In Jamestown for the 2026 Lucille Ball Comedy Festival, after checking into my hotel and unpacking everything, I opened up my Yelp app and searched for the best spot for dinner as I wanted to eat before seeing the Saturday headliner. One of the top spots was Wicked Warren's, which happened to be across the street from my hotel. In short, this was a great experience! I walked over on a Saturday around 5pm and upon entering, I was impressed how big it was inside! Plenty of tables and chairs and a large bar in the back with plenty of TVs playing all sorts of sports. Right at the entrance was the host station where I spoke to a pleasant, young woman. Since it was just me, she offered either a table or grabbing a seat at the bar, if one was available. Luckily, there were a few empty seats at the bar so I took one and enjoyed watching the bar staff working and chatted with other patrons! The bar staff were incredibly friendly, I could sense they were genuinely happy to be there and enjoyed chatting with the folks sitting at the bar! I'll be honest, this put me ease and relaxed me even more, or maybe it was the beer... haha I'm terrible with names, but I believe the gentleman who ended up taking care of me was Patrick - He was so personable, excellent customer service! I ordered their "Raz Beret" fruited wheat beer to sip on as I figured out what to order for dinner - Delicious, as it was a wheat beer, it had a great fruit-forward flavor without being puckeringly sweet like a fruited sour beer! It was pretty busy when I sat down but I need to say, the wait times were very reasonable! For dinner, I ended up ordering their Philly Cheesesteak Panuzzo with a side of chips and a pickle. What is a panuzzo you ask? A panuzzo is a sandwich made from pizza dough that's folded over and stuffed like a sandwich. The Philly Cheesesteak Panuzzo was their own fresh bake panuzzo bread filled with shaved sirloin steak on a garlic butter base with green peppers, onions, mushrooms, and white American cheese. This was phenomenal! The panuzzo was jam-packed with steak, veggies, and cheese and was plenty hot and tasted so fresh! The garlic butter base was brushed on the panuzzo bread, which left my fingers a little greasy, but it wasn't a big deal wiping my hands off. The chips were good, nothing extraordinary, but good! The panuzzo, side of chips, and a beer were plenty for my big appetite and I was perfectly satiated! I felt the price I paid for their own, locally made beer, and the fresh, high-quality ingredients and great portions were very reasonable. I really enjoyed my dinner at Wicked Warren's! The staff, the beer, the food, all of it was great! I don't make it down to Jamestown often, but next time I passthrough, I would definitely come to Wicked Warren's for dinner. read more

See all

Stopped in for a quick bite to eat before heading over to the Comedy Museum Ordered a Buffalo Chicken Pizza and a local brew. Bartender was a one man show He did a great job although must say could have used a little help. Pizza was good but not close to hot- Saw a pepperoni pizza sitting at the corner of the bar just getting cold while bartender was running around. Staffing is so difficult now but having two managers doing pretty much nothing instead of helping... doesn't help! Decent place but need to revisit there work distribution read more

We stumbled into this place as 'Hangry Tourists'. It's GREAT. Food we had (bbq chicken pizza & draft beers) was outstanding. This is a place I'd come to if I lived in this area. Good music, nice atmosphere. Nice staff. I want a tee shirt-my next purchase! read more

Wicked Warren's - Breweries Near Me - Jamestown, New York

What a way to ruin a nice night. We drove in from Buffalo for the Comedy show at the Comedy center. Seth MEYERs was excellent. Too bad this place is the opposite of excellent. After we were seated by the hostess, we waited 10 minutes. No one took our drink order. We finally flagged someone down. We ordered 2 root beers and 2 waters 1 pizza and pretzel bites. It took another 15 minutes for our drinks and then 10 more for our pretzel. After waiting an hour my husband asked where our pizza was. The waitress said she keeps checking after an additional 10 minutes the waitress came over and told us that "someone else took our pizza" So ridiculous! Then she proceeded to charge us for our drinks. She said the manager agrees to waive our pretzel but we owed 8 dollars for our root beer! What a joke. We threw her the money and got the h out of there. We have a long ride back to Buffalo on an empty stomach. This place is the worst . Do not go there. Such poor service. Management is clueless Waitress was rude. Will never come back here and will tell everyone how bad it is. Too bad. As I said, Seth MEYERs was great and the Comedy Center is amazing. This place should be ashamed of itself. read more

The smash burger was average but the service was terrible. Long wait for someone to take the order long wait for the food then I had to physically hunt down the server for the check since she never came back after we got the food. All in all almost 90 minutes for a burger. Terrible service. read more

Had our dog with us on a recent trip and dined outside. The food was delicious! There was a decorative metal fence to provide a barrier from the street. read more

See all

Brick oven pizza was awesome and rolled pepperoni with sauce was awesome so large ! Abby was very friendly and attentive to our needs and we talked for awhile about the area ... we wanted to come back when the rain stops later in May ... We got lots of suggestions thanks again .. read more

See all

Yummy!!! Wicked White Pizza and Poutine (which was gone before this photo op). Craft beer and an amazing Raspberry Mojito. Thank you Matthew, The Host with the Most. read more

Wicked Warren's - Breweries Near Me - Jamestown, New York

A short walk from the Doubletree. The beer selection was good. I had a pizza - OK, nothing spectacular, but a nice evening with good service and atmosphere. read more

We went to WWs on a weekday and arrived when it first opened. The atmosphere is very cool. I love all the mirrors and the different chandeliers in the place. It's a bar, so it's dark, but the upstairs looked interesting with the curtains for some privacy for events. We ordered the Blue Rooster Pizza, and it looked great! The temperature was not piping hot, so I wondered if it hadn't been in the oven long enough or what. The taste was amazing, though. Then we had the creme brulee cheesecake, which was also a bit disappointing. The fun part about creme brulee (cracking the sugar on top) was missing. The cheesecake was just average. The service was excellent, though, especially because we were only 1 of about 4 parties there so early. I am more than willing to give it another try if the opportunity presents itself. read more

See all

I owe them a revised review because they have new head chefs and I decided to give them another try for lunch. Kayla is an amazing bartender. Other world new England ipas and the raspberry lime cocktails she made me and added blueberry to were perfection. The peperoni balls she recommended were honestly the best I've ever had outside of nyc. They're in my top 3 peperoni balls EVER. Buttery, garlicky, cheesey, crispy, gooey, and amazing. GREAT ranch and marinara. The unstuffed mushroom pizza was so wonderful! Not a drop of grease on the tray perfect crisp crust and dough. Savory umami flavor. I'll get both of these again in a great beat. 5/5 bartender/waitress Kayla 5/5 beer 5/5 cocktail 5/5 pepperoni balls 5/5 marinara 5/5 ranch 5/5 mushroom pizza 5/5 cleanliness 5/5 decore read more

See all

Welcome to Jamestown WW! Beautiful place with excellent service--especially for how new they are. We had the wood fire oven veggie pizza. So good. The parmesean business on the crust us something special. All the food coming out looked amazing. We're looking forward to trying more. read more

Wicked Warren's - Veggie pizza - Breweries Near Me - Jamestown, New York

Great pizza!!! You can create your own... the dough was awesome. Wood wired and yummy! Forgot to take pictures but service and food outstanding. Decor was so much fun! Kind of Alice in Wonderland meets Nightmare before Christmas. Great job! read more

See all

I have never given a review this low but last night I never got my food. I ordered the Bacon Blue Berger and it was never made. That's what the waitress told my wife. In there defense it was very busy. The comic John Stewart was playing down the street and many people were trying to get dinner before the show. read more

Wicked Warren's - I had 2 Raz Berets, which were great. It's a wheat raspberry beer. - Breweries Near Me - Jamestown, New York

Wicked Warren's Pizza recently opened a few months back since I was in town. The local seemed to have mixed reviews, but some liked it so I had to give it a try. The ambience is pretty cool being a larger storefront converted into a restaurant. High ceilings and a nice bar area. Everything seems fairly open. There's really two sides to the restaurant, but it is all connected. Our server recommended a few choice. Pizzas off their specialty list. We selected two as I was traveling with a colleague. We split them and they were both really good. This is your good old-fashioned woodfired pizza. Great flavor They also have a large beer, selection and mixed drinks. I would recommend and come back again when in town. read more

Beer pretty good food is ok but only pizza shop level also not very Kid friendly staff is very good service. Excellent prices a little high parking not that great. read more

This was a really cool spot, very large with plenty of seating. It seems like they have a spooky vibe year round but the Halloween decorations were fun. The beer here is really great!! I got a flight with 4 separate beers and all of them were excellent. The wicked broth hazy ipa was one of the best hazy's I've tried. Can't speak on their food, but the menu had some options that sounded interesting, and all the food being ordered looked great. Definitely a fun brewery to check out! read more

Wicked Warren's - Beer flight - Breweries Near Me - Jamestown, New York

See all

Stumbled in out of the cold to find a huge though inviting space, good food and a nice stout. Tried the smash burger on server recommendation and it was pretty good but not anything worth seeking out. The tap stout was lively and full bodied, but oddly the same stout in a barrel aged bottle version was bitter, thin and unpleasant. Service asked a lot of unnecessary questions - interrupting conversation to ask if she should take an obviously empty plate or refill an empty water glass. But aside from that would recommend if you're looking for a lowkey bite and decent local brew in Jamestown. read more

Atmosphere has such an amazing vibe! Service was excellent. Very friendly and helpful. Beer and food were good. Really liked the Phili cheesesteak sandwich! read more

See all

Stopped for apps and beers between museums. Pepperoni balls and soft pretzels to be exact. They did not disappoint! The bartender was friendly, as were the locals who gave us all sorts of info about the comedy center. Great stop. read more

We visited on the 2nd day and the food was on par with the brewpub's original Warren, Pa. spot. Everything was tasty and made to order. Lots of servers on and the servers was great for a new spot. Ambiance is a little spooky, as planned. HaHa. read more

See all

Stoped in for a late lunch/snack and we're so happy we did. My husband and I split the pepperoni balls and pretzels. They were both top tier! These were the best pretzels I've ever had in a restaurant and the beer cheese was great. The pepperoni balls were a nice change from the typical bar apps- but so so good. Honestly the entire menue looked spot on. The staff were friendly and attentive. A lot of detail clearly went into the decor and menu to make it such a great spot! read more

Loved it, cool spot with good beer and great food. Fish Reuben sandwich was great and huge portion. Server did it all with a smile.

Great food! Great service! Not many good places in the area but this was really good. I'd definitely go back.

Great pizza and beers! They even let you try a sample to make sure it's to your liking. Several seasonal cocktails too. They even turned the channel on one of the TVs so we could watch the game we wanted to see! read more

Nice spot. Food was well made. Pickle pizza was very good. Atmosphere is very original I'd suggested for a football game, but the TV's were not in sink read more

I wouldn't waste your money or time going here or ordering from these guys. Terrible service and the cooks don't even know what the hell they are doing. Who in their right mind puts bbq sauce on a blue cheese burger or a burger at all? Especially when it was never asked for. That was absolutely disgusting. Burger went right into the trash, $17 wasted. My second attempt (today) at giving them another chance and got the same damn thing. F'n disgusting. I'll never, ever go here again. read more

The giant pretzel and pizza were delicious! Friendly service. They have trivia night there. If we're ever in town again, we'll definitely stop back. read more

My date, and I went in and sat down at the bar ,six people at the bar, two bartenders ,the one barmaid was talking to a couple and she went out back walked right in front of us didn't return the other bartender was chatting with another couple at the other end of the barCleaned some dishes or glasses and then turned around, started changing all the TV channels and talking with the same customer We said there for a total of five minutes without being greeted or getting drink or food menu Hope they're not gonna run the business this way won't last very long We left read more

I have been to the Jamestown, NY restaurant a few times. Restaurant is clean , good tasting brews, very good food. Service tends to be a little slow but overall , nice place to go to dine out. read more

Had the pizza and it was great! We only drink dark beer and the choices were so so. Our barmaid was super sweet and helpful. The atmosphere was also great. read more

Great service, fun atmosphere, good beer, acceptable food. Ate here twice while we were in town.

Our server was wonderful! We liked the atmosphere, and our food was good. We will be back!

Plates where dirty and greasy, food was bland Service was slow then the second the food came out they rushed us to finish. Constantly asking if we wanted box's read more

Good pizza and interesting seltzer flavors. Would definitely recommend eating here if you're in Jamestown.

Can I just say, I hate Gluten free crusts. Usually taste like cardboard. Omg. This cauliflower pizza (gluten free) tasted like a hand toss pizza. Wish I took a picture of it, but forgot. Boyfriend liked it too. He knew something was different about the original Wicked Warren's Pizza, and when I said it was the cauliflower crust, he said, "oh". No news from this man is good news . read more

Excellent beer, food and vibe. If you get a chance to sit at the bar and hang out with Maddie consider that your lucky day!

Got this to go and couldn't have been happier. Everything was so yummy! Love the atmosphere! The food was ready when I arrived so no waiting! read more

See all

First off i will say the pizza was pretty good so was the beer and there bruschetta i will say as of right now they need to work on there speed of everything was kind of slow read more

Wicked Warren's - Pizza - Breweries Near Me - Jamestown, New York

New business in town! Fun opening day for the community. Although they seem to have scheduling issues, and were over an hour late in opening last year. Hope their issues with supply chain get worked out. Great concept. Great location. Weird hours and unique staff. Food is good, I like the customizable alcoholic seltzer option, just wish the syrups were actually homemade... read more