Brooklyn Pizza

I'm impressed, Carlucci's! I've had countless "Supreme" or "Deluxe" pizzas in Columbus, and they're…read moreall pretty much the same quality. There's something about Carlucci's version of a Deluxe that sets it apart. The toppings were generous and delicious. I don't even like mushrooms, but they blended in well with the pepperoni, onions and green peppers. Shout out to the sausage for being the MVP ingredient. This was my first time going to Carlucci's, and I would go back to try additional pizzas - like their Super Deluxe!

Crust was not bad. Good amount of toppings for the deluxe. On the expensive side. Quick and very…read morenice employees. Sauce lacks flavor, pizza tasted bland

Stromboli just the way we love it!

Amazing Stromboli with extra pizza sauce

See all

Stromboli with pepperoni, sausage, onion, green pepper, black olives, and half with fresh sliced jalapeños. Incredible!

Gallos Pizza

4.2(20 reviews)

4.4 mi

It's been a while since I've had NY style pizza so I couldn't tell you how authentic the food is…read more I stopped by for lunch to grab a cheese slice and the Sistine chapel slice. They warm it up for you, which doesn't take long. It was delicious! You could really taste that they used a variety of cheeses. It's pricey for a slice but seems on par with inflation. I'd come back if I'm ever craving another slice!

Stopped here to get bubble tea felt like I really needed to eat something so I decided to veer away…read morefrom getting bubble tea and chose pizza Maybe not the smartest thing to do at 3 o'clock because pizza was probably out there since 12. I chose the bridge park special, which was a pizza with an olive oil base mozzarella cheese with a basil pesto over it. Grilled chicken and grilled onions. The chicken taste like rubber. I did not eat it after the first piece didn't trust it. It's very hard and chewy. The rest of the pizza had a good flavor. It was served a little too hot, but considering it was 3 o'clock, I was glad it was heated thoroughly. There was a lot of olive oil on it. It was a very greasy piece of pizza you needed an extra napkin. Service was excellent. The man that took my order was pleasant and he even brought my pizza to where I was sitting that was appreciated and a surprise. As far as ambience, there's like patio twinkle lights on the top. It's a big food hall so the seating is shared among all the vendors again I was there at 3 o'clock. There was maybe two other patrons it's not a very popular time. Would it come back? Sure I would just come back closer to 12 when the pizza was guaranteed fresh I feel this might've been sitting for a while. This would've been a four or 4 1/2 star piece of pizza had the chicken, thin tender Instead, I had to go with a three cause it was neither wonderful nor was it awful. It was just good. Again, I would come back... And will. And when I do, I hope I can give it a higher score.

Garlic bread

See all

Interior

George's Pizza

4.1(30 reviews)

3.1 mi

I could never say enough about this place…read more My grandmother always says, "pizza is pizza, it all always tastes the same after the first bite." I agree with that, mostly. There's plenty of pizza places in Columbus. Some have better first bites than others, but it's still just pizza. I don't mean to sound dramatic, but I don't keep coming back just for the pizza. It's how George's makes me feel. I started getting pizzas at George's when they had their old location on Olentangy. I lived right there at University Village and worked at the hotel next door. I got pizzas there because it was easy. Now George's is all the way up in Powell. It's about a 20-25 minute drive for me. I don't always get pizza from George's, sometimes I order a chain that delivers to my house and is easier. But it's not the same a George's. I can't really explain it. The pizza is good. But seeing the owner (I don't know if his name is really George), talking to him every time I go in, that's what makes you feel good. It's a small shop and it feels good supporting such a sweet business owner. And they usually add tootsie rolls to the box, added candy canes around Christmas time. If you really want to make your pizza even better, ask for some of that garlic salt. I just never knew I could feel so happy just from picking up a pizza. Thank you, George!

Tried for first time did not like Too spicy for me and…read morecrust very average and too chewy Would not go back

Cheese and Pepperoni & Mushrooms...and Tootsie Rolls

Pizza

See all

Taranto's Pizzeria

4.0(198 reviews)

3.9 mi

What a great cozy spot for pizza! Recommended when we staying at a nearby hotel. Pizza was very…read moretasty. Staff friendly and helpful. And the friendly manager / owner stopped by to check on us and our experience after our meal. That was a nice touch. Plan to return next time we're in the area!

I've been a fan of Taranto's for several years. I first discovered them around 2015 when I was…read moreworking in Lewis Center. I ended up ordering from them at least a couple times a month. At least once a month we would place a group order at my office and everybody loved it. I know that the ownership changed a couple years ago, but it's still the same great pizza and service! I've never eaten at the restaurant but I have gone in there a few times for pick up orders and it's always clean and neat and customers always seem to be happy. The service that I've received over the years whether it's over the phone or in person has always been great!

Vegetarian Works

See all

Meaty Lovers with added Jalapeños. Fantastic once again!

Flyers Pizza & Subs

4.0(43 reviews)

1.3 mi

I was waiting for my Quattro pizza with half pepperoni when I was told it had accidentally been…read moremade without any pepperoni. It was an honest mistake, and I was fine with it, but they insisted on making me the correct pizza while letting me keep the first one. While I waited, they offered me a fountain drink and great conversation. I left with two pizzas and a reminder that great customer service still exists. Not to mention, the food is always top tier and it's always so clean. So, another reason to love this place. Thank you!

Flyers has some of the best gluten free pizza that I've had in this area. The flavoring of the…read moresauce and the cupping pepperoni are pure perfection. I really liked that. The gluten free crust is bigger than most gluten free crusts you get from other pizza establishments. The service is always top-notch whether I dine in or pick up my orders. I definitely highly recommend if you love good pizza and need gluten free!

Garlic Chicken Supreme

See all

Half N Half - Garlic Chicken & South Western

Ange's Pizza

3.5(53 reviews)

1.9 mi

Not a fan of pizza's from a conveyor system but they have their act together with theirs…read more The pizza comes out medium crisp, never burned and has a golden cheese topping. The sauce seems like home made, I never asked, but it has a touch of sweetness and acid to it. Not over powering with spices and seasoning. Their Italian subs have a golden crust to them and are not crunchy hard. The double meat Italian sub is a true DOUBLE MEAT. Keep it up Ange's. You are an icon in the Powell area. I suggest going there and order. Go next door for a beer or 2 and your pizza will be piping hot and ready to go. I put my pizza in the trunk so I don't eat it all before getting home. It's that good.

Excellent pizza. Customer service was above and beyond. Everything about this pizza was spot on…read more The crust really brought it all together. Highly recommended.

See all

Bridge Street Pizza

4.2(100 reviews)

4.8 mi

Today I ate my words. Literally. After a frustrating experience with Bridge Street I decided to try…read moreand call them again. Somehow the stars aligned and not only did they answer but I wasn't put on hold. And thank goodness because that meal was amazing. We are in town for hockey for my oldest son so I made sure to order a big meal. Garlic cheesebread - yummy though not a show stopper Wings - wow. Amazing quality and fantastic flavor though the spicy bbq could've been hotter Meat pizza - now that's was fantastic! Perfect crust massive amount of toppings. Phenomenal flavor. In summary this place was a hat trick. Yum!

Soooo I really wanted to like this pizza, I did, but it was awful. I read that they changed…read moreownership, and man I really wish I had the chance to try them before they did. Older reviews and pictures looked bomb so I decided to give it a shot. Friday night we ordered 2 cheese pizzas and a chicken parm sandwich. Today is Tuesday and I've been trying to force my kids and the neighbor kids to eat it there's still a whole pie in the fridge that's about to go in the trash. Like imagine how bad pizza has to be that I can't get 8-11yr olds to eat it. I did try one slice I don't know how to describe it, kind of like frozen pizza but worse bc you've obviously paid a lot more for it than you would have a frozen pizza. Let's not even talk about the chicken parm sandwich that I tried to "fix", and I still couldn't save the rubbery chicken they put in there. That all wound up in the trash as well. I hate throwing food away, honestly I hate it, but I couldn't stomach anything we got from them.

Medium half cheese half Margherita

Margherita pizza with pepperoni added by request.

See all

One of the best pizza i ever had thanks to

Iacono's Pizza & Restaurant

3.5(104 reviews)

3.2 mi

I came here because a couple of my friends invited me and I had never been before. I have heard…read morepeople talk about it before and it did not disappoint. The place itself was very clean and they have a great bar and patio. We all sat at the bar and the bartender was very nice and friendly. She made the experience really fun for us. We started with some meatballs and they were AMAZING! The sauce was perfect that they came with and they were the perfect size! Then we had a custom olive pizza and the pizza was just the right amount of crunch. The sauce again was amazing. The cheese was cooked just enough. It was one of the best pizzas I have had. Their drinks and wine lists was phenomenal. Overall I had a great time with my friends and we will be back again for sure!

I had the spaghetti and meatballs. I've lived in the Youngstown area for 10 yrs and never in my…read morelife have I tasted a spaghetti sauce as the one here . Closest I can compare it to is a cross between ketchup and chef boyardee canned meals . Just nothing I'd ever eat again . The yellow noodles were interesting over cooked . Borderline mushy . The portion had to be equal to a pound of uncooked pasta . Dinner rolls weren't even Italian style . Store bought GFS, chef could care less , rolls . This is nothing like the mom and pop type recipes I've ever tasted . Disappointed. I Read this place was top 5 in Columbus . If that's true , people of Columbus do not know homemade sauce or pizza for that matter . Visit Youngstown . Save your money . I will say Service was great/ friendly . Not her fault the food was bad. Atmosphere was nice . Just really puzzzled about the sauce and pasta .

See all

OH Pizza & Wings - Worthington

4.1(218 reviews)

3.7 mi

I was just at the Worthington location and it was absolutely amazing. The store was clean. The food…read morecame out fresh and fast. Very efficient service. Customer service was great to not attend. Definitely will be coming back. Keep up the good work guys.

The worst customer service I've ever experienced in Columbus from ANY BUSINESS. This place used to…read morebe my families go to for good pizza yet we will never return. My husband and 7 year old daughter went to pick up at the Worthington Location and we called ahead to place our order and Alicia was who handled us from beginning to end absolutely horribly. On the phone she was extremely irritated with having to take our order so at pick up my husband walks up and she goes what's up, what's up aggressively before he can even say I'm here to pick up. He then said to her hey can I be honest she said sure he said when working in customer service I think it's important to be patient and kind when handling customers and she completely flipped out on him saying all kinds of curse words in front of a child. Saying you can get out of my store right now and you have till the count of three to get out or I'm calling the police. My husband then said you're gonna speak like that in front of a 7 year old, she then told him she'll be giving our pizza order away to the people who worked there. For $67 for two pizzas and 10 wings, we'll take our money where it's appreciated. Reached out to the owner he said he would deal with it and that he was reviewing footage only to not say anything else in response not even an I'm sorry for the way you were handled for this terrible and completely unprofessional behavior. Never again.

Mozzarella Meatball Sub

Funnel Cake

See all

Old work pepperoni pizza

Brenz Pizza Co. Dublin

3.8(54 reviews)

6.1 mi

Great pizza, great service…read more Located in the shopping center at Avery Square, this restaurant has ample parking outside and a few seats for those who want to dine in. I highly recommend trying the Heritage Honey pizza which is loaded with classic red sauce, cheese, pepperoni, sliced sausage, and creamy ricotta. They finish it off with shaved parmesan, fresh basil, and their signature hot honey drizzle . This pie is absolutely delicious.

Recently tried Brenz Pizza Co. for the first time and it was so good. We did pickup, and everything…read morewas still really fresh and hot when we got home. I especially loved the margherita pizza! Simple but really solid. Definitely see why it's a local favorite in Dublin. We'll for sure be going back.

See more unrecommended reviews

Breadsticks

See all

Front entrance

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

21 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Evan W.

16 years ago

I don't consider myself a food snob, or particularly choosey about what I eat. But once in a while I stumble across a restaurant that really does it for me. Brooklyn Pizza has been added to that list. The pizzeria itself is the archetype we've grown used to. Quaint, modest and tucked into that one plaza you forgot about. Upon entering you'll notice how clean it is and the assortment of pizza on display on the front counter (shielded by glass of course) followed by the intoxicating aroma of pizza. To my convenience, Brooklyn Pizza, unlike every other pizzeria in Powell, serves whole pies and slices. I went with the latter and only waited 10-15 minutes. During the wait I had a nice chat with the owner and primary chef, "Anthony" who moved here from NY years ago and has always sought to fill the NY pizza void in central Ohio. All of his employees are either his family members or close friends. It contributes to the atmosphere. Onto the pizza... The toppings vary from pepperoni to peppers to artichokes and are top shelf compared to the local competitors. The cheese is stringy, simple and delicious. The sauce tastes fresh and lacks that undesirable zesty-ness, typical of chain restaurants. Now, I can't extol the merits of Brooklyn Pizza's "authenticity" because I'm not a New Yorker, former New Yorker, or New York pizza aficionado but I've seen other customers marvel at it. The beverages on hand, coke products, are ridiculously cheap. Only 0.95¢ per can! They have an extensive menu which includes meatball subs, calzones, salads, stromboli, sandwiches and probably more that I'll be checking out in the near future. Give Brooklyn Pizza a shot, I'm glad I did. read more

John G.

16 years ago

I was born in Brooklyn and raised on LI similar to the owner of Brooklyn, Pizza. I lived in Santa Fe, NM in 1978 and 1979 where there was one pizzeria owned by a former Brooklynite (NY) that was outstanding with a local topping option of green chili. I moved to Ohio in 1980. While Brooklyn Pizza is right up there and probably better with a few in Central OH (Whole Foods, Sbarros, and a couple of others (1 near the OSU campus)are all pretty good) it still does not quite bring back the memory I have as a youngster in the early 60's living in Baldwin on LI where a slice was 15 cents and a pie $1. While Brooklyn Pizza's has a great thin crust slice that folds (requiring two hands to eat), holding the pizza vertically did not have the same oil drip as I remember and it was not a challenge to stop the cheese from stretching between your mouth and the slice. I recall walking into Godfather's pizza in the K-Mart mall on Bethel in 1980 and ordering a pie. The girl behind the counter said they did not sell pies they only sold pizza (when the moon hits your eye like ....). So Brooklyn Pizza is my pizzeria of choice as I beleive it is the best in the midwest for sure. The large chains can concnetrate on the folks that are looking for quantity - those who eat steaks medium well or worse, add salt before they taste and are addicted to A-1 sauce. Good luck Anthony we have needed Brooklyn Pizza for a Long Time John read more

Albert B.

16 years ago

I moved to central Ohio 32 years ago, and in all that time I could never find a "New York" pizza worthy of the name. My theory: Ohioans just don't like NY pizza, and any "NY" pizza place that wants to stay in business eventually changes its product to taste like Donatos. Please, Brooklyn Pizza--don't do that. Your pizza is top notch New York! The crust is just right: hand-stretched, thin, but not like a cracker. The sauce isn't too sweet--just the right acidity with a noticeable hint of garlic. Fine cheese, but not overloaded. Cut in pie-shaped slices. Real sliced sausage, not little crumbly balls. Just darn good pizza. I won't think of going anywhere else. read more

Anthony S.

13 years ago

I'm not a huge pizza fan, but this place made me change my mind. I bought a few pies on Friday for the family and some Stromboli. Everything was absolutely delicious. I just went back and bought three more pies. I've lived in Columbus for 26 years and I can't think of a place that can beat Brooklyn Pizza. Donatos, Romeos, jets, Tommy's are all ok. This place blows them all out of the water. Very impressed and will definitely become a regular customer I think. read more

Mike R.

15 years ago

After searching long and hard for a good quality NY style pizza, my search is over! Brooklyn pizza consistently produces great tasting products and delivers great service. Not a lot of room to sit but then again, this is the type of pizza where you order a few for a party or family get together and everyone loves the taste and compliments your choice. read more

Anthony C.

14 years ago

I called back and ask if I could talk to the manager after being hung up on and he said he was the owner and I ask if he hung up on me and he said yes so I told him I gave him a bad review on yelp so he proceeded to cuss me out! All because I wanted some lunch, lol would never support that business read more

Carol K.

12 years ago

Pizza Fan Friend brought me here recently and i must admit I've added this pizzeria to my list of good places to fill my NY pizza craving ! Thanks !! read more

Gracie A.

5 years ago

I always enjoy the sausage pizza but the cheese calzone is OUT OF THIS WORLD and sooo good!!!! Highly recommend!

David B.

1 year ago

Food - A perfect 10. Service - Fast, courteous a real home kitchen feeling. Ambiance - East coast pizzeria. read more

Al F.

4 years ago

Pizza is really good! Small nice dining room. Looks like family own! Visit it with kids, they like it too!

Paige E.

Elite 18

6 years ago

Excellent pizza! Big slices with big flavor. Can't wait to try other topping combinations!

Annie W.

282

5 years ago

Best pizza ever! My husband and I will never go anywhere else. You can't go wrong here.

Carl W.

14 years ago

I was dispointed to! The sauce was not good. The subs were bad to. Wont try again!

Cathy K.

15 years ago

Update, had the pizza again at a super bowl party and must say that it was better!

Fenton M.

4 years ago

The best! Try it! If you don't like their pizza, go to Italy!!!

B N.

8 years ago

Great NY style pizza! One of the best pizza places in Powell.

Albert A.

15 years ago

Subs aren't very good and not toasted. Will pass next time.

Dana S.

11 years ago

Great Slice!!! Very nice and fun place. Great Pie!

John C.

12 years ago

Went to eat here tonight and it is closed :-(

Michael S.

6 years ago

Mid-range, not great, not horrible.

Brooklyn Pizza - pizza - Updated October 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of Powell, Ohio Restaurants near Brooklyn Pizza

BEST of Powell, Ohio Coffee near Brooklyn Pizza

BEST of Powell, Ohio Breakfast near Brooklyn Pizza

BEST of Powell, Ohio Desserts near Brooklyn Pizza

BEST of Powell, Ohio Dinner near Brooklyn Pizza

BEST of Powell, Ohio Things to Do near Brooklyn Pizza

BEST of Powell, Ohio Parking near Brooklyn Pizza

BEST of Powell, Ohio Burgers near Brooklyn Pizza

BEST of Powell, Ohio Shopping near Brooklyn Pizza

BEST of Powell, Ohio Movie Theatre near Brooklyn Pizza

Best of Powell

Things to do in Powell

Browse Brands

Brands by name

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed Brooklyn Pizza also viewed

Pizzeria New York

3.9

(58 reviews)

White pie is incredible! Unfortunately no gluten free options. Staff is great, quick turnaround.read more

When I moved from Philadelphia, Pizzeria NY was like a taste of home. Authentic NY-style…read morethin-crust pizza. Pepperoni Pinwheels are a meal in themselves. True story - my step-daughter and her husband visited NYC. They tracked down the place that was supposed to have the best slice in New York. "It tasted just like Pizzeria NY," they said.

Terita's Pizza Carry Out

4.6

(164 reviews)

My go to spot and yes worth the wait.. I get the meat lovers extra sauce double cut done well and…read moreit's amazing every time. Go online and order trust me. Ok get to it the service is usually great and the sausage is homemade

Terita's Pizza - (Stays in Rotation)…read more North side classic that stays consistent. * Thin crust, square-cut * Sausage is the standout (slight kick, not heavy) * Toppings stay balanced--nothing overloaded First time: Sausage + pepperoni pizza (keep it simple) Best experience (this matters): Eat it fresh--this is at its best right out the box Keep it to 1-2 toppings max so the crust and sausage still come through Ask for it well-done if you like a little extra crisp on the bottom Once you know: Sausage + banana peppers or mushrooms What to know: * Better for carryout * Menu is straightforward * Known for consistency over time Atmosphere: Casual, no-frills, more takeout than dine-in Parking: Easy, on-site Price: $10-15 Wait: Usually quick Good pick when you want something reliable without overthinking it.

Josie's Pizza

3.8

(41 reviews)

We've lived down the street from Josie's for 21 years. It's never been our favorite but has always…read morebeen decent in a pinch. Well, unfortunately I think I had my last Josie's pizza. Ordered last night and walked to pick it up. Service was friendly. The pizza however was one of the worst I've ever had. Ever. Idk what has happened (new mgmt? different supplier?) The crust was paper thin, bland, and super floppy. I hate to complain about too many toppings but that was the case. Ordered old fashioned pepperoni which are good but just piled on it. And way too much cheese which seemed to be pretty cheap quality as well. Oh, did I mention the crust? So so bad. Like I said. We had a good long run supporting Josie's but I think they've finally tanked. What a shame

Ordering and pick up was easy . Everyone was friendly . Nice little spot tucked away off broad…read morestreet ample parking and the food was superior .

Rotolo's Pizza

3.5

(86 reviews)

Easily top 5 best Pizza in Columbus area ( in an area saturated with Pizza joints)…read more Highly Underrated are the Delicious Lasagna and Rigatoni Take home dinners. I was saddened when they pulled out the Hamilton Rd. Gahanna store but Rotolos in Grandview is Top Notch. Good People!

Delicious pepperoni pizza and stuffed garlic bread! Crispy bacon and crispy crust just the way I…read morelove my pizza. Lucky I got to snag a piece during a local event and thankful I did! I can't wait to come back here again

Pizza Primo

3.9

(50 reviews)

For starters, the guys who run this store located at the corner of a small strip mall near 161 and…read moreNorth High Street are so friendly and welcoming. We ordered a large supreme and it was very tasty. Pizza Primo has mastered the signature cracker crust we Columbus natives grew up with and love so well. The sweet, slightly spicy sauce, small cut vegetable toppings (could have added more green peppers and onions :-)) with edge-to-edge placement make eating their square cut pieces especially enjoyable for children. They also offer a thick crust pizza as well, which looks great.

Greatttttt pizza! The kind that is hard to put down. 10/10 Everyone and the owner is truly…read morekindhearted. Great place, highly recommend!

Bexley Pizza Plus

3.8

(105 reviews)

Great service and absolutely delicious pizza thank you not greasy, great crust and generous…read moretoppings...we had pineapple & pepperoni. It was so good. Only suggestion is offer some garlic salt on the tables just for people who need a little extra seasoning ...super surprised at some of the bad reviews. I would definitely say everyone thinks they're a professional foodie and or wanna be food influencer with no credentials these days. It's getting quite annoying. I'm a legit local Private chef and this pizza was completely satisfying for my family and I.

Ordered a large pizza for 24.45 undercooked , now I know why it took me almost a year to order…read moreanother one, But Never again.

Hobnob Pizza

3.9

(15 reviews)

Great, neat, family-oriented local restaurant in Upper Arlington. This time we ordered the pizza,…read moreand it was exactly what we were hoping for--thin, crispy, fresh, and absolutely delicious. The service was fast, friendly, and attentive, making for another great dining experience. We'll definitely be back!

Just left from having my daughter's birthday party here. There were 8 kids and two adults. They had…read morea table ready for us when I got there. Pizzas were ready when we arrived. It was a busy night but the whole team was great to work with there. Highly recommend.

Josie's Pizza

4.0

(33 reviews)

I was happy my friend Chris took me to this location. Had this pizza twice in a few days because I…read moredid not know that there were 2 locations. (Sorry for delay review). This one has lovely people working there who treated you like they knew you all their life. Very funny and very kind. The pizza was the same as the other one and I loved every bite! I was updated on the history of this place while we waited and it was fun listening to the story they had to share. I'm going back soon to have this pizza 3 times in 1 week.

Why. Just why? I have never had such a terrible pizza. As a…read moreyelper and pizza enthusiast, I try new pizza everywhere I go. With the higher rating, I was like "heck yeah, let's try it". No joke, it tasted EXACTLY like one of those frozen pizzas you get for a dollar with the super thin cardboard crust. It was just ... sick nasty. It just tasted frozen. Middle school lunch pizza but thinner. 1/10.

Gahanna Pizza Plus

4.0

(71 reviews)

Gahanna Pizza Plus is amazing. They are consistently great. They have amazing subs as well…read more. A guy who worked there for years bought the place which I think is really cool. Plus he still delivers pizza, I love his work ethic & how he isn't afraid to do whatever is needed... You won't be disappointed

Great pizza! Loaded toppings, cheesy, and a tasty red sauce. Just as another reviewer said, I ended…read moreup eating nearly half of the 12" pizza because it was so good. This was my first time here and I can't wait to order in the future. They have so many specialty pizza options that aren't only pork!

Ange's Pizza

3.6

(83 reviews)