The sushi was excellent. They have a pretty good selection if you like spicy alternatives. The fish all seemed to be fresh and nothing was out of place or taste bad. My wife got a sushi bowl and the rice veggies,etc where all perfect. Always love to trying a new sushi place and this one I will definitely be going back to. I guess if I had to give them one downfall it's that they only have a few beers and no sake. Nothing too drastic just me being picky. read more

Great food! Great people! This is a family run business. I am so thankful they are only 1 mile from my home. Must try items: garlic edamame, fried plantains and miso soup. I could make a meal of those alone. The sushi is huge, like two rolls from anywhere else. They will customize your order. My husband hated sushi before this place. This is now his favorite restaurant in all of Tulsa/BA. read more

This is my new goto place for sushi in south tulsa, I will give a tip and say go with the "Caribbean sushi" and not the regular sushi...I tried the regular sushi and it wasn't anything special and almost earned them 3 stars but I loved the other so they get 5 stars....try half and half of s fee rolls, they are huge and you'll be glad you did!! read more

This place really surprised me, despite the already high rating! It's next to a Ross, too, so you can walk and shop after! Despite arriving during the lunch hour, the place was empty, so I was a little worried the ratings were off, but a a couple of tables came in after me. The miso soup was a part of a Yelp check in offer, so I ordered that, the side salad, and the spicy tuna roll minus the mayo sauce. Not knowing how big the roll would be, I didn't immediately appreciate the lunch prices! It was $10 for 12 large pieces and the sides were a $1 each. The sushi chef asked me if I liked "hot" and when I said yes, he gave me a side of mango habenero sauce for my roll, and it really gave it a unique flavor! Only a small bit needed, haha Wonderful presentation on each dish, clean and well decorated restaurant, and friendly staff. The only thing I would change is having the avocado in the roll be more ripe. This is a BA gem! read more

I've visited twice so far. The edemame is delicious! I tried several rolls with no complaints! The rolls are fairly good size. Service was great; the place is small but cozy and the decor is pretty nice (great place for a date) read more

This is the best sushi in Tulsa! The chef knows how to create some amazing rolls! We have been here several times and have started getting chefs choice each time! They are great! The garlic edamame is delicious too! Sit at the bar and enjoy the art of sushi making. read more

Nobody should have given this restaurant just 2 stars. Especially not over cream cheese. This is THE sushi spot in Broken Arrow. The rolls are masterfully prepared, the miso soup was the best I've had in Oklahoma and the fresh ingredients were well beyond par for Oklahoma. Last time I had this good of sushi, it was fresh catch and served in the seaside town of Newport Beach, Oregon. The chef knew what he was doing, we ordered the "okansaka?" Chef's choice platter plus a few rolls out of their oven, and we could not have been happier. Try it for yourself and see. read more

This is my absolute favorite sushi place in the Tulsa/BA area. The best miso soup I've ever had. I try and get something new each time... the staff are amazing with recommendations. read more

Ordered 4 things off their menu for takeout. Everything was delicious. They have Garlic Edamame...WHY has no one else THOUGHT OF THIS?!? SOOO GOOD!! Very cool setting/atmosphere. I was the only one in the restaurant at the time though, may be loud when it is packed. Liked A LOT of stuff on their menu. Everything I got was fantastic, bit on the pricey side IMO (but it's been a while since I've been to a sushi place). read more

The sushi is amazing! The rolls are big and creative and there's a lot of variety. Some of their rolls have fried plantains which I had never had before eating here and wow it's delicious! I never would have thought I'd like fruit in a sushi roll but the flavor combinations are really good! The lunch specials are a really good deal and I like that you can get half portion rolls! Great vibes and kind employees. The owners are also really nice and they are always there! Definitely recommend. read more

Not your average sushi bar! This place is amazing. A different delicious take on sushi. A must try. I will be back. I'm going to need to try everything on the menu. read more

Being in a land-locked state sometimes people resolve themselves to knowing that we don't always have the freshest seafood around. However that opinion would be completely unfounded with Caribbean sushi! Fresh, well presented, everything you would expect from an upscale sushi restaurant! I'll be back for more soon! read more

Caribbean Sushi - The damage! - Sushi Bars Near Me - Broken Arrow, Oklahoma

My friend brought me to this hidden gem in the middle of a shopping center in broken arrow. We started out with an amazing garlic edamame appetizer. The sushi rolls (Caribbean roll) were fresh and different from the usual Japanese sushi. The owner greeted us warmly and brought two sauces to try with the sushi. One sauce was a sweet and hot habanero mango concoction. The other was a magical combination of siracha and chipotle. It complimented the plantain sushi that we also ordered to perfection. The restaurant was decorated in a tastefully playful manner. This was the first time I tried a "sushi meets Caribbean" flavored fusion. The unique twist on sushi is drawing me back to this place soon! I hope it stays in business. Please try it then spread the word! You won't regret it! read more

Excellent food, skillfully and artistically prepared, I recommend this place

Came in from out of town to visit a friend and decided upon Caribbean Sushi for our sushi fix based on the reviews. NOT DISAPPOINTED! I ordered for lunch pick up. The staff was extremely generous and kind. They even threw in some extra sauces for us to try! We were thoroughly satisfied. The prices were what you'd expect. If I lived here I would certainly frequent this business, but instead I'll be glad to order from Caribbean Sushi the next time I'm in town. read more

After returning to Caribbean a few more times since my previous review, I wanted to update my feelings on the place. When I went back to Caribbean, I ordered a few customs rolls and love how open they are with customization! They really will take care of you. The customer service is always great. They hire top notch wait staff. read more

My daughter and I love coming here! The Caribbean Roll is amazing. The atmosphere is calm and there always fun Asian music videos playing. The staff is super friendly. read more

Delicious!!! Not only great food, but also great service. Starting off with the garlic edamame is a must and then I have yet to try a roll that I haven't loved. Philly is a personal favorite! read more

I love sushi and had high hopes as it came highly recommended. My husband and I tried 4 different rolls and an appetizer and it just wasn't good. Soggy, fishy, and the flavors were just really weird. Way overpriced. Memories of Japan tastes way better and has way lower prices. It was so bad that we didn't finish our food and didn't care to take it home with us. Spent a bunch of money on food that we did not like at all. I know now that I do not like the Caribbean/Japanese fusion but that wasn't the only problem. I've never had fishy sushi, it was a huge turn off. read more

LOVE this place and their slightly different twist on sushi. The people are great and the food is better. I like their kid-friendly children's menu options, too. Wish they served wine and/or sake... but it certainly doesn't keep me from stopping by. read more

Probably my favorite sushi place ever. Owners and staff are fun and friendly. You won't regret stopping here.

This place is a hidden gem. The tuna is so fresh and literally melts in your mouth. Service amazing. Food amazing. My favorite sushi spot in tulsa area! read more

great prices and friendly environment. and super nice in modifying rolls:) have only been here twice so i cant say what my favorites are yet but so far great! read more

Went here for the first time this week after a recommendation from a friend and ended up going back again the next day because I couldn't get enough! The staff is friendly and the fish is fresh! I had a tuna poke bowl and it was INCREDIBLE! The garlic edamame is a must! Looking at the menu online, I was a little nervous of the cost, however the rolls are much larger than other sushi places and worth every penny! The staff is flexible and willing to tailor the rolls on the menu to you (i.e. If you don't want cream cheese in your roll, ask for it without cream cheese). The best part is their homemade sauces, which give an interesting spin the the already amazing sushi rolls! read more

We absolutely love Caribbean Sushi! They have several vegetarian options -harvest roll is a must. The tempera vegetables are delicious and they have endless miso soup!!! read more

My wife and I were pleasantly surprised to find such a good sushi place in Broken Arrow. They have a large selection and everything we had was great. Service can be slow, but the food is worth it. read more