Was in the area for a little hike and wanted seafood for a late lunch. It's a cozy restaurant on…read morethe main strip in Patchogue. About 10 people there when we walked in about 2 pm. Mike the bartender, waiter, bus boy - do it all was great. Helped with the beer, oysters and calamari selection. Everything was on point. There are probably lines down the block during the peak season. Must do if you're in town!

What a great little restaurant! Others have described it as a hidden gem and I can see why. The…read morecoastal decor is very welcoming and comfortable; there are a number of standalone tables and plenty of seats at the bar, which was crowded when we arrived Our waitress, Janine, was a sweetheart - super friendly and very knowledgeable about the menu. She made great recommendations on the oysters from the menu. We opted for Fire Island Blues and Lucky 13. They were both delicious and super, super fresh. I have to say out of all the food we ate, the oysters were our favorite. We also ordered the baked clams, sesame crusted tuna, and fried calamari . We thoroughly enjoyed the meal and I can't wait to get back for more of those fresh oysters and delicious and tasty baked clams. If you haven't checked out this place yet, give it a try, you won't be disappointed.

We thoroughly enjoyed our meal here. They are known for their lobster rolls and they offer hot…read morelobster in butter or cold lobster with a tarragon mayonnaise. We both had the hot lobster roll and it was delicious. We also enjoyed an appetizer of steamers which were cooked to perfection. Our waitress was very nice, knowledgeable and accommodating and the ambience was perfect for a fish market with outdoor seating right on the marina. I can't wait to bring my family back here and other friends as well.

An awful location. No parking. Caters to commercial customers, not the general public.read more

Best seafood around. Always fresh and cooked to perfection. You HAVE to have the lobster rolls!read more

The food was absolutely amazing! I ordered the Original Sayville Lobster Sandwich, and they were…read morevery generous with the fresh lobster. Even the pickle was delicious! The seasoned fries were so good, I didn't even need ketchup. The staff and other customers were all super friendly, which made the experience even better. It was about $30, and worth every penny. I loved the outdoor dining--it gave off total vacation vibes. Inside has that true seafood market aroma since they also sell a wide variety of fresh fish to cook at home. Will definitely be back!

The shrimp was amazing And the Cedar Planked Salmon was…read moredelish. Please add more potatoes to your Clam Chowder otherwise it would have been chefs kiss. No pics I was hungry

Extremely disappointing experience. The service was painfully slow and the staff came across as…read morevery impersonal. It took almost 30 minutes just to have our order taken, another 30 minutes for soup, another 30 minutes for the calamari appetizer, and yet another 30 minutes for our main dish, which was just a lobster roll. What should have been a simple meal turned into an unnecessarily long and frustrating wait. What made it worse was that our waitress didn't seem apologetic at all about how long everything was taking. In fact, she appeared much more attentive to the table next to us, who she seemed to know personally, while we were left waiting most of the time. To add to that, the water we asked for never even arrived. The experience ended on an uncomfortable note when we went to pay. Our card was flagged for possible fraud (likely because we're not from the area). While my husband was already pulling out cash to pay, a man wearing a beanie and chef jacket stood there in a pushy manner insisting we call the bank immediately while he waited. Between the extremely slow service, lack of attentiveness, and the uncomfortable payment interaction, the entire experience was frustrating from start to finish. Save yourself the trip and the time -- we should have listened to the reviews before making the drive.

Grabbed some drinks and food from Lily's after a day of boating at Silly Lily's Fishing Station…read more It's honestly impressive what they can do cocktail wise at this place from what looks like a tiny kiosk/kitchen/bar that you order from, but somehow they make it work. Service was prompt, we got our food and drinks mere minutes after placing our order. My two friends got the shrimp salad which they said hit the spot, and I split a steak sandwich with my other friend since we had dinner reservations coming up later that night. I'd definitely come back here for a quick bite especially when the weather is nice. It's an off the beaten path location in I guess what's considered the not so hip part of the Hamptons but whatever, when something's good it's good.

I saw an instagram pic of the adorable yellow/white tables and umbrellas along with the boats and I…read moreknew I had to make a trip out here to check it out. It didn't disappoint. So many boats, lounge chairs, picnic tables, and you can even sit at or in the boats while you enjoy your drink, food, and the views. The service was great. You can take the menu to view and you order at the bar. The young woman taking our order was friendly, made suggestions, and chatted with us while we ordered. On Thursdays, they offer free boat rides which we didn't take but it was really nice that the option was there. It looked nice and calming out on the water and they had life vests for everyone. We saw a few families out on the boat rides and it looked like a cool addition to the evening. We ordered the Hey There, Sailor ( rum punch). It was delicious. Sweet and strong. We shared the crabby fries, which was good. My friends and I agreed that it would have been even better if the crab and the sauce (Or some other binding agent) were more incorporated but the fries were crispy and hot. I ordered the shrimp roll which came with chips which was pretty good and a nice size. I liked the picnic style tables and the overall vibe. It was like sitting in a friend/family members yard on the water and just relaxing with good food and drinks.

Really great spot, I came here years ago with my wife when it was another place, but wasn't as good…read moreas whales tale! Came here with my wife and father in law a few weeks ago and the food and service was solid. Came on slow day so we pretty much had the whole place to ourselves, but I really enjoyed the food. Fathers in law got the poke tuna nachos and it was very good! Not the biggest tuna person but the flavor was excellent! My wife got bang bang shrimp with fries and the shrimp was very good! Shrimp was cut into small pieces and wasn't overly covered with sauce. Shrimp had great flavor and the French fries were very good. I got a steak bowl that came with rice, beans, avocado, sweet plantain, and a nice veggie slaw. The bowl was very good and the steak was pounded out and just very good. The bartender Tara & her sister were great! I would definitely recommend this place if you're looking for a new place to try. The food and service were great. Look forward to trying other things off the menu

Cuisine: 4 Service: 3…read moreDecor: 7 Value: 5 Overall: 4 This is the restaurant that now operates out of the former space of Finn & Forks. Unfortunately, the food is no longer seafood-centric and overall not nearly as good. Music was loud and the service was very lacking. Honestly, other than the frozen tasting mussels, nothing was necessarily bad. The smoky Chicken Quesadilla and Ahi Tuna Street Bowl were even decent. However, majority of everything else was just average at best and not memorable. To top it off, the prices are relatively high for what we received and the service was subpar. No one came to pour us water or take an order after we sat down for 20 minutes. Then a few different servers came by with our food. No refills on our water or check on our status. Next time we saw our server was when she came by to give us the check. Didn't even asked if we wanted dessert. Oh well, we will not be back.

Stopped at Castaway for a midday snack. Oysters were fresh and a good size. Even my friend who…read moredoesn't particular enjoy seafood thought they were delicious. We also got the wings and parmesan fries. The BBQ wings were good--saucy and not too small. Fries were just meh. They're just fries and a good shareable but nothing special. The staff is so sweet and accommodating. My friends and I were here a few years back and sat at the corner table outside. Our waitress didn't hesitate to prep the table for us when we requested to sit there again. When I was here a few years back, they had nachos and they were probably the best I've ever had. Been thinking about them ever since. Petition to bring the nachos back!

No wait for a table, Service was exceptional, food came out fairly quickly, I would give it 7 out…read moreof 10.

Our waitress, Jackie was amazing. She explained the dishes very well. She was also knowledgeable…read moreabout their wine list which I appreciate. The food was delicious - I love lobster but don't like to work to get it out of the shell. The entree lobster was served out of the shell and it was divine. Ambiance was unmatched as you might be able to see from my pictures. Additionally amenities worth mentioning: heated lamps for outdoor dining, live music on Sat night (when I was there) and valet parking. What else can a girl ask for?

We booked a reservation well in advance for a party of 10. While we were seated promptly and served…read moreinitial drinks, the service completely broke down after that. We waited an hour and a half, and our food never arrived. It felt as though our order was entirely forgotten. The staff never proactively communicated with us about the extreme delay. We had to go out of our way to chase them down just to get an update. Even then, they repeatedly assured us the food was "right on its way," but it never came. We ultimately had to leave without ever being served our food. Extremely disappointed with the complete lack of organization, communication, and basic customer service.

Another phenomenal experience dining here!!! The portions are out of this world. Came here between…read morelunch and dinner and decided on the dinner menu. I had a caesar salad with lobster which was so delicious. The lobster was already shelled out so no need to worry about cracking lobster! Tasted so fresh and hit the spot. My husband got a burger and fries and no complaints there. Me and my daughter tried the fries and they were so good. My daughter inhaled her fried calamari either the cocktail sauce. Nice presentation too. I got an Arnold palmer and it was pinkish due to the pink lemonade. I am not a fan of their pink lemonade and feel regular lemonade would taste fresher and better. The service here was so on point again. Please give your Tinker Bell waitress a raise she was so great with us! I don't know her name but she was adorable and very accommodating to our table. Explained what they were out of and knew the dish well when I asked if the eggplant with the penne alla vodka was breaded. It was breaded by the way and eas delicious. It was nicely cut thin and came with this sourdough bread that was toasted and spiced so good. Not sure what the spice was but it was a warm toasty flavor. I noticed the waitress was doing a lot of work the restaurant was pretty full and she was the only waitress we saw there. Excellent job she does keeping up. If I could have left her a bigger tip I would have. I think the restaurant needs at least another waiter or waitress because of how crowded it can get. I would dine here again if I am on the island again. It's great for families and get togethers!

Had cocktails here. The bartender 'Jonathan' was super polite and helpful. We went back for a meal…read moresince the menu looked amazing but they were out of a lot of the menu items. Food was okay but expected more. Maybe we caught an off time but would try again since it had a good vibe and location.

Excellent meal and excellent restaurant. Decor was great. Service was excellent. Definitely try it.read more

Ambiance- fabulous from the time you arrive until you leave. Intimate and cozy…read more Service- outstanding Food- exceptional. Once again the food and cocktails were great!The baby lamb chops must be experienced. The salmon. Was delicious ass as was the filet.