not. Save your money, go somewhere else.

We did not eat but heard the complimentary popcorn is delicious and the appetizers are great!…read moreService excellent with that home feel! The atmosphere is most welcoming!

The green door tavern is a great place to go to eat'mm lots of drink options also! The service was…read moreexcellent and needs no improved at all!!!

I think people are a little harsh on Yelp sometimes. So here it is,a one and a two are really bad,…read morea 3 is not very good but four is expected, thats why I give it a four . I thought it was good and it is exactly what I had expected for what they projected, and think that is the key. The service was pleasant, fast and it was clean. I really liked sitting outside looking at the boats and everyone working and listening to the music, what a lively place. There was a very good clean energy. Great job thanks for having us.

We visited on a midweek evening, and we sat outside. It was a lovely view of the lake. The menu is…read morecomprehensive with plenty of options. Service was prompt and genial. The food was typical quality, nothing outstanding but also nothing bad. Will probably visit only on wing special night, Wednesday, in the future.

Always excellent food, quick service and good pricing. The…read moreambiance is always nice. This place is the go to for locals, they have a nice outside area as well. Never had a bad meal.

It's been a while since we've been here but we loved it. The food and service were excellent. I…read morelove the building.

Good food! Friendly, accommodating staff. We just had our class reunion there, and they were all…read morehelpful.

I dined at Conti's Overtime on New Year's Eve with family while we were staying in Allegany State…read morePark. We arrived with a group of five and were seated promptly, and we were off to a great start, especially on such a busy night. However, it quickly became clear that there was seemingly only one server working and the restaurant was pretty crowded... I ordered chicken wings while other members of the group ordered sandwiches, chicken fingers, and similar items. Unfortunately, everyone else received their food well before I did which felt a bit awkward especially since all the other dishes had already hit the table. I completely understand that takeout orders were probably popping off on NYE but I still feel like dine-in customers should have a bit more priority once food was already being served at the table. The menu itself is extensive and appealing - all of my favorite Buffalo things - and had I not been visiting from out of town, I probably wouldn't have gone straight for wings. Even so, they were cooked nicely and generously sauced (I got BBQ). However, another disappointment came with the French onion soup: two of us ordered it, were later told it was unavailable, and yet it still appeared on our final bill. Unfortunately, my dad paid without catching the error and we didn't realize it until we were back at the cabin. I'd like to think it was an honest mistake on our server's part. All that said, I don't want this review to sound overly negative. Conti's Overtime feels like a solid local spot and I think I just caught it on a particularly hectic evening. I loved the fireplace/atmosphere even if there was a COLD drift coming from the window at our window side table. Sooo, despite this lackluster review, I would absolutely return and am actually looking forward to giving it another chance under calmer circumstances. Here's hoping for smoother service the next time around.

Twice Disappointed…read more We have now dined at this restaurant on two separate occasions, and unfortunately, both experiences left us very unimpressed--especially for a restaurant located in such a nice hotel and charging these prices. Our first experience was lunch in the spring of 2026 while we were staying at the hotel. We were extremely impressed with the hotel itself--the room, staff, and location were wonderful--so naturally we expected the restaurant to be of comparable quality. Sadly, it was not. Our food came out fairly quickly, but it was cold, and several items we ordered were missing. We then had to wait quite a while for someone to return so we could ask for the missing items and condiments, which were definitely needed to help the already subpar flavor. We left disappointed but decided perhaps it was simply an off day. We gave the restaurant another chance in August 2026 while celebrating my father-in-law's 89th birthday. Since this was dinner service, we hoped for a much better experience. His prime rib was actually very good, with no complaints other than the mashed potatoes being served cold. I ordered the Charbroiled Frenched Pork Chop, and unfortunately, it was awful. It had very little flavor and was dry and badly overcooked. The three onion rings served with it were rock hard, overcooked, and cold. They tasted as though they had been deep-fried much earlier and left sitting rather than being prepared fresh. I did send the onion rings back, but I chose not to send the pork chop back because I didn't want my 89-year-old father-in-law, who tires easily, to have to sit and wait while my meal was remade on his birthday. The coffee was another disappointment. At $15, even with a carafe provided, I certainly expected it to at least be hot. It wasn't. Our waiter was adequate and did nothing particularly wrong, but the level of service simply didn't match what I would expect at this price point. The interaction lacked the warmth, attentiveness, and polish you would normally associate with a higher-end dining experience. After two visits with many of the same issues--cold food, poorly prepared food, missing items, and service that doesn't match the prices--I don't think we can chalk this up to one bad night. The hotel itself is lovely, which makes the restaurant even more disappointing. With its location and atmosphere, this restaurant has the potential to be very good, but the kitchen and service need considerable attention. At these prices, guests should be able to expect freshly prepared, properly cooked, hot food accompanied by attentive service. Sadly, twice disappointed.

Have stayed here lately. Have had dinner and breakfast at the restaurant. Both were very good…read more Service is outstanding. Hotel is top-notch. The view is the best on the lake I think. Amenities are great.

We were at the casino and was planning to eat at their buffet, but they were closed. We ventured 7…read moremiles away to the hide-away. I was a little taken back when on the board it stated they had a sloppy Joe and ff special for $17. We ordered the stuffed mushrooms which were enormous and very good. They were the size of a cue ball. Hubby ordered the steak salad special and loved it. Loaded with large pieces of tender steak and he really enjoyed it. He also had a pinia colada which seemed like it was from a pre-made gallon jug. I tasted it and neither of us enjoyed it. I had the stuffed halibut or haddock I forget which. It was on the dry side. I guess I should've went for the extra charge and got it in garlic butter. The stuffing in it had very thin long straps of imitation crab which was gross. Would have been better w/out it. MUCH better. Nice baked potato and mediocre bagged salad in my opinion. Server was nice and friendly and the portion sizes were large, but overpriced.

I come here pretty regularly. the last 3 times prior to today has made me question if I should even…read morereturn. Tonight the service from Reagan was absolutely amazing. she was attentive, she checked in pretty regular and very personable. She knew her stuff and this honestly has been the best service I have ever received while dining here over the last two years. This type of service keeps me coming back. As long as regean continues to waitress here's I will keep returning. some of the other waitresses have very poor attitudes and rolls there eyes right in front of you.

We decided to get a quick New Year's Eve dinner here. Bangers & mash was my choice and it was so…read moregood. Maybe could've done without the diced carrots, but who even cares when the mash is this amazing? There's an excellent Irish whiskey selection - usual fare like Jamo and Tully, plus good stuff like Fighting 69th and Keeper's Heart. Lisa even let me investigate a couple of the bottles I had never heard of - bonus points! Ambience is everything you want from an Irish pub that also has a kitchen. Cozy, good music, extra friendly staff. This will be our go-to whenever we're in town from now on. **Big note: it's cash only but there's an ATM on site!

From the minute, we walked in to the minute we left everything was absolutely 10 stars. Would not…read morehave guessed a small local community bar could have such such exceptional food. This is definitely worth the drive out. It's beautiful on the way out, a great meal, very warm and inviting atmosphere.Exceptional prices. Definitely will be back.