This place was a welcome surprise! We were just picking random places off Maps to try and came across this one. Was a winner! The wings were delicious. Got spicy buffalo and got an order to go for later. Pizza was thin crust and while the crust was a little floppy the fresh meats on our meat lovers more than made up for it! It was delicious! The employees were so nice. We had four people say hello at once when we walked in. Definitely gonna come back for more! read more

Amazing! We had the Italian beef pizza and deluxe pizza. So flavorful. We started with the garlic fries- so delicious, we didn't even need ketchup or ranch. And lastly we had the cookie skillet desert. So decadent. It was such a pleasant experience. read more

See all

The vibe inside was nice. The staff were not attentive, though they were nice to a few young regulars. They never offered to refill our drinks, and charged us the credit card charge despite us using gift cards. When our pizza finally came out, it was smaller than the size we ordered. The pizza itself wasn't our favorite. Hopefully we have a better experience if we try again! read more

Delivery order arrived ice cold and pizza was completely dumped. Zero quality control. Will never try again. read more

Candlelite Chicago - Pizza box as delivered. Medium Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Very thin crust that doesn't leave you groggy afterwards! If you are a garlic and onion fan, go with the Candlelite White Pizza. The Margarita Pizza is also very good, and not soggy surprisingly since it contains a tomato. For salads, the candlelight salad was a hit. Good food, but don't expect to be stuffed afterwards, which is a good thing! read more

See all

Had an amazing atmosphere for watching the games along with amazing food and amazing service. My favorite was the cheese pizza which had the perfect cheese to sauce to crust ratio. read more

We ordered a deluxe pizza from here for the first time on uber eats and we received the smallest pizza in the world. It was supposed to be a 14 inch medium pizza for $26.50.... had I known we were paying $26.50 for a TINY pizza, I would've never done it. Overall taste was good but prices are insane!!!! read more

Candlelite Chicago - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

This place has never disappointed. My first time here was back in the 2000s when I lived in the area. I now live in Edison Park and I'd still go here. For their Feta fries, any of their pizza, and their service. Top notch, excellent neighborhood establishment. read more

Candlelite Chicago - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Our server/bartender genuinely approached my partner and I as we entered the restaurant for a quick late night meal, The menu offers plenty of delicious options but not overwhelming If you're not quite sure what you want. We ordered 2 shareable sized appetizers including the wings and loaded tots. My partner enjoyed a classic French Dip and it was delicious so we ordered a meat-lovers pizza to go. Our server was friendly and attentive and the meals came out fresh and In a timely manner. We will definitely go back. read more

Candlelite Chicago - Buffalo/Chipotle Wings and Loaded Tots - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

This place is the HOME of Chicago Tavern Style Thin Crust Pizza. You gotta go in, chat with owners Pete & Pat, hang out at the bar and complain about sports ball. This is a pub that we Love coming to again and again. We have lots of memories there and no one can top there pizza game. read more

Great food and service. The retro video game systems are fun. Definitely a good spot to eat and drink

We have heard about this palace from several people but decided to go after someone from the restaurant industry recommended checking out their big one get one free pizza deals on Tuesdays. The pizza is delicious. I highly recommend the margarita pizza, the veggie pizza suffered a bit from the standard issues that impact this pizza at most places we have visited, but we are looking forward to trying all of the pizzas here in the years to come because it's absolutely incredible. read more

Candlelite Chicago - the neon sign for candlelite - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Best Tavern style Pizza in the City of Chicago. They are opening soon in Lincoln Park at the IO Theater Comedy Venue (1501 N. Kingsbury); can't wait! read more

Evanston prices in Rogers Park. We had the pan meat lovers pizza and didn't think it was anything special. It was the perfect amount for two people to share. I see from the reviews that people ask for their pizza "well done" here, and I agree. Our pizza needed to go back in the oven for a few more minutes. Drinks were ok-but you can get the same thing at similar bars in the area, Howard Street Inn or Bringer Inn, for dollars less. read more

Candlelite is a Chicago staple. My family has been coming here for decades. The food is fantastic and staff always goes above and beyond. We just had a family event there the other day and it could not have gone better. Jessica took fantastic care of us. Highly recommend holding an event there. read more

An absolutely perfect neighborhood bar. Some of the best service in Chicago to boot. They are always accommodating and the biggest (maybe only) hiccups come when they are rented out. read more

I haven't handed out many 5s from my friends' monthly pizza nite, but this one deserves it. It's a little out of our bailiwick but well worth the drive. It's crispy without being cracker-thin or cardboard like. It's well balanced and positively addictive. They serve a nice but not ridiculously long list of drafts and more in bottles and cans. Great onion rings and tots, too. Good, Friendly service. Free parking across the street too. I wish I was there right now. read more

We went for dinner tonight with two young friends, celebrating a birthday. We were made to feel so, so welcome...and while we were being seated, the gentleman asked the name of the young woman celebrating her birthday, and then placed it on the sign outside the restaurant. She was thrilled. And, he added a gift which she greatly appreciated. In addition, the food was really great. Two of us are vegetarians, and had no trouble finding selections on the menu. And my husband, who is ultra fussy about his food loved his dinner. The young woman who took our orders was great. We will definitely go back to this warm and friendly restaurant. read more

Candlelite Chicago - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Great, great bar. It offers upscale good without getting upscale with the atmosphere or the prices. The burgers are really good--always well/prepared with good toppings. We are big, BIG fans in their pizzas, some of the best I've had (and I love pizza, so take that to the bank). They've got several TVs for sports but keep the sound off so you can have your convo without having to shout. Oh, and if you like tater tots, this is the place. read more

Candlelite Chicago - They will personalize their display for special events if you ask them. - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Disappointed in the pizza. Ordered 2 mediums and both had burned crust and sparse toppings. Chopped salad was very good, though.

Was just coming here to write that I've become a regular customer of their frozen pizzas through GoldBelly. I did also recently see they launched their own website (candlelitechicagopizzas.com) with cheaper prices, which I've also tried a few times now. I felt like I was crazy when I came here and read @Chris M's review. Holy smokes Chris, I couldn't disagree more! Candlelite frozen pizza might be the best high-quality frozen pizza I've had. I live next to Pequods - and Pequods is great! - but I'd choose a frozen Candlelite White or BBQ Chicken over a fresh Pequods. I hate to say it but I fear Chris M doesn't know pizza like I know pizza (if you saw me you'd immediately say "Wow, that guy knows pizza"). How Candlelite has been able to translate the quality of their in-restaurant pizza into frozen pizza is beyond me, maybe they have scientists in the kitchen there (I'm no scientist, I just know pizza). If you're local and feel safe in this environment, I definitely suggest getting it in person as I like the family atmosphere of the restaurant, plus the TVs, beer, and cookie skillet (I also know cookie skillets). However if you aren't local and/or prefer a pizza at home, their frozen pizza is a great option in bringing Candlelite to you. read more

Candlelite Chicago - a closeup of a candlelite white pizza - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

The wedge salad is very good. Along with pepperoni pizza. Great combination. Awesome service!! Thank you

The food is excellent and so is the service. The entire staff is pleasant and efficient.

Every summer and winter, my friends and I come here for dinner before we leave to go back to school, and without fail, they have always amazed us with excellent service and food! We got the poutine and the fried pickles as our appetizers and they tasted great! For the entrée, we got a large pizza with two flavors, one side was Margherita and the other was a new flavor, Sweet Soppressata. I really liked the Sweet Soppressata, however I wish there was some more hot honey on it. The Margherita side was also terrific! For dessert, we have always gotten a cookie skillet, but since it's so good, this time we got two! And we finished both of them. The cookie skillet has been my favorite dessert ever, and I definitely recommend! Our servers were Charlie and Peter and they were great! Very kind. They also added a jugglar outside for entertainment, the jugglar was very kind as well and it was very fun watching him juggle! read more

See all

Great service Great wedge salad and white pizza Will definitely go back Owner was present and friendly read more

Just a lil' update to this review; since COVID, they've started offering delivery, all the way into the city, and the food is still great. They've upgraded their packaging as well. Candlelite is a bit off the beaten path, at the edge of the city about 2 blocks before it becomes Evanston.  I used to work in the area, which is the only reason I know about this gem. It's a divey sports bar atmosphere, but the food and service are good enough that I drive all the way over there at least once a month.  The pizza is the standout - great Chicago style thin-crust pizza, hot and fresh.  One of my favorite places in the city for thin crust pizza. The salads are also amazing. I love a real ranch dressing; few places make their own and the jarred ones usually taste like mayo and nothing else, but Candlelite has great ranch. Great wings. And a great wedge salad with the infamous ranch, blue cheese crumbles & french fried onions. Also, the owners and staff are always in a great mood, the service is fast and friendly, and you can park right out front.  They do also have a good selection of craft beer. If you're in this hood and looking for good bar food, this is the place to be! read more

***PLEASE NOTE: This review is only based on the take out experience*** Thin crust pizza is my favorite kind of pizza. I hail from Chicago and although I should be indoctrinated to like Chicago deep dish, I find deep dish to be extremely heavy. I eat one slice and I'm done; leaving me with a food baby in my belly! It's been awhile since I've had a good thin crust and thankfully Candelite did well on my order with only one minor exception. I ordered a large sausage and mushroom thin crust for pick up and by the time I came home with it, the pizza was cold. The crust was so thin that after a 20 minute drive, it couldn't stay warm. Perhaps the box wasn't well insulated? Either way, it was a lesson learned. Eat your thin crust in house. This was my rookie mistake. If your going to eat thin crust here, you'll have to eat it fresh at the restaurant while it is still hot. The taste of the pizza is delicious and the bar atmosphere is quite friendly. SIDE NOTES Party rooms are available for private events. Inquire within to reserve your date. Lastly, take advantage of their specials. $5.00 bloody Mary's on Saturdays keep me coming back! read more

See all

**DISCLAIMER: This was delivery only** Ever heard of an order gone bad? I'm writing this an hour after eating it, because it was that bad. Horror story not so much, but bogus place/never getting again? Definitely. I got this because Jean C had much to proffer about the Garlic Fries. My girlfriend and I *LOVE* garlic so hey, not a bad idea right? So we get Garlic Fries and a White Pizza. My thoughts were that it was kinda new-york ish. So where to begin? Well, the phone guy was rude as hell, all "I've been here a long time hurry up", and apparently we get a $3 delivery? I've heard of places with $2, that's normal, but I don't get what the extra buck is for. Anyway, delivery done. The one plus is that they found our apartment complex and the right door properly, and quickly. My girlfriend noted that the Pizza wasn't hot, and that maybe this place is decent for a stoner. Anyway, take a look at the pics. Where the hell is the feta, and what happened to caramelized onions? We like onions just like we like garlic, but you know, it helps to get what you order. If you order a peanut butter sandwich you don't expect raw peanuts with butter. Lastly, to pay $29 for a "large" (like 12 or 14") that is probably the size of a small at places like Traitoria Demi, I will pass on ever considering these guys again. Maybe they're better as a bar? I don't plan to find out. read more

Candlelite Chicago - where's the feta on the fries we ordered? - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

I had been here recently and was not too impressed by their pizza but decided to give them another try because I received a promo code for some free food. This time I decided to try their other items aside from the pizza. I was very impressed with their fried pickles, loaded tots, and Nutella poppers. The fried pickles were huge and juicy rather than the smaller thinner fried pickles I'm used to. The loaded tots had the perfect amount of toppings but I didn't particularly like the cheese curds that were mixed in as they were bland and too chewy. The Nutella poppers were so scrumptious with a wonderful caramel dip and vanilla ice cream to complement it. I'm glad I tried some other items from here! read more

See all

This was my first time at Candlelite, but I was pleasantly surprised. What I enjoyed most was their spacious interior seating. It's also pretty quiet for a sports bar; music wasn't loud at all. They have a good variety of food as well as beers, both bottle and draft. I had their wings in 2 different flavors: chipotle, and barbecue. The flavors weren't that bad and the meet was pretty good. The only thing I didn't like was that the wings for smothered in sauce and it just seemed a little overkill. That night they were offering a free pint of beer with the purchase of any burger. Now that's a great deal that I would go back for it. UPDATE: I went back to try their pizza and I liked how many toppings they had to offer. I had feta with ground beef and it was good. I really appreciated the customer service I received when I ordered a beer I didn't like; my server offered to get me a new beer at no extra cost. This is a great neighborhood spot to watch the big game on the many t.v's or just hang out with a friend read more

Candlelite Chicago - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

I support local businesses and have loved this place for a long time. Unfortunately, the quality of their food for delivery is terrible, after three attempts. Go there in person. The food is outstanding when fresh out of the kitchen. Don't order delivery. read more

Food was not ready as indicated by the restaurant for pickup. I'm still waiting here for my food of which I did tip 20%. Wish I did not have a generous mind. Don't recommend this establishment. read more

Candlelite Chicago - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Great time! Arrived at around 7 p.m., we just found this place after moving from the West Loop and can not wait to make this spot our new neighborhood place! Finally found the BEST wings on the North Side, pizza is great! It was busy this last Saturday , but the service was very friendly and incredibly efficient, for as busy as they got. We almost closed the place down as we stayed for drinks that were also yummy. Headed back, perhaps on a week night, to check out the vibe! read more

The pizza is one of best in town-the crust is outstanding.Everything on the menu is good-love the chili and wings too !!

Amazing place and food! Just please update your grill/kitchen hours on yelp and online!

This place is an outstanding family neighborhood gem! A great bar and sit down areas. The Friday Fish Fry is excellent but the star of the show is the pizza! Perfectly crispy thin crust and delectable toppings. The White Pizza is outstanding!! Will come again and again!! read more

Great pizza and salads! Candlelit is a hidden gem - the food and service are great and the restaurant is very comfortable. Nice people and a low key atmosphere. read more

Went there with my family. The one owner was super unfriendly. He stood there and stared at us pretty much the whole time we were in. I had my baby with who cried a little bit but we stopped him crying asap and did what we could of course because we are not rude inconsiderate people who don't care about people around us. The moment we walked in he didn't like us. We did nothing wrong. The pizza want the same like it used to be. Definitely changed. The bathroom for changing babies was dirty. No hook to hang the diaper bag or a purse. Had dirty rag laying and cleaner in there. We will never be back. And of course the owner tried clearing our table as fast as he could and didn't say thank you or bye on the way out. Wow nice management! read more

Honestly, don't know who rated this joint a tops for thin tavern style pizza. We ordered a well done 16in. sausage and received an under cooked ground meat mess. It was gross! 2 bites and we had to get out of there. The apps were decent (pickles and pretzel bites). Service was subpar, pizza was inedible. $60 waste. *Update* Owner offered to make the situation right, although I declined the kind gesture I think that says something for the owners of this place. I respect them for owning it and trying to make it right. Best of luck. read more

My recent experience here from this Saturday Night was from the Culinary Twilight Zone...a dining and pizza malpractice if you will. When I came here after 10 pm this past Saturday Night I had the level of understanding that this is not Giardano's or Gibsons but I still had some level of expectation as far as the Pizza was concerned. The Red Eye a few weeks ago named this as a good place for Pizza and that this "joint" as they say in the classics was underrated. After further consideration maybe they are doing drugs in the break room at Red Eye. Dont erase this review as I really know they are not doing drugs @Red Eye . This is just a phrase that I am dolling out for for Hyperbole. The fries were great. Of course How could fries not be great? It seemed like the pizza was frozen then unfrozen and then nuked for 15 minutes. It was a medium veggie style pizza. Seemed like the veggies were reheated and then put on the pizza. It was horrible. The worst pizza I have ever had in my life. It would be good only if you just got out of a North Korean Gulag and they had to freshen you up for a Red Cross visit. To top it off I watched 5 dudes break into someones car which may have been their friends who forgot his keys or may have not. While that was happening someone asked them for change. I would come back but only if the pizza was good. Dress Code? you dont have to worry about that. Wear anything. When ordering pizza, you should inquire or interrogate your server to find out what its all about. read more