A few days before the birth of our first child, one of my oldest friends came down from Brooklyn for what we understood would be my final properly indulgent night before parenthood. We have known each other since we were five, lived together in New York for six years, and stayed close through marriages, children, and jobs that occasionally made us question our sanity. He has seen me at my absolute best and worst, and he was also the person who helped me get fit and regain some discipline while we worked in finance and used excess to numb the misery of those jobs. Choosing Butcher & Singer gave the evening exactly the ceremonial weight it deserved. Steakhouses take on different meanings as you move through life. In your early twenties, an expense account dinner feels like the dream: free drinks and an extravagant meal while you are broke, eating ramen, and sitting at the bottom of the professional food chain. By your early thirties, after enough wining and dining in Midtown Manhattan, the ritual can feel exhausted, and another steakhouse dinner holds little appeal. In your early forties, with young children and fewer unstructured nights, catching up with a lifelong best friend over a great steak feels incredibly meaningful, partly because neither the dinner nor the friendship needs to become a weekly habit. That contrast was especially fitting because my friend is remarkably health-conscious and frugal despite being tremendously successful. He seldom strays from his disciplined diet, while I have historically been much more willing to wander toward fries, dessert, and whatever reckless topping appears on the menu. A traditional steakhouse lets both people leave satisfied: one can order a lean steak and vegetables, while the other can treat the table as permission to suspend judgment for two hours. We shared the same celebratory dinner, but our plates still reflected exactly who each of us had always been. Inside, Butcher & Singer delivers the classic steakhouse fantasy with extraordinary conviction. The soaring ceiling, monumental columns, and amber lighting give the dining room a glamorous scale, while the dark wood, painted murals, and small shaded lamps keep all that grandeur from becoming severe. This is where Stephen Starr's judgment becomes especially apparent, because both Butcher & Singer and nearby Barclay Prime depend on concepts that could age badly: one could become stuffy and antiquated, while the other could become glossy and artificial. Instead, Butcher & Singer still feels transportive, Barclay Prime remains contemporary and cool, and each succeeds because the design, service, and atmosphere are executed with total confidence. Our meal included what I believe was a Caesar salad, filet mignon, asparagus, fries, and a rich chocolate fudge cake. I added a blue cheese garnish to my steak, a completely unnecessary flourish that became the crown jewel on an already excellent piece of meat, while my friend kept his side of the table considerably cleaner. Parc creates a useful third point in Starr's small Rittenhouse constellation: its bar steak and burger offer a more casual form of red meat, somewhere between an ordinary dinner and the full ceremony of Butcher & Singer or Barclay Prime. I appreciate both, but a burger leaves me feeling heavier, while a properly cooked lean steak can feel filling and indulgent without ruining the rest of the night. Only one detail could have improved our experience. We sat at a small table near the host stand and the clock, which was comfortable and entirely reasonable for a table for two, but it left us slightly outside the dramatic center of the room. This was no one's fault, merely the kind of learned preference that comes from seeing the full room afterward and knowing where I would request to sit on a future visit. I hope to return when the budget allows, settle farther inside among the leather booths, glowing lamps, and sweep of the murals, and once again let Butcher & Singer make a rare night with an old friend feel worthy of savoring. read more

This place is stunning on the inside and I absolutely love the lore of all the movies that have been filmed inside and the various businesses that the building housed before the restaurant. With that, the food was good and it didn't feel just like your typical steakhouse and I attribute that to the service and how wonderful the staff was. We ordered the oysters, onion soup, delmanico steak, porter house, and the fillet. The table shared the hash brown which was absolutely delicious and by far one of the best items I've had at a steakhouse potato wise. We also ordered the asparagus and the seasonal corn dish. For dessert we had peanut butter tart, cheesecake, and ice cream. Over all this was a great experience and I would definitely come back. read more

Had an absolutely incredible dinner at Butcher and Singer. We started with the biscuits, which were honestly the best biscuits I've ever had. Every steak at the table was cooked to perfection and full of flavor. The sides were just as impressive -- the mac and cheese, stuffed potato hash, broccolini, and mashed potatoes were all amazing. We also tried the cheesecake and lemon dessert, and both were outstanding. From start to finish, everything exceeded expectations. Easily one of the best steakhouse experiences we've had. read more

Butcher and Singer - American Near Me - Philadelphia, Pennsylvania

Service was amazing. Our waiter was so nice and took time to explain the menu and answer any questions we had about the food. The food itself was amazing. It is served family style and easy to share all the dishes, which was perfect because we got to try everything! We did go a little overboard and ordered 4 different desserts. Who could blame us, they all sounds so amazing and tasted even better. read more

See all

Arrived late at 10pm on a Friday without a reservation. The place was PACKED! Went to bar and waited 15 minutes for a seat. That's good. Be aware the bar is small. Ordered bone in filet with mashed potatoes and roasted Brussels sprouts. It was a little slow to receive (they were busy!) about 40 minutes. Steak was cooked perfectly sprouts were just right but the best part were the potatoes. Unbelievable taste! Crispy exterior with soft inside. I normally don't eat all of potatoes but I left nothing on plate. Simply delicious! Had homemade vanilla ice cream which was good but had a little too much honey flavor for my tastes. Biggest surprise were the biscuits. Unbelievably delicious!! Yes was a good experience! Enjoy but make a reservation. Just saying read more

See all

Surprisingly reasonably priced food for the quality. Great service, nice solid offerings. Our party got both steak and fish, and both were great. It has a nice quiet ambience that isn't pretentious. I will definitely come back the next time I'm in Philadelphia. read more

See all

Had 715PM reservations...seated immediately... Everything about this place amazing vibe...ambiance of the whole room......low jazz music in backgrounds. Our water JERAD was polite...courteous & highly informative ! Food was exceptional...biscuits are a must ..crap cake was delicious... filet minon cooked perfectly ....aged to.melt in one's mouth ...creamed spinach awesome side dish.... Save room for the BAKED ALASKA ...to die for Next visit to Philly on to.do.lidt ! read more

See all

Butcher and Singer delivered an outstanding dining experience. The food was exceptional, I ordered the New York strip, Chilean sea bass, and the hash browns, which were absolutely incredible and an absolute must-try. The ambiance is cozy, elegant, and beautifully designed, making it the perfect setting for a special night out. The service was attentive, welcoming, and added to the overall experience. Will be back! read more

See all

I made a reservation a few weeks in advance but was unfortunately not impressed by my experience here. I understand it's a popular spot for Philly natives but theirs nothing special or unique about this steakhouse. Our server Brian was nice. I ordered what I was familiar with, my friend ordered the pasta and did not finish it. read more

See all

They offer valet parking unless you get lucky and find parking on the street. We had reservations and decided to stop in early. They were extremely busy on a Thursday night. We went back and had to wait about 10-15 minutes after our reservation time to be seated. They had a vegetarian option and mocktail. I loved the decor of the restaurant. It gave speakeasy vibes. The deep and rich colors with an old days feel. read more

See all

Delicious from the service, to the ambiance, to the food. Not one thing we had was average. The food was incredible. I had the filet- highly recommend the hashbrown as a side as well. My boyfriend said that they had the Martinez he's ever had. Also the seafood platter was to die for. Come here for your next steakhouse experience! read more

See all

A well known steakhouse that did not disappoint! Service was friendly and professional. The small bar was cozy and bartenders very lively. 1. Bone in filet mignon - Big cut, cooked perfectly, loads of flavor and did not seem dry at all. Had it with broccolini. 2. Hash brown - Lived up to the hype with "full of love" filling inside. Lots of flavor, can be a bit salty on the outside. 3. Onion soup - Big portion. Very good flavor and lots of cheese on top. Appreciated that it did not have too much bread in it. Initially hesitant since it's a steakhouse. 4. Escargot - Very good, hot, garlicky. Close to classic and comes with some crunchy bread. 5. Cheesecake - Soft, fluffy, likely has cheesecake mixed in with sour cream or yogurt. Very good! Overall had a well rounded hearty meal and will definitely be back for more! I agree with other reviews that Barclay Prime has more advanced meats and a bigger menu but this steakhouse still executed well! read more

See all

Quarterly guys outing was a success. This is a regular. Service wasn't as great as usual but steaks were on point. You know what you're getting if you dine here. Was a little busier than our usual Thursday evening. read more

Four us came for dinner in a Saturday night. We came about a half an hour early so we could sit at the bar. Robbie was our bartender. He took great care of us. And he made the perfect dirty martini. I started with a Caesar salad with no croutons, but added garbanzo beans. I asked for the anchovies but they were not the white kind I like. Then I got the filet mignon medium rare. We ordered a lot of sides including the stuffed hashbrowns, which is their signature side. OMG it was delicious!! Perfectly crunchy on the outside and potato-y on the inside. We also ordered the broccolini, the mushrooms and onions and the mac & cheese. Service ok. Water constantly refilled. But wine and all drinks were backed up. They did ultimately comp a round of wine since the wait was so long. We could have drank more!! Our salads sat a long time in front of us and again a long wait after saying we wanted a few boxes to go. They seemed short handed which is surprising for a Saturday night. read more

See all

For starters we had the complimentary made in house biscuits with honey butter. Arguably one of, if not the best, complimentary breads I have ever had. Best way to describe it is grands flaky layers but turned up to a thousand. They're made in house by a lady who makes all of their desserts and has since the restaurant opened their doors. We also tried to wedge which was plenty big enough for two people to split. It was very good and the first time I have had a wedge with Russian dressing however, that could be a Philly thing. The steaks were flavorful, moist and cooked to perfection. The crust on the steak was perfect and did not contain too much gristle. For sides we had mashed potatoes and mac 'n' cheese. The mac 'n' cheese was good but not top 3 or 5 mac 'n' cheese in my experiences. However, the mashed potatoes were great! Have that homemade, buttery taste that pairs great with the steak and one of their side sauces. For dessert we had the Lemon Ice Box Pie. It was very good as well. Not too tart or too sweet. The service was 10/10. Jared was our waiter and he was very helpful and informative. He knew everything there was to know about the menu and history of the restaurant. read more

See all

This place is so beautiful and the filet mignon was melting in my mouth! It was amazing. It was packed on a Tuesday night so I definitely recommend getting a reservation. Our server was nice. read more

See all

We had dinner there last Saturday night. The service was first class and the food excellent. The Chincoteague oysters were served good and cold, no the usual half warm state. The porterhouse steak was better than any that I've ever eaten. When our bottle of wine turned out to be meh the staff allowed us to select another wine and didn't charge us for the first bottle. We are going back whenever we are in Philadelphia. read more

Butcher and Singer - American Near Me - Philadelphia, Pennsylvania

My first experience was amazing. The vibes were great and beautiful. The background music was perfect. The interior decor was very classic. Came here for desserts and they did delivered. Got coffee, baked Alaska and crème brûlée which was all amazing. All the employees and waiters were super amazing. Highly recommend coming here for dining experience. read more

Butcher and Singer - Baked Alaska - American Near Me - Philadelphia, Pennsylvania

See all

Butcher and Singer is a steakhouse, and in Steven Starr's thematic approach, has a kind of Mad-Men-era vibe. (Starr is famously a concert promoter-turned-restauranteur, which is often credited for his curated collection of foodie experiences.) There is a fascinating collection of Manhattans on the cocktail menu, and I found it interesting that there are no martinis featured on the menu in the way that the Manhattans are. I was sorely tempted to try the Robber Baron, which would be a Rob Roy by most definitions. I ordered a NY Strip, which is a cut I almost never cook at home, but often find on the menu in steakhouses. It's a leaner, grainier, beefier cut than the fan-favorite ribeye, but I make ribeye at home all the time. One thing I'll say about Butcher and Singer's take, and it reminded me immediately of the specimen my son, who attends a local technical high school's culinary arts program, brought home from class one memorable day: the cut was of the bone-in variety, and this made the experience of eating it completely different from the thinner boneless version I've usually enjoyed. I prefer the bone-in version hands down. The kitschy, throwback-to-bygone-era vibe even includes Baked Alaska as a dessert option. It's hard to pass up; like the Lobster Thermidor at the Knife and Fork in Atlantic City, it's one of the few (if only) places I go that has it on the menu. The service is impeccable-crisp and professional. read more

See all

I can't say anything negative EXCEPT I hate bananas and had no idea the baked Alaska would have banana ice cream . My husband loved it though and it was for his birthday so it is what it is. I guess he can have something nice for his birthday First: I don't recall the bartender's name but we sat at the bar while waiting for a table. I had the Butcher Old Fashioned. Husband had a whiskey mule. Both outstanding. PLUS their drink napkins had little dogs on them and they were so cute!! Second: the wedge salad is hands down the best I've ever had. The hard boiled egg crumbles lent a creaminess that wasn't needed (the blue cheese dressing was killer), but was an incredible touch. The crab cake was pretty much all crab and seasoned very well. Delicious. As good as those were... the biscuits and maple butter were SHOWSTOPPING. Slapyomama, slapyofriendamama type of good. I had the filet and added Oscar. Stunning and perfectly cooked. Husband had the porterhouse. Also stunning and perfectly cooked. We shared the broccolini which came with a kind of lemon cream sauce (?) all of it was incredible. If we are ever back in Philly, it'll be on the top of our must-stop list. That being said, I am fully aware we are privileged enough to afford to stop in. If you are too, I highly recommend. read more

After being in Philly for sometime (temporarily), we finally made it to the storied Butcher and Singer. The restaurant had been a bank and a stock brokerage before it became a restaurant. Stephen Starr renovated and reopened it in 2004. Its cavernous interior looks like it had been a bank - the overly dark atmosphere isn't my favorite. I'm not sure why they keep the lighting so low - it's not inviting at all - even with the bold design. Enough of that - let's talk food! First up - the biscuits. Light, fluffy and delicious, they were as good as any I've had - what a great starter! Next, The Wedge - I don't eat blue cheese often, but tonight was the exception. It's rich, creamy, but bold and pungent flavor is something I can only have once in a while. The salad was very good with LOTS of blue cheese chunks and dressing - a little too much. See picture - a thick layer underneath the bacon bits was slightly overwhelming. It could have come with twice as much lettuce - don't get me wrong - the dressing was fabulously decadent - but sometimes 'less is more'. We then ordered the crab cake - who expects to get a first class crab cake at a steakhouse - I wasn't. But it was - I spent 25 years in MD, so I have to admit I'm a crab aficionado. The lump crab with hardly any filling was excellent! Next, the stars of the evening - the steaks. I'm old fashioned - I like my steaks medium to medium well - pink throughout. I typically order filets - but after Delmonico's (NYC), Barclay Prime (Phil.) and Ruth's Chris (DC) all served undercooked versions, I was hesitant to order a filet. After a brief discussion with our server at Butcher (he said the filet would have to be 'butterflied' for medium well), I opted for the sirloin, which is MUCH easier to cook medium/medium well....and they executed perfectly! It was so juicy with an excellent texture and a rich peppery flavor. I decided immediately, no more filets - I was glad I converted. My partner however, resisted and ordered the filet mignon. It wasn't medium well as she had ordered - it was well done - and dry as a result. I want to point out, this is not a criticism of Butcher - but the realization you can't order a filet 'medium well'.....anywhere. From now on - we both order sirloins. The reviews of the stuffed hash browns on Yelp were so good, we HAD to order them - even though our go to potatoes with steak has always been mashed - not this time!! We ordered both - the mashed potatoes, which were very good, and the hashed browns, which were 'over the top', and a must order. It was my birthday dinner, and an excellent one I'll not forget! read more

See all

Butcher and Singer is truly a work of art. It is one of the most beautiful restaurants I have ever seen. The art and decor boasts post prohibition vibes. Service was excellent, even when we had a large party that came in later in the evening. I took all the waiter's recommendations, and was not disappointed. I can honestly say their rolls are the best I have ever eaten. I ordered the Blackberry cocktail, which was very refreshing. For my entree, I did Surf & Turf with the truffle butter, and the filet was one of the best I have had. If you are looking for a 5 star meal and experience when you are in Philly, you will not be disappointed! read more

See all

It was a resounding 100/100 experience. Crab cake: OMG BEST EVAAAAR Fresh rolls: I CAN DIE NOW HAPPILY OMG WITH HONER BUTTER I AM DEAD Chilean Sea Bass: THIS IS THE BEST CHILEAN SEA BASS I'VE EVER HAD, AND THE PORTION WAS HEFTY Broccolini: exquisite Evan's Filet Mignon with goat cheese and scallops: He gave it a 9.5/10! Investment Manhattan: I took my time with this, as it was the equivalent of an expensive perfume you never want to fully deplete. Again, I'm a cocktail snob, and this sophisticated concoction blew me away. They included a sherry and Grand Marmier in it, so...yeah. Ah say GOTTDAM! Ambience: Classic and upscale Service at the bar: Outstanding I will return with glee. read more

See all

Butcher and Singer is a fancy spot in Philadelphia's vibrant restaurant scene, brought to life by the legendary restaurateur Stephen Starr. It's like old Hollywood glamour of the 1940s. Its dim lighting, high ceilings, leather booths, and ornate chandeliers exude a timeless classiness. Originally constructed in the 1920s, it was home to a financial institution before its transformation into one of Philly's most iconic dining destinations. The building itself is steeped in history. The space retains its historic charm with art deco-inspired details, seamlessly blending old-world elegance with modern luxury. I stopped in for just a drink this time, and the Old Fashioned stole the show. I've eaten here several times but this stop was just to drink. Definitely put this in the list. read more

See all

Great steak house! We got the big tomahawk for 2 last time and a bunch of sides - the sides are absolutely massive! Always a treat to come here for a good steak and to take home leftovers haha. They treat us so well here for our anniversary! read more

We wanted to give this place five stars, but the tall thin (I believe) male host was one of the rudest people I have ever met. My friend works in food & beverage in a higher position, and she commented on his inappropriate and condescending behavior as well. Luckily, after we were seated, we did not see him again. The food (steaks, Caesar salad, macaroni and cheese) were all delicious and perfectly cooked. The wait staff and other older male host and female hostesses were polite, and apart from the individual who we checked in with, we loved the experience. We would hope not to interact with him again should we come back. read more

Butcher and Singer - Filet mignon (with au poivre) and macaroni and cheese - American Near Me - Philadelphia, Pennsylvania

See all

Butcher and Singer owes me nothing. I had a really great experience here, an expensive one but great nonetheless. The restaurant is beautiful and vibe great with a chill and sexy interior. It is not a quiet restaurant. Everyone is talking, laughing and having a good time. The cocktails were well crafted. The steaks delicious. The staff is on point. The service is well paced and not rushed at all. The dessert was yummy. First time having a baked Alaska and it was very enjoyable. Definitely recommend for a special occasion. Make reservations well in advance. read more

First off, this place looks amazing on the inside. Very nicely decorated. The light & noise level are mid level. Has that old school steakhouse charm & feel. The food & drinks are fantastic. The service was top notch. read more

Butcher and Singer - Oysters Rockefeller - American Near Me - Philadelphia, Pennsylvania

See all

Butcher and Singer offers a classic steakhouse experience with impressive flavor and culinary talent. The decor is low-lit with deep shades of brown, and the servers well-versed in the dishes. Most of the dishes exceeded my expectations. It started with the biscuits, which were perfect-- a bit of crisp, fluffy, and a hint of salt. Next came the crab and shrimp louie salad, which included a great addition of avocado and a subtle sprinkling of parsley, which worked well with the citrus and mayo. Usually it's hard to pull off parsley without overpowering a dish. The steak was standard: nice outer layer of seasoning and medium rare in the middle. The crown of the dinner was the baked alaska, which included banana iced cream on a layer of sponge cake and covered in toasted merengue. The picture of this dish looked gorgeous, and the flavor was impeccable. The toasted crust brought memories of smores marshmallows with a pleasant crisp. It was possibly the best dessert I've eaten in a restaurant. If you're looking for steak or to celebrate a special occasion, Butcher and Singer is a solid choice. read more

What a beautiful restaurant! We started at the cozy bar and had a round of drinks & appetizers. Wonderful espresso martinis - they're definitely on the sweeter side, which I loved! They gave use buttermilk biscuits and we had the escargot & crab cake to begin. The escargot were pretty good, but fairly bland. The crab cake was well worth it! The bartender was lovely. After we got to the table we had another round of drinks before ordering our meal. They have you order all at once and course it out for you, which makes sense but does make it hard if you aren't sure how hungry you'll be. We had the Caesar salad & wedge salad to start. For the main, we had a NY strip & 8 oz filet. Both were cooked perfectly, but the strip was rather tough to chew. Sides are shareable, so we had the Mac & cheese, brussel sprouts, & stuffed hashbrown. All were good. For dessert, we shared the creme brulee. It was a classic vanilla with fruit. Only downside was that when our food was boxed up for us, we were not given our filet and instead some else's entree. Given it was a considerably expensive dinner, we were rather disappointed the next day. Overall, the service was good and the food great. I think the biscuits might have been my favorite! read more

Butcher and Singer - American Near Me - Philadelphia, Pennsylvania

Probably one of the best steak houses I've been too, and I've been to a few different ones so far. The service was impeccable, and we always had what we needed, refills etc. I ended up getting the filet with truffle sauce and my oh my it was so delicious, I knew it would be good just by looking at it- it looked mouth watering good. I got it with asparagus and that was also cooked to perfection. Dessert- I got the baked Alaska, and it was rich and flavorful. My party was satisfied with all our meals and we would definitely return. read more

See all

Not only one of the best steakhouses I've ever been to, but one of the best meals I've ever had! We had reservations at 5:30 on a Sunday. We took an Uber from Jersey and were running a little behind due to some street closures. The staff was very understanding and forgiving. We met our friend who was waiting for us at the bar when we arrived. As we were getting shown to our table, the bartender made it a point to wish us an enjoyable night which was very nice. The staff as a whole were all very pleasant and professional. The restaurant was not very busy when we arrived but within 20 minutes of us being seated, every single table was occupied. Our friend's Old Fashioned, that he brought from the bar to our table, was very good so he says. I started with a very good stout from Great Lakes Brewing Company and my fiancé had one of her go-to cocktails, a Dirty Martini with Stoli Elit, which she loved. We couldn't help but notice the beautiful architecture, high ceilings, and large, fascinating chandeliers. The biscuits served before dinner were delicious. Freshly baked, flakey, and served with delicious honey butter. After much admiration of the building and decor, we were able to look over the menu and come to a consensus on some sides and appetizers. We started with the Butcher Salad, which is their version of a chopped salad. Vibrant colors, popping with flavor, my fiancé and I split it and really enjoyed our decision. We then had Oysters Rockefeller and Steak Tartare. Both appetizers were a hit with the table. It was my fiancés first time having both Oysters Rockefeller (she's a fan of oysters on the half shell) and steak tartare (she's also a fan of beef carpaccio) and loved both. The steak tartare was salty, savory, velvety, and very tender. A few orders of it and I could have made a meal out of it alone. For dinner we all chose steaks, my friend a NY Strip cooked medium rare, my fiancé a filet cooked medium, and for myself a 22oz porterhouse cooked medium rare. Consensus was that both the crust on the steaks and the temperature to which they were cooked was perfection. The steaks were seasoned to our liking. They were tender, and the fat on the NY strips melted in your mouth. For sides we split the Stuffed Hash Browns and Roasted Brussels. I knew from the moment I looked through Yelp pictures weeks prior to our reservation that I needed to have the Stuffed Hash Browns. Even with the bar being set so high, they exceeded expectations. These are a MUST ORDER for your dinner party. The outside of the Hash Browns were so crispy and the insides of the hash browns were stuffed with what I believe was cheese, sour cream, and onions. It was plenty to split between three of us. If I had to nitpick one thing about our dinner it would have been that the Brussels weren't crispy. I like a good char on my roasted Brussels sprouts, but they were still very delicious so I am in no way complaining. I did finish up my night with a Bombay Sapphire Martini with a twist since I wasn't driving. We chose to skip out on dessert since we were all so full. We didn't feel rushed once and our server was very nice. Each time one of us got up to use the restroom, our server would re-fold our napkin at our place setting for when we'd get back. We ended up making reservations due to a recommendation I received from a friend and it didn't disappoint. Dinner was stellar and I'd 100% dine at Butcher and Singer again. read more

See all

The steak arrived with a really nice crust and was cooked exactly how I'd hoped. The sides were worth getting too, especially the creamed spinach. Service had that polished steakhouse feel without being stiff, and the dark, old-school dining room gave the whole meal a classic atmosphere. read more

One of many great steakhouses in Philadelphia, Butcher & Singer is housed in a space that used to be a bank. Not the crappy little pop up kiosks type ATM banks of today. Rather, this was obvious prior powerhouse building with soaring ceilings, marble and cement, and a huge vault. The lighting is low, there are perimeter semi private booths, and decor sporting nontoxic masculinity which all seem appropriate in this space serving up the classics. A great steak is perhaps my favorite food genre and this was my first time here. I pledge it will not be my last and I would put this in my top 10 great steakhouses I have visited. You will need to save up to eat here, take out a loan, or be a guest of someone with an expense account because it is not cheap. But it is also not the most expensive I have seen either. Some things on the menu were inappropriately high in my opinion but others seemed reasonable. Examples of this include a corkage fee of $40 (my experience in most place is that it is $30 but some have been as high as $50), a house craft Manhattan cocktail is $30 (I have seen craft ones as low as $18 and as high as $32), and an aged Delmonico (Ribeye) steak is $67 (I have seen dry aged ones usually in the $79 range). Nothing was cheap but it was also not the most expensive pricing I have run into. What do you get for these prices? All you would expect from a classic high-end steak house. There were great, straightforward menu items that were perfectly executed. Highlights of our evening were the escargot, the fresh oysters, the Butcher Salad (their version of a chopped garbage salad), the steaks, and the Icebox Lemon Pie. They also have an epic wine list if you are an oenophile but be forewarned, there are very limited selections that are affordable. Expect a 300-500% markup (even more for collector vintage bottles) so although their corkage fee is a bit higher than most I have run into, it is still a good way to maintain some value if you have great wine to bring in of your own. Parking is tough all over city center Philly so find a public garage and walk. Expect service to be professional and friendly but not over the top doting on you. And you would be most comfortable dressing towards up, not down (you will be fine in a collared shirt and jeans or better but I would avoid the shorts and flip flops). If you are ever visiting Philly and in need of a great steak, this is a solid choice in my book read more

Butcher and Singer - Investment Manhattan, the Old Fashioned, and tough choices for a classic meal - American Near Me - Philadelphia, Pennsylvania

Always a great choice! Food and atmosphere has been the same for years and we keep coming back

Looking for an elevated dining experience in Philly? Look no further than Butcher and Singer, arguably one of the most beautiful restaurants in the city from a structural and architectural standpoint, there's a reason it's been on just about every "best of" list. I had my first experience over the weekend for a special night out with one of my girlfriends, and was really impressed from start to finish. I screwed up and forgot to book a reservation, but we decided to just show up and try our luck at the bar. This worked in our favor as we got to enjoy the full Butcher and Singer experience from a table in their cocktail lounge space, which is full service and was actually completely open when we walked in on a Friday night at 6:56pm. These unreserved tables filled in quite quickly, and the only hiccup of the night was trying to get a server over to us after we grabbed our seats. I went back up to the host stand after we waited for about 10 minutes, then after that point we waited awhile longer for someone to come over with a menu. Not enough to dock a star, but I found it surprising for a place that should seemingly have very clear and polished FOH systems in place. After this though: pure perfection. We each ordered a French 75 from our server Ricky who was a complete rockstar all night long. He gave great suggestions and was super attentive for our whole meal. We then put in our order (we were splitting everything) which one could essentially title "The basic bitch's guide to ordering dinner at a steakhouse" + Caesar salad + NY strip steak + Creamed spinach + Mashed potatoes + Glasses of Côtes du Rhône and Chianti Everything really was perfectly executed, presented, and priced for the quality. You are not going to have a cheap night but you will leave FULL, tipsy, and happy. This amount of food was too much for two people, but I regret nothing and wish I could have tried one of their many tasty desserts. I will absolutely be back, even just to the bar before a night out to take in the gorgeous space and feel transported away from 15th street for a brief moment. Thank you B&S for the wonderful evening and hospitality! read more

See all

Service was wonderful. Setting was beautiful, a tad loud with how busy it is and the high ceilings. Dirty martini was perfect. Cream spinach and mash potatoes were delicious. I'd order that creamed spinach a thousand times over. The side portions were bigger than it seemed in pictures (a good 3+ servings). The steaks were like... crusted. I would say pepper was a main ingredient in their rubs. Both the filet mignon and NY strip had it. I was kind of shocked that it wasn't mentioned in the menu. It made me even more grateful I added a side of Béarnaise. HIGHLY RECOMMEND the turtle cheesecake desert. Even just get it to go. I had 3-4 servings from how large the slice was. More importantly it delightful. read more

Butcher and Singer - New York Strip, side of Creamed Spinach, side of Mashed Potatoes - American Near Me - Philadelphia, Pennsylvania

See all

Great service in the bar. The biscuits were the best I've ever had! Pretty classic steak house vibes. I'd recommend for sure!

I took myself to dinner when I got a promotion I've be vying for over and year. I thought celebrating here would be perfect. To my dismay it was a horrible experience. I have yet to get a message from management. The ambiance was too dark too. I doubt I'd return after the food was overcooked. Then the manager said it was normal until my order came out again he say oh this look right so why did you say the overcooked lobster tails was acceptable. You made me feel like uncomfortable with making the complaint as if it was my fault. read more

Awesome ambience Super attentive staff Excellent food We loved the setting and atmosphere. We ordered one of the hibiscus drink-Sweet Nothing. Very delicious & refreshing Crab cake appetizers and complimentary breads were some of the best I've had. Entrees- Sirloin with mashed potatoes. Roast chicken I had fish , again awesome They served chocolate cake for my son's birthday and it made everything fantastic Will definitely be back read more