Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Cafe Mooney Bay

    4.5 (2 reviews)
    Open 9:00 am - 5:00 pm

    Cafe Mooney Bay Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Cafe Mooney Bay

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    13 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Joan K.
    21
    315
    36

    16 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for New American 651 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Twisted Carrot

    Twisted Carrot

    4.8
    (133 reviews)
    7.5 mi

    After checking numerous reviews and website menus, It appeared to me that Twisted Carrot was one of…read morethe most interesting restaurants in the area, in terms of menu and atmosphere. My dinner experience there certainly lived up to expectations. The restaurant is small, seating maybe about 30 people. I wouldn't call it intimate, but I would call it friendly. The menu items are enjoyably named, with some interesting ingredient and flavor combinations. Service is fast and friendly; 3 servers can take care of all the tables quite nicely, with time for fun conversation as you go. The cocktail list is small, and the drinks are simply garnished, but everything we tried was quite flavorful and reasonably priced. As an appetizer, the Moo Moo Dippers, filled with shaved ribeye and corned beef and combined with the remoulade sauce for dipping. were addicting. My salmon filet came atop a bed of roasted sweet potato and corn hash and a sauce on top to give it more interesting presentation and flavor. The pork medallions were similarly appealing. We passed on dessert, because most of the offerings had some form of caffeine in them (e.g., boozy affogato), but I'm certain they would have been equally delicious. I was surprised the restaurant closed so early on days they're actually open, i.e., 8pm. So if you want convenient dining, get there early for dinner, because it does fill up.

    Where have I been In…read moreand out. Of the best restaurant in Plattsburgh. It's a shame really. The bar and the drinks selection. I can only BLAME LAURA. Still slinging the most enticing drinks in town. SHES THE WORST!!! and my beautiful friend had the Open sesame salad with the buttermilk chicken (she says perfectly dressed) - to die for - I tell you truth. Meanwhile I had the off menu special The Ribeye steak (with scallops on top. Off menu surf and turf special. Perfect steak (rare) And perfect scallops. I might disagree But my friend is in love. Probably with the chef - oh well.

    Photos
    Twisted Carrot
    Little Devils.
    Little Devils.
    Twisted Carrot

    See all

    Cook Sisters Cafe & Catering

    Cook Sisters Cafe & Catering

    4.8
    (22 reviews)
    10.4 mi
    $$

    This is a hidden gem that we totally would have missed if not for our Airbnb hosts' excellent…read morerecommendation. We never expected such gourmet food to come out of what is essentially a dressed-up after-hours bagel shop. We called ahead to make a reservation (they highly encourage this) and were promptly greeted and seated by one of the sisters, Patty, as soon as we arrived. Their menu is small, but we didn't mind it, both of us finding a couple of things each that sounded delicious. I was a little bummed that they were both out of crab cakes and weren't serving the sweet pea and basil soup that they had advertised on Facebook as a weekend special, but we rallied and split the picnic plate instead as an app. It was so special--featuring homemade pickled veggies (the pickling brine was so delicious), some fantastic homemade country pate, cheese, cherries, olives and plenty of bread. We enjoyed every last bite. For our mains, I got the scallops Pernod, which were perfectly cooked and so sweet. The accompanying spinach and farro were simple but complemented it well. My husband got the seared tuna, which was a beautiful rare in the center and came with a wasabi sauce that really made the dish. For dessert, we split a slice of carrot cake, which looked and tasted very homemade (I saw Patty cutting it from a cake carrier), and it was the best carrot cake I've had in a long time. Moist, just sweet enough, and dangerously scarfable. I found myself wishing we had each gotten our own slice. Everything we ate was made with care and love, and the dining experience felt intimate and cozy, like we were being served a very nice meal at a friend's house. It's a three-person operation, with one sister (the very sweet Patty) running front-of-house, one sister running the kitchen, and a busboy, so be prepared to wait a little bit at times. We didn't mind though given how relaxing the atmosphere was. This ended up being my favorite dinner during our anniversary weekend in Burlington, and this is after Honey Road and Hen of the Wood. We look forward to coming back.

    Can't believe I almost forgot to review this place! Chillest vibes, trillest staff, orchestra of…read moreflavor food. Out. Of. This. World. I had the absolute best tuna steak sandwich I have ever eaten in my whole life here. It was seasoned just right. Cooked perfectly. And tasted so fresh you'd think there was tuna swimming in Lake Champlain! We sat on the back patio under the summer Vermont sun soaking in the detail oriented surroundings. I don't know who these sisters are, but they are hitting home runs with food. If you're ever on the isle, MAKE THIS A DESTINATION!!

    Photos
    Would yah just look at it! Mouth watering
    Would yah just look at it! Mouth watering
    Pan seared salmon special. The mash potatoes were especially delicious!
    Pan seared salmon special. The mash potatoes were especially delicious!
    Cook Sisters Cafe & Catering

    See all

    Cafe Mooney Bay - newamerican - Updated July 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...