Had a wonderful evening at Carlo and Johnny's. The bar area atmosphere was perfect, food amazing, especially the crab cake and key lime pie. The service was second to none and appreciated the visit from Jordan T. and Charlie ensuring everything was up to their high standards. read more

A gorgeous restaurant in a former mansion with a history. Free parking as well as valet parking for $5. Truly a top notch spot in Cincinnati. A perfect spot for a special occasion. We were here for my birthday and then here again for our anniversary. They are super attentive and if you need anything just ask! Christian our bartender/waiter was outstanding. This time we tried the Wagyu Carpaccio for an appetizer and it was a great way to start. The beef was fresh and tender and cut super thin along with the fresh arugula and saltiness of the parm crisps and capers it was a perfect bite. My main was the Lobster Thermidor, it was the first time I have tried that dish and it did not disappoint! The star of the day though was the 16 oz ribeye my husband ordered to a perfect medium rare and he said he could have cut it with a fork. He also had the creamy mashed potatoes and sautéed mushrooms on the side. The brought us out a lovely cupcake with a candle for our anniversary. We did not leave hungry for sure. We will be back here again for sure. read more

See all

I've heard many of good things about Carlo & Johnny. We were excited to try their food finally. We started with the small bluefin tuna flight experience. The quality of the fish blew me away! You cannot find fresh fish like this anywhere else in Cincy. The tuna melted in your mouth and the presentation was beautiful. We also got the mozzarella di bufala which was pretty good, I do wish they gave you more than 2 pieces of grilled bread with it. For our main course we got the bistecca ala florentina. This was a bit dissappointing for us since the steak felt chared and a little burnt on the outside. We couldn't really taste the flavor other than it being burnt. It was not cooked evenlty as one side was more well done than the other. I think for this price it would have been done a little better. The mac and cheese and truffle gnocchi was good as always. The one thing we did not like was how slow our dinner came out. We were there for 3 hours long when we only got 3 dishes and 1 side. We probably waited 30mins after we finished eating something for the next item to come out each time. The servers were great but I feel like we shouldn't have waited so long inbetween our dishes. read more

See all

Classic, rustic, and elegant. This restaurant makes you feel like you've stepped back to a time when quality and service were the top priorities. The exposed brick, rich wood accents, and dim lighting create the perfect atmosphere for a romantic evening. The service was outstanding, attentive, professional, and very knowledgeable about the menu and drink pairings. The prime steaks were cooked to perfection, and the mac and cheese was absolutely amazing. For me, the real standout was the Butter Pie. It's an absolute must-try and the perfect way to end a fantastic dining experience. Highly recommended! read more

See all

Always top tier, 10 out of 10. Friendly service from the host stand and everyone in between. Shout out to the manager Jordan. A warm and charming atmosphere with delicious food, can't miss. My husband and I have spent every anniversary with Jeff Ruby Culinary Entertainment; a tradition that started with a proposal at The Precinct, it's been 20 years of amazing dinners. read more

See all

Wait time: 5 minutes, must have reservations! Atmosphere: very elegant and appealing, lots of people Service: there is no better restaurant service than a Ruby's restaurant! Food: best steaks around, came out exactly as ordered. Price: $$$$ Cleanliness: 10/10 Ask for the history of the building! Amazing past and how they came up with the name! read more

See all

Came for one of my Bestfriends birthday and had a good time. Our man server Chandler was pretty great but the lady who sat down the bread and butter seemed to be in a rush or not interested in helping our table. I did however asked chandler if there was another flavor of the espresso martini I could order but he never got back to me with an answer. I ordered the prime skirt steak and truffle fries. The chimichurri that came with the skirt steak was some of the best I ever had and same goes for the truffle fries. I had the opportunity to try the Brussel sports, chicken Parmesan, Who Dey roll , Shrimp Tempura and Filet Scampi. To me the scampi was kind of salty. Some of the people I came with did have to send their food back to be cooked longer but the manger was really nice about the whole thing. If you don't like salt I would say don't get the bread! I made a mistake and bite into the crust and it was not pleasant. It is ever nice inside the restaurant and I'm glad I got to learn about the history of the building as well. read more

See all

Our dinner was delicious and our service was perfection! Chandler took great care of us and made our dining experience over-the-top! We so appreciated his service, as well as the rest of the wait-staff. The restaurant is beautiful, and we hope to return next time we are in Cincinnati. (We are from the Seattle area). read more

Been here many times and got a steak and the wife got the chicken so there are plenty of those pictures. Started off with oysters, east coast and west coast. I always do this as this is the only time I get to eat them since I am the only one that will eat them. Got our meal and as always it prepared well and delicious as well as the sides. It was our anniversary and we ordered a dessert but our daughter called them to have a dessert flight created for us. It was delicious and I have to say the staff is always top notch. I've been to all the other Jeff Ruby's restaurants and I enjoyed them all but to me this is easier for parking and the tables are more spaced out. read more

Carlo & Johnny - Desert flight - Steakhouses Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

Every now and then you deserve a little indulgence, and Carlos & Johnny's never disappoints! This month they offered a special $65 surf & turf menu, and it was absolutely worth it. The food was amazing -- perfectly prepared and full of flavor. The service was just as impressive: friendly, attentive, and made the whole experience even better. On top of that, the atmosphere is always lively and fun. It's such a great spot to relax, enjoy a fantastic meal, and hang out with friends. Consistently one of my favorite go-to places when I want a memorable night out. Highly recommend! read more

See all

Everything was amazing as always! And I love how they treat everyone age with respect at the table!

Just had an excellent meal at C&J. Chilean Sea Bass cooked perfectly. It was so tender. Mac & cheese and brussel sprouts were delicious. Split the Iceberg Bleu salad with my husband and the portion was still huge. Bleu cheese dressing was mild. Anticipating carrot cake we brought home for later! Chris and Sam took fantastic care of us. read more

Carlo & Johnny - Bread with mushroom truffle butter, iceberg Bleu salad, chilean sea bass and sides. - Steakhouses Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

The food at any Jeff Ruby restaurants do not disappoint. Overall a great fine dining experience at Carlo and Johnny's. The waitress was super nice and friendly and attentive. The sushi, wedge salad and filet were all on point. I was a bit disappointed at the beer temp. Both of my Mich Ultra's were slightly cooler than room temp. Had to put ice from my other glass into my beer to help it out. Also, not complaining but just advising that dining here takes longer than normally expected. Our diner from start to finish took almost three hours. I was ready to go after that. All in all the food is amazing and definitely I would recommend it to see for yourself. read more

See all

Carlo & Johnny continues to deliver one of the finest dining experiences in Cincinnati. The atmosphere is timeless, the service is attentive, and every course feels like a celebration. We started with six oysters were fresh, briny, and beautifully presented on ice. The tuna tartare followed, light and flavorful, setting us up perfectly for what is hands down my ultimate favorite: the blue crab bisque. Creamy, rich, and decadent, it's the kind of dish you'll think about long after you leave. For the main course, we shared an 8-ounce filet, cooked to perfection and topped with mushrooms and plenty of garlic butter. Paired with one of their signature blue cheese-stuffed martinis (truly the best martinis in town), it was unforgettable. To end the night, we tried the peanut butter mousse cake. While it was decadent and well-executed, my heart still belongs to their chocolate cake, which I'll definitely go back for next time. From start to finish, Carlo & Johnny embodies everything you want in a steakhouse - flawless service, indulgent dishes, and an atmosphere that makes every evening feel special. read more

See all

Their pastry chef has added some nice summer seasonal desserts like blueberry pie. Shout out to their pastry chef Koby! read more

Carlo & Johnny - Updated new dessert (July 2025) made by Koby. Blueberry pie so delicious - Steakhouses Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

It was amazing to get back to my favorite Jeff Ruby steakhouse! Carlo & Johnny NEVER disappoints and is always consistent with quality and customer service. The barrel cut filet is a go-to with a side of cream corn. You will not walk out hungry!! The restaurant and bar create an ambiance that cannot be matched. If you are in Cincinnati do yourself a favor and make a reservation. And, don't forget the old fashioned. Enjoy!! read more

We go a few times a year for special occasions. We have yearly NYE reservations. Usually the service and food is impeccable. However, this year for NYE was less than impressive. The service was slow and honestly, not even decent. Waited almost 45 minutes for our dinner. The server was literally ghosting us. We saw her to place our order, give us our bill and ordered a dessert to take home with us. It took her over 30 minutes to bring our dessert and that's only AFTER we asked where it was! She "forgot" to bring it out! Super disappointed with our service. For a $400 meal for two, I absolutely expected better service. I can't say we won't be back, but I will say this was by far the worst experience I've had here. And we were seated next to the fireplace which was unbelievably hot making our already poor service even a worse experience. All in all, I have to say, I could have gone to outback and had a better experience and saved $300. Pretty disappointed. read more

See all

We worked with the Jeff Ruby team after a challenging first visit, and they took our feedback and were wonderful about everything, making us feel heard. Our second visit was excellent; everything was detail-oriented, food was great, and overall an excellent date night. As much as the steak was great, I have to recommend the Caesar salad as a surprising winner; I'm usually not a salad guy but it was easily one of the best ones I've had. read more

See all

Carlo and Johnny's is my favorite steak experience and to me it is an experience! The steaks are perfectly cooked, seasoned and choice quality. When there's a special occasion, this is where I go. Ambience was lovely and our wait staff was very attentive but I'm not a fan of the upstairs rooms. I do think they need to add a bit more charm to the second floor, but the music in the bar and fun atmosphere on the first floor is my favorite. You never can go wrong here. Seafood bar looked amazing, it a hard decision to choose what to order, that's why you have to splurge every now and then and go back!! read more

Great service and amazing as always! We came to celebrate our anniversary and it happened to be the lobster and filet special. That's a great deal! We love celebrating here and they always do a superb job. read more

Carlo & Johnny - Steakhouses Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

See all

This was our second visit to this restaurant. We were greeted immediately after entering. We had a reservation and was early, but still had to wait. We were a table of five. I love the antique feel of the property and its historical flair. We were greeted by several staff members while at our table. Our server, a Michael Douglas look alike was helpful and engaging. Our food was delicious overall. The bread was just okay, but I don't like rye. We chose a meatball appetizer that was pared with grits. It was flavorful. We chose a delmonico steak entree and a Duhon pork chop. Our sides were garlic mash and mac and cheese. Our food portions were substantial and we were able to finish our food for lunch the next day. Cookie and cream ice cream was a tasty treat to finish the night. read more

See all

Beautiful place full of stories and character. Classy, yet relaxed atmosphere. I had the petite filet mignon, and it was cooked to order just perfectly. Unfortunately, I did have a couple of bites that were not chewable. We had a side of baby carrots and these babies were quite large and plentiful, but fresh & tasty. Finished with the butter pie and it was outstanding. Overall, wonderful atmosphere and great food. The only real negative is their pricing, which is way above market (and that's in any market). read more

Carlo & Johnny - Butter pie - Steakhouses Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

Our dinner for 4 started with apps of the freshiest Ruby pearl oysters and sushi that were delicious and good size. Two of us had the steak and lobster special of which the lobster was significantly overdone. Our server took care of securing replacements that were better, but still not of what we have previously had at other JR restaurants. Our other couple said their steak was good, but have had better.We ordered carrot cake for dessert to go which was top notch! The drinks were good, service was good, but frankly we left disappointed it had been our least favorite of the JR restaurants in Cincy, Nashville, or Lex based on main courses and service. The restaurant is absolutely gorgeous, but I don't see a repeat return here unfortunately. Just good isn't good enough when the others are better. read more

We had an 8:30 reservation, our server was good but I could tell she was ready for it to be over. Not the service I have come to love from this brand. The filet was delicious but was undercooked. My husband and I both asked for medium but both steaks were definitely medium rare. I was there for a birthday dinner and did not want to complain about my steak being undercooked. A bit disappointed though. The vibe was nice and the live music in the bar area was perfect. We were seated upstairs and I loved that. I still really enjoy this steakhouse. read more

See all

Birthday for a good friend (we came from Dayton) wanted something spectacular and Carlo did not disappoint. Sarah our server gave us a detailed history of the building while we enjoyed cocktails. The decor is so perfect and service was top notch at every stage .Steak (Delmonico loved every amazing bite) and others with sea bass and steak scampi said the same. What a perfect choice to make our friend who has traveled the world and eaten everywhere (she had not been here before) feel super special. This will remain the best choice for a really great experience in my world as never lets me down. Also the bread is ridiculous and I know good bread from work trips to NYC (we always hit Sullivans bakery) keep up the great work! read more

Our team dinner was wonderful! The food, service, and especially the desserts were a huge hit. Thank you for all of your help organizing the dinner and for everything you did to make the evening such a success. We truly appreciate everyone's efforts and hospitality. read more

We love Carlo & Johnny's so much! The food is fantastic, and we love the ambience as well. But what we love most is the people that work there. We're so fortunate to know so many of these wonderful people. Our absolute favorite bartender would be Kate. Ashley is also a superstar. We also love Greg. You can't go to a Jeffrey Ruby restaurant without always appreciating Charlie. And also thanks to Brian at Carlos & Johnny's as well. We always say, they put the FINE, into fine dining! Tonight we all had hamburgers, which were fantastic. So from a hamburger to steak to lobster, always the absolute best meal! read more

See all

The best service + food in the city! Our server Ally was incredible. Steak was juicy and delicious. This place never disappoints

This place is nothing but class from the moment you enter the restaurant. The ambience is rich and moody, the staff is utterly professional and wonderful, the food is out of this world. We didn't feel rushed and were able to enjoy our cocktails and meal with ample time. The filet mignon was tender and juicy and cooked to perfection. The sushi was fresh and delicious. We enjoyed carrot cake and cappuccino at the end of our meal and walked away very happy. The price is high, but you get what you pay for here. We will be back. A magnificent first class meal. read more

Carlo & Johnny - Santo Paloma - Steakhouses Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

See all

Had dinner at Carlo and Johnny on Thursday. Absolutely fantastic service from Ally B and Blake. Couldn't have asked for a better crew to take care of my good friend Trevor on his 21st birthday. Steak was top tier, sides were spot on, sushi was decadent, and don't even get me started on the Dessert, can't go wrong with any of them. I highly recommend the air ruby and house of ruby especially. Will definitely be back soon! read more

Everything was perfect , we had a private room and the service was amazing. Chandler, Kailyn and Olivia did a great job .

Last Evening was not a pleasurable one. We were celebrating 2 Birthdays last and the night unfortunately spiraled and tanked. Definitely NOT the experience we are used to at the Rubys establishments. The night started off wonderfully, our waiter Chris very enthusiastic and comical kicked off the night very well. It was my Mothers 1st time to the Carlo & Johnny Location & Chris was kind enough to tell her the history. We started with shrimp appetizer and some drinks then things kind of went south after that. The restaurant was not really busy except the left back horseshoe of the restaurant. We were able to mains order placed, but ended up waiting a good while for it to come out. Im assuming while I was in the restroom the waiters attendant took the remaining bread off the table along with the butter. When I returned I asked the young man if we can have some more bread and butter since it was removed from the table. The young man replied " I personally am unable to get that for you, you will have to ask your waiter"( which is running around like crazy trying to keep his head above water). So you "personally can remove bread & butter from the table but can not replace it. Okaaaay got it ! Our meal arrives. I ordered the surf & turf. I automatically knew the lobster came with drawn butter. So again I asked the attendant to get the butter for the lobster. Good news he was able to get that ! When our food was delivered to the table by a female expo she asked if we would like some side plates for the family style sides; we said yes.... She never showed with them. When Chris stopped by the table to see if everything was to our liking he did mention the plates but we told him expo was getting them. We could see he was extremely busy and to not worry about them, we ended up just passing the sides around the table no big deal. End of meal the waiters attendant grabbed our food up to be boxed.... Never brought our food back to the table. We then waited about 25 min for birthday desserts to arrive, which consisted of a cookie and a triangle of butter cake, nothing that needed to be prepared. No candle like the other tables received with their birthday celebrations that I noticed, kind of frustrating seeing we were celebrating 2 Birthdays. After that had to get up twice from the table to ask for our boxed food we had not received yet and also the bill. Ended up getting our bill from another waiter which seemed frustrated that he had to lift a finger for his fellow staff. Being in the service industry myself left a bad taste in my mouth. You guys can visibly see he is seriously in the weeds and nobody offered to help. They just let him tank!!! I know RUBY himself would not tolerate this! Chris comes to the table to express his apologies and take care of our bill personally at this point he is in a full blown sweat :( We paid our bill. Here the waiter attendant comes with some more water NOT with our food he took 30+ minutes ago but more water!! We said where is our food you were supposed to box up 30 minutes ago??? Go's in the back get our food, 1 small bag for 3 people! Of course the side of béarnaise I ordered was not in there when we checked to see if it was even our food!!! At those point I didn't care I just wanted to leave!!! Do to other staff members not willing to pitch in and help out we were probably there an hour to an hour and 1/2 longer than we should have been. For a $500 + food bill including tip, I feel this experience should have gone waaaaaaay better. The " star " is for Chris holding it together. Thank you Chris ! read more

See all

Service was outstanding Hall was very accommodating. The lobster filet special was delicious. Steak was cooked perfectly. Bread service is so good. I had the oysters from East and west coast and they were amazing. Butter cake was their complimentary anniversary dessert and it never disappoints. Such a better experience than some of our last visits here. Bar staff was also very good and this visit we were seated at a beautiful booth. Kudos. read more

Not being big red meat eaters [my husband eats zero red meat, daughter is pescatarian, and I indulge in a good filet on special occasions] we are not big steakhouse aficionados. Following my precious Mom-in-Law's funeral last week, my husband wanted to treat the 3 of us to a relaxing, exceptional dining experience. He selected C&J and daughter clinched the reservation. Our dining experience was exceptional, to say the least! The closest I have come to dining at a restaurant like C&J is The Capital Grille in DC [dined there numerous times] and a Morton's in northern VA. Although both of these restaurants provide solid, exceptional experiences, C&J completely eclipsed both of them in every way possible! The abundant staff were all friendly, courteous, and beyond knowledgeable! They all really displayed a heart for service, which is exceptionally rare these days. I asked one of our servers about their training, being a long-time server/cocktail waitress "back in the day" myself, and I mentioned that they must have a 15 minute "stand up" meeting prior to service each shift. She said, "No, our training is much more extensive than that," which was clearly evident in their execution. Well done C&J! I absolutely love artichokes, and their treatment of the artichoke appetizer I ordered was exceptional [that adjective seems to be a theme here!], creative, and unique. It was very filling. It inspired me to go on an artichoke preparation adventure and try to replicate their recipe along with a long-time Italian version I've been wanting to cook. The gnocchi were delicious! The crab cake was exceptional, and all dishes were prepared to our special requests, plates removed at the appropriate time, and waters never empty - all inconspicuously and unobtrusively. Their wine list was the size of a small town's phone book, and daughter and I split a sauvignon blanc which was an excellent accompaniment to our dinner selections. Thank you, C&J for providing an uplifting memorable experience for our family, after such an extremely solemn day! We look forward to visiting your restaurant in nearby Nashville for a special occasion! read more

See all

My husband and I celebrated our 48th Wedding Anniversary at Carlo & Johnny October 15th. The Entrees were absolutely delicious we enjoyed Filet Mignon, Mashed Potatoes, Mushrooms and Salad. As soon as we arrived the waiter served complementary Champaign to celebrate our Anniversary and our names were printed at the top of the menu we were given! The atmosphere is romantic, elegant and beautifully decorated. Our waiter Greg filled us in on the History of the restaurant and the possibility of a Ghost haunting. It was a very enjoyable evening and I would recommend Carol & Johnny we definitely will be returning. read more

The service and food are absolutely standout and the location is beautiful! It was tastefully decorated for Christmas and had a cozy feel with the fireplaces lit upstairs. Although we had a few issues with our visit (long wait time despite a reservation, being out of cowboy steak and nori, and wrong side dish came out), our server, Jeff, and the manager did everything in their power to take care of us and make up for it. This 5 star care and the delicious food is why we always keep coming back to Carlo & Johnny (in addition to the other Jeff Ruby restaurants)! read more

We came here for our 10th Valentine's Day together this year. The service we had at the bar was phenomenal. I definitely recommend they were great. The drinks was great. The meals were out of this world. The dessert was incredible. Obviously an upscale steakhouse with a wonderful ambience. We even picked up a signature cigar for my husband. The quality of the cigar was out of this world. The ice cream cigar mousse dessert we had was also one of the best presentations I've ever seen in my life. Jeff Rubys completely out of their selves with this one. To top it off, we had reservations at 10 PM and normally when you have reservations late at a restaurant, you're not expecting to have quite quality service by that point in the evening, but man they were just on point. Amazing staff highly recommend taking your loved ones here. read more

See all

Food incredible, service amazing, great vibe in this place as always. Fantastic place for special occasions, not cheep but for the food and service not a bad value for your money! read more

See all

Ashley and Kate were the staff at bar and they greeted us promptly. Kate was on it as soon as we sat down. I asked for recommendations and she was on it! She got me their moscato and then recommended the surf and turf special with salad, Freddy 6oz lobster tail, 6 oz petite steak and mashed potato's. Dessert was a hbd treat with whipped cheesecake butter pie and truffle chocolate. Every item was very delicious and prepared exactly as we asked. I'd definitely return. I appreciated the hospitality and service provided by their team. Parking is out front for free or there is valet as well. It's dark inside the restaurant so this would be good for a date night spot as well. read more

See all

One of the best place to dine in Cincy area , never disappointed, the new addition of the menus ---Sushiiiii ! Omg they are so yummy ! The Crab cake is on point , and of course Steak never can go wrong ! read more

See all