Great family atmosphere Authentic tasting New York style pizza. Definitely not an imitation! Employee Vinny- great communicator and great at making customers feel at home, but could see it being overwhelming to customers who are not a custom to it. People could feel pressured to stay if they don't have the personality to shut the conversation short. But with the right customer the feeling of being welcomed can have the effect of staying longer and tasting more great Sicilian food. Other employees can learn the methods of great customer service from Vinny alongside with their own personality could lead to a great welcoming establishment. - Don't know what their cleaning schedule is but - Other employees did a great job of active listening when putting the chocolate sauce on the side of the cinnamon dessert instead of directly on the fried cinnamon bread giving me the option to customize it at my discretion, as initially I was ordering my pizza to go but decided to stay due to the welcoming environment. read more

Let's start with the positive. Salads and dressings are good. The pasta has never disappointed. The service if you dine-in or are waiting on a carry out order has always been solid. But the pizza... I really wanted to enjoy the pizza. And I don't mind a little grease on my pizza, but every time I've gotten it here it's been absolutely drenched in grease. To the point where you can't taste anything but the grease, even after multiple attempts to soak it up. I always force myself to stomach a couple pieces, but I just regret it and feel sick afterward. It may not be a big deal for some, after all pizza is traditionally a 'greasy' meal, but in my opinion you should be able to taste ingredients that go into the pizza and enjoy it without being overwhelmed by the grease. On the topic of ingredients, maybe using higher quality meat and cheese, with a little less fat.. or sauce with a little less oil. Unfortunately, I don't think I'll be able to give it another chance. read more

Brooklyn V's Pizza - 14" Pepperoni Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Gilbert, Arizona

See all

Ordered a Caesar Salad w Chicken and Meatball sub to go. Got home NO chicken on salad and yet the gal that took my order repeated it to me. She got it right: kitchen GOT IT wrong. Teach me not to look at receipt before leaving restaurant. Not much of a restaurant. Not going back there read more

Food is always great! Whether you dine in or have food delivered. Great pizza and wings too!

Food is always good. We have tried everything on the menu, really great food . Vinny the waiter makes the evening fun

Ordered pizza for delivery. Pizza was ok but they missed toppings that I paid for and when I asked for a refund for the cost of the missing toppings, they refused to refund that amount. They would only give me a credit for the next time I order. Very frustrating and bad customer service. read more

For me to give a pizza place 5 stars it has to be good on all aspects. This place exceeded all my expectations and deserves 5 stars! I wanted to treat my husband to lunch for Father's day, and he had this place bookmarked and has been wanting to try it, so today was the day. This place is located in a strip mall, and has ample seating. They were moderately busy and only had two guys waiting tables, that did not stop the amazing service we received from our server Brian. After reviewing the menu, we decided on the 6 piece garlic knots as an appetizer, and I ordered the bowtie pasta with pesto sauce and my husband ordered a 14" bruschetta pizza. It wasn't long after ordering that our garlic knots came out. They were smothered with ooey gooey mozzarella cheese and were very good. Some of the best! I wasn't even done eating my last knots when my huge bowl of pasta came out, the pasta was cooked perfect al dente and you could clearly tell that the pesto sauce was homemade. My husband snuck a couple of bites and was impressed, as was I. I couldn't finish the whole bowl, so I brought it home and can't wait to have it again for supper. My husband's pizza came out just after my food, and I took a piece and it was so good, hot and flavorful. The crust was crispy and complemented the toppings perfectly. I found the prices to be reasonable, our bill before the tip was under $50! Not too shabby, as I would have paid more for the amazing food and service we received here. We were glad to finally try this place, and not only was our server Brian top notch with his witty comments and engaging personality, but the place was clean and it felt like a family owned place would be. We can't wait to go back again for more pizza! read more

See all

We frequent the Gilbert shop often, in house and take out. Never had a bad experience. This is our go to Pizza/ past shop. Bill and Pam read more

Brooklyn V's Pizza - We frequent the Gilbert shop often, in house and take out. Never had a bad experience. This is our go to Pizza/ past shop. Bill and Pam - Pizza Near Me - Gilbert, Arizona

Great pizza. Extra friendly service. Good large Garlic knotts. Really liked them here. They kept up on our drinks and went out of the way for us. Highly recommend read more

Moving to Gilbert we struggled for a while to find an Italian restaurant that was actually truly authentic. My husband has allergies to soy and canola oil and we were looking for a place that used olive oil. Brooklyn V's is very authentic! Their pizzas, sauce, pasta dishes are so good! They have generous portions and use a nice amount of real cheese on their pizzas! They also have a gluten free pizza option, which is helpful for me. My only request would be that they add the option for a gluten free pasta for their homemade pasta dishes. read more

LOVE AT FIRST "BITE"! I went in today to check out a new pizza place...the restaurant was clean, gorgeous desserts, super friendly employee, the owner even served me a drink, feeling good already about the vibes and anticipating my first bite....before even I even finished enjoying my first bite the phrase "Love at First Bite" jumped into my mind. I think I may have just found your new slogan! Truly THIS is the ONLY New York Style Pizza ANYWHERE in Arizona! I am now your new bestie! Well done Brooklyn V's!!!!! I can see why your opening another location off of Alma School! You are WINNING!!!!! see you again....and again....and again....to the moon & back! read more

The food is good.the service was good. I had the Chicken Marsala as reccomend by Vinnie. Good chicken! Don't skip the appetizers.

Pizza was good, pasta was good. Service was great. Just nothing exciting to separate from all the competition. If I'm in the area I would go without issue, just not a destination location. read more

Was looking for Italian and Brooklyn V's popped up. Located in a small strip mall it's not much to look at from the outside. Inside is super casual booth seating that was packed. Pizza being tossed back in the kitchen, take out orders being picked up--it was hopping and felt like New York. I liked it immediately. We were hungry and ordered garlic twists, chicken pesto pizza, a Stromboli, stuffed shells and the spaghetti with sausage and peppers. Everything was so good! Had way too much and could have skipped the twists. Also grabbed cannoli and a slice of cheese cake Pizza crust and sauce were really good. Would try a different combo next time. Shells were tender and flavorful. Spaghetti, sausage and peppers were so good. I barely put a dent in it but left with a bunch of leftovers. All agreed the Stromboli was the best pick of the night--packed with meats and cheese with a bright marinara for dipping. Yum. The desserts were good but probably could have skipped the chocolate sauce. Best of all what the great service from Kyle - took care of all of our requests for extra napkins and sauce and even threw in an extra cannoli so we could all have one (an order is three, he gave us a fourth). Will definitely go back. read more

Brooklyn V's Pizza - a white plate topped with chocolate and bananas - Pizza Near Me - Gilbert, Arizona

See all

Ordered this tonight through Uber eats and everything was soooo yummy. Even my side salad was good. I ordered the pasta carbonara with chicken. My partner ordered fettuccine Alfredo with sausage. It was so good. Both pastas tasted like they were worth way more than we paid. After the two pastas and the two salads we paid around 60 dollars delivered but it was worth it cause we have food left over. We definitely recommend and will be back! read more

Brooklyn V's Pizza - Fettuccine Alfredo with sausage - Pizza Near Me - Gilbert, Arizona

This place is relatively small, but they have powerfully delicious food and a friendly atmosphere. We don't go often, but we do go for fun family events and always enjoy when we do. Pizza, pastas, heros, and calzones are all fantastic. read more

Brooklyn V's is the bomb! My husband and I went In dinner on Wednesday night and ordered it via Door Dash on Saturday because we just couldn't get enough! The Stromboli was absolutely amazing! Pizza was excellent! Wish I knew what they did differently about their crust, it's like so chewy soft and crunchy at the same time. The Caesar salad came on the most ice cold plate and the dressing was so good, I bet it's homemade and the lettuce was crisp and crunchy. We finished our dinner with some choc chip cannolis to go. Once we had room we scarfed them down and they are perfection! read more

See all

From Sicily to Brooklyn to Arizona is their motto and they ain't lying!!! This place is authentic from start to finish. It may be unheard of to get authentic in AZ but it's true. Got the Stromboli and it was so delicious. If you're anywhere near this spot, you better stop here. read more

Brooklyn V's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Gilbert, Arizona

Update from the last review Came in today and owner took vare of us and fixed the pizza and made a new one and it was excellent! Thank you V! read more

Utilized UBER eats and I asked for pizza to be cooked well done and it wasn't. The pizza is ok lacks some flavor in its sauce. Garlic Knots pretty good but pasta was solid. Pasta much better the pizza in my opinion. read more

This is our second time here and will continue to come back. The Service is amazing. They greet you the minute you walk in the door. We loooove the baked caprese!!! The wings are amazing as well. The atmosphere is very cozy. The Banana Cheesecake is to die for!!!! read more

Brooklyn V's Pizza - Banana Cheesecake. Pepperoni Slices, Medium Wings & Baked Caprese. - Pizza Near Me - Gilbert, Arizona

See all

Food is always so good and service is fabulous. Pizza is delish, and we love their salads too

Pizza was bland. And salad was unwashed. Literally cut and plated. No quality control. Won't be odering here again. read more

Brooklyn V's Pizza - That's dirt. And that's not the only leaf with it. - Pizza Near Me - Gilbert, Arizona

This is THE restaurant to go for authentic Italian food and vibes! My husband took me on a lunch date and our waiter Vinnie was so kind making sure we had everything we needed, we didn't have to ask for anything because he already had thought of it! We got their Chicken Bruschetta Pizza and their Baked Ziti and shared it was perfect and we have a ton of left overs that we are so excited to eat later. We decided we couldn't leave without trying their cannolis and homemade cheesecake that was banana crème but they have a variety and we heard Vito makes different kinds all the time! Did I mention Vinnie got us to-go drinks as well? We are so excited to come back and make this a regular spot, the hospitality was just amazing! read more

Brooklyn V's Pizza - Cannoli and Banana Homemade Cheesecake - Pizza Near Me - Gilbert, Arizona

See all

The first two times I had Brooklyn V's I was blown away. I thought it was soo good but each time I've gone back it hasn't been the same since that very first time I tried it. Lately our pizza seems super greasy and the crust is so tough. I hate to say it but tastes like roller rink pizza. We absolutely loved the fried jalapeño ravioli the first time we had it but multiple times we've gotten it they are over cooked and inedible. They always forget the sauce sides like pizza sauce for the fried ravioli or ranch for our salad. I've given them a shot so many times but it's too inconsistent. The last 5 times we've gotten take out I've been really disappointed. read more

2 1/2 Star Rating: The Toppings And Bread Are Amazing!!! But the pizza itself is so wet!!! As if if they just water down the sauce to much or something. The flavor isn't bad like I said, but if you want pizza that doesn't fall apart and isn't paper thin! I wouldn't recommend this particular spot if you don't like "wet" pizza. read more

Great pasta! Great hero's! Great Stromboli! As authentic as it gets. Drove out to Gilbert today and found this little gem. read more

Brooklyn V's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Gilbert, Arizona

Pizza was excellent and the garlic knots were really good. Highly recommend this restuarent.

Great pizza, thin, perfect Crust is perfect Sauce is on point. I think they need "one bite, everybody knows the rules"... read more

Went here for the first time the other night after it was recommended by my coworker. All locations are a bit out of the way for me, but my husband and I decided to venture out just because my coworker made it sound so darn good! Well, we were not disappointed I'll tell you that much! When we first walked in I was a little surprised by how small the place was. But, staff was super friendly. We loved our waiter, Vinnie. He made sure we were happy and even stopped to genuinely chat with us in between checking in on our dining experience. We ordered the deep fried jalapeño ravioli to start, then ordered a 1/2 white pizza, 1/2 bbq bacon chicken pizza. The pizza was delicious. White pizza, although without sauce, was so light and tasty, and the bbq bacon chicken was loaded! Every bite had bacon, bbq, and the ranch that was drizzled on top was not skimped at all! Of course we couldn't stop at an appetizer and pizza. We just HAD to try dessert! We ordered the cannolis as well as an Oreo cheesecake, which we found out from our waiter is made from scratch and they have weekly rotating flavors for the cheesecakes. Both desserts were phenomenal. At the end of our dinner, my husband asked me which food item was my favorite, and I honestly couldn't pick! All of it was delicious!! We can't wait to come back and try more menu items, but I am especially excited to try more of their cheesecake flavors - absolutely delicious cheesecake!! Brooklyn V's may be a new spot for us! read more

Love a great pizza this is the place . Good food fresh made pizza go and try you will not be disappointed

My go to spot for the busy nights when I can't catch up with work and run out of time to cook dinner. The pizza is delicious and the Buffalo salad. We recently branched out and tried a different dish than normal and of course it was amazing. read more

Prices on the menu here do NOT match the actual prices. A dozen wings is 17, not 12.50. Called in an the order was ready within 1/2 an hour. We got medium wings, golden bbq, mango habanero, fettuccini Alfredo, honey bbq wings, Parmesan garlic boneless and bone-in. The wings were all delicious and had plenty of sauce. Pretty expensive. I'm not a wing connoisseur, but I'd definitely eat here again. read more

Always a great meal and Pizza was the icing on the cake! Thankful we still have mom and pop style food around us

Amazing service!! We will be returning next time we are in Gilbert! The pizza and wings were so tasty and fresh! The services was great and would fit a big party. read more

We were originally going to a different restaurant, but it was having plumbing issues....thank goodness!!!!! We would have never had the pleasure of dining at Brooklyn V's. Our waiter, Vinnie from Long Island was pure delight....not bad on the eyes either!! I had the Spaghetti with clam sauce and it was the best I ever had...perfectly seasoned with a kick. The side Ceaser salad was more than enough and the dressing was fabulous. We also split the fried Calamari, crunchy batter and cooked to perfection. It had a yummy creamy pesto parmesan sauce for dipping... My Chitown girls and I are going to go back and try New York style pizza.... Even though it probably doesn't hold a candle to Chicago style ... read more

I haven't been there in a few years and they were super busy last Friday when I picked up my online order. I did that on Yelp via Grubhub I think but it was me who ordered. I show him my order on my phone and he said he could not find it :/ A few minutes later he found it. I picked them up and left. The food was hot and delicious. But my Portobello ravioli was soupy. I meant the sauce was like watery instead of a cream like sauce. I think maybe it's the wine? But regardless it was delicious! I will be back maybe I will dine it next time。 read more

I'm am a Brooklyn NY transplant . The pizza at Brooklyn VS is the closest Brooklyn pizza you'll find in Arizona . People in Arizona ask me where they can find real NY pizza ? I direct everyone too Brooklyn VS read more

We have been regular customers for years. You guys have the best pizza in the Valley! We love the pasta, salads and wings too. Thank you for the great food and great service. You guys are the best!!!!!!! read more

I order from here often. I have introduced them to a lot of friends too. I love this place! The food is amazing, as are the staff!!