Just had a fantastic birthday celebration at the cafe! I want to thank George for making the evening so special for my wife and family. This restaurant is a gem. As soon as you walk in George welcomes you like family. The food is outstanding. The service is excellent. It's always been our go to for family events. Should be yours too! read more

We had a waitress that was rushed and inattentive. Four of us. 630 reservations. We were seated immediately. I had requested indoor. (When we arrived we were told if it was an outdoor table, there would be a 45-50 min wait!!) Ordered apps, salad and entrees. We all had the same pasta as an app. Filleto de Pomadoro. (Sp?). Pasta was undercooked and there were really no pieces of the prosciutto? Or what they use in this dish. The Caesar salad was delicious, even if I only got 1 crouton! Lol. . Then they cleared the table and brought us dessert menus. We told them we hadn't had our entrees yet. We waited probably 45 mins for our dinner. Veal and Sole, delicious. The fourth dish, the Bronzino fish special, black. Top was burned black, and the fish was totally dried out. $42.50. Small piece. We asked the waitress and she said that's how it's supposed to look. What? At this point we'd been at the table 2.5 hrs. They comped dessert, mine was the wrong one. Not what I ordered. And lastly, every time they brought a dish to person on my right, the waitress leaned halfway across my plate, almost hitting me with elbow. I finally just pushed my chair all the way back when I saw her coming. We've come here before and had no complaints. Tonight was not good. And I believe totally the waitresses fault. Never apologized or told us what was happening. She needs to be trained. (We visit the Martinsville Tavern) your sister restaurant as well. read more

Cafe Azzurro in Peapack is a BYOB serving up classic Italian dishes in a welcoming setting. We really enjoyed our dinner and they even have an outdoor patio during the warmer months as a nice bonus. Hungry for more NJ food finds? Follow Wonderwithlyss on Instagram & TikTok! read more

See all

We always have a nice anniversary meal at Cafe Azzuro! The food was really good. We were hoping for indoor seating but that wasn't available and they ran out of Chocolate Soufflé (again). read more

See all

I thought this place was great. The parking lot is small for sure and the inside of the restaurant is small but it is quaint and cozy. We ordered appetizers of burrata and eggplant and the main dishes were rigatoni with pink sauce and peas and risotto. The food was great and the portions weren't too large. This place is also BYOB which we did not know when we got here so don't make that mistake! We also got tartufo and the lemon sorbet which comes in a real lemon!! read more

See all

I'll give this place 3.5 A group of us girls sat outside on the patio and was the nicest ambiance and roomy. The apps were great, not pictured; Eggplant Rollatini, sweet & spicy calamari & burrata special. When it came to the dinner, they had a parpadelle pasta on special but with seafood. I asked if they can do a simple parpadelle bolognese, they said yes. A few mins later he says they ran out of the pasta. I thought odd but ordered the egg fettuccine. I was very underwhelmed by the taste of their jarred meat sauce. That's just my opinion. However, it's a byo and a nice patio, as well as my friends did enjoy their dishes so I will definitely go back and try again. read more

See all

Food, service, ambiance and value are all 5 star rated. 2 of my party had Chicken Giovanni, 1 had Chicken Francaise and I had Veal Francaise all were outstanding, tender, and good sized. The service was very attentive. The dining room is pretty and not loud. We will definitely return. read more

We've been going to this restaurant for many years! The food and service always impeccable!

Spectacular experience!!! A friend suggested we go there for dinner and the experience was definitely 5 stars beginning to end. Reservation was made and we were seated right the way , appetizers, food and dessert were excellent , I had the pan seared salmon . Service is on point and very attentive. It is BYOB so make sure you bring you wine. But just in case there's a liquor store right down the street . The vibe is great and they also have adorable outdoor tables and a very cute decor . Perfect for a date , special occasion or even just dinner with friends . We will definitely go back . read more

Cafe Azzurro - Italian Near Me - Peapack, New Jersey

We had the best experience here. They weren't even open and fully set up and insisted it was no problem and we could still eat here. The wait staff were so friendly and kind to my 2 toddlers. Our food was fresh, delicious and out quickly. We really had a great late lunch here and highly recommend it. We aren't even local to the area but would absolutely be back when we're in the area. **Our waiter was awesome with our kids and took fun photos with them near the huge tree outside. read more

Cafe Azzurro - Fun taking silly pics with the waiter we had near the huge tree outside (my daughters face is not indicative of our experience haha) - Italian Near Me - Peapack, New Jersey

I met an old friend for dinner last night, I absolutely adored this place. Staff was super attentive, old school service, love it ! Food was great, ambiance was beautiful. Located in a cute little town. I will definitely be back read more

We traveled 50 minutes to dine here for the first time with another couple and upon being seating outdoors, we were rushed to order our meals and when asked for more time we were given less than a minute to make a decision. We needed to ask multiple times for water to be refilled. Our wine bucket was shared with another table so I never found it till it was time to go home. I will say the food was delicious but the service was disappointing and we honestly felt rushed as if this was a 90 minute sitting and the bill came without asking if there was anything else needed and we couldn't even finish our wine and had to wait to get corks for our wines. I shared my comments with the hostess so that they can get extra help with outdoor dining and improve their service. read more

My favorite food. Great outdoor seating. Excellent service. I love the Carbonara. Best I've had.

Went last night with another couple. First of all they have a beautiful outdoor dining area. Service was great and attentive. Both couples started with their shrimp and chopped tomato salad, a special, and it was delicious. For mains my wife had the salmon and loved it. Her friend had the branzino and said it was excellent. My buddy had the chicken Giovanni and said it too was very good. I had the risotto pescatore with shrimp, scallops, clams and calamari- so good and the rice and seafood were cooked to perfection. I shared a tartufo with my wife and our friend shared apple pie with ice cream. Both great. Honestly it was a perfect night and a perfect dinner. Bennie the owner checked in with us several times . Can't say enough good things about this place. Definitely check it out. read more

Cafe Azzurro is simply awesome. Food is amazing, service is exceptional, and everyone is extremely friendly. If you can pick a nice evening and spend dinner (or a lunch) on the patio, it is the best! Remember to bring your own wine. There is a wine store just a short block away if needed. read more

We've become regulars at Cafe Azzurro. A cozy yet lively setting to enjoy some really outstanding dishes. The pastas are homemade and the meat and fish entrees are fresh and inviting. The hosts and servers are friendly and attentive. We always feel welcomed and leave knowing we'll be back for yet another satisfying dining experience. Thank you! read more

Love this eatery, always good food, good service and good atmosphere. I've never had a bad experience and the food and quality are always consistently good. read more

Everything was wonderful from start to finish. We were seated immediately and service was impeccable. The food was heavenly...you must try the fried mozzarella...deliciously decadent! All three course we ordered were excellent and the service was delightful. Thank you for a great evening, Cafe Azzuro! read more

We were visiting friends in the area and we all decided to try Cafe Azzurro again, as we thought the meal we had last time was quite good, and wanted to give it another try. I'm sorry to say it will probably be our last. This time, the food was again good, but going out to dinner isn't just about the food. Its about enjoying the experience, getting away from the stress, and while Cafe Azzurro is a lovely setting with nice decor, and white tablecloths, it unfortunately misses the mark for making dining there a nice experience where customers feel welcome. Before we even sat down, and while we were taking our coats off, we were asked if we had wine that we'd like served. That should have been a clue, because the rest of our meal was followed by constant interruption by various servers asking if we'd like more wine, or needed anything else. We barely had 5 minutes without an interruption to our conversation. We felt that we were being rushed from the minute we entered, and encouraged to eat and drink our wine quickly, in anticipation of the arrival of future guest reservations. Perhaps it was just an overzealous, uncoordinated group of servers who were trying to provide excellent service, but sadly it came off as everyone trying to rush us, and rudely interrupting us when we had a few minutes to talk among the 4 of us. Nice place, good food, but not worth the trip in the cold of winter to feel rushed from the moment we entered. read more

I think Yelp has this restaurant about right at 3.5 stars. I was in between but the service was really very good. Very welcoming, caring people put their passion into making you feel comfortable. For veal Arruzzo, shrimp on veal, I always order a menu item with the name in the dish. Maybe that tactic wasn't the best choice here. The food is 'good' and the dining room is lovely. BYO, so bring something if you need to. read more

Cafe Azzurro - Antipast- hot - Italian Near Me - Peapack, New Jersey

See all

Lovely experience, fabulous food and excellent service! I'll definitely be back. Food was prepared to perfection, love that it's a BYOB as well Amply parking in back. read more

See all

The food was absolutely delicious. We got the veal chop from the special and the rigatoni azzurro. Would definitely get both again. Also the staff were super friendly and the service was amazing. We can't wait to go back read more

Cafe Azzurro - Veal chop and rigatoni azzurro - Italian Near Me - Peapack, New Jersey

Food and service were both amazing! Highly recommend. Went on Easter Sunday, they did not rush us, we were a table of 9 and it was a wonderful experience. read more

I love this place! chicken parm is my favorite and the girls that welcome you at the front are so nice!

Mediocre at best, many complaints about our meal last night. Poor, low quality ingredients, service is good. Many young men in white shirts available to serve, that and the patio ambience was nice. The food was a bust, another phony Italian restaurant that draws many patrons that dont know what good Italian food looks and tastes like. Never going back.. read more

Had an amazing experience last night for dinner. We were offered outdoor seating for a 5:30 reservation and despite my skepticism it was wonderful as was the service and food! The redone wide tiles and heaters made the alfresco experience all the more special. The 5 of us were not rushed to order and all dishes were served hot and fresh - especially our favorite Caio de Pepe! Fantastic experience read more

The food is not bad. But they always overbook. The past two times we waited almost an hour before we were seated even though we had a reservation. When I asked the (young) hostess what the point of a reservation was, she replied flippantly 'everybody has a reservation'. We literally witnessed a couple walk in off the street and be given a table before our foursome did. Once you're seated the food is slow to come out. No surprises there. Our dinner turned into a four hour affair as a result. read more

Elegantly Casual..service is professional,attentive, and knowledgable. The food is well plated and above average for this area. A must if you're in the area! read more

Oh my where to begin. My husband and I have been there about a dozen times. Have brought family and friends. It never disappoints. Food and service impeccable. Highly recommend this establishment. read more

What an excellent dinner! Family gathering of almost 20 plus a fairly busy restaurant and yet the service and food was superior. Wonderful appetizers- eggplant rollatini was delicious and shrimp coconut divine. While our group had many different main dishes we were all very happy. Veal Azzuro was perfect and my husband had a special of pasta and various seafood. A beautiful room for a party of 20+ if you would like and lovely indoor and outdoor dining. Highly recommend this restaurant and unlike many restaurants who are struggling with staffing, our service was attentive and consistent. Can't wait to go back. read more

Cafe Azzurro - Veal Azzurro - Italian Near Me - Peapack, New Jersey

The best food, service and atmosphere! We celebrated 2 birthdays the past year as well as a baptism last weekend. Everything was amazing! We had babies to older adults, the staff accommodated everyone. Feels like we are eating at our own home. Highly recommend! Best of the best in such a great small town! read more

Ambiance & food is always top notch here. Staff is always on hand for your every need. BYOB which is very nice. Albanian owned, one of the best restaurants in the area. Can't say enough about the food & the service, have never had a bad meal, the specials are outstanding also. Great for a date nite, girls get together or a family meal. They always make you feel like you are coming home for an amazing home cooked meal and then some! read more

See all

Never had a bad meal here. Tonight was no exception. Ordered the special - spinach fettuccini. Excellent. Should add to the regular menu.

Excellent food, ambiance and service. Always a warm greeting by senior staff who discuss the menu and make recommendations according to your preferences. Have never been dissapointed. read more

Best lunch in the area. Pasta dishes are excellent , complimentary salad and dessert make a complete mea Can't agree more. Never a bad dish orbad read more

I ordered the seafood ravioli. I was shocked at first bite - it tasted like a big piece of liverwurst. I spit it out. The side order of spaghetti tasted like it was left out of for days - it was stiff. The eggplant parmigiano was mushy, thin and tasteless. It is unfathomable that a so called chef made this food. I would seriously like my money back. read more

Always good place to meet for lunch with old friends Good stuff Best of Peapack BYOB read more

Amazing service. Delicious food. Lovely location. Make reservations well in advance - it's a popular spot

This place never fails. My girlfriends and I have dinner here every now and then to catch up. The food is always amazing and the service is so attentive. Our wine glasses are never empty!! read more

Cafe Azzurro - Italian Near Me - Peapack, New Jersey

I was reading the reviews and couldn't believe some of the bad ones. Have eaten here regularly since it first opened and have never had a bad meal. I love it and all the people in my family do also. Every time they come down this way they are happy to come to Cafe Azzurro. It is my favorite restaurant in New Jersey by far, so don't be afraid......and the staff are wonderful...just read the 5 Star reviews..I'd give them 6 if it were available!!!!!! read more