So my wife and I saw this on Triple D, and since we were in Baltimore for a conference, we had to try it. SO glad we did. I had the Rachel (corned beef, swiss, coleslaw, and thousand island dressing on rye) and it was so freaking good. The pit style of the corned beef was definitely on of the best ways I've ever had corned beef. It was so tender and flavorful it was great. Every part of the sandwich was great.
My wife had the original Pit Beef sandwich. While excellent, we both felt it would be even better with a type of sauce. An Au jus dipping sauce would be a perfect compliment, and we even thought cheese sauce or plain old mustard could amp it up. Again, very flavorful smokey flavor, but not too smokey. I'm not a fan of smokey beef, and this was just perfect.
We also had the mac and cheese and highly recommend that as a side. The large is in the picture. Get that, as everyone there told us the small is basically a Dixie cup. We didn't try the fries, but a ton of people had them and were finishing them.
The place is tiny. Very few tables, more outside in warmer months we were told. The place was packed, but didn't take more than about 15 minutes to get in, order, and get our food. We easily got a table, as most everyone in there was on a lunch hour and left quickly after eating. Plus, I think it's an unwritten rule there that once you're done, you get out and make room for the next person to enjoy. It's not a sit-down service place, so you won't be lingering anyway.
Yes, the restaurant is in the parking lot of a strip club and across the street from an adult bookstore, but it's totally safe. We Ubered there and had to wait in a line outside (a couple of people in line said it's typically not wrapped outside), and felt totally fine...just had to avoid two cars that almost backed into us since they weren't looking. We then waited for our driver outside afterward and again had no hesitation.
Other than people not watching where they're driving in the parking lot, don't let the reviews of the neighborhood deter you. It's a bit "rougher" than Fell's Point or the Inner Harbor for sure, but nothing that anyone who has ever been to a city hasn't seen before. No fancy hotels or office buildings, mostly industrial and commercial properties, as well as older houses and apartments. Plus, we saw a ton of police in and around the area getting there and while there (literally 7 cars and 3 roaming packs of cops on foot). I've actually never seen a city with as big of a police presence everywhere you look than Baltimore. This includes this area and the other two I mentioned. Some members of the fire department were actually there with us eating at the time. Go at lunch or dinner when there are a bunch of people to feel more comfortable if you'd like, but DEFINITELY go here. read more