Captain Jack's Roadside Shack is the kind of seasonal seafood spot that attracts attention the moment the food starts coming out of the kitchen. We walked up to a casual outdoor seating area with picnic tables set alongside the road, giving it the laid back atmosphere of a New England seafood shack where the focus is entirely on generous portions and classic seafood favorites rather than anything overly polished. The setup is simple and relaxed, making it an easy stop for a casual lunch or dinner during the warmer months. The lobster roll is the clear highlight here. The portion was surprisingly large for the price, packed generously and substantial enough to feel like a full meal on its own. The lobster was the star of the sandwich, and the overall value stood out given how expensive lobster rolls have become across Massachusetts. We also ordered the fish and chips, which came with an equally generous portion size, though the fish was a little drier than expected. While it was still satisfying, it lacked some of the moisture and flakiness that would have made it more memorable. What stands out most is the portion to price ratio. Nearly everything coming out of the kitchen is oversized, which helps explain why the restaurant has built such a strong reputation as a destination for seafood in the area. The food leans toward hearty and filling rather than refined, and the experience works best when you arrive hungry and ready for a substantial meal. Service moved efficiently despite the steady crowds, and the casual outdoor setting kept the experience relaxed. For anyone looking for a classic roadside seafood stop in Western Massachusetts, Captain Jack's delivers generous portions, solid seafood, and a lobster roll that easily justifies the visit. read more

See all

I'm intrigued by getting a full belly clam roll here, but I've been spoiled by eating at Bob's up in Kittery, ME. So rating on the Chicago dogs - hit the spot. Great find in Northampton. I'll be back for the kraut - and maybe a clam roll. read more

Captain Jack's Roadside Shack - Chicago Dogs - Seafood Near Me - Easthampton, Massachusetts

Ahoy Matey! If you're looking for one of the best whole belly clams or fish tacos then welcome to Captain Jack's Roadside shack. I've coming here for a few years already and finally decided to officially review it. Whole belly clams are plump and juicy and the fish tacos are delicious. Plus you get two tacos per order. What a deal! I love the contrast between the cold crunchy cabbage/cilantro and hot crispy fish. The belly platter comes with a small side of coleslaw and fries but you can substitute the fries for the onion rings for only $.50 more. It's worth it! Their haystack style onion rings are super skinny and tasty. Portions are generous too! Lobster rolls are great with nice large lump and claw meat. However, I would recommend to go when the lobsters are in season between June and December so the meat is sweeter. Outdoor seatings are plentiful but in the winter, you can sit inside the river valley co*op market next door. Service is friendly, quick, and simple. One window for ordering and one to pick up. I always come here once or twice a year when I visit my Northampton friend. Highly recommend this place for comfort and casual dining! read more

See all

I ordered fried clam dinner. The fries were cold, the clams were gross. 35.00 paid for a meal that truly was gross

The lobster roll is absolutely amazing! There's so much lobster in it that we got an extra roll and my husband and I split it. The onion strings are to die for! read more

Captain Jack's Roadside Shack - Seafood Near Me - Easthampton, Massachusetts

Great lobster roll. Used to be a regular stop. Unfortunately the manager had an attitude and was rude and condescending (and untruthful). Followed up with the owner, who clearly doesn't care about customers or feedback. Haven't been back since. read more

The best lobster roll! Just back from the Cape. I had the most disappointing lobster roll in Orleans. Couldn't wait to get back here for one at Captain Jacks. So much delicious lobster! Split the roll with my mother, and it was plenty for both of us! One star off because we couldn't stand the smell from the trash cans! We moved our seats, twice! read more

We were looking for a spot to get a lobster roll while we were traveling through the area, and we chose Captain Jack's. It was DELICIOUS! So good and so glad we stopped. The roll was packed with lobster, and the fries were great too. You order at the window, and all the tables and seating are outside. They call your name when your order is ready. We didn't have to wait too long, and it was a beautiful day so it was nice to sit outside. Definitely stop here for a lobster roll! read more

Captain Jack's Roadside Shack - a lobster sandwich and fries - Seafood Near Me - Easthampton, Massachusetts

One of my requests during my visit to Massachusetts was to visit this place. We lucked out and it was empty. Plenty of outdoor seating and no line. I knew I wanted the lobster roll. My husband went a little crazy and ordered fish tacos and fish and chips as well. Daughter in law had the clam sandwich. So much food! Expensive but I feel like it was worth it. Quality seafood. Delicious! Perfect visit. So glad we came. read more

See all

They didn't have clams at Captain Jack's Roadside shack because prices had gone up 70% last week, so I settled for the best lobster roll I've ever had, anywhere. The onion rings also were the best, thin, sweet, crispy. My lemonade too! I have had lobster rolls from Maine to Rhode Island, but this beat them all. Why? Generosity. The sweet lobster meat was loaded onto a buttery roll then placed on top of a pile of the most delicate onion rings imaginable. The guys inside the shack deserve applause. read more

See all

There's a certain romanticism behind the idea of being in New England, stopping by a roadside seafood shack, ordering a Lobster Roll and sitting outside while enjoying the Summer breeze. Actually, that's probably on a lot of people's bucket list. I only recently found out about this place thanks to Yelp, but it was a little confusing because even though there was a sign for Captain Jacks, we couldn't visibly see it from the roadside. All you could see was the River Valley Co-Op, and even while driving around the parking lot, we had to ask someone to find out that it was located behind the building. An additional sign in the parking lot would've been helpful. You form a line and order at the window and wait for your number to be called. Depending on what you order, it could be a good deal or very expensive. On this visit a lobster roll was $30 and it came with hand cut fries. I never finished the roll even though I ate from it and both my mom and dad ate from it too. The scallops were good but being a Floridian and having had many scallops in my lifetime, this wasn't the best I've had but again, it was good. We also had the fish and chips and those were just ok. I wish the fish had been a little bit more crispy, or maybe that's the NE way? I think the little onion rings were better than the fries. Overall the food to me was just ok. The ambience and setup they have is very nice, especially on a cool summer day. I could see myself coming back here sometime if I were in the area. read more

Captain Jack's Roadside Shack - A feast - Seafood Near Me - Easthampton, Massachusetts

See all

My wife and I both really like Captain Jack's Roadside Shack. It is truly a classic mostly seafood shack which would more commonly be seen along the Maine and Massachusetts coastline. We most commonly have ordered clam or lobster rolls, The portions are generous and quite tasty and are companied with an ample portion of French fries or onion rings. There is lots of outdoor seating. The servers are friendly, efficient and helpful in making choices. The Shack is right next door to the River Valley co-op, one of our favorite places locally to food shop in Easthamptonand very close to Northampton. Barry read more

Well well well. We found it. On a trip back from an anniversary night in Burlington, VT we drove back home and randomly stumbled upon this restaurant. It had some of the best seafood we had ever had. Well we could never remember the name. A few years later and we were driving around and finally found it. Just as good as we remember. Something new to celebrate. read more

Sunday lunch at Captain Jacks exceeded all expectations! Went there for the lobster roll substituted onion rings for fries. The Lobster roll easily had enough lobster to make rolls, delicious and so generous on the portions. The onion rings where thin shoestring which I absolutely love. Jacks is in a small building, with outdoor seating only which is shared with neighboring Ri er Valley Coop; the dining area is covered which is nice as it was very sunny the day we were there. I will be back again! read more

Captain Jack's Roadside Shack - An amazing lobster roll! - Seafood Near Me - Easthampton, Massachusetts

Yummy food with outside tables to eat at. Great view of the sunset. Not gluten free friendly.

Seriously fresh and delicious lobster rolls! Light mayo so the flavor of lobster really shines through. The buttered up roll compliments the lobster's flavor! Service was quick. Also you can choose to eat outside or inside the Co-op. And there's clean restrooms and plenty of parking. Definitely coming back ! read more

Captain Jack's Roadside Shack - Lobster rolls - Seafood Near Me - Easthampton, Massachusetts

See all

The clams, scallops, lobster roll all were good but the French fries were not. They were thin, limp and greasy. The onion rings were onion strings, just delicate threads of batter. They crumbled to the touch. The main part of the meal was good but the sides need some work. The lemonade was so sour it was hard to drink. read more

What can you say ? Hands-down my favorite lobster roll ever. But that is just the beginning. The onion straws/rings are out of this world. They are worth the trip by themselves. Keep up the good work love this place. read more

See all

Captain Jack's is the only place around with decent seafood. Their lobster roll is epic!! They also make a good clam chowder. They're not inexpensive but I, for one, prefer quality over anything. It's a roadside shack and seating is outside. It's very unassuming but you're guaranteed good food! read more

We were in the seafood mood. Decided on a stop at captain jacks roadside stand in easthampton. Great open outdoor seating with plenty of picnic tables and covered with "sails". It's a walk up and order type of place. I ordered a lobster roll with onion strings instead of hand cut fries and a clam basket. I was a bit hesitant for the $60 I paid but I must say....well worth it. The presentation was impressive for a clam shack. The lobster roll was overflowing with tail and claw meat in a delicate mayonnaise blend. Not too much....served with a nice wedge of lemon. No it wasn't fresh lobster but being 120 miles from the coast what can you expect? The volume of this nicely grilled roll with green leaf lettuce was more than worth the price. I had to knock off lobster just to pick up the roll to eat it. The onion strings melted in my mouth. So good. The clam plate ($27) was just as delicious. Perfectly cooked whole belly clams with hand cut fries, slaw and tartar sauce....of course a side of lemon wedge. This was a larger portion and cheaper than what cape cod prices were. Staring at Mt. Tom in the distance was just as satisfying as staring at a waterfront. The portions are worth the prices. Great outdoor seating area. Also very good non seafood options. read more

Captain Jack's Roadside Shack - Clam plate and side of onion strings - Seafood Near Me - Easthampton, Massachusetts

See all

Amazing lobsta roll. Great onion straws! Staff is pleasant and works great. Easy to order read more

Captain Jack's Roadside Shack - Lobster roll with onion straws - Seafood Near Me - Easthampton, Massachusetts

best lobster roll on the planet... and the clams are pretty good too! Funny location .... but great food. The Lobster roll is HUGE. read more

I had to wait in the hot sun for my order. For the price I felt the quality should have been better. The fried clams were soggy. Will not be going back. read more

I stopped today for some whole belly clams and fish and chips. Man who took my order was polite and friendly. Order took about 8-10 mins to cook. The fries were underwhelming but edible. Cole slaw was good. The fish was kind of dry but not over cooked - the breading was a little soggy. The whole bellys had a different taste. Not necessarily spoiled but not really fresh. Odd aftertaste which I thought may be the oil not being fresh. About an hour later, both me and my lady had diarrhea. I'm not positive it was the food, could have been the Dunkin coffee. Either way, not very good, pricy and will not return. read more

The best Lobster roll in Western Massachusetts! AND the onion straws/rings are to die for! We visit family in this area three times a year and I always make sure we get to go to Captain Jack's and get high on Lobster!! read more

Very casual carry out only w/ outside picnic tables. Didnt even look at anything but fried seafood. Hubbie got fish + chips- big portion of fish/ great light batter/skinny but good fries, alsi plentiful. I got clam bellies, fries+slaw for$27. Good sized portion, tasted great. Place is in town, but surrounded by plants, so fairly private. Be aware- its Behind the food co-op- you might never see it otherwise. read more

The best lobster rolls in Western Massachusetts. Nobody else comes close. Not inexpensive, but worth every penny.

Had fish & chips there last week and it was delicious and generous. Three large pieces of white fish (I think) wonderful but the fries are lousy grease, over cooked but overly generous. read more

Stopped here today and the lobster roll was outstanding! a little pricey, but well worth it. It came with fries that were really good too! great service and quick order completion. Seating is plentiful, but all outside. read more

Captain Jack's Roadside Shack - Lobster roll and fries - delish! - Seafood Near Me - Easthampton, Massachusetts

These guys are crushing it. Huge lobster roll piled to the lid with lobster. Love it, thank you!

Above average all around. No complaints in any way. This is a food shack next to a co-op. They go well above expectations.

4 stars for giant portions, fresh lobster and delicious thin cut crispy onion strings. The only thing holding it from 5 stars is that the pricing is up there. No shame in sharing given the price and generous portions. Just fyi that the only seating is outdoor picnic bench style. read more

Captain Jack's Roadside Shack - Lobster roll - Seafood Near Me - Easthampton, Massachusetts

OK, everything I've had here is delicious--fish fry, hot dogs, crispy chicken sandwich, fries, slaw-- but honestly, my #1 favorite thing on the menu? The thing I dream about and will come here just for? The onion rings. I feel like "rings" is a smidge inaccurate because they are cut so finally that the only thing keeping them from being "strings" or shoelace style is they somehow manage to (mostly) remain intact end-to-end. They are fried perfectly, seasoned perfectly, and are utter heaven for people who like salty crispy light things. Also: servings are ridiculously generous, you can bring your own beer, the picnic tables closer to the trees are in shade and there's a view of the Mt Tom/Holyoke range, and it's all set back far enough from the road to feel peaceful. Oh! And you can bring your friendly dog. read more

See all

Their food is delicious with many fish and other choices. I do believe Captain Jack's is open only in warm weather since all eating is outside. A friend and I often eat there. I highly recommend it'!! read more

Been going here for years. Food is always good. Service is good. Tends to be a little line so make sure you get there early.

OMG! This place has THE BEST seafood! Their LOBSTER ROLLS seem like they have TWO LOBSTERS in them! Their ONION RINGS are thin & crispy, and DELICIOUS. Their fries are very good, but my favorite are their SWEET POTATO FRIES! The SCALLOPS are PERFECTLY cooked, and also quite delectable! I've heard their other foods are very good, too, but their seafood is amazing, that I can't order anything else! I have yet to try their fried clams, but I'm sure they won't disappoint! read more

Great tacos. Great service and overall superb ambiance. It may be cold out during winter, but the location offers the ability to eat within the adjacent market. I could not recommend this place more. read more

Did road trip to pick up something in the area and saw this on yelp. Reviews were generally positive so figure we give it a try. Look at how generous of the portion. We paid $22 vs when we were up in Maine a few years ago and paid $20 lobster roll on a hot dog roll with barely any lobster meat which was full of mayo and no fries. Now on to the taste test - The lobster meat was amazing with just enough of mayo and the bread was soo buttery that it melts in your mouth as we took each bite. Normally I am not fan of homemade fries because they are too thick. But this fries were like shoestring fries and it has a perfect texture of crunchy and starch. Go out of your way to check them out and you won't be disappointed. read more

Captain Jack's Roadside Shack - Lobster roll - Seafood Near Me - Easthampton, Massachusetts

This place is enjoyable even if you're a land lubber I got the barbecue chicken sandwich and the little fried onions and pickles made the sandwich. The home made fries were crunchy and delicious. Lots of outdoor seating. read more

See all

Holy Wow! This place is a do.not.miss! As others have mentioned, it's a little tricky to find. It's at the local food co-op. Park and go to the front door of the co-op and then you will see it between there and the road all the way toward the back. There is an enormous amount of outdoor picnic table seating. We ordered the famous lobster roll with fries and a clam basket . The Lobster roll is enough to feed two people, especially with the fries. We saw many people order food to go, but proceeded to eat there and take the rest home. The clam basket was also fantastic-- whole belly clams delicately fried-- so fresh and delicious! These were my favorite but only because it seems to rare to get such high quality whole belly clams. I do wish they had cocktail sauce, but they do not (and honestly, wasn't really missed). We ordered the onion straws with the clam basket, and if I lived near here, I would order them once a week just to sprinkle on vegetables, salads, etc. Soooooo good and light. The above with two drinks and a 20% tip came to $65. Considering that if we weren't just passing through town we could have easily had 4 meals from this, it was such a great deal! We are in New England yearly and Captain Jack's is already on our list of must return locations. read more