I have been to this establishment probably half a dozen times in my life, never once had a bad experience. Tonight specifically, I went to dinner with my girlfriend for an early Valentine's Day dinner, and had yet another pleasant experience! I ordered a ribeye steak, it was cooked perfectly, which is something that rarely happens at restaurants. It was also very good, one of the best steaks I've ever had, which is especially impressive for a non-steakhouse! I was overall very impressed tonight that it prompted me to leave a review. Not that I haven't been impressed the other times. Our waiter, Chris, was also exceptional. Very speedy and proficient in the serving process. Very accommodating and constantly asking to help. Went above and beyond to ensure us a good experience. The atmosphere every-time I go is great, I always love the southern-like feel with the country music playing, and the clover leaf to highlight Irish heritage! Would recommend this place to anyone, they always deliver a great experience. Look forward to returning as I always do. They have never disappointed! Of course, nobody is perfect besides Jesus. My only critique is how long it took for us to be seated when we first arrived. This, of course, is a good sign for the restaurant, as they're busy! I'm just nitpicking, but I did get impatient while waiting to be seated. After that, I had yet another tremendous experience as always! I wish I was able to give 4.5 stars, because I don't like to give out 5s as nobody is perfect besides Jesus, however 4 stars is too low! Think of this as a 4.5 star review! Well done to Caffrey's as usual, and waiter Chris! read more

Tried this place for the first time yesterday. We've passed by it so many times. I'm glad we gave it a shot. Ate in the backyard part. Our waitress was very nice (can't remember her name). Our food was soooooo good! I can't wait to go back for more crab. The only complaint I have is the unsweetened iced tea tastes like water and the food runner girl was extremely unfriendly. Place is huge and clean. Looking forward to coming back and bringing some friends with us! read more

Caffrey's Tavern Backyard - This was the best crab I've ever had! So nice and sweet - American Near Me - Forked River, New Jersey

See all

I must say, the sushi selection is better here, at an Irish bar in NJ, than where I live in Florida! read more

Caffrey's Tavern Backyard - Picture says it all... - American Near Me - Forked River, New Jersey

See all

We were in the area for a Halloween event and my fiancé found this place as a go to spot. When we pulled in the parking lot was PACKED but managed to get a table right away. We didn't have to wait long for service either and our waitress was very good, making sure we had what we needed the entire time. We got an order of their cheese curds for the table. I honestly have to say they were probably the best cheese curds I've had anywhere! I got the steak and shrimp combo, which was an 8 Oz steak with 3 pieces of stuffed shrimp. The steak was flavorful and the shrimp was STUFFED. The mashed potatoes were great and I got their seafood bisque with it which was tasty. My only complaint was the steak was more medium rare when I ordered medium. I didn't say anything and still enjoyed the steak. With it being a Saturday there was college football on all the TVs so the place was Def loud, but you know to expect that! We would definitely come back read more

Stopped by for an ice cold beverage while visiting family. Our favorite bartender, Laura made us a delicious drink. My wife and I also tried their Sushi. I give it a 10+. DELICIOUS! Thank you, Caffrey's... See you again, soon read more

Caffrey's Tavern Backyard - Mermaid Water ~ Grey Goose vodka, Bacardi Coconut, Bacardi Pineapple, Blue Curacoo, Pineapple Juice, Splash of Sprite - American Near Me - Forked River, New Jersey

See all

Stopped by Caffrey's in Forked River on a Saturday night. The food itself was pretty good -- no complaints there -- but the overall experience was just okay. The restaurant was very busy, and parking was a bit of a nightmare. The backyard area was packed too, which made it hard to relax. The staff was fine, not overly friendly but not rude either -- just kind of in between. The biggest downside for me was how loud and chaotic it was. Between the crowd and the noise, it was tough to enjoy the meal. If you like a lively, bustling atmosphere, you'll probably love it here. But if you're looking for something more chill or quiet, this might not be the best spot. read more

We've eaten here quite a bit over the last year and love the food. The chicken & waffles special today was amazing. The chicken wasn't dry at all and the syrup tasted delicious. The French dip is made on garlic bread which gave it just a bit of a twist and upgrade from other French dips around town. The chicken fajita wrap, however, is what I recommend every time. I could put the fajita sauce on everything! The only downfall: the credit card charge. They aren't the only ones who do this but I will point it out every time. 2.5% added to your bill. read more

Caffrey's Tavern Backyard - Credit card surcharge - American Near Me - Forked River, New Jersey

See all

My husband and I went there for Saint Paddy's day. It was a first and it won't be the last.. the service and the food was excellent. The people are down to earth you feel comfortable. You have fun and the owner I met named Danny is just a stand-up guy. It will be one of our regular places to go.... Thank you so much for making us feel so comfortable. read more

Food was good. Service was terrible. Apparently no fun is allowed here. We got drunk and thats not allowed here. If your looking to have fun dont come here read more

We regularly go to Caffreys every other month or so. We stopped in on a Monday evening. Great atmosphere. Plenty of TVs. We were a party of four tonight. Two of us got the chicken parmesan over pasta. They loved the sauce. The serving size was huge for both of them. There is plenty to take home. They gave it a 4.5 out of 5. My husband and I split 3 special special sushi rolls and one regular sushi roll. We also had seaweed salad and edamame. The sushi appetizers are just as good as sushi establishment. All the sushi rolls are very good for an American style restaurant. The Kevin Roll and Caffrey Roll are our favorite. Anything with their Spicy Tuna is delicious. They have one of the best spicy tuna mixtures. read more

See all

There is two sections of this restaurant. They have their tavern and then the backyard. We went over to the backyard for a friends birthday and had such a good time. The service, even considering that it was busy. We had a wide range of different foods from sushi., Poké bowl, beef stick, and chicken on a stick. All the meals were good and recommended. They have these large rum buckets for drinks for anybody that likes rum. I have been here a few times for different holidays and it's a really really great time. It's also family-friendly! It's definitely a must read more

Caffrey's Tavern Backyard - Mac and cheese - American Near Me - Forked River, New Jersey

See all

Bartenders were friendly and efficient, music was lively and varied and we had a great time!

I love this place but unfortunately I cant eat gluten and there are no gluten free options :(

This hopping bar restaurant is like a landmark! This bar burned down and they rebuilt bigger and better.They offer a backyard bar with outdoor seating as well as the main restaurant and bar.Our waitress was wonderful and sweet! I adore the bartender Barbara that's also a neighbor. I'm really confused why ,if you get a plant based patty melt it's $4 more than a red meat burger!? The patty melt with the plant based burger was delicious and my friend loved her french dip.The blooming onion I wouldn't recommend because it tasted twice fried and hard but the sauce was good. Caffrey's also has a sushi bar,the sushi is great! read more

See all

Came here on a Saturday night as a group of 6 women. There was a nice crowd by surrounding the bar & we enjoyed the vibe. We waited 10 minutes for a table & everyone ordered sushi. We all loved our dinner. We left this place on the hunt for a nice bar to end up in since this place seemed like a family style restaurant/bar & we were in the mood for a more adult night. After visiting 4 different bars in the surrounding area, I have to say this was the best one. I don't think I would come back here since it's a 45 min drive from home. There was nothing special about this place that would make me come back. It's your average bar with a large room in the back for dinner or I assume private parties. Gave this place 4 stars because the bartenders were not as quick to take our orders & the waitress was not attentive. read more

Caffrey's Tavern Backyard - Sushi - American Near Me - Forked River, New Jersey

We love Caffreys!! Always great food and great service! The burgers are our favorite! read more

Good prices and portioned food. Cold beer. What else do you need? Salads are great - sorry for suggesting this pub has great, filling salads. read more

Always a good meal inside. We love their French onion soup. My son loves the steamers in the backyard part. Food a bit better in the main restaurant, but still very good. Service is polite and attentive. Always clean. Wait isn't always bad. Prefer eating in than take out. Just better. read more

Great atmosphere and good food as well. I visit every time I'm in town which is at least six times a year

Everything !! Dirty and staff, waitress, nasty. If you don't like working with public get a job that keeps you away from people. No ambiance. Reminded me of an old cafetière. read more

Best overall Restaurant in Forked River for casual food of all kinds! Never had a bad meal in well over 100 visits! The Back Yard created after the main restaurant burned down a number of years ago acted as the temporary now life saver while they rebuilt the main restaurant. It serves as a great Beach Style Indoor/Outdoor Restaurant depending on Weather Conditions. Beach Volleyball, Corn Hole, and other Tiki type games are available along with live Music, which isn't available in the main restaurant. BTW, the Bar Pies are the best Pizzas in all of Lacey and Waretown! Sushi? Yes! They have great Sushi rivaling the Asian restaurants in the area. Definitely try the Poky bowl! Staff are friendly and professional! Tons of Parking! Why wouldn't you want to go?? read more

Food here was good but was not quite happy with the service I wanted to substitute my fries for tater tots and they wanted to charge an extra 8 dollars. I do not like the regular fries because they are breaded. Very loud restaurant. read more

Caffrey's Tavern Backyard - a man sitting at a table - American Near Me - Forked River, New Jersey

See all

Stopped by for lunch on Saturday with my family. What a pleasant surprise this place turned out to be. Food was fresh and delicious and drinks were terrific. My margarita was one of the best I've had in awhile . We ate at their backyard section that was really nice , read more

See all

New look at an old restaurant This review really focused on the Caffreys backyard based on ambiance, food, service, price So being familiar with Caffreys, we were planning a Friday night visit for to burgers and beers. Once we pulled into the seriously overcrowded lot for the holiday weekend we decided to checkout the backyard which seemed less busy but still crowded.. So let me just say this place looks fun.. a games area in a sandbox that people are playing corn hole, lots of outside seating in a very casual bar feel to it.. I love the summertime feel of this place. So really cool place to have a few drinks annd food check. 5 star So after a short 15 minute wait at the bar, we got seated in an area of the bar a few feet away.. (there is no bad seat) to start off we shared some Buffalo wings (12), the nachos (12) were also good and pretzel and beer cheese (6) everyone was happy and the beers were flowing.. service was fast even thought we saw complaints about the speed and food coming from the main restaurant we didn't see any delay. The area around us was wafting we a garlicky steak smell so I had to ask.. a garlic cheese steak (16) which tasted great but I was trying to shake a garlic smell for two days.. others had Caffreys burger , Caesar salad with chicken, Everyone enjoyed the food it was a great alternative to any of the local chains but really nothing spectacular food 3-4 stars Service was pretty good, we had to wait long for a check but beers and food came quickly and considering the amount of people in the place we were happy.. . Service was 3-4 stars Overall the cost was very reasonable and it was a good time with some entertainment value also! We'll definitely be back read more

See all

5 stars for the backyard. 1 star for inside. They have different cooks/staff for both so that's why the difference is night and day. Outside everything is great--steak sandwich is awesome. Drinks great too. Inside is awful. I ordered chicken and waffles and i got an ego waffle. Such a sorry excuse of a meal. Burger was bad too (and it's usually great in the yard). Never seen anything like this, it's a shame because it really means I can only come in the summertime for good food. Hopefully they step it up inside. read more

Caffrey's Tavern Backyard - Sorry excuse for chicken and waffles. An ego waffle, really? - American Near Me - Forked River, New Jersey

Had a VERY good meal here. They are checking temps before you are sat, all employees are wearing masks correctly so then theres that... if that's important to you, you can feel safe coming here. Our server Emily was on point, she was great with her recommendations and we listened and were glad we did. Started with General Tso chicken wings which were huge and juicy/cooked perfectly. I had a cheesesteak that I would definitely have again... roll was soft and meat was seasoned perfectly. My wife had the carnitas sandwich and raved about it. We also had their shrimp scampi pizza and WOW was that awesome!!! We will definitely come back for sure!!!! read more

Caffrey's Tavern Backyard - Pumpkin Spice Martini at Caffrey's Backyard! - American Near Me - Forked River, New Jersey

Just tried to have lunch at Caffreys they refused me serve because I have a service dog. They are not legally allowed to even ask if my dog is a service dog. Very rude.... obnoxious man very nasty..... will never go back. read more

the food was okay, the beer was almost ice cold but i would go back if i had to and maybe try different items

Have been here multiple times and the service is consistently good. Always get a nice greeting upon entering. Always satisfied with our meal selections and bar drinks. read more

My friend and I each got a bar-sized pizza and they were perfectly sized and absolutely delicious. You can tell that its made with real, quality ingredients thats worth every dollar. Tremendous place to grab a drink or food. read more

Pretty basic food. Pretty cool atmosphere though especially if you want to watch live sports

Very slow, very busy. We have had good food and not so good food. We heard a lot about this restaurant, but maybe the couple times we've been there, it was just off nights for them. It's not our 1st choice when we are trying to choose a place for dinner. Maybe we'll try them again read more

Been here a few times, and finally got around to trying the sushi. Wow. So good, so fresh, I'll probably never get anything else there again. read more

Caffrey's - go indoors during the cold months, but dine at the outdoor backyard bar if you have the chance. Great atmosphere and food is good. We've ordered pretty much everything from the menu, and haven't really been disappointed. The wraps are good quality. The wings stand up to any in the area. The pizza is pretty good too. Service is always the question mark, but when it's super busy in the summer months, they do their best to get things to you quickly - just gotta have patience! No question we'll be back again and you should give it a try too. read more

Caffreys is amazing! I love eating in the Tavern and also the backyard. Food is amazing, especially the appetizers! Drinks are also the best. Seafood is fresh and servers are attentive. Head to the Backyard for some great vibes. read more

This is our go to spot for wings and a nice cold refreshing beer. Love coming here in the summer and hanging out in the backyard playing some cornhole. Whatever craving you may have, Caffrey's food options can fill that craving and more. Family friendly and the staff is awesome. Prices are reasonable. Never any parking issues. Bathrooms are kept clean. Definitely recommend to anyone driving through route 9. read more

Caffrey's Tavern Backyard - American Near Me - Forked River, New Jersey

See all

UPDATE: 5/2/21 So decided to give "The Backyard" a "3rd" chance since the past 2 times the service was horrible and this time was no different. Took 30 minutes just to get a drink then followed up 40 minutes later! Had to grab bus boys just to get them to find our waiter that would disappear and never come back. Wife ordered cheesesteak sandwich and my son and I ordered sushi, wife's meal came out and she was finished 20 minutes before our sushi even arrived. Such a shame as Caffery's has good food and we will go to the main restaurant but will NEVER EVER go back to The Backyard again. read more

Great local spot. HUGE menu, with great prices. place packs it in. Especially on Sunday's for football. Ordered the NY steak , fantastic. We got the new raspberry donut cheesecake for dessert , which I think was new to the menu this week. read more

Caffrey's Tavern Backyard - Raspberry Donut Cheesecake - American Near Me - Forked River, New Jersey

See all

Very friendly and accommodating and very nice and very big food selection and they have fantastic sushi

Great friendly staff!! Off the charts food went with my friend for lunch had the crab cake sandwich and was amazing! read more

Caffrey's Tavern Backyard - Crab cake sandwich - American Near Me - Forked River, New Jersey