I was really excited walking in and hearing all the accents and such, but if this is New York pizza, I'd rather stick with Arizona. Pizza was not terrible, but the sauce was way too watery. Everything slid off of our pizza. They also seemed to be big on the oil as well. Both the pizza and knots had excessive amounts of oil. The service was great and the staff was friendly, which is why I say 3 stars. Would I return? No. Not with all the great choices in the area. $28 for a med pizza, knots, and drink. read more

I am originally from NYC and moved to Arizona close to 2 years ago. I found out about this place from a random New Yorker I met. To say the least, this place is amazing. I go to Brooklyn V's all the time. I feel a price of home and nostalgia when I walk in. I spent about a year and a half trying to find good NY pizza and did not find it, until I went to Brooklyn V's. I won't eat any other pizza, except for theirs. Not only do they have great pizza, they offer amazing pasta dishes, desserts, and their staff is the greatest. I will always be a New Yorker and their food makes me miss/appreciate the NY style of food. read more

Checked out this joint based on the positive reviews. Had garlic knots to start...good but nothing better than the norm. Pizza was also good but nothing I would consider significantly better than your average pizza joint. Tried bruschetta pizza. Although it was good, probably will stick to pie shops closer to our home. read more

Brooklyn V's Pizza - Garlic knots...ok - Pizza Near Me - Gilbert, Arizona

See all

This is my first experience with Brooklyn V's, so I will be specific to what I ordered, in fairness to menu items I have not tried. Order - 14" Margherita pizza Antipasto salad Cannoli Let's start with the delivery - 90 minutes at least, which may have been a fluke, but almost always means cold pizza. :( The salad was extremely bitter - it tasted like half of the salad was giardiniera - perhaps they made it wrong. It was barely edible as a "salad" - it tasted like edible garnish. The pizza was predictably cold, so I warmed a slice in the oven a little. First off, the only reason I ordered the pizza was because the picture showed a solid looking Margherita - fresh mozzarella SLICES, fresh green basil, etc. Once you have had a real Margherita, your life will forever be a littler brighter. What I got was a 17 buck "freezer box" quality pizza. The cannoli were ok, but nothing to write home about, and certainly nowhere near restaurant or deli quality cannoli, of which there are plenty around. I feel like I wasted half a Franklin - that's never fun. read more

Brooklyn V's Pizza - what poor Margherita pizza looks like - Pizza Near Me - Gilbert, Arizona

Amazingly great food. Owner is super nice and friendly. Good prices and very clean inside and out. Taste flavor everything absolutely amazing. First time here found my new home for pizza definitely won't go anywhere else now. If your ever in Gilbert Arizona don't pass up this place without stopping in and grabbing something to eat. Thanks for the great food experience and service. read more

See all

As a former New Yorker this place delivers on the promise of a true NY style pizza in AZ. We're so happy a friend recommended Brooklyn V's to us! read more

Brooklyn V's Pizza - Meatballs are legit! - Pizza Near Me - Gilbert, Arizona

I should be dumbfounded by the rave reviews of this place given the quality of pizza, but there are other very average pizza places in Gilbert that have also garnered 4.5 star ratings. I suggested Brooklyn V's last Friday when I was watching a movie with my parents. No one felt like driving so our usual go to, Grimaldi's, wasn't going to happen. I checked on Yelp and saw that I could get delivery from a place that I bookmarked over a year ago. Perfect timing! Unfortunately, the pizza was a big let down. We got the margherita ($29 with tip and tax), and it was so unmemorable. The crust was really bad. Usually, I love crust, but with this one, I was wishing my dogs were around so I give them their "pizza bones." I didn't like the grape tomatoes either. Cheese and sauce were fine. Again, just very average. My dad crisped up my 2nd piece in a frying pan, and that seemed to help. Lesson learned. Don't be lazy. Drive to Grimaldi's. read more

Been to Brooklyn V's several times since they've open, my complaint isn't the food... Last night my husband tried to order a pizza for take out. It was 845, they close at 9. The young female on the phone stated that they didn't want to make our pizza since they were closing... Wow. Great customer service. We normally aren't those ppl that order for right before close, but we are moving away from the area and that would have been our last time there. Thanks for the great memory. read more

Had mushroom spinach calzone it was probably the best calzone I ever had. Super busy for a small place and only one stall in the restroom. My only concern was the size of the place and what happens if one night 2 people have to shit at the same time! read more

FANTASTIC!!! This is a great little find. tucked in the corner, real mom/pop feel. The bread knots were a fun appetizer (amazingly priced) and my family enjoyed a pepperoni pizza. the red sauces were fantastic!! Vito himself even came out and chatted with us for a few. Nice atmosphere, great food, great price. You've got a customer here!!! We'll be back!! read more

I am not from New York, I have never been to New York. I have no expectations for pizza based on my old New York neighborhood or from childhood memories. Growing up in Mexico, pizza choices in the small town of Agua Prieta were somewhat limited to a couple of restaurants that served pies that had one thing in common to New York style pizza, the shape was round. Hungry last night, after a very stressful day at work, we wanted some food to be delivered to us. We wanted to be able to order it without hassle and we wanted it delivered fast. Demanding, I know. In this area ,Brooklyn V's Pizza delivered. I ordered it online, in a very easy to use website, they delivered it to my home and took about 45 minutes, which is a great time on a friday night. The pizza we ordered was the buffalo chicken pizza, not a very traditional pie, but I had been wanting to try it. The cost for an 18" pie was $20.00, a little on the expensive side. I was hoping for a delicious pizza, and I am not going to lie, the dough had very good flavor, but that was it. The chicken was extremely salty, to the point that we had to take it off the pizza, which wasn't a big task because there hardly was any chicken on the pizza to begin with, and the worst is the chicken was way too dry, and it hardly had any buffalo sauce in it. So I wasn't too pleased with this pie, but I am sure if I stick to a classic next time, they will do better in this department. We also ordered a cheese calzone with bacon and their garlic knots and those were the highlight of our meal. The calzone was filled with lots of cheese and bacon and tasted delicious. The garlic knots and the accompanying marinara sauce were so delicious we were fighting over them. I would definitely go back to Brooklyn V's pizza and probably eat in and order a more traditional pie or something else off the menu. For a pizza, a calzone and the order of knots I spent $45.00 including delivery and tip. read more

Love this place. I've been three times, once for pizza, then penne in vodka sauce, and most recently spaghetti with meat sauce. Absolutely everything is made fresh and I can taste every bit of it! The sauces are fantastic. Next time I'm trying the pesto. I don't even like pesto, but that's how much I enjoy the food here. The service is great too. Very friendly and warm staff. Feels like home. read more

Brooklyn V's Pizza - Ah, the classic spaghetti! I'm costantly disappointed at how many places mess this up. Brooklyn V's does it right! - Pizza Near Me - Gilbert, Arizona

There have been a few pizza places in this suite over the years, I tried them all but never went back after trying them out once or twice (and I live pretty much right across the street). Love the food here, owners and servers are very nice and bend over backwards to give you what you want. I've brought friends here and they've enjoyed the food and atmosphere as well!!! read more

Pizza was fine. Televisions in the place had on Fox News. Why? I don't want to watch this junk. I should have asked if they would turn the channel. Brooklyn V's please turn off Fox News. read more

Best Pizza in Arizona hands down, best authentic NY pizza ive ever had! I come from the east coast and believe you me I've been back to NY & NJ several times and I've never had NY pizza like this before! My first time trying this pizza was August 2018! Ive recommended this great place to multiple family members and friends and they all love it! Once you try it, its hard to eat pizza from anywhere else! read more

We were not impressed with the food or service. We ordered an 18" half pepperoni and mushroom half buffalo chicken with the intention of having leftovers. The chicken tasted burnt. Even my husband who likes well grilled chicken thought the chicken tasted like charcoal. We picked off most of the chicken and the mushrooms which may have been canned or at least not real fresh. When the server asked about a box we said we would like a small box but had no interest in the chicken pizza because the burnt taste was too much. Our server shrugged and said,"Ok." Finally we received the bill and were surprised to have been charged for the higher priced chicken pizza plus the two ingredients on the other half as 'extras.' The pepperoni pizza that we ended up with would have been half the cost and we probably wouldn't have left half on our plates and the serving tray. read more

Our family was introduced to Brooklyn V's about two years ago. We were very impressed with the quality of food and service which is why this location has grown into a weekly stop for us. We look forward to it each week. The pizza is amazing, our boys love their wings, and my wife loves that they offer gluten free dough. Always greeted promptly and all the servers are fantastic. I couldn't leave a review without mentioning our regular server Vin. Grew up not far from myself in NY, the kids love him, and he is one of the reasons we frequent this place. read more

I agree with people who say this is the best New York Pizza that can be found in Arizona. I'm glad I don't live closer because I would be there two or three times a week. The pizza is outstanding. The garlic rolls are the best I have had outside of New York. Everything I tried was fresh and the cannoli were especially delicious. The service was extremely friendly and you have to be a little patient, but you're getting quality with your wait. Best pizza I have found in 23 years of living in Arizona other than Pizzeria Bianco, but that is more Italian style than New York style. read more

First off we had the garlic knots. They were SO DAMN GOOD. Perfect balance of crispy outside with soft gooey insides and not overly garlic'd. The sauce was made fresh in house and had great flavor. We ordered 12 - 6 would be enough for most people as they are larger than I expected them to be. None survived though :) Excellent pizza. Tried the margherita and was very impressed. The basil was super fresh, as were the tomatoes and it had clumps of gooey real mozzarella. The crust was perfect. If you like NY pizza this is the closest I've found it in AZ. The pepperoni was also very good. Not too greasy with nice flavor. Also, you can order by the slice and it still comes fresh so that was great for lunch. For dessert the Snickers pie was amazing. It was not too sweet which is often something I dislike in those types of pie. The owner, Vito, came over and chatted with us for a bit which was a nice touch and our server Nadine was super friendly and attentive. Dining room and restrooms were very clean. We will definitely be back to try other things off the menu. Hands down crushes Casanova Bros. read more

We love their pizza, and it's become a weekly staple on Friday nights. The dough is fabulous (crunchy and chewy) and the toppings always taste fresh and are flavorful. Do expect to wait on the weekends. They are always busy and getting pizza to go usually takes us an hour. read more

I'm so bummed I didn't have the same experience as everyone else with the pizza. I placed the order through yelp delivery. It initially said 45 min to 1 hour. Great! I placed and paid for my order. Then I go through my email to check the tracker and the bump up my delivery time to an hour and a half. Whoa! I guess I don't have a choice now that I paid. The food is delivered and I missed meeting the delivery person so I had no interaction with the staff. I ordered : BBQ chicken pizza, bruschetta pizza , and pepperoni pizza .... Honestly I can appreciate this pizza and see how people could love it. I just wasn't one of those people. It was just OK. It could be that I am not a fan of "real" pizza... I really have no idea. Again, the pizza definitely was not bad, just not to my taste and a bit overpriced. Would I try this place again? Yes, sometimes first impressions are deceiving read more

Delish, delish and delish. The perfect amount of everything. Very authentic NY pizza. I have not tried anything else on the menu because the pizza is so darn good! read more

Great lunch special. The sell slices. It's my go to pizza place now. Prices are good. Pizza is good. Service is good. What more do you want. So tired of chain delvery pizza. Good pizza with a mom and pop feal. Place gets packed at night. I recommend it. Kinda place makes you feal like a regular the first time your there. They also have a small patio. read more

After living in AZ for almost 20 years, I FINALLY found a restaurant where they know how to *correctly* pronounce mozzarella! (Mootsarel, of course!) This place is the real deal; the owners are from Bay Ridge! Between the four of us, we had garlic knots, three-meat Stromboli, pepperoni calzone, stuffed shells, and a couple of Hawaiian pizza slices. Aside from the garlic knots being a little hard on the bottoms but very flavorful, everything was delicious! The staff was very friendly, great atmosphere, and Brooklyn decorated. We will definitely be returning! read more

Really awesome pasta dishes, I love the fact they don't use sausage in every dish. Wished they had garlic bread as a side. Pizza is good, wife likes it a lot more than I do, probably wouldn't order it if not for her. Side salads are pricey but entrees will leave you enough for lunch the next day and are priced right. Nothing fancy , real casual but yummy. read more

See all

It was their two year anniversary when we got there, not knowing this information; but we got treated very well. Customer service was beyond wonderful. Bianco pizza: one of the best pizzas I've had in awhile. The ricotta cheese definitely gives it that extra something. The thinness of it was light and crispy. Wings: we got them hot..could have had more sauce but you could actually taste the chicken, which is way better than other places considering they taste like oil and sauce. Garlic knots: soft and small pillows of goodness. Not an overwhelming amount of garlic. read more

We ate outside. Very nice and clean! We had bruschetta bread for an appetizer. They served us about 9 slices of very good bruschetta. A LOT for an appetizer! The pizza was DELICIOUS! We asked for extra cheese and mushrooms for toppings. They did put a really great amount of cheese, and REAL big fresh mushrooms MMMMM! We had a plate of cannolis for dessert. They were the short more thin type of cannolis vs the long thick type. They serve 3 on a plate decorated with powdered sugar. They were very good! I never had a cannoli before, it was a good first experience. :D The waiter was so sweet, kind and attentive, and we had leftovers to take home! WILL go back and WILL recommend! There were SO many things that I plan to go back and try. Stuffed shells too. Oh my goodness... That menu... ^v^ read more

I can't wait to try the pizza! I found some menus for Brooklyn V's that had been delivered to my shop. After seeing their great Yelp reviews I HAD to try it for myself. I ordered the sausage and pepper hero, the bruschetta, and the garlic knots. Here's what I think: *Bruschetta- It's 7 pieces of loveliness. The bread itself it very good and the toppings are of exceptional quality. The balsamic glaze really stole my heart. Tomatoes were ripe, onions fresh, and basil bright...winner any day. *Garlic knots- great value. 12 pieces for $3 and change! The texture and butteriness of the dough was perfect. My only critique on these would be that I'd like more garlic flavor. That will not keep me from getting these every time I eat here, however. *Sausage and pepper hero- absolutely terrific flavors! The sausage is thin cut and cooked with red peppers and onion so it ends up nice and juicy. Those juices and the olive oil blend making this really nice sauce. I wish the bread (although tasty) was a bit more stout. By the time my order was delivered it was quite soggy. Next time I order delivery I'll definitely go with pizza or pasta. But If I ever dine in this is gonna be at the top of my list. This restaurant is not what I would call inexpensive. For the three items I ordered I paid $25 before the gratuity. I definitely feel like I got my money's worth though. I had to share the bruschetta with a coworker so it wouldn't go weird, and I'm going home with a bunch of garlic knots and half of a sandwich. I would have given 5 stars but I wish they would use a heavier bread for such a wet Hero. If I could give 4.5 stars I would have, no problem. read more

See all

Great pizza. Been looking for a great pizza in Az and finally found it. Had a Calzone the other day and it was just as great as the pizza.

Wow! I popped in for lunch on a Tuesday and was kindly greeted by Bob, one of the owners. I sat down for lunch and thought I'd give their pizza and Stromboli a try. The pizza was good. I'm from NJ, and I was very impressed. It's on par with some of the other NY style pizza places in Gilbert. The Stromboli, though... Out of this world. I saw how big it was and I figured I'd get through half after a slice of pizza, but I couldn't leave any of it. The dough was flavorful, crunchy on the outside and soft in the middle. There was a ton of cheese! One of the best I ever had and it's made from scratch, so it takes about 20min of you just walk in. Absolutely worth it! Thanks Bob for a great experience! I know where I'm going for my pizza fix from now on! read more

We celebrated my daughter's first birthday here last night and could not have been more impressed. My wife reserved a table for our party and the staff was not only accommodating, but went above and beyond by decorating our table with balloons, birthday napkins and even had a special candle for the cake. The food was phenomenal. My party tried garlic knots, spaghetti and pizza. Everything tasted delicious and the pizza was excellent. Cheese, sauce, garlic, pepperoni, spinach and dough all came together perfectly. Beer and wine were very reasonably priced and the live music completed the night. The staff was very attentive to our needs and I cannot say enough about how welcomed they made all of us feel. This is a family owned business that shows tremendous pride in quality and preparation of food and care for their patrons. A big thank you to the entire staff at Brooklyn V's for making my daughter's first birthday one that we will never forget. read more

Went to their new location soft opening by Harkins Theaters by accident. My son and I came out of Harkins wanting to go todinner. Noticed this pizza place had opened. Glad we did. Food was very good. Service was even better. Very knowledgeable of menu. Will definetly be back. read more

Had a birthday party tonight and the food was amazing the service was awesome, I had the linguini with clams my nephew had an amazing calzone and my wife had the chicken marsala that was out of this world We will be coming back for many more family functions read more

Finally found a NY/NJ style pizza joint here in Az. This place is the real deal. Stopped in for lunch today. Shared an antipasto and 14" pie with my wife. Both dishes were delicious. The antipasto had tons of ingredients with were all very fresh and flavorful. For the pie, we went half eggplant and half pesto chicken. Our server, Anna, was extremely friendly and helpful. Being from NJ as a child we struck up conversation quite easily. For dessert we each had a mini cannoli, to die for. We shall return and refer our east coast friends as well. read more

Brooklyn V's Pizza - 14" pizza, half eggplant half pesto chicken....so good! - Pizza Near Me - Gilbert, Arizona

First time I tried this place and it will be the last. It took 1 hour 7 min to get my pizza and cheese sticks delivered. Now the delivery time was long but would not be a reason for a one star rating. The pizza and cheese sticks were delivered cold. The cheese sticks cheese was solid type cold now imagine the pizza. So the food was thrown away as it was nasty. What restaurant would actually allow food to be delivered this way? Well this one did! The temp of the pizza was 73 with a food thermometer, the cheese sticks were 69 degrees. Not only does this increase the possibility of food poisoning it's just plan bad service. On top of this they offered a credit back to my card of 19.00 from a 36.00 bill. They want to charge me 17.00 for food that was thrown away? Now included in this 17.00 is a 5.00 delivery fee and the drivers tip. You have to add the tip when you order thru them as they use slice for there on line orders. So now I have to file a dispute with the cc company. My option is stay away, cold dangerous food is delivered I would not risk it. I will also be filing a complaint with the health department on Monday as it is really dangerous delivering cold food like it was tonight. read more

I ordered a large Margherita pizza at $28 total and it was probably one of the worst pizza's I've ever gotten. Hardly any sauce and only one little quarter size mozzarella on each slice. Will never order there again!! read more

I've been here before and fortunately it was really good, unfortunately the pizza I just got was more like cheese bread. How does one making pizza error on the side of no sauce and all cheese? Needs to be more consistent or else you'll be getting something different every single time you go here. read more

Just another awesome experience. I would love to try other things on the menu but I cant get past the pie. read more

Brooklyn V's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Gilbert, Arizona

These guys are legitimately cooking New York food. After bonding over our shared history in Bay Ridge, we settled down to a pepperoni pizza, the white eggplant pizza, and stuffed shells. Pizzas were perfectly done with crisp, tasty crust, perfect thinness, just enough grease cooked out of the cheese, fresh ricotta and a really superb sauce. Stuffed shells are often heavy and dense, but Vito makes a really light, well seasoned filling and the shells are expertly al dente. The only thing better than the food is the service - thanks Desiree! Thoughtful, friendly, attentive and never overbearing. Twice we asked them to open a place in Scottsdale, but until then its time very, very, very well spent to get to them for such great food. read more

Man the food here is soooo good. I am in love with their Stromboli and think the sausage and pepper is supreme. The layout is a little cluttered on the inside but when the weather warms up a bit they have a nice outside section. The staff is friendly and nice to see owners in the operation. The pizza is best ordered by the slide as you will get that perfect crispiness vs. the standard flabby droop you find in most places. They nail their marinara sauce with just the right balance of acidity and sweetness. The cheese they use is top notch and produces little oil when heated. Great flavor too! We will certainly be back and between this place and Gilbert Pizza I really do not feel the need to venture out further in this area. read more