As soon as you walk in you feel transported to your happy place. Sure, the ambience and decor are inviting, easy on the eyes, and the aroma of delicious food draws you further in, but it's the people who work there that shine. Went with my mother and sister while we were staying nearby attending a wedding party in Bartlett. Read about Catherine and Mary's online and decided to give it a shot based on pics and reviews. As soon as we stepped inside we were warmly greeted and made to feel at home. I must say here that my sister has a small disorder such that it's hard for her to talk in complete sentences, and she has a notable stutter. This means she also experiences a great deal of social anxiety. She felt so welcomed that she hardly stuttered while we were there, and when we left she said, "This was such a good place for people like me." I loved that they made me and my mom welcome, but am doubly grateful that you went out of your way to make my sister so happy. She really felt like you treated her like an old friend. My sister has a speech problem, but she's not mentally disabled (in fact she's an electrical engineer). So the kindness was not lost on her, and I know this will be a place we'll look forward to when we visit family in the Memphis area. Thank you so much for the excellent food and the awesome vibes! Nicky Gina Connie read more

What a neat gem in the heart of Memphis. We were expecting standard Italian finds, but it was a great change to be Italianisc without being Italian. They have pasta dishes, as expected, but with a twist, much like their noodles. (Pun intended.) We started with a charcuterie board. There are three selections: meat and cheese, just cheese, or just meat. We opted for meat and cheese. Presentation was elegant. Taste was good. Preference for us was more on the mild side. Some of the cheeses a bit earthy. read more

See all

Best friend at the bar yeahahhhhh so service was cool. Drinks SOO drinks Really coool vibe inside too reminded me of grandma's house especially bartender best friend , but ngl a little disappointed w the pastas. Drinks were really good and so was the environment, but yeah read more

We had an extended family celebration at Catherine and Mary's, and we truly enjoyed the entire experience. We tried the fried mozzarella and corn bread appetizers. We shared two of the salad platters. Then we dug into multiple pasta dishes along with the chicken and fish entrees. There's a wide variety of mixed drinks, wine and beer to choose from. The coffee and gelato are excellent as well. James provided wonderful service. The place used to be an old hotel and the restaurant is located in what used to be the lobby. It's a big space, but you can still easily hold a conversation. There's complimentary valet parking just around the corner. read more

We came here to eat after a musical at 4:30. The ambience is relaxing and hip. I felt very comfortable and like I was in a more upscale establishment. Our service was excellent! Our server was very nice. Having one picky eater that sent her dish back twice is annoying but our server handled it perfectly. The food was all delicious but small servings. I would not recommend the artichoke; it's good but barely enough for a tasting and expensive for what you receive. The grouper was cooked perfectly but again for $40 the serving was small. The cornbread was delicious and a better serving. I would have personally preferred a small cast iron skillet of cornbread for the price instead of I think 4 slices. The cannoli was good, the carrot cake excellent and the parmesan gelato tasteless but for us a must try because we had not tasted it before. The heat was also out so it was cold but not unbearable. read more

See all

The atmosphere and service was great. Our waitress gave us amazing recommendations and made fun small talk which made the experience nice. We really liked the industrial look of the restaurant. The food was pretty good. The best was the brussel sprouts. The cornbread (even a little crispy) was great, especially with the mascarpone. My wife had the halibut which she said was great and I had the quail which was decent (a little over salted and too much sauce). The desert was carrot cake which honestly could have done without. It was about the size of a half dollar and dry. Almost like it was store bought and frozen. read more

See all

The interior is gorgeous. Very nice dining experience. We were sat in a little nook with shelving behind it in a half booth. We had exemplary service from someone who was very knowledgeable about the menu and very friendly to boot. The little gem buttermilk salad was fantastic and flavorful. We weren't as impressed with our two pastas choices, the agnolotti and mafalde. But it was nice to try something new. The desserts were heavenly, however. Good cocktails, too. read more

See all

I was walking downtown one day when a friend recommended this restaurant, so I decided to book a reservation online through Resy. Chefs Andy Ticer and Michael Hudman, also known for Andrew Michael Italian Kitchen, own this establishment. Catherine & Mary's is named in honor of their grandmothers. The complimentary valet parking is available Monday through Saturday; otherwise, street parking can be found nearby. Upon entering, the hostess stand is directly ahead, with the main bar to the left. The primary dining area is to the right, featuring high ceilings and a dimly lit, industrial ambiance with exposed walls and columns. FOOD: 1. Caprese Salad: Heirloom tomatoes, buffalo mozzarella, shallots, and red wine vinaigrette (4/5): This was a refreshing start! This is ideally shared between 2 people. The heirloom tomatoes were ripe and sweet, pairing beautifully with the buffalo mozzarella. 2. Pork Belly: Frisée, cabbage, pear, balsamic, sorghum vinaigrette, and hazelnut crunch (4/5): It is perfect for sharing between two people. Rich, fatty, and delicious. The sorghum vinaigrette tied everything together with a tad of sweetness that balanced the richness of the meat. 3. Carbonara: Guanciale, egg yolk, pecorino, and black pepper (3/5): Flavor-wise, it was comforting and familiar, though it didn't quite stand out compared to the other dishes. 4. Halibut: Parsnip purée, root vegetables, and cara blanc (4/5): It was a lighter dish, and it was cooked just right. 5. Tiramisu: Espresso anglaise, mascarpone, and cacao nibs (5/5): The best tiramisu I've ever had, easily shared between 3 people. I loved it from the textures with the cacao nibs and with the perfect amount of espresso flavor. We devoured it within minutes. The service was great. Our server checked in regularly, and the food arrived promptly. The restaurant also hosts a monthly Enjoy AM Wine Dinner Series, featuring a four-course meal with wine pairings curated by the sommelier and culinary team. There's also a happy hour Monday through Friday from 4 p.m. to 6 p.m. Would I come back? Absolutely. read more

See all

Always serving up the freshest and most amazing pasta and Italian dishes in town! Not to mention the craftiest and best bartenders you could ever ask for! read more

See all

Our new favorite Italian in Memphis! Fun modernized vintage facility! Higher end, but not too fofo, no table linens... good and friendly service. The appetizers are great, but are truly one person sized.... Loved the artichoke and crispy polenta! See photos.. We loved the rigatoni and added meatballs... The Lumache is like Mac n Cheese on steroids then a trip to finishing school. Perfectly black peppered! This is one of the few places where the fresh pasta actually tasted noticeably better than dry. Lots of chewy goodness, not just al dente. I don't claim to be anything like an epicurean but can appreciate the depth and complexity of the food here. New, different, and great! Our new goto when visiting our son..... Warning: this place is the opposite of quiet. Lots of people enjoying themselves.... read more

See all

Had a great dinner at Catherine & Mary's in Memphis while sitting at the bar, which is usually my preferred spot. They have an excellent bourbon selection, which immediately caught my attention, along with a really solid wine list. From the moment I sat down, the staff and bartenders were friendly and welcoming. One thing I especially appreciated was that all of the bartenders worked together to take care of guests instead of the "that's not my customer" approach you sometimes see. That level of teamwork makes for great service. I started with the Formaggi, then ordered the Gnocchi because if gnocchi is on the menu, I'm ordering it. This version was especially delicious -- alla vodka, crème fraîche, mozzarella, and basil. Rich, flavorful, and absolutely worth it. Great food, great service, and a great atmosphere. I'll definitely be back next time I'm in Memphis. read more

See all

Catherine & Mary's nails the Italian fare with meatballs, house made innovative pasta and exquisitely prepared mains. I absolutely adore their scarpinocc with subtle flavors of beets and with poppyseeds for fun texture. The halibut stole the show of the meal--the tender filet is seared to the perfect crisp. Searing both sides would be perfect. C&M's is pure rugged elegance. The negative space between tables, the torn down walls and columns, the lowly hung chandelier and soft jazzy sets the perfect New York City ambiance. It's the perfect restaurant for a quiet classy evening. Either stop by the beautiful bar for a drink while savor how the pouring sunlight changes its shadows across the restaurant during the golden hour. l am swooned just by being immersed in the space. read more

See all

The portion sizes are non existent. 6 noodles was served as my entree. Complete BS. Waste of money do not come here.

The food was absolutely incredible. This was our first time here and I wasn't sure what to get but our waiter was great and made really good recommendations. The restaurant itself is really nice and wasn't too loud or too quiet. Overall the price really isn't bad, we did family style so we ordered and shared but it was still cheaper than I anticipated. All in all, will definitely come back. read more

Up on very high recommendations I tried this restaurant for downtown diners week and it did not disappoint. My server was excellent. She was very sweet and friendly and attentive. The atmosphere calming, but yet the music has soul. Photos and descriptions below. Price tag of meal before tip $66.00. read more

See all

I had the wonderful opportunity to take my wife on a long-awaited date to Catherine and Mary's, a place we'd been itching to try for ages. We'd initially made reservations here a while back but had canceled due to the lack of valet parking at the time. Thankfully, they've since added valet service. However, I wasn't particularly a fan of its location--it's tucked on the side of the restaurant rather than the front. It felt a bit out-of-the-way and isolated, especially at night. The restaurant itself is in a prime downtown spot, just a block from the Orpheum. The ambiance is truly delightful, and the service? Absolutely impeccable. For anyone who has been to Italy (as we have), this restaurant's authentic approach to serving food in courses will be a nostalgic treat. The portions may appear modest at first glance, but don't let that fool you--each dish is so richly satisfying that it fills you up. My wife and I shared every course, which I highly recommend, as sharing is not only encouraged but also enhances the experience. Antipasti We kicked off our meal with the antipasti charcuterie board. If you're looking for the perfect appetizer, pair this with your favorite wine--it's a must-try. Meatballs Next up were the meatballs. Though they were on the smaller side, the tomato sauce more than made up for it, bursting with flavor and elevating the dish. Cacio e Pepe Now, let's talk about the Cacio e Pepe--a dish close to my heart. Confession time: when my family and I visited Rome, Italy, last spring, I became thoroughly addicted to Cacio e Pepe. For eight straight days, I indulged in it! So naturally, when I saw it on Catherine and Mary's menu, I couldn't resist. While their take on Cacio e Pepe was undeniably good, it didn't quite match the culinary heights of the versions I had in Italy. To be fair, few places in the U.S. truly replicate the magic of Italian cuisine, which is why Italy is, well, Italy. That said, with a few tweaks, this dish could reach Italian-level greatness. Catherine and Mary's puts their own spin on the dish, using pasta shells instead of the classic spaghetti. While this adds their unique touch, I found the shells slightly too firm, and they detracted from the authenticity of the experience. In Italy, it's always spaghetti--every time, without fail. Additionally, the sauce, while rich and tasty, leaned a bit too heavily on butter at the expense of the cheese flavor. It was also more liquid than I'm accustomed to. The Cacio e Pepe I fell in love with in Rome had a thicker sauce with a perfectly balanced texture and flavor. Final Thoughts For these reasons, I'd give Catherine and Mary's 4 out of 5 stars! read more

Catherine and Mary's - Antipasti! AWESOME! - Italian Near Me - Memphis, Tennessee

See all

Love this place. At a very minimum the vibe is perfect for some drinks at the bar, a little appetizer and great conversation. Our first full sit down and it was good. Aspects that were great, others just not a fan. Like the scallops, the risotto was awesome, scallops maybe a tad too heavy on sear, but grapes were too sweet. Carbonara was incredible. Mafalde flavor great, pork texture not a fan. Ups and downs, but that's just my taste not necessarily C&M. We had Foccacia appetizer, but I forgot to get a picture. That app was def top notch. Service was awesome as I have been accustomed to experiencing at their restaurants. All in all give a try, it's well worth it. read more

See all

Went here recently (September 2025) for dinner, and the atmosphere was lively and a bit loud for fine dining. The place was definitely hopping. We ordered steak and veal both were absolutely delicious. Drinks were a mixed experience: we had to order off the menu, and I didn't love mine, though my friend enjoyed their wine. The menu is on the fancy side, and I didn't recognize a lot of the terms. Overall, it's not a bad spot just a bit more upscale and noisier than I usually prefer. read more

Catherine and Mary's - Italian Near Me - Memphis, Tennessee

The food was great, nothing like I had eaten before - very unique, but great. I just snacked a little, I had the cornbread and whipped ricotta appetizer. The cornbread was not traditional, it had some citrus notes in it but it was very good. It had a nice sweetness and texture, super soft melted in my mouth but not soggy at all. The ricotta added a nice flavor pairing. The tiramisu was amazing. I love desserts that aren't too sweet and this one was just perfect. The cocoa nibs added a nice crunch and flavor and the cake itself was super soft. read more

Catherine and Mary's - Tiramisu - Italian Near Me - Memphis, Tennessee

See all

Delicious! Came in with some coworkers. I had the mozzarella and beef carpaccio to start. The mozzarella were fantastic, could take or leave the carpaccio. I had the carbonara pasta which was lovely. The star was the halibut, it was buttery and cooked perfectly. This might be my new Memphis go to! read more

See all

Catherine and Mary's has been on my Memphis restaurant bucket list for years, and I was so excited to finally give it a try. We started with an order of the fried mozzarella and the brussels sprouts. The fried mozzarella were fairly standard -- packed with a smoky mozzarella and a light breading. The side of slightly sweet marinara sauce paired well with the savory mozzarella and breading. The brussels sprouts were tremendous -- flavored and cooked to a slight crisp. I could have eaten an entire order myself. For my entree, I ordered the Lumache (cacio e pepe). The sauce was rich, creamy and savory, while the pasta was cooked perfectly. The portion was on the smaller size, but after two appetizers I couldn't have eaten much more. I also ordered an espresso martini, which was amazing -- one of the best I've had in Memphis. The service was excellent and I loved the decor and atmosphere inside. I look forward to returning to explore more of the menu. read more

Catherine and Mary's - Espresso martini - Italian Near Me - Memphis, Tennessee

The staff were very accommodating as we arrived late. The pasta dish I ordered was a real hit with me and several others who ordered the same on my recommendation. read more

Catherine and Mary's - Italian Near Me - Memphis, Tennessee

came to celebrate friends and had a great time, very cool vibes and ambience. The service was friendly and quick. The food overall was really good, but for simple dishes my expectations are for them to be perfect and I just wished a bit more from them. All around, a great dining spot downtown and glad to have stopped by. read more

See all

So I was at a conference and tempted to just eat the reception buffet and head back to my room. In what became a fortunate turn of events, my roommate was allergic to everything on the buffet, so off to Catherine and Mary's we went. I went straight to the main event- Halibut. It was one of the best dishes I've had in a long time. Seriously, I would put the beurre blanc sauce on this fish up against any in the world. Add to this the fact that the fish was perfectly seared and I relished every bite. Not to be outdone, my roommate order the spinach agnolotti which was almost as good. You could taste the care that went into the pasta. Dessert was less successful. I first tried a carrot cake which I found odd enough to return. The cannoli I received in its place weren't any better. I wasn't mad. I didn't need anything but that halibut! The dining room is really lovely, ornate enough atmosphere for a date night but made more fun by whimsical murals. Our server was abrupt and uninterested in a way that was unpleasant, but he seemed the exception rather than the rule. The other servers we encountered were lovely. I can see why this is considered a top spot in Memphis. read more

Catherine and Mary's - Halibut - Italian Near Me - Memphis, Tennessee

Catherine and Mary's is absolutely gorgeous inside--it's a whole vibe. It's the perfect spot for a happy hour drink or a date night. We sat at the bar and tried a few cocktails, all well-made and delicious. The Pear Focaccia was a standout, offering a mix of unique flavors that worked beautifully together. The bartender was sweet and welcoming, adding to the great experience. We'll definitely be back! read more

Catherine and Mary's - Pear focaccia - Italian Near Me - Memphis, Tennessee

Food above average. Service horrible. Wrong items sent out multiple times. Ordered a glass of wine and never got it. Didn't receive utensils until 5 minutes after food arrived. Bush league for such a high profile restaurant. This was one of my wife's favorite places to eat. We've been at least 5-6 times. Pales in comparison to Amelia Gene's. read more

The service the ambience and the food is amazing. We had a wonderful experience dining for our anniversary. The gravy was magnificent on the rigatoni. The grouper was cooked to perfection. The beef carpaccio was one of the best I've had. read more

Catherine and Mary's - Beef carpaccio - Italian Near Me - Memphis, Tennessee

See all

My boyfriend took me here for our first valentines together. He said it is named after the two owners grandmothers. The service was amazing. The servers take really great care of you. The food was super tasty. We got oysters, gnocchi and scallops. We also tried the mozzarella bites and a salad, but I am forgetting the name. It was all really tasty. I sometimes dream about my food and the oysters will make an appearance for sure! The inside of the restaurant was comfortable and had great lighting. Sometimes places like that will be too dim, this one was just right. We were sat at a table that was half booth and half chair, but I like to have the boyfriend sitting next to me, so we turned the table sideways. Don't worry there was plenty of room for the other guests next to us. We also ordered some cocktails. He got the old fashioned and I got a mezcal, carrot and ginger cocktail. It was smokey and delightful. I said this is a juicer's dream! read more

See all

Definitely on the fancier side, they have a limited menu, and not a lot of vegetarian options. It's a cozy spot nestled a few blocks from Beale with great service and fresh food. You can tell a lot of time is spent on ensuring every bite is delicious and a blending of flavors. read more

Catherine and Mary's - Caprese - Italian Near Me - Memphis, Tennessee

See all

This was my first time at C and M! We had fantastic service all night, with our main waitress Marsia. We picked more of the classic options on the menu. They do have a rotating menu that adds seasonal changes to dishes, such as the Brussel sprouts. I would highly recommend trying multiple snacks and little plates. Each dish has unique flavors and fun twists on Italian cuisine. The creamy richness of the pastas and the melt in your mouth short rib was to die for. I loved the atmosphere of this restaurant! They played great music and had the lights dimmed for a more romantic feel. Definitely will be going back! read more

See all

Had a fantastic dinner tonight! The spring salad was one of the best salads I've had in awhile. Fresh, light and flavorful. The spinach agnolotti pasta was perfectly Al dente and delicious. The crudo and carpaccio were good with new interesting flavors. The cornbread was spicy read more

Catherine and Mary's - SPINACH AGNOLOTTI beef genovese, pomodoro sugo, ricotta salata - Italian Near Me - Memphis, Tennessee

Nice atmosphere/vibe. I love the building and the art. It was sorta moody, but not pretentious. Very loud, but not in an obnoxious way. Service was good. Gentleman serving us was very knowledgeable about the menu and make great recommendations. Nice Italian wine options. Good selection of dishes. We loved the fried mozzarella. (The red sauce with it was extra yum, and our server brought some pan seared bread out to dip in the left over sauce.) My agnolotti was delicious, but a rather small portion. Since I also got a salad, it was just enough. My colleagues dishes looked great too! Overall, solid choice for dinner. read more

Love the vibe of this place SO much. It's my go to, for taking out of town guests. We even had my husbands Christmas office party here and it was so impressive...one of the husbands attending the party decided to move HIS office party there. The menu can be a little confusing in the beginning, but once you figure that out, you are golden. read more

Date night landed my husband and I trying Catherine & Mary's FINALLY. We had reservations on a Friday night around 6, and were able to find street parking (though they offer complimentary valet). The ambiance is a mixture of beautiful and charming, yet sophisticated. It was pretty full when we arrived and when we left which was a good sign for business. We started with the cornbread. It had good flavor overall, but be warned that it has a small bite to it. If you're spice sensitive like me, it won't be your favorite. I got the AGNOLOTTI del PLIN for dinner which was a smaller plate of pasta (totally fine as it is dense and meant to be eaten with other things). You could definitely tell the pasta was homemade. It was good, but wasn't my favorite. Very mild in flavor. I'd likely get something else next time that has more of a sauce. My husband got the short rib and it was very good and full of flavor. The celery root risotto is different and refreshing. The star of the show was dessert. It was some kind of sticky toffee pudding with gelato. Possibly one of the best desserts I've ever eaten. I'd love to go back and try something else and for the dessert alone. read more

Best Italian I've ever had! And we've been to Italy. The staff knows the food and wine well. Don't be afraid to try new grapes or blends. read more

Catherine and Mary's - Italian Near Me - Memphis, Tennessee

Food was mediocre, but the service was awful. Nice guy, but he really couldn't explain the menu items to us, instead just regurgitating how the menu was written. The food runners consistently messed up who had which meal and the server mixed up the bill. Love the ambience, but that's about it. I'll go somewhere else next time. read more

Saw this place on a lot of lists for the top foods in Memphis while planning a vacation, so we made a reservation. It did not disappoint! Amazing food and great atmosphere! The first thing to know (which our server advised us) is that the menu is designed to share smaller plates. I took that as a challenge to eat all four courses, and I would not recommend that, because it is SO MUCH food! We had fried mozzarella as a "snack" and it was fantastic. We then had the meatballs, and honestly that would have been a super filling meal so far, but push on we did. Next course we shared both the Carbonara and the Rigatoni. Both were so good, pasta made in house with sauces that were some of the best I've had. Then on to the entrees. By this time we wised up and only ordered one, the veal cutlet. I wish I could adequately describe how delicious it was, but by this time I was so full it hurt to keep eating, but I did not want to stop. Finally we threw in the towel and got a box. The only complaint I have is that it took a long time between when we were finished eating and when our server came back. In fairness, they may have just been giving us time to enjoy the meal but compared to the very fast and attentive service earlier in the meal, it seemed like a long wait. Not a big deal overall, because the experience was absolutely amazing. read more

First of all the service was excellent! Our server James did a great job! The vibe and ambiance of this place was cool! The food however was just okay for us. The portions for some of the food were too small! The cornbread was dry and tasted old. The ricotta was amazing. The little gem salad was good. My husband had fried mozzarella and liked it. I wasn't a fan but the sauce it came with was really good. I ordered Ridiatore "Cacio e Pepe" and my husband ordered Tagliatelle "Bolgenese". Both were good. For some reason my noodles tasted a little rubbery. I've never had noodle with that texture. We enjoyed our experience overall and would consider coming back. The portions should be a bit bigger and the bread should be amazing because it sets the tone for the meal and it wasn't. read more

See all

Yes yes yes! Could this place be any more adorable? A restaurant named after 2 Italian grandmas? I can't. It's the coolest. The whipped feta cornbread, osso buco, the pasta, the little gem ceasar, the drinks! The wait staff!! I hope everyone discovers and keeps coming back to this jewel! read more

Janias was the best server! The lamb was a small portion but amazing! We also got old fashions and an espresso martini. 10/10 read more

Catherine and Mary's - Italian Near Me - Memphis, Tennessee