We have been here 4 times now and not once have we been disappointed. The service is top notch, fast and friendly. It is obviously gaining a lot of attention, so do not be surprised if there is a wait. If there is a wait don't be discouraged, it's totally worth it. Everything is fresh and bright in flavor. This is our spot, we can't get enough! -Brad read more

See all

I love this place and will be coming back often! Oysters and Tacos who ever thought of this might be a genius or they know me very well. We were greeted with a lovely waitress who had plenty of recommendations upon request. We started with 3 types of oysters with 2 of them being from the local area. I then got the fish tacos which were extremely tasty. They also have a great beer and cocktail selection. 10/10 would recommend to anyone. read more

Month's back, I've heard about this place by watching a local news segment for Friday Flavors. If you're not aware of the backstory, it was a former gas station that was out of business for years until a couple (who are both trained chefs) turned it into a small restaurant that opened up a year ago. With many good reviews on Yelp, local coverage on both TV and in print and a Coastal Virginia award in its pocket, let's just say I had to try it out for myself to see if it lives up to the hype. Walking inside, you're immediately greeted by the hostess and in front of you are a display of spirits on the right side and a bar where you see the chefs whip up food in the back along with a few seats (probably seating between 30-40 people). Definitely a nice sight to make you feel welcomed. Once our party got seated, we ordered food after a few minutes. Most of us ordered tacos (with one person ordering hush puppies and chargrilled oysters which she really enjoyed) so I'll just break down my meal: -Oyster po-boy taco consisting of fried oysters, Napa cabbage, jalapeno, tomatillo salsa verde and remoulade. Talk about delicious!! From the crunch of the fried oysters to the tomatillo salsa, this one was a winner. Being from Louisiana, you would see fried oysters in a French baguette topped with lettuce tomatoes, mayo and cheese. But the soft taco replaced the baguette here and I'm a-OK with that!! I did taste a hint of lime even though I didn't squeeze any on my tacos, but it was probably the salsa. -Fried chicken taco consisting of fried chicken, pimento cheese slaw, B&B pickles and garlic aioli. I thought for a minute the oyster po-boy taco would be the winner here, but I was so mistaken. This one here was a complete home run. Kind of messy because of the slaw along with some spice (I believe this was Casa Pearl's own brand of hot sauce which you can find on every table), but so so good!!! Probably one of the best tacos I've ever eaten. Overall, this visit was a blast. Williamsburg truly has a hidden gem here. Come here if you can. You will not be disappointed. read more

See all

Searched on yelp for a place to dine alone. Group arriving tomorrow so I am excited to try this place. Must by a plate of 6 oysters so I couldn't do that and tacos. Dang but I understand. The pork was moist toppings flavorful and drips of their Casa Pearl hot sauce was perfect for heat. Wondering if they make their tortillas- they were great. Now th swordfish taco. Wow! The chimichurri was so good with the swordfish. Getting the key lime mousse to go. Too full for it now. Support this place it is a hidden gem! read more

Casa Pearl - Pork taco front / swordfish taco back. - Seafood Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

We've been here twice plus once for take out because my husband is a fan. The first time was my favorite, although I thought the halibut tasted kind of odd. Not that it wasn't fresh, I just didn't care for the seasoning on it. I loved my Asian salad the first time but the second time it fell flat. Not enough dressing maybe? The second time I got two fried oysters on top and they were delicious, so fresh, but again, the salad was bland...oh well. My husband likes the po boy tacos and the fish tacos. He doesn't think the mahi tastes weird so take your pick on who to believe. Brussels sprouts are better without the cheese. Ceviche is wonderful. Kids love the pork tacos. The service is very good. Worth it to come, but not sure I'm going to continue to be a repeat offender unless I'm really craving the ceviche and a fried oyster. read more

First time here, but already ready to dish out the 5 stars! Well, maybe 4.5 due to the onion heavy recipes, but that's just my nitpick. We came here on a Thursday and got a seat right away. However, soon after it filled up. The atmosphere is casual, maybe a tad claustrophobic, and the staff is friendly. We had the hush puppies and Brussels sprouts followed by a fried chicken taco for me (yep, fried chicken) and a pork taco for my lady. We tend to avoid sea food, but a lot of folks were downing oysters like they were free candy. All food was fantastic. Full flavor, hot, and well portioned. Don't miss this place if you're passing through or if you live here. Just be prepared to hold your nose at the onion overload. read more

Casa Pearl - Fried chicken taco - Seafood Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

Couldn't tell you how the food was because the hospitality is absolutely awful. Tonight I ver the phone the hostess says you can come in to place to go orders. So we drove there and then the host says "We do not accept to go orders." I have worked in this industry my entire life and your service is atrocious. read more

My husband and I came here for dinner on a Friday night around 5pm in August. We were able to get a table but when we left, which was around 6:30, there were a bunch of people waiting to be sat. We ordered the fried plantains and hush puppies for appetizers, which were both amazing and large portions. Then he had the fried chicken and pork tacos and I had a fish taco. The tacos were really big and pretty good but not anything too special. We had a couple of cocktails which we thought were a bit pricey but overall good. It's a small place and there isn't much going on around the immediate area. Good for a date night if you are a seafood lover! read more

Casa Pearl is all about flavor, and that shows through every single dish. I came here for a work lunch and it wasn't slammed. All of our food came out quickly. We ordered all of the snacks to share. My favorites were the Chips & Dip and Smoked Fish Dip. I was worried that pimento cheese with the Chips & Dip would be too much for the chicharrones, but it was so light and had a great barbecue chip-style flavor. The Fried Plantains were also a big hit at the table. I ended up spreading some of the sambal crema on my hush puppies. We also had the Brussels sprouts, which I initially turned my nose to because they are my least favorite vegetable. I am now a sprouts stan, solely because Casa Pearl prepares them in the most incredible way. There's a fantastic acidity and the dish also includes shaved parmesan in capers. After all of that, I was pretty full so I only ordered one taco. I chose the Oyster Po Boy taco, which also had a fantastic acidity in the cabbage. The oyster pieces were fried perfectly and didn't get soggy despite being under the cabbage and salsa. The remoulade with the oyster gave me big Louisiana vibes. read more

Casa Pearl - Menu - Seafood Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

I LOVE this place. They have a great happy hour and the food is delicious. I come here for the oysters but I must say that the smoked pork taco is amazing. The brussel sprouts were a little too lemony for me so I would likely not get those again. read more

Casa Pearl - Oyster po boy and smoked pork tacos. - Seafood Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

My first visit, on a beautiful Sunday afternoon. The cocktail list is impressive but we stuck with iced tea and a beer, heading for other activities. It's a calming, attractive place in a converted gas station, on the Edge (it's a tourism label) of Colonial Williamsburg. Small, wood and metal decor. There's an outdoor patio that is below the busy road surface. Not scenic, but not noisy. Food was stylish in presentation and well prepared. Our server was excellent, unobtrusive and helpful. I had a fish taco and Brussels sprouts in a lemon caper vinaigrette, my favorite dish and prepared perfectly, crisp, well seasoned, so good I wanted to lick the plate. The taco was okay, not huge but filling, not a stand-out in flavor but fresh and good. I have been spoiled by Southern California versions in beachfront dives. My friend had a white gazpacho special which was plated with style from a small flask with all the garnishes in an attractive crescent on the side of the soup bowl. She enjoyed it. She also had hush puppies with honey butter, tasty, though I'm not a big fan of hush puppies. Good crust, moist interior and fried without excess grease. The oyster menu looked tempting for another visit and seemed a popular choice. It's a tapas, small plate kind of place, fun for a group to taste and share. Our fellow diners were prosperous looking older couples but it was a Sunday late lunch time frame. A young dad came in with two excited little girls as we left, asking for tacos. The manager asked for our opinion as we left. Happy! Will come back. read more

This is a long overdue review for our co-favorite restaurant in Williamsburg, a place we have visited frequently through the years partly via affiliation to W&M. There is one other long-time favorite restaurant, and a few years ago it was the chef/owner there who told us to try Casa Pearl, where he goes on his nights off. We've had many occasions to be grateful for this advice. Had an early dinner on Friday evening during the busy Christmas season in Williamsburg. No wait for a table at 6:00, but folks were waiting when we got done. The crowd appears to be mostly locals, not tourists, always a great sign especially in this town. I love the ambiance of this place - busy and lively, nicely low-lit, casual, fun. I bet the patio is great in warmer weather. Our server, Jade, was terrific - super efficient, and funny and friendly, stopping to chat even as she got busier. (Asked Jade if she has any other favorite restaurants in the area. No. This is the only place she will eat out because the food is so fresh, and the kitchen is so clean.) Every bite was delicious. Everything is super fresh and bursting with flavor. We had the ceviche, smoked fish dip, fish taco, po' boy taco, and a salad. Every. single. bite was good. And the key lime dessert is fabulous. I don't even love key lime pie but this? Light, zesty, creamy. Good. So, we decided there was no reason to go anyplace else on Saturday, and went straight back to Casa Pearl, and sat in Jade's section and enjoyed talking with her some more, and had a few more wonderful things, and declared it the best part of our whole weekend. read more

This was a great stop on our way home. Thoughtful menu with fish, oysters, chicken and yummy tacos. Great staff including, hostess, busboys and waiters. Highly recommended. The key lime pie is a must! Gracias new favorite spot in the area. read more

Great food, it was St Patrick's Day and you wouldn't know it. The service was great. Our waitress was so helpful and understanding. Helped us find the hockey game we wanted to watch. Even though it was busy we didn't have to shout to talk to each other. I would recommend a meal and a beer here. read more

First, always happy to support a local business even when traveling. Too, I can be more than a little picky, but found few things to complain about here. Spoiler alert: we liked it SO much, we ate there twice during our short stay in Williamsburg, once for lunch and then again for dinner. Blew off reservations at another place to return. The atmosphere was cool and clean, sleek. The margarita was very good, loved the way the salt was on the side of the glass so you could have as much as you wanted , the only minor criticism was it seemed a little slight on the pour, but it was balanced out some by the cost and quality of the food. Service was kind and efficient. We really liked Andy, he was especially good. All the food we had was really good, especially liked the raw oysters, fried oyster tacos and the peel and eat shrimp. The whole fish a nearby table ordered to share at dinner looked wonderful! It's a small menu, but it's more than enough choices. Owner on site both visits. A fine place, a testament to what can be done when people give a damn about their business, keep up the good work! Yum! PS it was an EASY drive from Colonial Williamsburg. read more

See all

Good food. Recommend the Oyster Shooter with Fresno Vodka. Fast service. Clean and friendly service.

The oyster tacos were great. A glass of Merlot Gor $9 a bit steep in my mind for a restaurant with $$

Fresh, new upscale restaurant that has tacos and oysters. Industrials vibe on the inside. Variety of house made drinks with a small selection of craft beer. Excellent food. read more

Great meal. Come if you love oysters! We had a dozen salty oysters that were great. Best we're from Norwalk Ct. Next we had the Brussel sprouts which were amazing. Shrimp toast was up next which we wished were more flavorful. Husband had grilled oysters, which I loved and he found ok. I had the oyster Po'boy taco that had a great fried oyster. Son had the special, bouillabaisse, which was cooked well, but the sauce tasted of V8. Will come again and be mostly oyster based. Side note/ drinks were greet! read more

This is one of our favorite restaurants in the Williamsburg area. The food is excellent as is the service.

The food was freshly prepared and so tasty. The atmosphere was perfect for our Saturday lunch and Sierra was very informational and gave great suggestions. My husband doesn't eat seafood so he had the chicken taco and pork taco- chicken taco had a little heat but not too much. read more

See all

Casa Pearl is delicious! I suggest the oysters on the half shell, grilled fish taco, stacked salad with crispy chicken and the hush puppies. Their margaritas are also great! read more

Casa Pearl - Stacked salad with crispy chicken - Seafood Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

What a terrific find this restaurant is! Awesome cocktails and fabulous food. Their roasted oysters are hands down the best I have ever tasted. We liked the hush puppies and clams as well. My favorite taco was the oyster po boy - great flavors - unexpected and delicious! Can't wait to go back again! read more

Fresh Fabulous Food from Friendly Folks Awesome oysters and tacos and the entire menu will be on list to enjoy. read more

I'm a beach boy so Gringos by the ocean front in va beach is almost always number 1 for a fish taco ... not a lot of fish taco spots in the burg so this one doesn't have much competition .... The tacos have a decent flavor but the fish is lost behind the sauce and toppings .... the hush puppies are average until you add the sweet butter then they have a great salty sweet mixture ... I tried an old fashioned as a drink ... it was a bit strong for my taste but I'm not a big drinker so there ya go .... Overall average seafood spot, a step above fast food but not a place that will make my recommend list Service was a 4 Atmosphere 2.5 Food was a 3 Price was a 3 43$ for 4 tacos a plate of huspuppies and drink read more

Casa Pearl - Seafood Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

small but great place, what is not to like about oysters & tacos? plus the crispy Brussel sprouts were the bomb! read more

See all

Wow! It is so refreshing to have an original here in Williamsburg. These guys are serving up some mean tacos that are full of fresh ingredients. Their hush puppies are barking hot and the butter that comes with them just melts. It is sooo good. We got one of each oyster and they were all delicious but my favorite by far was the colonial. The oyster taco is crunchy and the shaved jalapeño gives it the best kick. I cannot wait to go back and try something else. I did not get a chance to try the drinks but I did spy a couple of local beers including the keep Virginia beautiful which is from Va Beer Company which is down the street. The restaurant is clean and well decorated. The ample natural light lets the dining room feel open and welcoming. Would definitely recommend giving this place a try. read more

See all

Our family visited Williamsburg Busch Gardens from Washington DC, and we stopped by for dinner at Casa Pearl. We love seafood. We sat on the patio with our dog, and this place delivered class A+ atmosphere, and a great variety of seafood. The shrimp toast appetizer with shrimp farse with a soy aioli sauce and a creamy hot sauce was incredible and so detailed with beauty. Whole fish with brussel sprouts were yummy. The server was knowledgeable and funny. This place really had passion for their crafted menu, and it showed. We had a fun and relaxing evening, and will always come back when in town. Thank you Casa Pearl! read more

Casa Pearl - Whole fish with brussel sprouts - Seafood Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

We visited here on vacation and the best dinner of our vacation. Lots of oysters and authentically-Mexican inspired tacos and ceviche were enjoyed by all. The topper was my broiled whole flounder which can compete with any fish dish in a Michelin rated restaurant. read more

Cool vibe, good food, generally good service. They were a little short staffed the evening we were there, pretty slow getting our food.

Went here on a lovely spring evening. Food was outstanding patio was great, and drinks were good too. Definitely recommend the charcoal grilled oysters. read more

Casa Pearl is the best restaurant in town. Always delicious. Always consistent. Owner/Chef has an incredible pedigree and knows exactly what he is doing. Consider myself somewhat of a regular and have had everything on their menu - living in big cities for the last 15 years, Williamsburg is truly lucky to have this addition come to town. Be sure to check them out! Especially when they have a daily special! Gem. read more

Don't judge a book by its cover. Limited menu but if you like anything "oystery", this is the place. Service is excellent as well. Brittany remembered my dad and it made his day! read more

The food is good and the drinks are better. Not your typical restaurant, nice atmosphere and service is pleasant. I just wish they were a little bigger, I drive from Hampton to come here and it kills me when there's a long wait. Other than that you have gold :) read more

Casa Pearl - Ceviche with a twist! On point! - Seafood Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

See all

Second time I have been there. The wait staff is friendly. The recommendation on the food and drinks was amazing. I have never had ceviche and I wanted to try to something I have never had before. It was light tender and you could taste everything. I was worried it would be one flavor and acidic. Not the case. The hush puppies are total comfort food. The clams with a hint of curry flavor is so nice. And the shrimp can never go wrong. Recommend order something to share. read more

Casa Pearl - Ceviche - Seafood Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

Great food! We got the Brussels sprouts as an appetizer (yum) and the fish tacos. Excellent food! Will be back.

AMAZING! We ordered like 10 things. We were so excited to be there. The raw oysters, char-grilled oysters, Brussel sprouts and golden salad were my favorites. The ceviche was my most favorite! My son loved the shrimp toast and pork taco. It was so nice to also have a kids menu for my daughter. She really enjoyed the cheese quesadillas. We will be back! Best meal I've enjoyed in years. Only disappointment was the hurricane slushee was sold out and it was hours before closing tine. Staff was very attentive and friendly. This place is a must visit! So fresh and yummy! read more

See all

Not a very big menu but everything is done top notch! Loved the raw oysters as well as the oysters casino. The cocktails were amazing! My wife's drink had a toasted black peppercorn and grapefruit simple syrup made in house. Shrimp toast, salads even the hush puppies were over the top. Would definitely recommend! read more

Absolutely amazing service and amazing food! There hasn't been a dish or appetizer on the menu the family hasn't enjoyed! For most businesses that are having difficulties finding good staff, Casa is not! Our waitress knew every special off the top of her head and was always there to get us anything we needed! read more

Excellent! So much better than the usual tourist stuff in Williamsburg. Authentic tacos and a dessert to die for. If we were staying longer we'd definitely come back! read more