First time. I had the Gollo Burro #1 and it was pretty tasty. Waitress was great. Definitely will try again. read more

Casa Reynoso - Menu - Mexican Near Me - Tempe, Arizona

See all

I will start by saying I genuinely like the food here. I am from the Globe-Miami area and this reminds me of home. With that said, the prices have become unreasonable for the portion sizes. I placed an order to go today for 1 regular burro (red chili and beans), 2 bean and cheese burros, and a large rice and beans. The total out the door was $33.73 including tax and their credit card fee. The burros were a bit smaller than the last time I was there and the "large" rice and beans were embarrassingly lacking. It equated to 1/2 cup of beans and 3/4 cup of rice (see photos). The containers were 2.75 inches by 7 inches as a reference. You can see in the side photo that there was less than half an inch of beans in the bottom of this "large" container. read more

Casa Reynoso - 3 burros and "large rice and beans" - Mexican Near Me - Tempe, Arizona

See all

We came by for lunch on a weekday & were seated right away. Chips, salsa & a menu came right to the table & among other items we ordered the Gollo Burro and a Chile Relleno. The Gollo Burro delivers great on taste but is weak in value -- it could be bigger for the price paid. In a proper meal we'd want two of what we got. The relleno was a bit of a disappointment, with the chile not sufficiently roasted for a smooth mouthfeel. Rice & beans were serviceable as was the table salsa. The dining room was comfortable, though our table seemed a few inches taller than necessary. Service was on point throughout. Pay cash to avoid a 3% card fee. We'll give Casa Reynoso's other dishes a try sometime soon, but the prices will surely keep us from awarding a top rating. read more

In my quest to try new restaurants in the area, Yelp reviews led me to Casa Reynoso, as did some Instagram reels. The hype was pretty heavy and I needed to see what the excitement was about. Sadly, I was disappointed. It's rare when a top rated place on Yelp lets me down, but this was one of those times. The location was fine, and it was relatively crowded for a late evening. I was seated promptly and had plenty of time to look at what others were eating even though I knew my first order would be a burrito which is my go-to test meal. The chips and salsa were good. The salsa was a bit bland, but great consistency and the chips were fresh. I don't know if they make them or not, but they were fine. The burrito was good but not great. I'm not even sure I remember enough about it to give much detail because it simply didn't stand out. Please note - most reviews commend on their specialty burrito made with green salsa and more so it's very very possible the specialty is what gets the great reviews. That wasn't my experience. The ambiance was nice, the server was great but in an area with literally hundreds of options, this just didn't make the cut for a frequent experience with me. read more

Casa Reynoso - July '26 - Mexican Near Me - Tempe, Arizona

See all

Social media had me. Loved the #8 plate cheese, enchilada, chili relleno, red chile burrito. Service was fast. Salsa spicy- chips little to done for my taste. The New upgrades are nice. Little laugh Had to ask the husband who is "Jake Plumber!" I'm now enlightened. read more

Casa Reynoso - #8 is GREAT. - Mexican Near Me - Tempe, Arizona

Came here for dinner on a weekend and it was pretty busy! We waited about 30 minutes (which is how long they said it would be) before being seated even though it looked like plenty of tables were open. I'm guessing they didn't have enough staff working? We were brought chips and salsa right away and it was amazing! A little spicy but not too bad I'm a pretty big baby with spicy stuff. Our server was friendly and the food came out very quickly. It wasn't the best Mexican food ever but it was good and the prices are reasonable. The inside was very nice and clean but there was trash and an abandoned shopping cart outside the entrance which was definitely a little off putting. read more

See all

The service here was amazing. Flavors are very good and the serving sizes are huge! It truly feels like you're enjoying a sitdown meal at a homemade restaurant, something that appears to be someone's house. It felt very cozy and comforting. Like you were eating a meal at a friend's house or a long lost relative. When it comes to the options of food, there is something for everyone. I really enjoyed the specialty platters that give you an option of enchilada, burrito, taco, or even Chile Rillenos. As of lately, there are a lot of people on the Internet, saying that this is the most authentic food in Tempe Arizona! As far as authenticity goes, the flavor is definitely there. I highly recommend stopping by and trying it for yourself! It's an awesome place to grab food with a friend or even family members. Be ready to eat! Or ask her to go back so you can enjoy the leftovers for later. The burritos are huge! Red chili and green chili both taste so good Located tucked away in the corner of southern and Mill, by the Fry grocery store. Their chips and salsa is complementary and it's also very good! read more

Casa Reynoso - Cheese crisp! And my brother Eli and dad Fred! - Mexican Near Me - Tempe, Arizona

If you like traditional Mexican food this is the place to go. The food, service, and decor is amazing. We all enjoyed our meals and definitely will be back. read more

See all

Ok the food was fine.. place fine .. my 1 critical note: they have a fee to use a card for payment.. fine.. but they conveniently had the sign covered.. by hats.... already had paid.. not the worst thing.. but what's with some random hats covering sign? ... read more

Food was great. However the wait for two plates of food was a little disappointing. We waited over 25- 30 minutes at our table for a bean burrito and plate of green chili. This was after a 20 minute wait to be seated. Needless to say I was quite hangry by the time we ate which made the food not as enjoyable. read more

Don't leave many reviews but had to for this one. Saw it on TikTok but we live quite a ways away. Happened to be out here so made it a point to stop by with the fam. Had the pleasure of being served by Gabriella and she's half the reason for this review. Very attentive and accommodating. The food as amazing as it was it was matched by the service. We'll definitely be back read more

Casa Reynoso - Deep fried ice cream and sopapillas - Mexican Near Me - Tempe, Arizona

See all

Was in the area and hungry. Noticed Casa Reynoso was near by. I ordered the chili Verde cheese crisp, and chili Verde plate with eggs. Yes, I had alot to take home with the amount of food that was ordered. And the food was good. Nothing spectacular though. The service was great and very friendly. Would I make a special trip to eat here again? No. But I would eat here again if I'm in the area. read more

Came here to celebrate my daughter's promotion for work by recommendation. We had an amazing experience. The food was authentic and had great flavor. The service was top notch. Yvette was our bar tender that made the best margarita and her son Andres was our waiter for dinner. We had a party of 8 and he made sure we had everything we needed. Drove from Gilbert and don't venture out too much, but I'm glad we did. Highly recommend visiting. read more

Came here for a work lunch a few weeks back. Had a good meal! Service was great, place was cozy. For food, I went with a #5 which was an enchilada, a taco and a red mixed burrito. Their combos come with the entrees alone, and you can upgrade with rice and beans. I just went with the entrees. Food was tasty! Great beef taco, cheesy enchilada, and a pretty solid knife and fork burrito. Everyone else enjoyed their food, too. I would come back if I were in Tempe looking for a sit down Mexican food place. read more

Casa Reynoso - Combo #5. Red mixed burrito, beef taco and cheese enchilada. Solid! - Mexican Near Me - Tempe, Arizona

My husband and I have been going to this fabulous restaurant for YEARS!! My husband introduced this restaurant to me in high school and said this was the best Mexican restaurant he's been to; his family has been going to this restaurant his entire life. The original one opened in Globe-Miami. I was skeptical at first because there are not many great restaurants with true Mexican food; my family is from New Mexico so I am completely biased and grew up eating my abuelas food. I am so glad that this restaurant did not disappoint! The staff is very welcoming and always greets everyone as well as treating everyone with respect. The quality of food has always been satisfactory and the restaurant itself gives off a true authentic atmosphere!! Our experiences are always pleasant and the service is very fast with fresh food. It is a family owned business and you can tell how much they love this restaurant! You should definitely have this restaurant on your list to go to! read more

See all

Food was very good and the service was great. If you are in the area we do recommend it.

After seeing a glowing YouTube review of this restaurant, I was itching to try it. I had their #5 Combo (mixed beef burrito, cheese enchilada and a beef crunchy taco). It was tasty but not exceptionally so. But what spoiled it for me was the Arnold Palmer I had with it. The lemonade was from a mix! Overall it was blah. They are no where near top drawer. read more

Place felt authentic, decorated with colors. Service was great, server was nice and helpful. The Corn Cheese Crisp was amazing! First time trying it and it was crispy, cheeses, and the green chile was soft --- definitely recommend for appetizer. The salsa had a little kick to it, which was perfect. The chips were good and crispy. I got the Charro Completo and so happy that I got the enchilada style cos I'm a sauce person and the green chile with cheese on top were perfect, made all the parts of the meal come together. read more

See all

Stopped in for lunch during the week. Joint was fairly crowded. Menu covers a lot of the familiar dishes. Service was fast and friendly. The strip center might need updating, but the restaurant itself has been updated. A clean, refreshed feel inside. I opted to a standard combination plate - enchilada, tostada, rice and beans. All were good, more than I could eat. The chips and salsa was good as well. The salsa is not spicy, but that was okay with me. In the area, worth a look. N*joy! read more

Was very good. We ordered take out and it was great. They are a popular place and the wait was a little long, but worth it! Will go again and eat in. read more

Food was excellent and Eyvette our server was great. Longer then normal wait for a Friday night however, would not have an issue waiting again. It was worth it. read more

Had the Gallo burrito it was good flavor, but It had no meat in it never again horrible experience

Briella at this location had the most wonderful customer experience and all servers and staff were so friendly. The food was delicious and the ambiance was second to none. Will recommend this restaurant as one of the best in the Phoenix area! Thank you Casa Reynoso!! read more

It was our first time in, Amazing service, amazing food!! It's very busy so expect a wait but it's totally worth it!! Family-owned restaurant, will definitely be back!! Wouldn't recommend it more!! read more

I ordered one red chile beef enchilada, one chicken enchilada with green sauce, and a side of beans and rice. The food was absolutely disgusting. The meat in both enchiladas tasted awful, and to make matters worse, the meat wasn't even inside the enchiladas. It was just thrown on top of the tortillas. Last time I checked, enchiladas are supposed to have the filling rolled inside them. The service was just as bad as the food. We waited about 40 minutes to just get our food, and it took forever for anyone to even come take our order. The restaurant wasn't busy enough to justify such terrible service. Once the food finally arrived, no one checked on us, offered refills, or asked if we needed anything. I honestly can't think of a single positive thing to say about the experience. Save your money, save your time, and eat literally anywhere else. read more

Great little spot. The food was really good, next time I'm in AZ will definitely go back.

This place felt so homie, absolutely loved the taste and great portions for a good price! Customer service was great too, will definitely come back. read more

Casa Reynoso - Chicken enchiladas - Mexican Near Me - Tempe, Arizona

Very disappointing. Definitely NOT the best Mexican food in the valley as seen on social media. The service was awful. Food was mediocre at best, very bland. Not authentic Mexican food. Paid extra for the rice and beans - they were better than the meal itself. 2 people - 2 basic cocktails at bar, 2 sodas at dinner, both had #1 (taco, tamale, and enchilada) added rice and beans $80. We paid cash, card would incur additional charge. read more

Love, love, love this restaurant. The food is so delicious with a wide variety of choices. The service we've received has always been exceptional. It's so enjoyable/comfortable to dine here because you can actually have conversations and not be distracted by loud music/noise. read more

I never had any problem with the service or the food always been excellent my biggest beef with this place is I wish they had a milder hot sauce and more handicap parking places other than that I would recommend this place wholeheartedly read more

I don't understand the hype around this place. I've given it multiple chances, but I always leave disappointed and wondering why it's so popular. The food never seems very fresh, and the flavors are bland and underwhelming. Unfortunately, it just hasn't lived up to the reputation for me. read more

Great location, great food and service. Chili relleno was awesome. This place never disappoints.

First time eating here and everything food wise was soooooo delicious!!! The margaritas were amazing and the beer was served nice and chilled (great when the weathers getting warmer out). Friendly staff, nice comfortable atmosphere, and amazing tasting food. We will definitely come back when we visit the area again. read more

Casa Reynoso - Machacha Chimichanga with enchilada sauce, rice and beans - Mexican Near Me - Tempe, Arizona

Great food, come here often 1/3 plate is my go to every time. Family loves all the other stuff. Cheesecrisp is great also.

Ordered the combo 10 that comes with a beef taco , enchilada and rice and beans for 14.20$ ! I thought the enchilada would have meat but it was just cheese. I'd get the red chile beef burro next time with rice and beans! The rice and beans were good along with the beef taco! Service was smooth and if you have the chance maybe ask them what's on their "secret menu" I know someone whose hometown food is this restaurant and they love it. The inside is nicely decorated and cool on this hot summer day . read more

See all

Went here as was craving real authentic Mexican food! This place did not disappoint. The salsa was AMAZING! It's spicy but then a hint of lime and cilantro to finish it off. The portion sizes are good for the cost! We had a great server who was very attentive and knowledgeable of the menu! The ambiance was very nice and welcoming, can be intimate depending on your party size ! read more

Casa Reynoso - 2 chicken tacos, combination dinner #9 & #10 - Mexican Near Me - Tempe, Arizona

. The waiting area could have used some cleaning and that almost made me turn back but the rest of the restaurant was clean. Food was good.

Really good authentic Mexican food. Service was great, waitress and hostess were super nice! 100% recommend if you want authentic Mexican food. read more

See all

I definitely recommend this restaurant, I had the red chile enchilada with rice and beans. The rice and beans were very good specifically and I'm already craving them again. I would definitely dine here again, everyone was friendly and the portion sizes are fair for the price. read more

Casa Reynoso - Chips and salsa - Mexican Near Me - Tempe, Arizona

See all

Great food burritos are the Goto for me, friendly attentive service with your topical I am having real Mexican food in America decor Will definitely repeat read more