I've been a ride or die Brooklyn Pickle fan for a very long time. In my opinion they make some of the best sandwiches around & are very consistent. I've tried maybe half of their menu & still have more things I'd love to try. I've had their Neptune soup before which I enjoyed. I also appreciate the variety of chips & salads they have available if you're in the mood for a side. I've had really good experiences with their staff. I appreciate that they always seem to be working as a team. (even during the lunch rush) I actually have never sat down to eat there but they have plenty of tables & even space outside weather permitting. One of my favorite things is that they have a little area where they have paper, crayons, markers, etc. so people can color or add their art to the wall. I think that's fantastic for kids & adults a like. read more

See all

This place has quality ingredients and a nice atmosphere, but it is very meat heavy. It's usually easy to get something vegan at a sandwich shop, but they were a bit limited on toppings. The sandwich was still good - it just wasn't great. And it was VERY messy with oil. After making sandwiches for my friends, I did ask the staff member if she could change her gloves (because they were covered in liverwurst and Italian meats), and she did - but very begrudgingly. I would recommend friends to go, but I'm unlikely to eat here again. read more

I love the sandwiches here!!! But they are now using different bread now, my sandwhich fell apart. It is not artisan bread like they made before. The slice of pickle is now small cut pieces and it gives a totally different taste. It's clean and well lit. Casual . I look forward to their lemonade they make for summer. read more

Haven't been in quite awhile but used to go regularly when I worked in Widewaters office park. This is a favorite of mine and never disappoints. Sandwiches are huge and reasonable priced. If you are looking for a sandwich or baked treat this is the place to go. This is a made to order restaurant where you walk up to counter Service is quick and efficient. They also offer soups and salads but in all these years I have stuck with just sandwiches. read more

Brooklyn Pickle - Outside - Sandwiches Near Me - Syracuse, New York

Before heading to the zoo, we needed to eat. We decided to order online since we had a 4 year old with us, and it would make it easier. My order was a "half" Reuben on gluten free bread toasted. I wasn't sure what to expect, but I was blown away! The sandwich was crazy worthy! In fact, as im writing this almost a week later, I am wishing I lived closer! The size was great, and the corner beef was thin sliced and delicious. Next time im in town, I will definitely be stopping back in! Not pictured are the pickle slices that came with it on the outside of the package. Oh! And I tried a can of Dr. Browns cream soda, which was pleasantly tasty, despite the odd name. read more

Brooklyn Pickle - Gluten-free Reuben Sandwich - Sandwiches Near Me - Syracuse, New York

The sandwiches were delicious. We had a Brooklyn pickle special, a Ruben and an Italian. They were big and fresh and delicious. The customer service however wasn't great. I'd eat the sandwiches again but I'll order online and just pickup. They're also doing renovations inside right near where the food is prepared. It doesn't feel very sanitary. read more

Hearty Sandwiches, but Rye Bread Could Use a Toast" Stopped by Brooklyn Pickles during a business trip on a local friend's recommendation. I ordered the corned beef on rye with Russian dressing and all the fixings. The sandwich was packed with plenty of meat and made just right! The only minor letdown was the rye bread, which I would've preferred toasted. Still, the quality of the sandwich was great, and I'm definitely coming back to try other options. If you're in the area, it's worth a visit for a solid deli lunch! read more

See all

The Brooklyn Pickle on Buckley Road is disappointing... The last 3 sandwiches from that location ( every time) the dark rye bread was stale. I think the employees are leaving the plastic bag open (in between orders ) .......on the bright side, I will say that the corn beef is always fresh.....the rye bread: not so much . read more

Good subs and sandwiches. Delicious soup options, they have different daily specials. Oh and don't forget to add extra pickles on the side! read more

Brooklyn Pickle - Sandwiches Near Me - Syracuse, New York

Terrible service. we ordered subs at Brooklyn Pickle and it was made by a totally incompetent employee. absolutely terrible how an untrained staff member made our subs. It's unfortunate how bad service can ruin a once good estab read more

Love it here! I stopped here for lunch. There were lots of people inside but the line moved quickly. I ordered a half sub with turkey, lettuce, tomatoes, pickles and oil/vinegar. It's my favorite sandwich at BP. The bread was fresh and the sandwich was delicious. I'll be stopping back again soon! read more

See all

WOW!!!! What a sandwich, Ive had the BLT & egg n Olive a couple times here. Absolutely fantastic. Highly recommend. The chicken salad sandwich is equally deserving of a try. They have chicken riggies on Thursday's and another tortellini dish that's bomb. Their brownies & white chocolate macadamia nut cookies are to die for. WILL. BE. BACK! read more

Brooklyn Pickle - Cherry Soda - Sandwiches Near Me - Syracuse, New York

See all

Good food, good people, good prices. Brooklyn Pickle has been my go-to lunch spot for nearly 6 years. Just a half sandwich is PLENTY for me, tons of food! My favorite is the Reuben sandwich. Plus way too many pickles on the side read more

Brooklyn Pickle - Reuben Sandwich - Sandwiches Near Me - Syracuse, New York

We are driving on our way through the area and happened by this restaurant! My wife had been here a number of years ago and me and the girls had never been. We were on limited time and they were fast to make our sandwiches! All together, the four of us had a half a turkey sandwich, a chicken salad sandwich, a seafood salad sandwich and a Brooklyn pickle sandwich. All of them were half size. We were all more than stuffed to the gills! We all commented on how clean the restrooms were; which is often times a good indicator of what the back of the restaurant will look like too! read more

Brooklyn Pickle - Brooklyn Pickle Special Sandwich - Sandwiches Near Me - Syracuse, New York

Pretty legit little sandwich shop. I could t even finish the sandwich it was so big. Great cuts of meat, really good slice of bread, and really fresh veggies chips weren't too shabby and the chocolate chip cookie was a great snack later in the afternoon! They are made fresh right in front of you and the staf was great for a newbie with all the questions. read more

Brooklyn Pickle - Sandwiches Near Me - Syracuse, New York

See all

we went in to order today and the person who took our order seemed clueless on how to make a sandwich. all the toppings fell out of mine and I had to tell him they all fell out. he was planning on wrapping mine up.in addition he wiped the knife he was using with some wet rag and just started cutting my sub roll. I was completely turned off and wish I had someone else remake my sub. my husband had the same situation too with his sub. I love Brooklyn pickle but this visit will make me rethink coming back. Please train Your employees properly. read more

I got food poisoning from their tuna salad sandwich. They need to do a better job with making sure the food is fresh and not expired.

This is the best sandwich shop in the USA. They give you so much meat and the sandwiches just melt in your mouth. My favorite is the Turkey! Occasionally you can get a hard roll but other than that it is pure perfection. My favorite stop when I am home in Syracuse! read more

I was in Syracuse for a week and I made it a point to grab two full sandwiches for lunch while I was there. I grew up on these sandwiches and I absolutely loved getting them. Service there is pretty pointed. The staff doesn't have the kindest inflection in their voice and they honestly look bothered to serve you - but WHO CARES when your food is that good. I honestly enjoy the crabby attitudes. For the first sandwich I ordered the Brooklyn Pickle Specialty. Its incredible. Second sandwich I got was a Cajun Turkey with bacon. Both sandwiches lasted me two lunches. Even only having half a sandwich per meal, I was completely full for four lunches! Only ding on them is the cajun turkey order was made completely wrong. I drove in to pick up my online order, drove home - and opened it up to have lack luster sandwiches with completely wrong ingredients. We drove back over and they were willing to remake the sandwiches and comp everything including the drinks, chips, and dessert. We didn't take them up on the offer but it was very nice to receive. I just wanted what I ordered. Every time I'm in town I'm happy to come by. read more

Brooklyn Pickle - Corned Beef sandwich - Sandwiches Near Me - Syracuse, New York

See all

I wish I had took a photo of this enormous sandwich. I had the Brooklyn Pickle special which is corned beef and pastrami. It too me two meals to finish that sandwich. I also tried the Neptune Stew which was also tasty. Would strongly recommend this place, but you need to come hungry. read more

Pastrami on rye with Swiss and Russian dressing, full sandwich split with my husband, we got a bag of chips and we both left satisfied! The sandwich was piled high with pastrami, the Russian dressing and Swiss cheese complimenting every bite. I loved it. I am not from Syracuse, but heard this was a sandwich staple in Syracuse and I was blown away. I saw pastrami and stopped looking at the menu at all. I can tell you nothing more than the pastrami on rye is perfect! read more

Fantastic deli! I can see why Brooklyn Pickle locations are growing after a first trip there. I placed a pick up order online which couldn't have been easier. Everything was ready to go when I arrived. The fresh pickles wrapped on the top of the sandwiches were a nice touch. The bread was fantastic- next time I'll ask for a little lighter in the dressing so it doesn't get soggy. The quality/flavor of the meat was phenomenal on my Brooklyn Pickle special. I wasn't sure what to expect inside but there was a lot more seating at the East Syracuse location than I expected. read more

Brooklyn Pickle - Brooklyn Pickle Special - Sandwiches Near Me - Syracuse, New York

Great, fresh, subs and sandwiches. Busy but the line moved fast and efficiently! Lots of seating.

I came in for lunch recently and had the pastrami with Swiss on rye sandwich. It reminded me of a NYC deli. Absolutely delicious! I will be coming back again. read more

Brooklyn Pickle - Sandwiches Near Me - Syracuse, New York

This place was slammed and yet they got people through with such efficiency it makes me wonder what happens at the DMV??! it's simple sandwiches and of course homemade pickles! It was lunch with my counterpart from work and our boss. I got corned beef on rye with Swiss warmed and of course, pickles. First I got a half which is a lie it's what you'd think a full sandwich is it was really good. A good blend of everything and the bread was soft. Have you every order rye bread and think that the baker thought rye equals dry??? Not here ... also had some sort of brownie which was rich and as I shouldn't have eaten the whole thing if you ever read any of my other reviews I can't resist a good dessert. All in all a great place friendly staff and even busy places to sit when busy. If you want a sandwich and are in the area it's worth a try read more

Great lunch! Superior soups and real deli sandwiches. Lean meat and fresh bread! You won't be disappointed.

Great sandwich joint! Has a real mom-and-pop feel. Quick service too. A whole sandwich will feed the entire state of New York, so a half sandwich will do, unless you want leftovers. read more

Brooklyn Pickle - The Brooklyn Pickle Special - Sandwiches Near Me - Syracuse, New York

Great food, good customer relations! My favorites are the Italian sub and the Reuben but ALL of their sandwiches are fresh and jam packed with meat, made to order. I recently had a problem with confusion over a delivery order that went through as a pickup and they refunded it for me, much to my surprise. Lovely people. They made a better customer out of me as we will now be ordering even more often! read more

For my first time here I must say that even though I was overwhelmed with the plethora of menu choices that once I made my decision (a full size pastrami sandwich on gluten free bread with Russian dressing and tomato) I was very pleased with the service and speed of receiving my order as well as the portions. I was able to take home half my lunch for a later full meal. I highly recommend this sandwich shop! read more

Brooklyn Pickle - Burnet Avenue location - Sandwiches Near Me - Syracuse, New York

Just not the same old Pickle. I've been going there since the nineties, two locations always spot on. Now Ken is gone, they've expanded to Buckley, Utica and now out of state. Lastly though, since new ownership it's gone way down hill. The food quality has dipped a bit but what really struck me was the cleanliness, and quality of help. Some of the worker workers looked like they just got out of bed and acted like they could care less about being there. Ken ran a tight ship and was present. The workers were sharp and courteous. By the way I went to Burnett today. Bigger does not equal better... read more

Brooklyn Pickle's best feature is definitely their portion sizes; their half sandwich would be considered a full sandwich in a lot of other places. Living up to their name, the pickles don't disappoint. The egg and olive is my go to choice. A solid deli style sandwich shop. read more

Great sandwiches and sides! They move a lot of people through putting excellent sandwiches across the counter in record time.

Tuna sandwich looked like slop, bread was hard. Lettuce and tomatoes had no order just packed on sandwich I had to separate them because it was too thick and messy. Just gross read more

Tbh not bad but I was eating my turkey club once and I took three bites and spit out a fly. I know crazier things have happened though.

Food was delish. Ordered takeout no problems. Generous portions. Quick turn around and friendly delivery person

I usually go to the Brooklyn pickle west, but I was over in that direction so I stopped at the one on Burnet Avenue. Super disappointed at the quality of food I received after paying almost $30 for two sandwiches. The one worker making the sandwiches failed to put the correct type of tomato, wrong bread, and the wrong meat that I asked for. One of the sandwiches was wrapped OK, but the other as you can see in the picture, looks absolutely terrible. The bag was in a horizontal position with the sandwich exposed and now there are pieces of the sandwich on the floor of my car. The other workers were just standing around and watching, not helping. Not happy at all, I usually brush off bad experiences but this has got to be better. PERIOD. Not to mention the guy sneezed twice and was wearing his mask below his nose. read more

Brooklyn Pickle - a sub sandwich and pickles - Sandwiches Near Me - Syracuse, New York

See all

Roast Beef sandwich and Special sandwich were delicious and very large. The pickles were really good. The Neptune stew and the Chef Salad with Seafood were also large, but disappointing. The stew is like a Manhattan Clam Chowder with some added vegetables, but very little seafood. The Chef Salad was a large portion of iceberg lettuce but little else; and the seafood on it was ground up something that I couldn't discern. Prices were reasonable, service was very good (we did pickup) and the staff was friendly. read more

Called today from California to order a gift card for a family member living in Syracuse. Frank at the West location was awesome ! He was super friendly, had me all set up and taken care of in a matter of minutes. It's so nice to speak to someone who seems to guenuinely love their job (it tends to be rare these days). Also, I've eaten at that location when visiting and the food is amazing. I love Brooklyn Pickle !!! ( ,,, and actually craving a sandwich now, LOL) KUDOS to Brooklyn Pickle West !!! Holly - Redondo Beach, CA read more

Not authentic! This is not real pastrami or corned beef, this is similar to what you buy at a supermarket deli counter. Trust me I was born in brooklyn! And how about giving me more than 1 little slice of pickle read more

I absolutely love their sandwiches and subs. I place my order and it's always ready when they say it will be, and the pickles are so crunchy. I also love the fact that there is a separate line for phone orders so never a long wait. read more