Cancel

Open app

Search

Carnegie's

3.7 (88 reviews)
ModerateSandwiches, Soup, Delis

Carnegie's Photos

CARNEGIE'S ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?
Moderate noise
Casual
Outdoor seating
Good for kids

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Carnegie's

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Chicken salad sandwich on sweet French and tomato basil soup
Lily B.

Cute little cafe lunch style places that serves soup, sandwich and salads. I got the chicken salad on sweet French with tomato soup. Sandwich was good. Soup was only warm and not my favorite but to each their own. Service was nice and fast. Also there is outdoor seating. Coffee and pastries.

Susan S.

I've been a fan of Carnegie's for years. Loved their salads, soup and bread. Recently, the quality of the food has been on the decline and the cost has been on the rise; a simple lunch for myself and my sons will quickly rise to $40 for some not-so-fancy fare. Today my son and I decided to drop by on one of Redding's all-too-frequent 100 degree days. The interior temps are near 85. When I asked the waiter if he could "cool the restaurant a bit?" he said he "couldn't." Couldn't or wouldn't ? To appease us, he reseated us at table 4--next to 1/2 grimy ac ducts in the building. I ordered a cashew chicken salad on wheat. I received a cashew chicken salad on white. Couldn't the lunch I ordered, either. Priceless? Nah. 1/2 sandwiches for two: $25.76

Melissa B.

I have gone to Carnegie's since I have moved here--they are my goto place for soups and salads. Oh, yeah they also have good beer on tap plus kombucha! The addition of the Parklet add a lot of outdoor seating, which is key during these crazy COVID times.

Ridiculous

First time here. Waitress was very rushed even though it really wasn't that busy. Asked her about the club and didn't realize it was grilled. Not a big deal I thought so I asked her if it was possible to make a different sandwich. She said yes and never told me I would be billed for both. A sandwich lunch turned into almost 40 dollar meal. Absolutely ridiculous. When I asked her about it she said it was owners policy. She should have told me she would have charged me for both. So then I asked for the other sandwich back. Not coming back.

Half turkey sandwich and potato salad.

See all

10 years ago

Their Reuben sandwich and tomato basil soup was delicious! The service was prompt and the restaurant looked clean.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

15 years ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Jay B.
4
75
0

16 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

7 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

15 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

11 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Page 3 of 3

Ask the Community - Carnegie's

You might also consider

Sourdough Bread Company

Sourdough Bread Company

3.5(31 reviews)
3.6 mi

I've been eating here for the past year, and up until last Wednesday, I would have told anyone this…read moreplace was one of my favorites. The workers were always friendly, the food was always solid, and I had never had a reason to complain. And then... I ordered an 8-inch sandwich through Uber and opened it up to find not one, not two, BUT THREE LONG BLACK HAIRS IN MY SANDWICH. Three. Not "oops, maybe a stray hair fell in by accident" territory. I'm talking about a full-blown hair trilogy. A hair every couple of inches like somebody was out here seasoning my sandwich with their hair. It was beyond disgusting. At that point, it honestly felt impossible to believe this was accidental. How do you get three long hairs in one sandwich, spread out across the whole thing, and nobody notices? Be serious. What made it even worse was that I was stuck in trial all day, couldn't leave to get anything else, and needed lunch so I could function through a long day in court. Instead, I got a stomach-turning surprise and basically lost my meal. I'm not even writing this angry as much as I'm writing it heartbroken. This was one of my favorite places. But after finding three long hairs in a single sandwich, I'm done. I can't unsee that. I can't unread that. I can't un-gross that. Sadly, this was enough to end a one-year relationship. RIP to what used to be one of my favorite lunch spots.

I would not recommend this to ANYONE!. 2 small sandwiches, small Mac & cheese and a drink was…read moreover $45.00. I told them TWICE, no coleslaw on my sandwich and when it finally came out it had coleslaw. NOT A POSITIVE EXPERIENCE.

Photos
Sourdough Bread Company
Sourdough Bread Company
Sourdough Bread Company - Sourdough Bread Company "sandwiched" between crumbl and AT&T

See all

Sourdough Bread Company "sandwiched" between crumbl and AT&T

From the Hearth Kitchen & Pie Shop - Tomato Basil soup/Grilled Cheese

From the Hearth Kitchen & Pie Shop

3.8(289 reviews)
3.2 mi
$$

They updated the online ordering and have had things smooth ever since! Thanks so much!! I can…read morefinally order breakfast again! Love the food here.

I've sat on giving this review for some time now. I don't like giving negative reviews and want to…read moremake sure I give accurate feedback. Let's start with In store ordering is the only way to order from them. The food is really really good, fresh, fairly quick and moderately priced. It's worth the cost for what you get. Ordering Togo can have mistakes and ordering for delivery, well continue reading. Now.... I Would not recommend ordering from their 'From the Hearth' app. When you download it and order from it it seems as though it's an app they monitor and delivery would be private. It's DoorDash that the 'ordering/payment/delivery it actually goes through. Here's where it gets frustrating. On DoorDash app when an order is incorrect you can file a claim and get a refund. You cannot do that with this app, nor is there anyone to help you through From the Hearth side and it's missing the DoorDash side. I've done several home deliveries through the app and mostly items were correct, a few times fries or sauces, added ingredient's to a dish we're missing and we'd than have to go to the store to get them, which is manageable but the experience I'd like to really share is: I made a $175 order to feed my family and friends that were in town. It took over 2.5hrs to finally get delivered to us, it even got delivered to the wrong house and when trying to get it figured out through From the Hearth staff they treated me as if I was lying and would not remake the food nor refund me. The food was literally "missing" and I was told I had to go through the subsidiary (DoorDash) that's when I learned it was not their app and they had no responsibility once it left their store. But really for me, It was the way the From the Hearth staff responded to the incident that truly baffles me and makes me not eat there anymore. I use to frequent the business several times a month, this was extremely rude and made me very disappointed. I would NOT recommend them based on their customer service by this experience.

Photos
From the Hearth Kitchen & Pie Shop
From the Hearth Kitchen & Pie Shop - Avocado Toast

Avocado Toast

From the Hearth Kitchen & Pie Shop - Menu

See all

Menu

Dill's Deli & Bbq - Freshly baked cookies

Dill's Deli & Bbq

4.0(447 reviews)
3.3 mi
$$

I was hangry for a salad for dinner and needed a sandwich for the next days hiking…read more The salad was massive! Fresh Romaine leaves and croutons and the grilled chicken was moist with a nice, tasty grill on the outside while easy to bite through. I couldn't stop eating it. You have about 7 choices of dressing which the put on the side so you can choose how much. $14.50 but it could easily feed 2 people. The sandwich was so big I had it for 2 meals. The turkey was juicy with sourdough bread, good cheddar cheese, not overly mayonnaised, and a few large leaves of lettuce. I had the best hike after this delicious 1/2 of the sandwich. Ate the other the day prior and it was so delicious I scarfed it down forgetting to take a picture. $14.49 and again can feed 2 people. This place stays really busy for a reason - exceptional food and great service. If I lived in Redding, this would be a dangerous place for me.

My husband is what you would consider a professional sandwich eater. He can make a stack at home…read morethat you could really pay top dollar for, and he is incredibly choosy and picky about where he will eat a sandwich outside of the house. Don't get me wrong, there are plenty of places that he likes to get a sandwich... I just need you to understand how incredibly picky he is. Enter Dills deli m. Not only was he completely blown away by their delicious sandwiches, but my daughter stands by the fact that this was the best pastrami she's ever had. Now, as any good parent would, I have educated this kid on the ins and outs of pastrami, and for her to deem this one the best is a major accomplishment. The spot is super clean, the servers are incredibly friendly, and the food is spot on. Absolutely worth your time.

Photos
Dill's Deli & Bbq - Dining area

Dining area

Dill's Deli & Bbq - Signage

Signage

Dill's Deli & Bbq - Looks like they got a good BBQ set up!!

See all

Looks like they got a good BBQ set up!!

Carnegie's - sandwiches - Updated May 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...