I don't eat in the restaurant, I eat at the lovely bar/pub next door. There is a door connecting the two and they share services, so if you eat in the BYOB restaurant you can order a cocktail from the bar and if you like to sit at the bar you can order food from the restaurant. This is an area with a lot of Italian restaurants, by far, Casa Giuseppe has the best Italian food around. A very small dining room so I would suggest reservations, especially on weekends. read more

Homey Italian restaurant. Shrimp Tuscany was outstanding. They have no liquor license but you can get drinks from the adjoining bar.

Our favorite place! The good is scrumptious! The staff is the friendliest around! It's like having dinner with family and friends. Chef Joe has even made my favorite and it wasn't one the menu. Great night out and always relaxing! read more

We came here to celebrate my friend's birthday. I had the squid ink pasta with seafood special and it was incredible. Loved the ambiance. Service was great. The only negative was a couple who was berating us and talking to other tables about us being loud. We had a party of 10 , but we weren't being unruly or anything. It was just 10 people talking across the table. We apologized to the waiter but he told us we were fine. Can't blame the location for rude patrons , so I would definitely return ! read more

First time here in a few years. Started with drinks at connected bar next door. Great vibe. Then passed through to restaurant and brought a nice bottle for our dinner. Crab cake was terrific. Right amount of crab and nice size in a piccata sauce. Spot on. Well worth the $16.95. Eggplant Rollitini was flavorful with creamy ricotta and excellent smooth red sauce. Had the stuffed pork chop $27 and swordfish $33 specials for entrees. Very tasty but not as good as appetizers. Was surprised at high price of specials. Will definitely return and try another menu item with the red sauce (one of the best this foodie has had). Cozy atmosphere with good service. Packed so make reservations. $93 for only 2 appetizers and 2 entrees is a wee bit pricy. But with the connected bar as a pre dinner warmup makes this place a good choice. read more

A small well ran local restaurant. Coming from an Italian family this place has a spot in my heart. A small friendly location with excellent service and some of the best Italian dishes out there. I Hurd all the reviews from friends at the firehouse and family so I had to be the final judge. My new favorite spot for a romantic Italian dinner. I'm a huge fan of great service. Casa Giuseppe delivers class A service and food. read more

Delicious meal once again but as I said last time the food needs to be seasoned a little better. Chop special and the accompaniments lacked seasoning as well as the burrata salad special , Fresh food but fell a little short . Lava cake was over microwaved ! I will return and hope some corrections will happen read more

This is my favorite Italian restaurant! The food is always freshly made and super delicious. Some of my favorite dishes are Shrimp Tuscany, Crab Cakes or Chicken Hunter Style. Staff is very friendly, you feel like a family there. Awesome place. read more

Casa Giuseppe - Shrimp Tuscany - Italian Near Me - Lyndhurst, New Jersey

We came here last night for our Anniversary, our first time. Everything was perfect. The food was delicious and flavorful. We had the crab cake for an appetizer. Let me say, one of the best or maybe the best crab cake I've ever had. For our meals we had the Bronzino special with scallops and shrimp, and the Shrimp Tuscany. We cannot wait to go back. What a great Italian gem we came across. Highly recommend. read more

Had dinner here a few years ago. Was in neighborhood last week and decided to stop there for late lunch, but the restaurant was not open for lunch. The owner saw us at the door trying to see if they were open, unlocked the door and said he was getting ready for dinner and if we didn't mind waiting a bit, he would be happy to serve us So we went in and had the whole place to ourselves. We were given the menu and he told of his specials. He mentioned an interesting veal dish with some kind of mushrooms that I never heard of. When I asked a question about the dish, he explained something about the mushrooms (I think he said they were imported - whatever he said, I do remember that they were described as special). When I told him that I would like to try the dish, he mentioned the price, which was expensive. I appreciate that he mentioned the price so that I wouldn't get sticker shock when the check was presented. (Usually, when specials are mentioned, they leave out the price) I ordered it, and the veal, mushrooms and sauce were delicious. A good choice, and a new experience. Since we were the only ones in the restaurant and it was not officially open for dinner yet, the owner had a bit of time to talk to us. Currently, the place is small and intimate and BYOB. But,, he said he is soon knocking down a wall to expand and will better be able to accommodate private parties. There will also be a bar. The food was great. And the owner was friendly. Oh! And I was pleasantly surprised when I got the bill. Since I ordered an expensive dish, I was prepped to get a hefty bill. But since everything else on the menu that we ordered was average priced, our entire bill was quite affordable. What was supposed to be a late lunch, turned into a lovely dinner. read more

EXCELLENT.... YES EXCELLENT! My first visit... The bread was an indicator as to how good my dinner would be... The Seafood salad... to die for... pasta special with lump crab meat awesome... So appetizers and dinner hit the mark.... However.... espresso... mediocre at best... my dinner partner's coffee week at best... Service... although he was a little overwhelmed... a great job.... All and all I will be back as soon as I can.... Put this little gem on your list as a must visit! read more

Love this restaurant.... Cozy and classy!!! The chef is very nice and the food is amazing... Crab cake and osso buco are my favorites. For desert go for the creme brûlée. read more

Casa Giuseppe - Crab cake - Italian Near Me - Lyndhurst, New Jersey

This is a place with some great aspects and some not-so-great aspects. As far as the great, I have to start with the service. I'm not sure if I have been to many other restaurants with better service than Casa Giuseppe. My family went back a second time a few months after our first visit and the waitress remembered our faces. How often does that happen?! I also love the fact that they do not rush you out here. They seem to encourage you to take your time and stay for awhile after the meal. I can't tell you how annoying it is to be rushed out of your seat to sit another party. As far as the food, I had the chicken parm. I have to say I also enjoyed the portion of pasta on the side, which was large. However, the sauce lacked flavor for me and the chicken just overall did not taste too spectacular. Overall, I'd say the food is OK - I have definitely had better but not horrible. This would be a great place to go for a date or to have a dinner and talk for a hour or so afterwards. read more

You wont find a better Italian restaurant in this little town where Italians have the majority. Nice little place off the beaten path. Staff is friendly and knowledgable and the food is authentic. Whether you're out with a date or just family dinner, this place has everything, food, great staff and amazing atmosphere. read more

Been here many times, never disappointed. The crab cake is amazing. Highly recommend the hog wing appetizer. The specials are always fresh and interesting. Byob so bring a nice bottle and enjoy. read more

Casa Giuseppe - Crab cake is excellent. - Italian Near Me - Lyndhurst, New Jersey

My boyfriend and I went to this restaurant for our anniversary. We made reservations for 8PM and was seated as we walked in at 7:55PM. The service was great. Our waitress always checked up on us and asked if everything was good. The food I got was the chicken cutlet over spaghetti. The spaghetti came on the side but it was a large portion of it. I even had to bring some of it home. My boyfriend ordered the Zuppa Di Pesce and he said it was fantastic. We will definitely be going here again. read more

We had a family dinner for 5 here while visiting my daughter and future son-in-law. The service was wonderful, friendly and well informed of specials and the regular menu. The food was simply fantastic! Ingredients were fresh and you can taste the love with every bite! read more

I Went on Tuesday night and it was very quiet, no music was on. The fried artichoke Was good but I wish there was a different dressing, It came with honey mustard and remind me of chicken nuggets The food seemed fresh and the waitress was pleasant. Thank you for a great experience and we will see you soon. read more

My family and I went there for Dinner. The service and the food was delicious. I would highly recommend Casa Giuseppe. restaurant .

Came here last night with my boss; he would rave about the crab cakes and the desserts here so he thought it was time to bring me by. BOY, DID THIS PLACE NOT DISAPPOINT! Being a jersey girl, I've eaten at well over 100 claims-to-authentic Italian restaurants. This was by far the best -- and extremely local to me. I wish I heard of it sooner! We started off with the crab cake appetizer with capers in a lemony-wine sauce. Seriously, so moist, delicious, to die for. I'm a crab cake snob and this was by far the best I've had. Since most of the menu items contained pork and I do not eat it, I ordered the penne alfredo with chicken. So good, literally, so, so fresh and good. Their house made cheesecake with ricotta was so fluffy, not too sweet, and had NO crust just how I love it. Reminded me of the cheesecake at Carmine's in NYC and AC. The service was great, its BYOB and the food was reasonably priced. Definitely a must to try out. read more

Great atmosphere, cozy and clean. Fried calamari, Sea bass special and spaghetti puttanesca were AMAZING. Spaghetti and meatballs special was ok. Meatballs were just ok and spaghetti was VERY al dente, but that's a personal preference. Cavatelli with broccoli raab was good, shrimp were cooked well. Bottom line, Definitely the best red sauce in town, Great service, will definitely be back. read more

If you are looking for authentic Italian food this is your place. Great food and amazing customer service;very friendly! read more

After reading such rave reviews I had to give this place a try. Overall there was a mix of good and bad. Starting with the good, the crab cake appetizer and hog wings were great. I enjoyed the veal Giuseppe and my wife and cousin said the sirloin was very bland. My cousin's wife had the pasta with lump crab and she said it was tasty. The biggest let down had to be the service. There's an older waitress who is great but everyone else is not up to snuff. All things considered, this place is a great value and the ingredients were very fresh. I'll definitely give this place another shot real soon. read more

See all

Went for dinner with Mom and it was absolutely amazing. Everything we ate was delicious. Atmosphere was so perfect Jersey Italian restaurant. Loved it. Waitress was a doll. Can't wait to go back. Our favorite was the crab cakes on the specials menu! read more

Delish!!! Chicken Fontina was amazing! Fried Calamari was to die for! Very professional wait staff! BYOB they don't have a bar! Everything was just greatttttt read more

5* food at a reasonable price. I would highly recommend this restaurant. great service and very friendly atmosphere. read more

Casa Giuseppe - happy birthday Paul Jean - Italian Near Me - Lyndhurst, New Jersey

See all

Great food and atmosphere! Staff is so friendly and welcoming. Always a delicious meal and fun night out!

Being from Newark ,I have dined in many restaraunts.when I was taken to casa Giuseppe I was impressed from the minute I was in.first an amazing crab cake ,and the rice ball with shrimp.the house salad a must .the house dressing is great.My meal was the country chicken .I recommend this restaurant hands down.Ask for Lefty she is amazing. read more

There's no shortage of italian restaurants in Lyndhurst, NJ. But this is the best one so far. Food: Really fresh food & well made. I had the special blackened shrimp with broccoli rabe. My friend had the eggplant appetizer as an entree and it was delicious. We had the almond tiramisu for dessert & it was so fresh! The chef makes everything fresh! its BYOB Service: We were running quite late & the staff was friendly enough to accomodate us. Both the chef and staff are super friendly. Would come back again to try their famous cheesecake :) read more

What a cozy little place filled w home cooked meals I started w some mussels in marinara sauce which were pretty tasty. I ordered the Chicken Fontini I hope I spelled that right but It had prosciutto and mozzarella and a i pink sauce which was great. Very filling so take it easy on the bread. You're able to enjoy some drink which you get from the attached 503 bar. If you like cozy and family like this is the place. read more

Casa Giuseppe - Italian Near Me - Lyndhurst, New Jersey

See all

Four of us were visiting from out of town and we had a fantastic experience here on July 22, 2018. The food was absolutely delicious. Our waiter, Juan, was very attentive and friendly. The restaurant added brand new menus that illuminate upon opening. Would 100% recommend, and will definitely return on future trips! read more

The evening started off well until dinner when the order of tripe was not up to the same standard as previous visits and we where not offered would you like to order something but they did the right thing by not charging..but the person left hungry..then the hostess asked if we were done and we hadn't even ordered dessert because she had people waiting not my issue dont overbook your room. Then once again was asked how much longer..wow never have ever been rushed out of any restaurant before and this all started 1 hr 45 minutes in with a party of 8 other food excellent but hostess needs some people skills training..and the waitress"lefty" was awesome. read more

Great old school Italian semi fine dining Italian restaurant with white table clothes and complementary bread. Delicious food, friendly service and its a byob so it was perfect. read more

With my party of 30! This food was amazing! From the bread to the pasta to the chocolate lava cake! Cheryl, you were amazing too! There was not a minute were I did NOT enjoy it! Well done Casa Giuseppe! read more

Amazing is all I can say. The steak with madeira sauce is probably the best steak I've ever had. The new expanded location is great. Been here probably six times now and every time the food has been among the best we've ever had. read more

All I could say is the food was fantastic from A-Z! The food was great so tasty and portions where were big! The atmosphere was warm and very welcoming! The Maitre D Sherral, Chef Joe and waiters were all friendly and very accommodating! We love the menus which used a lited background which allowed you to see everything so clearly and retain the ambiance with the low light atmosphere! We will definitely be going back to experience the rest of the menu and dessert! Me and my girl were very pleased and happy to have our first Valentine Dinner at such a beautiful restaurant! Buon Apptitio Fred Amorosa read more

Tonight was a great start, Lefty was such a pleasure to meet and take our dinner requests. Dinner and Appetizers were fantastic. The staff were Fantastic. Only problem, the Rush to move us out, never heard of a Time limit. Also, the female Hostess accused a female of breaking a wine glass as we departed. Untrue !!!! and unacceptable !!!!!. Totally out of line. The female accused was a waitress for 19 years and would NEVER conduct herself in such a manner. Thank you for a wonderful dinner. See you soon. 5 stars !! read more

All I have to say is amazing! Food and service was amazing. Next time I am in town I will difently come back.

One of the best Italian restaurant in town. My favorrrrrrrrrr! I been so many times and never had 1 fish that I don't like. And they are BYOB ! read more

Me and my husband we went Saturday for dinner at casa Giuseppe was beautiful everything was delicious I will Recommend it to my friends and family read more