Honest John's Pizzeria

Amazing awesome fun dive bar with foodgasm wings. I even use dive in a nice way…read more The place has probably never been remodeled since it opened but you know what? It works ! You get a feel there that's great. The place is so chill and interesting . No frat boy bros. No fall down drunks. No clusters of loud chicks drinking mixed drinks. No dress code or fancy anything. It is what it is and it's fine. Amazing butter garlic wings, amazing medium wings, amazing ranch, and amazing crispy hot waffle fries. The bartender lady also waitresses. The crowd is 25yo-55yo working middle class . There's a dart board, pool table, classic rock posters all over, and classic rock music playing . Bartender lady always gets my crown royal drinks right on the money, this isn't her first rodeo.

Stopped for wings and they were fantastic. Pool table was a nice touch .read more

The bar

Did you know that Fannie Riggoli gave us her pizza sub secret?

See all

Waffle fries

Cherry Lounge

3.3(53 reviews)

1.7 mi

My husband and I had a wonderful time together today. Our waitress was great and very on the ball…read more Our wings were amazing...some of the best we've had around in this area. My turkey club was great and portioned out well. The fries needed a little bit more cooking but still good. My husband had an Italian sandwich but the bread was not very good. He ate the sandwich with marina sauce. We shared the brownie hot fudge sundae but it was melting so fast i didn't want to take a photo. It was very good though.

Great take out service! Excellent chicken wings!…read moreEmployee's were awesome when taking orders for us. Very patient with questions.

Medium 20 Piece Wings

See all

Fried Pickles

Odis 12 Bar & Grille

3.8(177 reviews)

48.6 mi

Was there with a party of 11 on Saturday night. Food was fantastic. Drinks were good as well. I…read moregot my bill and it was higher than i expected, but i didn't question it. Wanted to leave a cash tip as i normally do. Didn't realize until after i had left my cash tip that my bill might have included automatic gratuity as we had a large party. The next morning i was thinking, oh no, i tipped double. Not until i checked my bank account did i realize that they had backed off the automatic gratuity. Much appreciated honesty in service. Not easy to find in todays world. Thank you!

!!!WINGS WINGS WINGS!! I don't know much about their other…read morefood, but these were perhaps some of the best wings I have ever had. And what a selection of sauces and styles. The pizza balls were also tasty! Great beer selection, as well. And they have pitchers! Very good. Definitely returning.

Inside

Bombers, 10 traditional wings

See all

Front entrance

Smoky Martins BBQ

4.5(70 reviews)

58.7 mi

Everything is fantastic. The food the service and the price. They used to be a little food truck…read moreand park outside the courthouse at lunch time. Glad they finally got into a building they don't run out of things anymore.

The food is pretty good here. We especially like the pulled chicken and maybe most importantly the…read morebarbecue sauce is VERY GOOD here. I would like to try the pizzas. I've heard a lot of people love them. The one in Meadville is a walk in only establishment, with seating outside, so unfortunately rating the ambience is limited. The service here has been meh at times. I've gone in a few times and didn't have to wait in line as the employees were still just kind of meh. I'm not saying you have to do a handstand or be annoyingly happy, but a smile and a "Hey how are you!?" Would be a little more welcoming than a rather mundane "hi" at times you feel like you're bothering them. All that aside, I would still recommend this place. The food is delicious

Brisket nachos... I took a lot off of it but normally comes with sour cream, jalapeños, olives, and BBQ sauce!

See all

Amazing chicken wings

The Green Door Tavern

4.7(18 reviews)

11.6 mi

The green door tavern is a great place to go to eat'mm lots of drink options also! The service was…read moreexcellent and needs no improved at all!!!

We did not eat but heard the complimentary popcorn is delicious and the appetizers are great!…read moreService excellent with that home feel! The atmosphere is most welcoming!

They just opened

Yes, it's as good as it looks!

See all

Frewsburger Pizza Shop

4.2(19 reviews)

5.1 mi

Decided to come in and try the Stromboli. I got the sausage roll and my friend got the Stromboli…read moreroll. I got to try both and they are fantastic! The seasoning on the roll is perfect. The inside is cheesy and delicious! Service was friendly and food came out Jan timely manner. Highly recommend!

Order was for takeout . Lobby was empty and food was ready on time. The pizza had very sweet sauce,…read morewhich was ok but the crust was real thick and the cheese tasted fake and rubbery. Wings were cook good, large and saucy. Butter garlic was perfect and the med wings were actually med for a change. Don't like they put the cold items on top of the hot wings in same container. They need to be in a separate bag.

Best Stromboli around!

See all

3rd Base Bar & Grill

4.0(45 reviews)

39.7 mi

I was here for work and picked up wings twice. They were so good! Lol I got mine extra crispy, and…read moreI tried the Chesapeake garlic, and the lemon pepper. No complaints whatsoever. Everything was really good. The wings were hot and the fries were decent as well. I did not love the ranch or blue cheese dressing, but that's just my preference. Can't speak to the service because it was just to go order and everything went fine. Seems like a very chill dive bar type of place.

Wow! I thought the half way inn was the best wings in the area until I had wings at the 3rd base!…read moreOur minds are blown! It's more of a cozy friendly dive bar without a nice view like halfway inn, but the halfway in wings, fries, and staff don't hold a candle to 3rd base! The wait staff and management at 3rd base are what make it a Cheers type vibe. Don't sleep on it or be fooled by the unassuming outside. The place is dated, but very clean, fast, super welcoming, exceptional at what they do, a well oiled machine, and delicious! My mouth is watering and I can smell the wings and Cajun fries vividly in my memory while I write this. I'm kicking myself for driving by without trying them for forever. I'm addicted now!

Great wing options. The best in olean

The best wings in olean!

See all

2nd time of not enough ranch or sauce even though extra was ordered on both :(

Clark’s Subs

4.3(24 reviews)

40.1 mi

I travel back-and-forth between Ithaca and Jamestown regularly, so I'm always looking for quick,…read morehealthy spots to grab a bite. Clarks is a little off the beaten path, but I couldn't have enjoyed my experience more. They have a wonderful veggie sub that was ready in under five minutes on a quiet fall Sunday afternoon. Service was friendly. There are a few spots to eat in if you choose, (but I destroyed my car by eating it on the go!) This will be a regular stop!

The BEST subs I've had in awhile! We did an online order and went to pick it up and the staff is…read moreawesome and super friendly. We got the philly and a chicken tender sub and both were delicious. The subs are PACKED and so filling, we split a half and it was still huge! We also split pizza logs and they were really good. The cherry pepper relish is awesome and the habanero jack cheese is SO GOOD AND ACTUALLY SPICY I loved it! Seriously go get Clarks. It is worth the $$!!!

Clean, well run shop

Steak sub with pizza sauce

See all

Super expensive, but delicious!

Forester Resturant and Tavern

3.9(47 reviews)

21.2 mi

Service was friendly. The bun on the chicken sandwich was sturdy and chicken was moist and had good…read moreflavor. The only criticism would be no option for cheese, would have preferred a pepper jack over the cheddar. The burger was cooked well, but the bacon could've used a little longer in the pan as it was a little under. The fish had great flavor and was cooked well, but the breading was a tad thick. The serving size was massive.....unless you are super hungry, go with the smaller portion . The pickle spears were good, but again the breading was a little too thick. Not pictured was the bang bang shrimp. The shrimp was a 10 out of 10 highly recommend. Don't pass them up if you opt for an appetizer. Over all a great meal and definitely on the must go places for a solid dinner in the Warren area.

great place. good food. good service. dining room tight and loud but will return. kind of hidden…read moreaway.

Bar area

Crispy Chicken Sandwich

See all

Pickle Spears

Fattie G's Pizzeria

4.6(16 reviews)

38.0 mi

Absolutely Amazing! Best Pizza and Service Around!…read more Fattie G's Pizzeria is an absolute gem! From the delicious food to the outstanding customer service, everything about this place deserves five stars. The food is fresh, flavorful, and made with care, and you can tell that quality and customer satisfaction are a priority here. The staff is incredibly friendly, welcoming, and attentive. They make you feel appreciated as a customer, provide excellent service, and help create a great atmosphere that makes you want to keep coming back. It's refreshing to find a place where both the food and the people make such a great impression. Whether you're stopping in for pizza, wings, subs, or anything else on the menu, Fattie G's delivers a great experience. The combination of delicious food, generous hospitality, and excellent service truly sets this place apart. If you're in Angola, NY, and looking for a great local pizzeria, Fattie G's is definitely worth checking out! Support local businesses like this one that work hard to give their customers a great experience. Highly recommend to anyone looking for amazing food and friendly service! Keep up the great work, Fattie G's! You guys are killing it!

We just moved to Angola and took a chance on Fatty G's for wings. We are so glad we did. Honey…read moreSesame, hot bbq and mango habanero were our sauces of choice. They were all delicious. My favorite were the mango habanero, perfectly spicy. The wings were all cooked to perfection. The staff were very friendly and helpful. Someone was busy washing the windows. The restaurant was spotless. They even let me put my daughter's dog sitting business card on the bulletin board. Long story short we'll be back. Sorry no pictures, we dug in like animals .

See all

Steak sub with mushrooms and sweet peppers and provolone cheese. Very good dinner

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

1 review that is not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Kristin V.

6 years ago

Love the wings. Best in town. A lot of specials to choose from.

Honest John's Pizzeria - pizza - Updated October 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of Jamestown, New York Things to Do near Honest John's Pizzeria

BEST of Jamestown, New York Restaurants near Honest John's Pizzeria

BEST of Jamestown, New York Desserts near Honest John's Pizzeria

BEST of Jamestown, New York Coffee near Honest John's Pizzeria

BEST of Jamestown, New York Breakfast near Honest John's Pizzeria

BEST of Jamestown, New York Dinner near Honest John's Pizzeria

BEST of Jamestown, New York Thrift Stores near Honest John's Pizzeria

BEST of Jamestown, New York Burgers near Honest John's Pizzeria

BEST of Jamestown, New York Shopping near Honest John's Pizzeria

Best of Jamestown

Things to do in Jamestown

Browse Brands

Brands by name

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed Honest John's Pizzeria also viewed

Lena’s Pizza - TaQo

3.5

(10 reviews)

We were passing through from out of town and found this cute little place. The wings and pizza were…read moreamazing. Great value and good quality.

Never answers the phone. The employees sit outside and smoke instead of actually working.read more

Elmo's Pizza

4.8

(31 reviews)

Got the online 10 chicken wings for $7.50. They were the best, most amazing wings I have ever had!…read more Highly recommend

Good food and terrific service. I live the pizza. This place is my family's go-to place. We love it…read morehere!

Wicked Warren's

4.1

(51 reviews)

In Jamestown for the 2026 Lucille Ball Comedy Festival, after checking into my hotel and unpacking…read moreeverything, I opened up my Yelp app and searched for the best spot for dinner as I wanted to eat before seeing the Saturday headliner. One of the top spots was Wicked Warren's, which happened to be across the street from my hotel. In short, this was a great experience! I walked over on a Saturday around 5pm and upon entering, I was impressed how big it was inside! Plenty of tables and chairs and a large bar in the back with plenty of TVs playing all sorts of sports. Right at the entrance was the host station where I spoke to a pleasant, young woman. Since it was just me, she offered either a table or grabbing a seat at the bar, if one was available. Luckily, there were a few empty seats at the bar so I took one and enjoyed watching the bar staff working and chatted with other patrons! The bar staff were incredibly friendly, I could sense they were genuinely happy to be there and enjoyed chatting with the folks sitting at the bar! I'll be honest, this put me ease and relaxed me even more, or maybe it was the beer... haha I'm terrible with names, but I believe the gentleman who ended up taking care of me was Patrick - He was so personable, excellent customer service! I ordered their "Raz Beret" fruited wheat beer to sip on as I figured out what to order for dinner - Delicious, as it was a wheat beer, it had a great fruit-forward flavor without being puckeringly sweet like a fruited sour beer! It was pretty busy when I sat down but I need to say, the wait times were very reasonable! For dinner, I ended up ordering their Philly Cheesesteak Panuzzo with a side of chips and a pickle. What is a panuzzo you ask? A panuzzo is a sandwich made from pizza dough that's folded over and stuffed like a sandwich. The Philly Cheesesteak Panuzzo was their own fresh bake panuzzo bread filled with shaved sirloin steak on a garlic butter base with green peppers, onions, mushrooms, and white American cheese. This was phenomenal! The panuzzo was jam-packed with steak, veggies, and cheese and was plenty hot and tasted so fresh! The garlic butter base was brushed on the panuzzo bread, which left my fingers a little greasy, but it wasn't a big deal wiping my hands off. The chips were good, nothing extraordinary, but good! The panuzzo, side of chips, and a beer were plenty for my big appetite and I was perfectly satiated! I felt the price I paid for their own, locally made beer, and the fresh, high-quality ingredients and great portions were very reasonable. I really enjoyed my dinner at Wicked Warren's! The staff, the beer, the food, all of it was great! I don't make it down to Jamestown often, but next time I passthrough, I would definitely come to Wicked Warren's for dinner.

Stopped in for a quick bite to eat before heading over to the Comedy Museum…read more Ordered a Buffalo Chicken Pizza and a local brew. Bartender was a one man show He did a great job although must say could have used a little help. Pizza was good but not close to hot- Saw a pepperoni pizza sitting at the corner of the bar just getting cold while bartender was running around. Staffing is so difficult now but having two managers doing pretty much nothing instead of helping... doesn't help! Decent place but need to revisit there work distribution

The Main Landing

3.8

(91 reviews)

There simply are not enough stars. This is a true American restaurant which makes us feel like kids…read moreagain! Takes you way, way back in time! Reminds me how good fish can taste : and 1 am a pescatarian! The kind people who take care of you there, the view and air which are a treatment on their own.

Great view! Very clean! Nice cold AC! Good selection on the menu! Good alcohol selection including…read morenon alcohol beer! I honestly think our last experience was just a fluke or off night for the wait staff and kitchen. This time everything we ordered was accurate and well seasoned. Our waitress was super fast and friendly. Our food was delicious in every single way. We loved the shrimp scampi, the salad was crisp, and the loaded jalapeño potato bites with white cheddar and tender juicy pulled pork were absolutely mouth watering. Our in house made desserts were out of this world,especially the addictive coconut cream! The owner came over and served us our desserts, she was such a nice lady. She's also a very talented cook because she makes the pulled pork and desserts herself. I highly recommend! We'll be back!

Hide-A-Way Restaurant

3.8

(53 reviews)

I come here pretty regularly. the last 3 times prior to today has made me question if I should even…read morereturn. Tonight the service from Reagan was absolutely amazing. she was attentive, she checked in pretty regular and very personable. She knew her stuff and this honestly has been the best service I have ever received while dining here over the last two years. This type of service keeps me coming back. As long as regean continues to waitress here's I will keep returning. some of the other waitresses have very poor attitudes and rolls there eyes right in front of you.

I had the fish fry with fries and coleslaw because as a Yankee living in Virginia it is almost…read moreimpossible to find good beer batter fish fry. This was a huge, delicious serving , our server was very nice so my friends and I really enjoyed ourselves.

Lena's Pizza

4.2

(58 reviews)

Great pizza! The sauce-to-cheese ratio is right on. And the flavor is delicious my family doesn't…read morewant to go anywhere else. 5My only negative thing is they don't offer delivery

we've purchased from here several times since we bought a bed and breakfast 5 months ago. It's the…read morewhole management approach that was dusappointing. When you place an order and you spend almost $40 you expected to be right and you don't expect to get an attitude about it. We ordered two different sets of chicken wings one barbecue and one Buffalo that they gave us wings with no sauce on one set. Then the manager says I have to pay a dollar for each sauce but they didn't get the sauce right. We are done. There's too many choices in this town for wings and pizza.

Jaggerz

4.7

(3 reviews)

Best cheeseburger in Randolph and Kennedy area hands down…read more Casual Diner in a cute plaza downtown serving American and woodfire pizza parlor type food. Free street parking on both sides. After 6pm Monday-Friday you can park in the next door parking lot of Randolph Auto Supply if the street is full. 10/10 Cheeseburger. Absolutely amazing! 10/10 service from our waitress and the manager (Jamie) that stopped at everyone's tables to ask how we liked everything. 10/10 friendliness of everyone 9/10 thick creamy delicious ranch 10/10 cleanliness 8/10 marinara sauce 8/10 Stromboli (pepperoni, salami, and mozzarella) 10/10 speed of service 10/10 prices My next try will be the Philly cheese steak. They are made with real chopped steak and fresh rolls. We will be back for sure! We highly recommend Jaggerz! Fyi: Monday is wing special day.

Friendly staff. Good location in downtown…read more Street parking. Amazing burgers, best in town. Monday wing specials. Clean. Fast. Good prices.

Davidson's Family Restaurant

3.8

(78 reviews)

I recently went on a tour to celebrate the I LOVE Lucy show's 75th anniversary. I had a meal at…read morethis restaurant and it was a great experience. The food was great-the fried chicken was tasty and tasted like home cooked chicken. The soup was great-vegetable soup with ground beef, fresh tomatoes, vegetables, tomato soup broth was fantastic. However, the service given by the waittress, Cathy Jo was OUTSTANDING!!!! Cathy was one of the best waitresses I have ever encountered-not pushy, didn't oversell, friendly, and could not do enough to make sure I had a great time and pleasant meal. All I can say if you ever go to this restaurant ask for Cathy Jo!!!!!

Kind of sad but I need to get this restaurant for a 30 years keeps getting worse and worse first…read morethey went away from the haddock fish and they went to Cod try to do with that and then it used to be a big piece of fish that hung over your plate now they've Shrunk the fish that hard to even reaches each side of the plate it's over done doesn't taste good at all plus it's $20 for a fish $3 more than a steak prices are Sky High service is still good but the food is terribly expensive and it's just plain garbage anymore another restaurant soon to close

Big Eddie’s Pizza And Sub

4.5

(2 reviews)

What an amazing sub shop! New owners opened a few months ago and are serving up great pizza and…read moreawesome subs. These things are HUGE! We are there three days in a row and I think the last sub I had was maybe the best - the Italian (see pic). I believe all the subs are 8-9" for a half and about 15" for a whole. Realistically a half should feed two people, they're super stuffed. Best of luck to the owners and hopefully they stay in business a long time.

Food is good and they have a lot to choose from in this small area. The service is quick and the…read moreworkers are always friendly. Prices fluctuate but aren't to outrageous.

Subway

3.0

(5 reviews)