I would give this a 4.5 rating if Yelp allowed me. Not sure what all the crazy negative reviews are about. We had a fantastic time at this restaurant and the food was amazing. I totally dig the no phones thing. Food was amazing. We had the meatballs (not on the menu), whatever salad they were featuring (it changes), rigatoni, and the veal parmesean. All great! Our meal also came with complimentary sparkling wine to start, Parmesan and I think prosciutto, and limoncello. Yes, it's expensive but I don't necessarily think it's crazy overpriced. The Finer things in life cost more. The reason why I'm taking half a star out is because our cocktails weren't as good as they could be. My martini was not shaken enough and wasn't cold enough even after asking for it extra extra cold. My fiancé's old fashioned was too sweet the first time and then just right the second. If I'm paying this much I expect the cocktails to be perfect every time. The location confuses me as well since you got men in suits and then parties of women coming to dine in cowboy boots... the parking situation on the weekend is horrendous. Tim Love should build a parking structure in the stockyards next! read more

I came here for my fiancé's bday tonight. Overall experience and ambience was really good until the main course (I had the Lobster Alison) and it came out almost completely raw! My server was nice but the management blatantly refused a refund for an almost completely raw dish. I would've considered coming back but after that experience and being charged $70 for an uncooked meal! Absolutely absurd!! Experience wasn't a good end to what was supposed to be a very special occasion with my fiancé turned sour. I even requested a cake for her on my reservation and never received it! read more

I rarely ever send food back, but I had to send back two dishes and canceled our orders and went to another restaurant to have dinner. Our waitress recommended the meat balls so we ordered that as appertizer. OMG, the marina sauce was extremely salty. I could not even taste the tomato. I could only taste the salt. My tongue literally was stunted. I sent it back and ordered the fried zucchini to replace the meat balls. This dish was even saltier. I asked the waitress to taste it. The look on her face concurred with us that it was extremely salty and inedible. Had no idea what happened in that kitchen, but someone must have spilled salt into the marinara sauce and the batter for the zucchini. I asked for the bill to pay for the complementary prosecco charcuterie but the manager said we didn't need to. I left a tip for our waitress as she provided good service. I rated this dining experience with another star for the service. I am now terrified to give this restaurant another try. My tongue couldn't taste anything for a few hours. read more

We had just finished eating at another chef Love establishment (across the street from here. Had our Togo bag with us, even, if that matters) but walking to our car our daughters saw the ice cream place next to this establishment. This Place was closed, it had been closed for 52 min! We decided to sit at one of their outdoor tables while we waited for our daughters to get ice cream next door. A man that speaks English with an accent came out and ran us off. Asked if we wanted a table knowing full well they've been closed and just spoke to us like we were idiots. So freaking rudely! Will definitely think about spending our money out here next time. This is why us locals DO NOT want or support this type of development. The neighborly aspect and just plain humanity gets sucked out of places like our lovely stockyards. read more

I am not one to leave a low review, so this is something that is a little uncomfortable for me. However, my experience here needed to be shared as I was utterly embarrassed, and I feel they should be aware. I was visiting from out of town about two weeks ago, and haven't been to the area for about ten years. After having dinner elsewhere, I decided to try Caterina's because it looked like a nice place to have one drink before going back to the hotel to bed. Full disclosure, I was by myself as my date had cancelled earlier that evening and I was trying to still enjoy my night out. I had done no research on this restaurant prior to me coming in. When I arrived, the bar had one seat in the middle of two couples. I asked the bartender if anyone was seated there, and she told me it was empty. Once I sat down, I immediately ordered without looking at a menu. As stated before, I had done zero research, so I was completely unaware of the no-phone policy, and did not notice any sign anywhere once I was seated, nor had anyone said anything. My drink comes and I take a sip; it was delicious. Since I was by myself, and was not waiting for anyone, I had my phone out to read from my Kindle app. It is the usual thing I do if I am dining/drinking by myself. The couples next to me were enjoying their evening together and not talking to me, and I'm not one to interject into conversation unless invited. That's when the manager comes up to say hello and ask how I was. After exchanging pleasantries, he then informs me of the "no phone" policy. He tells me he has to "unfortunately take my phone and lock it up." This immediately threw me off, and the way it was presented had everyone at the bar now focused on me. I felt embarrassed and without thinking, just handed him my phone for him to put in a pouch that I didn't realize locked. Once he walks away, the bar tender tries to hand me a menu just in case I "wanted some reading material." When I said no, she walked away from the bar. So now, not only have the other people at the bar gone back to their conversations, but the person behind the bar is gone along with her manager. I was alone. I don't want to ramble on more than I have, so I'm going to end with this. I completely understand that the policy is "no phone," and I definitely respect that. As a business, that is the right of the owner to have that policy. When it comes to customer service however, something needs to change. I was at a restaurant, not a performance. I was by myself, and not waiting for anyone. I needed to be informed before I ordered my $20 drink about the policy, so that way I had a choice to stay or not. Instead, I was embarrassed and honestly, felt public shamed, over a policy I was unaware of. On top of it, was then left alone with no one to talk to for some time. It felt like being back in elementary school sitting out of recess while everyone else played. As a suggestion, I recommend not only informing people of the policy right away, but also giving them a chance to follow the policy once informed. I would've put the phone away if the choice was given. But taking it and locking it up once I was obligated to stay made me feel like a child. It was embarrassing. Ultimately, after a few minutes of sitting alone and trying to compose myself, I decided to leave. I paid $25 (added tip) for my drink that was barely touched and went to get my phone out of the pouch. Unfortunately, I had to go back up to the manager who originally embarrassed me to retrieve my property back, which just added another layer to this awful experience. I hate writing this because I love the chef of this restaurant and the policy itself wasn't my issue, it was the execution. Honestly, it'll take a lot for me to come back if I ever choose to, as well as recommend this place to anyone. read more

The manager found a table after I messed up my Drover reservation. He was very sweet and it was a Saturday night. Our waitress Michelle was excellent. The food was AMAZING.. It is unusually prepared but to me was flawless. We had the porkchop which was enough for 2 and the huge Caesar. The atmosphere is very sultry and is a good escape from the street activity. The meatballs were the best I have ever had .. and I am Italian! Overall a wonderful night at Caterinas. read more

We had our anniversary dinner there tonight .it was a very poor choice.ALL HAT AND NO CATTLE. The staff was very indulged and the food was very disappointing. Would I go back....Never read more

Wow!!! Amazing!!! Admittedly I read the reviews ahead of time. And I was worried as some reviews were trying to keep me from going this wonderful restaurant. I am amazed at the level of culinary indulgence my wife and I shared here. A beautiful 3-hour dining experience that was gracious, delicious and inspired. The flavors explode and the textures inviting more. Fortunately the portions are perfect for sharing (and encouraged). Staff was impeccable. We will be back and bring both in-town guests and out of town guests. A gem! The naysayers are either ignorant, tyrannical or just plain stupid. read more

Let me start by saying the Prosecco and charcuterie was the best thing we ate. Oh the piece of bread was delicious. The beef carpaccio was good. The Araceli was ok, the sauce was way too salty. The gnocchi soup was extremely salty and tomatoey and had 2 Lima bean sized gnocchi in it. The Caesar salad was presented nicely, however flavorless. Onto the pasta the rigatoni was way too salty, I think my tongue is still stuck to the top of my mouth. The bucatini was good, however in my head I heard my mom say "twirl the pasta with your fork and spoon"... no spoon provided. The branzino was overly salted and that is all you could taste since the fish was paper thin. On to what we hoped would be the star... the veal chop Parmesan was a huge disappointment, $61 and the meat was mushy not tender.., kind of like a frozen piece of meat would be, the sauce may have been the same red sauce as the Araceli. The wine was very good, however the waiter did not notice empty glasses and did not pour more, although we handled that! We were there for a birthday and the waiter was reminded of this several times and no special recognition! The atmosphere was fantastic! However I guess they dropped the jacket requirement for men... that is too bad as it is always nice to see people dressed for dinner. read more

good food, great service, went there for our 30th anniversary. When I made the reservation I chose the option on Open Table for flowers on the table. There were no flowers. Waiter asked if we were there for any occasion, which we replied, and it was never mentioned again. Great restaurants Great restaurants pay attention to details, just like great 5 star hotel. 11/12/2022 read more

The food at Caterina's is the best food I've ever had! I've been to places in Dallas and I've been to places all over the country but the food was just so good .... the prices match the quality so keep that in mind. There is a no phone policy but I've always walked in and they let us know right away and they give us a pouch to lock up our phone. I do hate that we can't take pictures of our food because I really love taking pictures of the food and I really love the food but that's not something that's gonna stop me from eating there. Customer service is second to none. The vibe is very upscale. Gentleman must wear coats but if you don't have one they have some there that you can wear. This is my go to special occasion place. The food is amazing. read more

service was great. we did get our bread at the end of the dinner but. as for the food. it was less then desirable. honestly the food was no better then Olive Garden. read more

Outstanding dinner! We went to Catalina's as a party of 10 and sat in the private room. Everything we ate and drank was fantastic! The service was incredible and we loved everything. The rigatoni, meatballs, Caesar salad, Wagyu steak, etc were all incredible. We had such a great time! Loved it all!!!!! We are definitely coming back! Thank you for making our evening special and one we will all not forget! read more

Place is way over priced. Definitely better spots in Fort Worth for way less! Also they are trying too hard to be something they are not!

I agree with the less than stellar reviews this place has been given. The food was mediocre at best. One of our pasta dishes was so salty, it was inedible. Everything came out hot - ish. The service started out ok, but then we had to ask where our waiter was just to order appetizers. Totally not worth the hype or the money. If you're going to require men to wear jackets and take cell phones away in addition to charging high end prices, things should be impeccable. Not impressed at all and would not recommend. You're better off getting wings and beers at Second Rodeo - right across the street and they never disappoint. read more

Wow, I wanted to ask for a refund! We went here for our wedding anniversary and were incredibly disappointed. This place did not hold up to all the hype, plus the food was terrible especially for the price that you pay. You could tell the ingredients were low quality, our lobster was over cooked, the pasta was way too spicy. We will not be back here. Save your time and your money! read more

Tonight was our second time dining here, and the experience tonight was vastly different than the first. Very understaffed (extremely slow service) and not so great food (overcooked pasta, WAY overcooked lobster). Some dishes had great flavor (beef carpaccio) but others (lobster Alison) definitely missed the mark. read more

Caterina's blew my husband and me away! My husband and I love trying locally owned spots, but I haven't been awed by TIm Love's other restaurants... the quality just hasn't measured up, in my book. But this place is 10/10. Atmosphere: We went for our wedding anniversary, so my husband had his own jacket... and we'd read ahead, so we were prepared (and delighted, TBH) to relinquish our cell phones. This is a place made for intimate conversation. Dark wood, elegant fixtures. It was clubby glam. Service: Solicitous but not overbearing at all. My water glass was never less than half-full, but we weren't interrupted mid-conversation, either. Our waiter, Milos from Serbia, has amazing recommendations. We both appreciated that he recommended a four-course experience but, as opposed to trying to upsell us, suggested splitting the first three courses. Food: Wow. Just wow. We were served complimentary Prosecco, parm and prosciutto when we were seated. Then there was a complimentary mini-bread service. We split the meatballs - off-menu - to start. They were tender, juicy, and spicy... also a tad bit salty toward the end, but I'll take salty over bland any day. Next, we split a Caesar. Very generous helping. Wasn't the world's best Caesar, but I'd definitely order it again. The pasta... oh the pasta. We shared the linguine with clams, and it was ethereal. Really, really great. A little bit briny, a little bit buttery, just perfect. I enjoy sampling the whole menu (vs. my husband, who orders the same thing over and over and over at places), but I'd be hard pressed not to order this again. For entrees, my husband had the branzino. I didn't try it because I'm just not a fish person (and yes, I like clams), but he said it was flaky and he loved the herb sauce with it. I had the rabbit. It was crazy good. Spicy, sweet, sour... wow. I find rabbit meat itself to be a little blank canvas - kind of like very skinny chicken legs - but the prep was absolutely killer. Value: It's not cheap, and it's worth every penny. There are things here that you just won't find elsewhere in Fort Worth. Highly recommend! read more

This Tim Love restaurant opened fairly recently in the Fort Worth Stockyards and four of us chose to visit for an early dinner. We had checked their web site that afternoon, just to find out that a jacket was required for the men---lucky we went online. We apparently were the first ones at the restaurant and were told that use of cell phones were not allowed, that we would have to turn them completely off. They then took the phones, put them into a pouch that was then locked. To our surprise the food was very mediocre and service was only adequate. However, the most annoying fact was that when we received our credit card statement, we saw that the restaurant had increased the amount of the total bill. Did they not care for the amount of tip we left? I view this as unethical if not illegal. read more

This was a great experience! We were greeted as soon as we entered. After putting our phones in a bag, we were shown to our table. The server came right over. Kristen was great! She brought a bubbly rosé over to start and a drink menu. My daughter ordered a martini and I a Negroni. We were both given a small bite to go with our drinks, hers was a housemaid potato chip with crème fraîche and caviar. For mine, she brought over a housemaid chip with braised rabbit. She then brought a piece of Parmesan cheese and prosciutto for each of us. Then she brought over bread and olive oil. We then placed our order. We ordered fried zucchini, thin strips, lightly battered with the sauce on the side, very good. Next came the caprese salad a mixture of tomatoes, cut into bite-size pieces with some mozzarella balls with the balsamic vinegar on the top. Also very good. Then came the bucatini, perfect! The main dish was the grilled shrimp, with a side of mushrooms. Those were the largest shrimp I had ever seen great meal! Great service! A truly excellent evening! read more

TIM LOVE GO TO YOUR RESTAURANT AND SEE HOW BAD THIS IS... YOU SHOULD BE ASHAMED TO HAVE YOUR NAME ON THIS, YOU HAVE LOST TOUCH ON YOUR RESTAURANT....The reason they won't let you have your phones is so you cannot take a picture of how bad the food is from presentation to taste....I wish I could rate a 0. Please do not waste your time or money here. I was here Saturday night with a party of 7, 8:15 reservation , we were so excited for this dinner. I love Italian and loved the idea of no phones and fine dining. Starting out with a sport coat required for men (which is so rare any more) I expected true fine dining. We walked in and were seated fairly quickly. Everything went downhill from there. Once seated we were then brought complimentary prosecco ( was fine but 1/2 of us just wanted a cocktail) We did not get someone to take a drink order for another 45 minutes. So it was 9pm before we got a drink.... Still no mention of food. My daughter had to get up after 40 minutes and get us menus because no one ever brought one. .. Finally the waitress came back and "explained" the menu starting we had to put in our full order at the same time, we could not get any food until we had decided on our entire meal start to finish and the restaurant would pace how food came out.. We were all literally starving at this point not even bread on the table. The waitress explained we should all each order antipasti, salad, pasta and an entree. That that was how the meal was designed, just felt like an upsell. Never told us about the food or specials, recommendations nothing. Just basically wanted us to order. After placing order it was another 30 minutes until first round of antipasti came out. We tried about 5 different starters nothing impressive, basically could have been any chain italian restaurant then salad came 30 minutes after that. so we were literally at 10:30 still no entree. We did chop salad and ceasar both again chain Italian taste just bland. During this time the waitress would disappear for 15-20 minutes at a time no asking to freshen drinks, I had to ask for wine list and she brought and walked away. So at this point still no entree. so around 10:45 the entrees came out food was freezing cold. 5 of 7 had to be remade. If it wasn't 10:45pm we would have walked out . They remade food... was below average but at this point we were just so hungry. ... There is so much more I could say about the lack of fine dining, but just don't go. Don't do it. It was such a disappointment. They are there for gimick, wearing the jacket, putting phones away, etc... I have never written a review in my life but this was so bad that i felt I had to. I am from Newport Beach, CA and the people we were with are from Seattle , WA we were visiting our daughters at TCU. read more

Our group of 5 went to this restaurant for the first time . I understand why they lock up your phone when you arrive , to enjoy the entire experience. However, I am a mom with daughters away at school on different time zones and one in Europe so I want to be available. So as my phone, which was locked in a special pouch, vibrated with text messages in my purse , it actually made more nervous wondering what I was missing . I feel that they could suggest you put your phones in a basket in the middle of the table and enjoy the experience versus being forced . Service was good, cocktails were excellent, bottle of wine was excellent , food presentation was excellent, food was very good . Rigatoni was a bit too spicy but we shared other pastas that were very good . We were trying to divide up the bill , no calculator as it's in our locked phone , tried to take a picture of wine bottle , could not as our phone was locked up . Would be 5 stars but did not like the forced locked phone. read more

Very Good Service, The Food it's very good and the ingredients are the top of quality. Great Wine selection.

Won't be back so long as they continue to lock up all customer mobile phones in a case that only they can open. Big brother like. They said it is because they want their guests talking and visiting and not using their phones. That is their desired behavior control and maybe not what the customers want. There is no honor system here, like some private clubs who ask you not to use your phones and you don't. This is forced on the customers. And, not even effective for those with Apple watches. Food was good and waiter was great. Seating was very crowded downstairs and the banco is sunken and too low for comfort. We would have walked out at the outset but they had a required deposit in advance. read more

Dining out should be a memorable experience. Part of keeping the memories is photographs of the event! The food was okay, not great, the service was excellent, it gets 1 star for them getting pissed off because we asked for photo of us at our table! Dumb ass rule. Tim needs to re-think. We won't be back, and we'll discourage anyone from going! EVER! Plus, they don't offer regular coffee for an after dinner drink, only espresso! Come on Tim! read more

We had a phenomenal experience. Colton was a great server and had excellent recommendations & made the experience so enjoyable. The food was phenomenal. Everything had great flavor from the wines to the appetizers, entrees, & desserts. It can get pricey, but the experience and ambiance make it so worth it! Definitely a different and more upscale Tim Love experience than all of his other restaurants. read more

Our dining experience and server were great; but for the price, the food left a lot to be desired. We had scallops, beef carpaccio, meatballs, Cacio e Pepe, rigatoni, veal parm, pork chop piccata and shrimp scampi. Food is just okay. Overall disappointing and definitely not worth the hype. Glad we tried it, but would not return. For the same or better experience and better food-- just go to Carbone. Also feel the need to mention that there is also only 1 restroom for the entire restaurant which was...interesting. read more

Absolutely incredible food and service. We had the meatball appetizer, rigatoni, and pork chop. The service was impeccable, and each dish was prepared perfectly. Loved it and can't wait to go back! read more

We went for my birthday and it was just exquisite and that is not a word I use. Our waitress was so sweet and helpful and just amazing. The food was very good. The hospitality is above what you normally find in Fort Worth - and I've lived and dined here forever. Think Carriage House level hospitality and you're there. The bygone days of customer service. The Negroni cocktail to start was the best I've ever had and made table side. I wanted to see what Tim Love would do with basic fried zucchini and it was delicious. The caprese salad was good. The salt and pepper pasta was good - too Al dente for me but that's me. The lobster Alison was the highlight. OMG. So good. I do not eat veal but our host did and the piece was so big that he took over half home. Get the Negroni and the lobster. My highlights. No one will have a picture to post because they put your phone in a little sleeve - they will take your Polaroid for a souvenir!! read more