Stopped there today...after recently moving here from the best pizza state we stumbled on this gem in Gilbert. Tucked away in a strip mall it was fantastic. Had to tray a traditional slice.Tasty crust, perfect amount of mozz and a familiar tangy sauce. Also shared a chicken parm hero...again prepared perfectly!!! Cant wait to try their Chanler location as it is closer to home. read more

Service is awful! Management is worse. Extremely argumentative and certainly not customer friendly. We will never eat here again. I've worked food service for many years and never have I seen so many people hate their job as I saw here today. Awful. read more

We had this place recommended to us so we tried it out! They were open for dine in so we ordered meals! The pizza looked and smelled amazing but I had shrimp and stuffed shells. Very very great food. Honest Italian authentic food! Let me tell you about the cheesecake ... made in house and perfect! We're going back with friends! The owner was working and made sure we were happy with his food! Gotta give this place a try for pizza or authentic Italian food in-house and take out. read more

This is one of those times that I was led astray by the reviews. Ordered two pizzas for take out - an 18 inch cheese and an 18 inch three meat. Asked upon ordering for them to be double cut. Had to explain to the employee on the phone what that was and then be put on hold to check!? Brought these pizzas to a potluck so by the time we ate it was cold. I was not impressed. It was edible but that is about it. Another person brought Barros pizza to the potluck. The Barros pizza was gone almost in an instant while my pizzas sat and got picked at. Brought an entire pizza home with me. Our family has eaten it reheated and cold and it is just okay. Not gross but not that good. I paid almost $37 for these mediocre pizzas. I can't imagine ever trying this place again. read more

Visited the Queen Creek restaurant. Disappointed. Wife and I had sausage cheese pizza. Sausage lacks flavor. Sauce is applied sparsely. The dough tasted like toast. Staff was freindy and courteous. Clean and commodious eating area. read more

We have ordered from here before and this time it was worse than little Caesar's day old pizza. I even waited for the trays to get done, and it looked and tasted like the dough was made a week ago and it was cold and dry. For $50 for two pizzas, I expect a lot more. There was only one table, so can't chalk it up to being busy. Back to the drawing board, extremely disappointed!! read more

Went to meet out of state family for pizza. Wanted a place where we could meet halfway. After arriving at our destination pizza restaurant found a sign that stated that the restaurant was closed on Monday and Tuesday, which wasn't posted on their website. Did a quick Yelp search and found Brooklyn V Pizza. I would like to say maybe it turned out for the better. The pizza and service was excellent . My out of state family was very impressed stating I wish I didn't live 2200 miles from here that was a great pizza. If you're in the area give them a try. I don't think you will be disappointed. read more

Pretty good casual pizza place. The servers were nice. I ordered the garlic knots with cheese and the Penne Vodka pizza with added sausage. The homemade marinara for the knots was a little watery and I prefer mine thicker, but it had great flavor. The 14' pizza was a good size to share for 2 or 3 people. The crust could have been a little crispier in my opinion. It wasn't too thin or thick, a perfect size. I probably wouldn't order the same pizza again, would rather try something else. The bruschetta is a favorite. read more

Brooklyn V's Pizza - Garlic knots w/ cheese - Pizza Near Me - Gilbert, Arizona

See all

Wow!!! The crust on the pie was amazing! Taste great. It's the kind of slice that you can't really cut with a fork and knife; stays stiff without flopping when you pick it up. Staff was really nice. The owner/chef even made a round to ask everyone how their meal was, told us some of the secrets to the amazing cheesecake recipe. The waiter told us that the owner only makes a couple of the cheesecakes every month. "Once they are gone, they're gone". Glad we got in on it, it was light, fluffy, delicious. We were there early by 4:45. There was about 4 tables w customers. The kitchen was buzzing w preparation and to go orders. More people came in as it got later; definitely a busy place. The strip mall where this divine pizza is located is so-so. It looked like it was closing down but there was definitely life at Brooklyn Vs. Pizza wise-this place tops out in rank of my favorite authentic pizzas in Gilbert: #1 Brooklyn V, #2 Sals Gilbert Pizza #3 Casanova. If I include location and dining room in my ranking then I would probably have Sals or Casanova (new location) in the top #1 & #2. I'm eager to go back to Brooklyn V with the kids. I brought home some slices and they loved it. read more

We found this pizza place from a good friend so we decided to dine in . Right as we walk through the door we were greeted with smiles and it didn't stop there the food was amazing ! Pizza , wings , down to the Oreo Cheesecake ! The owner came over to our table introduced himself very nice gentleman he told us he had been making pizzas since he was 14 yrs old and it shows trust me . If you live in the Gilbert Az area it's a must Desiree thank you for the wonderful service also read more

This is our second time I have ordered thru Door Dash! This is truly up there among the best pizzas I have ever had! The amount of thick cut meets and the abundant cheese without having to pay extra was a pleasing surprise! Stay away from the large "cookie cutter" pizza chains and give Brooklyn V's a try! read more

Pizza is so so good!!! New York! I love it! Super nice customer service! It's hidden but worth it!

Great pizza and breadsticks. We called the waitress mom the whole time during our visit. (Inside joke) great food and reminded me of pizza back east. Must try if you love New York pizza!!! read more

Brooklyn V's Pizza - Free garlic knots!!! Why yes please - Pizza Near Me - Gilbert, Arizona

Everything is fresh! I was first pleased at how good the ranch dressing was, light, not heavy. I ordered pizza, which was great, but immediately thought the baked ziti looked so good...I'll be back! The price is super for the quality and I'd recommend anyone that likes New York style pizza give this place a try. read more

Brooklyn V's Pizza - Great lunch at Brooklyn V's! - Pizza Near Me - Gilbert, Arizona

The wife and I stopped in yesterday, on the humble not knowing what to expect. Food was awesome they made us some special pasta just for us to try yum yum yum. Brooklyn V's service was excellent the best service we have had since arriving in Phoenix & Desiree is the Bomb.com she was our server and she hung out with us while we were there it was just like hanging with out of your cousins or close friends. Definitely going back. PS. The wings were A1 read more

So disappointed. I order pizza from Brooklyn v's every week. I have gotten other local families to change to Brooklyn v's as their go to pizzeria as well. But now I will never go back. Their customer service is horrendous. They messed up our takeout order today, my husband waited for the correct order to be made, and then they wanted to charge him more for the order than the original quote because our order was more expensive. Yes, I am happy to pay full price on my order. But when you mess up and then don't have our food ready and then you decide to charge us more instead of giving us a discount because of the inconvenience you caused...that's just horrible management. Now our weekly pizza business and all of our friends and family business will go elsewhere. read more

First of all, if you're looking for the best authentic New York pizza in AZ, you've found it. The owner here, Vito, is from Sicily Italy, and the culinary skills he's brought over from his world really shines through. Everything at Brooklyn V's is handmade from scratch and tastes WONDERFUL. He and his family have made this atmosphere amazing with all of the love they have for their customers. When I was in high school, I used to to Ballet at Joffrey every summer in the Big Apple and, I kid you not, Brooklyn pizza became a way of life. Vito's here is AMAZING and brought that nostalgia back to me last night and I felt like a 18 year old winding down after a long day from the studio. With his pizza there's more cheese and toppings than crust, and the cheese was perfectly melted and there was NO EXTRA GREASE!! The ranch is homemade and THE BEST RANCH EVER!! I wish I could take it back to PDX lmao. The price was right, the regular size fed 2-3 of us, and we actually have family that flew in today; I'm hope we can convince them to get Brooklyn V's this weekend! We cannot wait to be back Vito!! read more

We have a new favorite Italian restaurant and it's Brooklyn V's! We dined there on a busy Friday night and were seated right away. We started our dining experience with the caprese appetizer, which was really good! We ordered a glass of wine and relaxed, listening to the live music who was an amazing singer/songwriter and guitar player, Aaron Howard and Sarah Price, who also has an amazing voice. Anyway, after a short wait, our dinners arrived. My husband had the eggplant parmesan and I had the special, cheese tortellini with alfredo sauce, with peppers and mushrooms. We really enjoyed each of our dinners, especially the eggplant parmesan, or as my husband says, "The best eggplant parm that he has had here in Arizona!" Also, the owner, Desiree was our hostess and server for the evening. She went above and beyond in regards to her service and attention to us. She treated us like her personal VIPs and I was blown away by her generosity. We will be back again, for more music, fun, and excellent food. Thank you, Brooklyn Vs! read more

Poor customer service. There are too many good pizza places in Gilbert to go somewhere with bad customer service. I ordered a pizza today and the girl who answered the phone couldn't even hear me to take my order. The other workers were all around her yelling, to the point where she couldn't hear me and I had to repeat myself several times, it was very frustrating as the customer. Then when I arrived to pick up my pizza and wings, I looked at the pizza and it was incorrect. I ordered a white pizza and they gave me a white eggplant pizza. When I returned it I was told "you can keep the wings." NO, you can keep the wings and keep them hot for me, there goes the extra crispy I asked for as they sat in sauce for an extra 20+ mins while I waited for them to make the correct pizza. During that 20+ minute wait I was never once asked if I would like a beverage or even a water, you know, while they correct their mistake. Last time we will give this restaurant almost $50 for a pizza and dozen wings. read more

Hidden gem tucked away...great atmosphere with music and theme that matches its great food. As you glance around the room as you wait for your food you see pictures of happy families enjoying their time here at Brooklyn V's. Very friendly staff with a customer service speciality. The chef delivered my food with a smile as the waiter refilled my drink. Such a pleasant quite lunch. A must try! read more

I can't believe people think the pizza here is good. We had it delivered through uber eats and never again will I eat here. The pizza had basically no sauce. Frozen pizza is better then their pizza. Also I thought I order pepperoni and mushroom but apparently it was only for half the pizza and it was $2 each. So $4 for toppings on HALF of a 14"!! What a joke. The boneless wings are fine even though they look more like popcorn chicken because they're so small and round. Their prices are ridiculous. Definitely spend your money elsewhere. read more

We found this place by accident, happily so. We've ordered 6x and haven't been disappointed. This is a little gem in our area.

This is the best pizza in Chandler. Food is awesome. Staff is even better. Say hello to big Mike behind the counter. They make you feel like family. I love this place. read more

Our busy schedules started to make us order online through Seamless. We LOVED the food at BrooklynV's. We've had multiple horrible experiences with not receiving the correct order/missing food/and the food coming in half the portions you receive in the restaurant. When calling the restaurant to correct the issues the staff was extremely unprofessional and RUDE! I gave the restaurant one last chance today and the food was delivered missing a salad and the sauce dripping out of the bag that was handed to me! So disappointing. If I'm gonna spend 40$ on two entrees, wether it be delivery or in house- the quality should be the same. Not sure what's going on here. Maybe the owners aren't as involved with the quality and care provided to their guests?? read more

This was great food tonight. Absolutely try the ricotta and eggplant pizza . Sounds crazy but it is amazing. If you are a pasta person, try the meat sauce on anything. Excellent. Fun staff and decent prices. Try the canoli too. Wow! read more

See all

Just opened in Queen Creek, we had Pesto Chicken pizza and Pineapple/Ham pizza and Cannolis, great staff and great food, I will be back with more friends too. This place will be a local favorite I have no doubt. Thank you Anna for great service too. read more

If you love Italian food like Stromboli, Calzone, Pizza and pasta this is the best choice for that home cooked quality. Great portions, great service and the quality of the food is outstanding! You must try this place! read more

Good place for slices, I feel like the Stromboli was overpriced. Service is friendly and the place is clean.

TASTY ITALIAN!! We've had a hard time finding GOOD, TRADITIONAL Italian in the east valley. Brooklyn V's hit the spot for us! Penne Vodka, Fett. Alfredo, Chicken Parm..all of it! Their portions are huge and make for two days of meals per dish. That thrilled us, as you don't find that value anymore. We appreciated being able to stretch that dollar. The service was friendly and this place is busy on a Friday night. So happy to see that! read more

We give Brooklyn V's a hearty 5 stars. We were looking for a good local Italian restaurant and decided to try this local treasure. It had received high ratings and after eating there, we agree with those marks. The staff was extremely friendly and the food was amazing. We will definitely be back. We have found our new favorite Italian restaurant in the Gilbert area. read more

Ordered take out. Pizza was delicious. Caesar salad was fresh except croutons got hydrated so they weren't crunchy bu the time I got home. Maybe package them separately for to go orders? Calamari was ok, was a little over cooked. The pizza made up for these two negatives. Would order again. read more

Love this place. Food is fantastic with all the traditional favorites.

The food was delicious and he service was great. Anna took care of us and Vito came out from the kitchen to make sure the food was great. We will be back! read more

See all

Ask for Desirée she is the best server she knows the menu, including off the menu dishes that are to die for. The owners are on hand ready to cook up fresh delicious food. Everything we had was just that, fresh and delicious. The atmosphere is inviting and family friendly. We caught part of the football game on one of the many tv's on the wall. The restaurant as a whole has the feeling of a New York restaurant (minus the shopping center). I will bring the entire family next time. Although we didn't try the pizza we were satisfied with our choices. I had the chicken Marsala it was rich and delicious. The extra crispy wings were perfection. Off the menu item was a bowl of spaghetti with peppers and Italian sausages. We also got to try these buttery Garlic rolls they were a garlic lovers dream. Don't get me started on desert. Cannolis and cheesecake of the day reminded me of New York's little Italy in the middle of Saint Gennaro festival. Do your self a favor and enjoy a great delicious time at V's! read more

See all

Simply the best Italian food I've had in AZ! These people know how to serve up some of the best food . Their stores are clean and staff are the friendliest around. I would recommend them to anyone and everyone ! Took my fam to Brooklyn V today for lunch at this location in Gilbert as it was my moms bday and once again it was simply the best! We all enjoyed it so much and the fact it was in our neighborhood was just a bonus but frankly I'd travel much farther just for the food and atmosphere and staff that BV offers! Cozy space with great ambiance my family and I will return many times . Thanks Kerry you were the BEST. read more

Visited last night for dinner with friends. Our party of 4 split a large 18" pepperoni pizza and an order of 12 garlic knots. The food was EXCELLENT! I think the dough/crust MAKES the pizza and Brooklyn V's has it down pat. This space has been occupied by a few pizza joints since I've lived in the area and I've never been too impressed - but I'll definitely be back to Brooklyn V's. Other +'s: *Cannoli's - Very good! *Iced Tea - Fresh! *Friendly staff *Nice family/owners that took the time to say hello and welcome us to their establishment. read more

The pizza was terrible it was very thin with the margarita pizza it was may be three small tomatoes really no topping and just very very unsatisfying Meal Vito in Brooklyn V's used to be one of our favorite places for pizza however not anymore the last few times I've just been very disappointing OK enough read more

It's been awhile since we have been here and now I remember why. We ordered a white pizza with ham and pineapple and there was no ham or pineapple on half the pizza. Don't really understand how they messed that one up. read more

Our new favorite pizza place! The pizza was delicious. We got the cheese, pepperoni and sausage and it was gone in no time. We also tried the jalapeno ravioli and we are glad we did! It too was so flavorful and a perfect amount of kick! Staff was nice and the beer was cold! We will be back! read more

OMG! THIS IS THE PLACE for an authentic NY Italian meal!!!! My man decided on a whim that I was going to try a new place after he had tried it for lunch. He said he couldn't wait to take me to Brooklyn V's. I am a very picky eater and I am not a fan of chains so I was really happy to support a small business that really knows its business! We started with these little bread things they call garlic knots that come with marinara YUM! This was starting out fantastic. You can tell a lot from the marinara, ya know ;) We each ordered a Stromboli and they were to die for! I could have cut it lengthwise and just crawled in, they do kinda look like sleeping bags. You know when you taste something so good the world just kinda stops spinning? Yeah......Oh sorry! We took a tiramisu home to split for later. The waitress said it was heaven in a box. I haven't had too much luck with tiramisu here in AZ so I wasn't too excited. A couple hours later her words were still echoing in my head and I just had to taste it. Fireworks shot off! The band started playing and suddenly I was in Italy! Reluctantly I put the other half (well almost half, he he) back in the fridge for my man. The liquor license is coming folks! read more