My mother went there with my daughter to buy a few slices to go. The man at the front was extremely rude and disrespectful. He helped the person behind my mother and when the person who was behind her tried to tell the man that she was next, the man very rudely told her "you have to wait". My mother was with my toddler, who was restless. Regardless, he should not have skipped my mom because she was next in line. The food here is ok, definitely not worth the aggravation of dealing with rude employees. read more

I'm sorry but 15.43 for a chicken parm hero and 20oz drink is a rip off... it's West Babylon not Manhattan. I guess we know who paid for their remodel ha! read more

Came here on a weekday night and we were seated immediately. The space is well decorated and comfy, great for large parties. The service was wonderful from beginning to end, we had the most attentive and friendly waiter. As for the food, everything was delicious. We had the buffalo fried calamari (was great), pork chops wrapped with prosciutto and mozzarella (could be larger to coincide with the price), and a pizzette that was fresh and loaded with cheese (no complaints there). I'd definitely come back here again, whether to dine in or grab some slices to go! read more

Regular pizza is sub par. Specialty slices are the best thing here. I don't really want to go back, every time I'm in there I'm served by a grumpy old man. I feel more miserable just being in the same room as him. read more

It was ok. Food was decent but it was way overpriced. $40 for some pasta and a small soup is a little ridiculous.

Just had a dinner party of 20 here. Owner very nice when I booked and very accommodating but when got there with guests it looked like the table was set by children. They jammed my guests in with no room. When asked them to add tables or do something it took like 8 minutes while my guests all looking on to even work something out while my husband had to move tables himself. Very embarrassing for us. We had apps and the calamari and zucchini were horrible. The only good course was the Cesar salad and penne a la vodka before main dish. We had a canoli occasion cake which had all cream and hardly any canoli. PLUS... i didn't even realize until next day we didn't even get assorted cookies on the table with cake which was in the package we chose and paid for. Only bright light waa the waitress Lenore who was very sweet and attentive. read more

I ordered a chicken parm and shrimp dish on a weekday and it was so bland. But their garlic knots are really big and so good. Not sure if I should give this place another try !! read more

Horrible customer service. False advertising- had a price listed in the window for a special but would not honor the advertised price (which is against the law)! Instead of giving the special this time and taking the sign down they were extremely rude and even insulted me. They refused to give me the deal they had advertised in the window and took the pizzw out of my hands. No customer loyalty! Stay away! read more

This place has really gone downhill. Terrible service, the manager is unprofessional and has a bad attitude and worst of all the food is gross! We decided to stop eating there because the atmosphere is terrible and so we ordered in a pepperoni pizza and they delivered a box of slop. When I called for the manager, he was nasty and basically didn't care. Don't waste your time or money! read more

Cafe Gio - This is the pizza they delivered and the worst part was when I called the manager, he was nasty and basically didn't care. - Pizza Near Me - West Babylon, New York

There are so many better pizza places on the island. This place is over priced and the pizza is sub par when compared to other pizzerias in the immediate area. the take out portions are small and the slices are just not good. they have recently seemed to add more specialty slices but those to lack when compared to other places. final thoughts: go somewhere else. read more

Lunch Specials are enough food for a dinner. Good food. Don't order stupid stuff. Stick to simple red sauce Italian and pizza. Why would you think that a pizzeria makes good Thai food? Relax. The guys behind the counter are gonna give you attitude. It's a wise-guy thing. Don't bother trying to figure out what the slice girls problem is. She's just a b!tch read more

Sal at Cafe Gio rocks!! Him, along with Jill, were understanding and compassionate in taking my order for a gift card to give to my sister-in-law who is doing chemo. They went over and above in their customer service!! May all the good that they are putting out during these toug come back to them tenfold! I can't wait to get in there and hug him myself ... oh by the way- Sal just called and he MATCHED my gift card ! There's some beautiful things going on out there folks and one is right here in West Babylon read more

very disappointed with the meat ball parm. had 3 meatballs 2 on one side & 1 on the other.The rest bread

I've been to Cafe Gio twice now, and I can honestly say it's an alright place. It's not my first choice, but I don't mind coming here. Tonight we were seated right away, even though it seemed to be pretty busy. It did take awhile for a server to greet us though. When she did finally come to us, she was extremely sweet and pleasant! I ordered a soda, which was awful. It was flat and watered down. The syrup needed to be changed badly. But whatever, I didn't mention it to our server. It wasn't a big deal. The salad and garlic knots that come with the meal are great! Everyone is right about that salad dressing, it's delicious! I ordered the pasta fanatico. It had rigatoni pasta with asparagus, mushrooms and chicken in a pink pesto sauce. It was pretty yummy. I just didn't like the chicken that was in it. It was a little chewy, and had an off putting flavor. I pushed all of that to the side. It was a lot of food, I wrapped up most of it to go! When we were finished our server came over quickly and promptly gave us the bill. Again, Cafe Gio is a nice place if you are in the area. I myself just wouldn't make it a regular destination. But I do like it enough to come once in awhile! read more

Pizza is pretty good, the restaurant has some good weekly specials. They did get new kiosks for a reward/loyalty system that the staff knew nothing about, and referred me to come back when the owner is in as he is the only one who knows how to use it. read more

Cafe Gio's is conveniently located off of Sunrise Hwy or locally off of Hubbards Path. The restaurant itself is nicely decorated and makes you feel like you're in a steakhouse rather than a pizzeria. Although I have yet to try their pasta, the pizza never disappoints. I've stopped in more than I'd like to admit during my lunch hour. It gets pretty busy, so if you have a limited time I would suggest ordering ahead. My only complaint is that the one time I've had zeppoles they were pretty greasy, but other than that it's delicious. Give it a try! You won't regret it read more

Cafe Gio - Chicken Bacon Ranch - Pizza Near Me - West Babylon, New York

See all

God I love writing reviews for pizza cause It all comes back to me on how many I have been to. I like this place. Garlic knot pizza is a must and they started this trend. No one does it better. The sit down is very nice also. I have done that many times for first birthdays, confirmations etc... read more

In a word? Yum! So I recently moved into this area, and on moving day we were looking for a local pizzeria to grab some food for our trusty moving helpers. I stumbled upon this place, and it looks like I picked the best of the lot right off the bat! The pizza here is DELICIOUS! But that's not all! The regular food is fantastic as well! They have weekly Pasta Night specials on Mondays and Chicken Night Specials on Thursdays. These come with your choice of dish, a salad, garlic knots, coffee or tea, and dessert. Trust me on this, when you go, get the cheesecake for dessert. I don't know where they get it from, but it is BY FAR the single best slice of cheesecake I've EVER eaten. Better than Whistle Stop? Yes. Better than Cheesecake Factory? Yes. Better than Juniors? Hell yes! This is now my GO-TO Italian place in my new area. See you there! read more

Went there the other night, Tuesday. Slow night, went for Pasta night. 6 people. 2 people had "ordered" 1 glass of wine each. Bill came, and without studying the bill, my mom paid $180.00 (and change). One of the people in our party, left the waitress, Jill, $40.00 tip in cash. The next day when our was disclosed how much the bill was, we called, and then went in person to discuss the high bill. It turns out that not only were we overcharged for a glass of wine ( menu says 9.00, charged 12.00), the waitress added in a $28.00 tip, without informing us, so then she was tipped on top of her tip. The owner only refunded us $28.00. Needless to say, we will never be going back read more

We stopped here on a Saturday for a quick slice of pizza. Delicious! Perfect. Fresh out of the oven. New slice pie. It's on our map if we're in the area. read more

Cafe Gio - Pizza Near Me - West Babylon, New York

Being my long time favorite, my wife and I gave Cafe Rio another chance. The food was very good, as usual. But now there is a new, smaller menu (there WAS way too many pasta dishes on the old one.) and a majority of the prices went up several dollars. So our pasta and a glass of wine each costs us almost $70 with tip. Sadly, our go-to spot will now only be our special occasion visit. read more

L'italiano cibo e' fantastico! (The italian food is fantastic for all you non-Italians out there ^_^) I used to come to this place firstly for pizza because they not only have a great selection of yummy pizza to choose from, but they also have a "restaurant" portion where you can sit down and enjoy a full three course Italian style dinner. The restaurant menu is out of this world! So many classic Italian dishes/options to choose from! Don't get me wrong a little pricey, but definitely worth it. When I took one of my friends here we both couldn't finish our plates and ended up having left overs. I think for both of us a full three course dinner was around $30-$40. Not too shabby, but definitely worth a visit if you're in the mood for some pretty dayum good l'italiano cibo :] read more

Wow this place was a gem! I didn't expect the food to be sooooo tasty. My boyfriend took me here, I was hungry and as usual didn't know what I wanted to eat. When we arrived, I honestly thought we were gonna grab a couple slices of pizza to go but we decided to dine in and I'm so happy we did! Our waitress Jules was a pleasure to have, she was funny, attentive, and made me super excited to try everything!! Lol whenever we ordered something she would make an expression that just made us know we made a delicious choice. The margarita was extremely refreshing, and had me feeling nice! Then we also got a Caesar salad which was filled with Parmesan cheese and croutons and the garlic knots were to die for!!!! Soooo buttery and flavorful probably the best I've had. Then for the lobster ravioli I'll admit I was way too full to eat but it was a great lunch the next day. The SAUCE omg I'm still thinking about it and the restaurant supplies a generous supply of it!! Don't have to worry about your pasta being dry if you decide to have leftovers the next day! Great place I will definitely have to come more often! Love it here read more

See all

Outstanding food excellent service you'll be crazy not to stop there and have a Great meal and excellent excellent service

Consistently great food. Relaxing atmosphere. If you want good service, you definitely have to ask for Francesca as your server. She is the best! read more

Stopped it for lunch finally found a good pizzeria in longisland the Buffalo chicken was really good as well as the Sicilian

Excellant place for a slice of buffalo chicken or sit down with the family and enjoy an entire meal such as the chicken with mashed potatoes covered in a white creamy sauce served with asparagus and a glass of wine !!! Highly recommended ! Sal and the crew are great and the atmosphere is beautiful and elegant... SteveO read more

I heard this restaurant was great and finally made it in. I had Pasta Paese. Sautéed spinach, carmelized onions, sausage in a cream Gorgonzola sauce. It was outstanding. I would definitely go back for that. All the pasta dishes sounded so good it was hard to decide. My husband is more conventional and had pasta chicken francaise. He loved it read more

Cafe Gio - Pizza Near Me - West Babylon, New York

See all

Great pasta specials for both my daughter and I but the delicious meal and luscious chocolate cake was only bested by our waitress Justina. She was a delight ,a polished pro beyond her years. She made our cuisine questions actually sound better than our dishes which were great. We are coming back, great restaurant. read more

Went there last night, very good, this is going to be my new little Italian restaurant! Love it , you must try it. Very nice dining, service great, they play nice music , very cozy, so much to choose from Omig! read more

Cafe Gio's website advertises Wednesday Dinner Specials with 23 entrees at $14.95 each. We figured it was worth a try. NOT!! When we were seated, we were presented with the Wednesday Specials menu. The list of entrees was the same as the website, but there was no price indicated. I asked our waitress to confirm the $14.95 price and was informed that Wednesday Specials are now $17.95! I pointed out the website pricing and instead of saying she'd honor the price (because it is falsely advertised!!!), she told us "they need to take that site down! We get calls all the time for things on that site that we don't even make anymore!" So, my wife and I each order a special. My chicken parm (which is on the regular menu for $17.95...I guess the pasty cheesecake and a cup of coffee are what make it "special") arrives ice cold. My wife's chicken sorrentino (cutlets layered with prosciutto, eggplant and mozzarella) is the saddest thing I've ever seen served in an Italian restaurant. Three really small pieces of chicken side by side on a plate. The middle piece has half dollar size toppings of prosciutto, mozz and eggplant. The other two pieces are bare. We let the waitress know how unhappy we were with my wife's dish ( I kept quiet about the temperature of my dinner because I was starving and just ate it). After the waitress agreed that we should be upset and said the kitchen staff should know better, she quickly removed it and offered a replacement. My wife's second dinner certainly looked better but the rubber chicken made the dish barely edible. Earlier in the evening we informed our waitress that we were going to need a dinner order to go. She took the order and told us she'd put it in when our dessert was served so it would be ready when we paid our check. That never happened!!! 30 minutes after we were done with dinner and ready to leave, we were still waiting for the take out order. We should have just cancelled it. When we got home, my son opened a dinner that contained hard uncooked pasta and two tiny pieces of chicken swimming in greasy sauce!! So here are a few tips for Cafe Gio: 1) Change the pricing on your website or honor it when customers ask. Right now you are guilty of false advertising and that's illegal! 2) If your servers make a mistake that keeps customers sitting at table for an extra 35 minutes, offer them a free glass of wine. It will go a long way toward making the wait more tolerable. We didn't even get our water glasses refilled!! 3) To our waitress (you know who you are), if you're bringing a dish to a table and it doesn't look right to you, DON'T SERVE IT!! Complaining to your customers about the kitchen staff doesn't make it OK. It means you knew the dish looked like crap and served anyway. And when you said you wouldn't blame us if we never came back, I was so relieved because we won't be back and I might have lost some sleep if I thought you blamed me. 4) Lose the cheesecake! It's terrible!! read more

DON'T BUY GIFT CARDS HERE! I tried to use one, granted it was old because I forgot about it for a while, and they refused to accept it. There was no expiration date and I looked it up online and it said it was available to use for $40. We are not strangers to this restaurant. We live in the neighborhood and used to eat there at least once a week with my family. We always used them for pizza too. To make things even worse, the owner, who refused to accept it, wouldn't even talk to us face to face or return our calls. Waitresses are very nice and understanding but with all the really good and reputable Italian restaurants in the area, this guy has lost us as customers! Don't give them your cash for gift cards; who knows if they may refuse to accept them in the future. Very disappointed in this place. read more

Been going to GIO for over 10 years .. love it never disappointing... pizza is always fresh not left out for 10 hours like most pizzeria's.

For a small local pizzeria/restaurant the food is fabulous. The staff is welcoming and accommodating. Their food is always fresh. Their chicken Daniella is to die for. And their pizza is just yummy read more

GREAT PIZZA, BEST IN THE AREA, EASILY! However, the specialty slices and Italian food can be hit or miss and a little too pricey for no reason. But honestly it's a pizza place, go there for pizza. The REAL reason I can only give it 4 stars, and I hope someone who works there reads this: A lot of the people who work there are VERY RUDE. Some of these guys give you an attitude for no reason, and some seem mad or upset about you ordering food and I've never ONCE been told to have a good day. But the food's good enough to make me ignore that. Really good pizza, but don't expect to be buddies with the guys behind the counter. read more

Overpriced and nothing to write home about. Tried to order 2 chicken Parmesan hero's and 6 garlic knots to pick up. I was quoted $28+. We called back because when you look on their online menu it was $18 for the heroes and 3 for the knots. We were told that the menu is old and these are the new prices. When we explained it was off their site the woman said no those prices are wrong. Each hero went up $3. No offer to honor the price so we cancelled. Luckily we live in Babylon and were able to get another pizza place that we like for $18. BIG difference. Bye Bye!!!! read more

I am so furious!! We USED to eat here often, my family too. Never again! I made a reservation 10 days ago for 10 people I called today to change it to 11 people, they changed it with no problem. A few hours later the manager called to cancel it because he said they have 2 parties of 30 coming in. Today is Thursday, this reservation was for Saturday for my son's communion! So many restaurants are booked and can not accommodate this late....I am screwed. Thanks for your unprofessional manner Cafe Gio, I will be sure to tell everyone read more

I walked in at 930 pm and the guys in the place just looked at me, I had to flag one of the pizza heads behind the counter for service. I ordered two slices, one regular and one with garlic knots....9 bucks??? Hey guys I hope you don't do this for a living because you wont see me again. My son thought the pizza was under cooked and rather doughy Poor service poor pizza..... read more

Food was good and they are always very friendly. Wife liked the Greek salad and I had Chicken Franchese with asparagus. All their Pizza is good too. read more

I've always liked Cafe Gio. We used to go there all the time. Great food! But I went there tonight and I was totally grossed out! At the pizza counter, they exchange the money directly over the pizza!!!! OMG I almost puked. I ordered a Buffalo slice. It looked really good. So the girl says $5.25 and I go to hand her the money and I realize that there is no way for me to hand her the money without exchanging it directly over a pizza pie!!! Only half the pizzas are covered by glass. The rest of them are sitting right there waiting for your pocket lint to drop right onto them. I almost cancelled my order but I figured what the heck, I've probably eaten worst things that I didn't know about. But this is a problem with a lot of pizzerias in our area. It's a health code violation! But for some reason, these shop owners think the health code only counts when the SCDHS inspector is in the house. As for the Buffalo chicken slice. It was good. Very tasty. Too much blue cheese dressing for my taste. They should put a less blue cheese dressing and replace it with crumbled blue cheese and it would be perfect. But overall the slice was pretty good. They really need to do something about the pizzas not being covered where the money is exchanged. It's gross! I really drives me crazy that the owner and everyone working there doesn't realize how disgusting this is. I won't be back unless they correct this. read more