My usual go-to is a Maui Wowie at Sahara Pizza (5 stars). However, this time I wanted to keep it simple and go New York style. I got a slice of the Bowery (sausage & pepperoni). It really doesn't compare to others. It stands on its own. It was light yet delicious and I can't get over how delicate the thin layer of crunch you get when you bite into it. New York is definitely new territory for me and I love it! Very friendly service and the interior of this place was sick. read more

This place absolutely ruined pizza for me! Because of the magnitude of quality, how delicious, fresh, and hand picked each ingredient is - it set my standards for pizza waaay too high. I have traveled far and wide and nothing can satisfy my cravings for a slice of Brooklyn Brothers pizza other than Brooklyn Brothers itself. If I could give this a 10 - star rating, I would give it 20. So, come here if you love an amazing environment, delicious pies, stellar company, and supporting your local businesses!! read more

Miss the Mill Creek location, but I'd rather drive a little further to get good pizza. Good people, great pizza, well worth a short drive.

Found this place on a whim while craving pizza. Never heard of the place before though. Inside was kinda cool with graffiti all over the wall. The lady at the counter was super helpful in explaining all of their lunch special options (there is 4). Grabbed a two slice and soda lunch special. Had a Bowery and Pepperoni. Pizza took 4 minutes from payment to come out. Came out piping hot too! For me, it had the perfect ratio of protein, cheese, and dough. 12/10 will be back again! read more

See all

They were BUSY before an event at the Angel of the Winds. Long line and seating is challenging, waiting for people to leave but we found seating well before our pizza arrived. If there are two people sitting at a 6 top table, share the table. The pizza was good but different. The crust is very crispy from being cooked wood fired. read more

Brooklyn Bros. Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Everett, Washington

Delicious pizza and great customer service! Limited menu items so easy to choose, definitely worth trying the pizza. They even sell pizza by the slice so you can try multiple options. They offer indoor and outdoor seating and it's family friendly. Good for any size groups. We went for a late lunch and it was steadily busy but were served quickly. read more

(From March, 2025) Heading to Vancouver, the hunger kicked in so I pulled up YELP to see what's around. This spot came up and the words "pizza slice" & beer along with a photo of a gorgeous slice led me to tell our group this is where we should stop. Close to the highway and on the way to Vancouver, we parked on the road, walked in, and stood in line waiting to order. We arrived at a good time since happy hour was in effect which is deals on pizza and beer. Pizza is "new york style"; probably not the real thing but pretty close to it. Pizza is available by the slice or whole (thick or thin crust). Premade pizzas were on display which gave us ideas of what slices we wanted. I decided on the Bayridge (pepperoni, mushroom, red onion), a pretty good slice that hit the spot. I paired it with a Bodhizafa IPA, a local hoppy beer. Goes well with it. There were a couple slices my friends ordered that I was a bit envious of such as the Hudson with the sausage and creamy ricotta. But I'm satisfied with what I ate. Overrall, this low key pizza spot is convenient and affordable. If I'm in the area, I'll certainly be back. read more

See all

This is a low key, lil casual pizza shop. Graffiti decor. Previous reviews solid. Stopped here for the first time with a group, on our way for a road trip to Canada. Parking- no designated lot. But there is a paid lot across the street. Which we did. You may luck up on street parking. It appeared to have a lot of regulars stop in and out, that boades well at any place. We arrived in time to catch there happy hour deals, which is worth it. Food- I went with the slice + beer, happy hour special , cost around $7 bucks. My slice was the Bensonhurt - which is mostly veggie. I was torn between that and the Hudson. The Hudson has really good reviews. Mine wasn't too bad. I got the Rainer beer, a local brewery, light and easy. Service- was good. You order at the counter, and they bring it you. Slice came out hot. Lots of seating. read more

See all

Staff is always super friendly. They do not always have a huge selection available for slices, depends on time of day. I don't recommend coming late for dinner or lunch for this reason. Sicilian pizza tastes amazing! But a whole pizza 16inches is $55 after tax. Took us a few days to finish. Cannolis are also great, we always get the mini ones. read more

Brooklyn Bros. Pizzeria - Sicilian Bay Ridge - Pizza Near Me - Everett, Washington

Brooklyn brothers is right near the Angel of the wind arena in Everett. It is exceedingly busy in event days. Plan on arriving 2-3 hours prior to an event starting if pre-feeding. Pizza, salad, beverages all excellent here. This visit we opted to share a salad and got just two slices of pizza. Slices are large and fresh, thin crust pizza bursting with flavor. The salad was delicious and filling, even for two people. Super crowded, but expected. Finding a seat is a challenge as there is standing room only. Everyone was great though and the food exceptional. Very loud. Our favorite pre event restaurant. read more

Brooklyn Bros. Pizzeria - Bensonhurst pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Everett, Washington

See all

Great stop on our road trip home from Canada. My bf had it once and when he remembered that we'll be passing, he had convinced me to stop by a pizza snack. Totally worth it! There's a parking lot across the street and street parking. Located right across the street from Angel of the Winds Arena. The 4 slices came out a little under $30. My favorite was the pepperoni. The crust was thin and crunchy and the pepperoni had a hint of spice. My bf preferred the thicker crust. Both was so good and very filling. read more

Brooklyn Bros. Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Everett, Washington

See all

This place is usually packed anytime I am in the area. While I am not a NYC pizza expert I have had most of the greats in NYC and along Long Island. Having said that, stopped in for a slice of cheese pizza - by the slice. Service was quick, crust was excellent. However. I don't care much for the pizza. I mean, miles ahead of say any pizza chain, but miles behind in flavor. Could have been an older slice, not sure your mileage may vary! read more

Brooklyn Bros. Pizzeria - Cheese, pepperoni and Hudson in that order. - Pizza Near Me - Everett, Washington

Pizza was so good, but we usually don't get slices and a whole pizza was WAY over priced. The service was great. We would definitely be back when we're in Everett!! read more

Brooklyn Bros. Pizzeria - Pepperoni and a combo - Pizza Near Me - Everett, Washington

See all

Good pizza but kind of a weird set up. Reminds me of places in small college towns. Not ideal for nice evening out.

Overall bad experience waited 20+ minutes for a slice of cheese pizza & I only ordered the cheese because it was the only one ready at the time of ordering, the salad was bland and lacking just like the pizza especially for their price point. needs more toppings and quicker service. read more

Brooklyn Bros. Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Everett, Washington

Worst service we've ever experienced at a restaurant. We ordered three slices of pizza and waited an hour with no food. We ended up leaving and were late to an event because of the delay. What made it worse was the manager's response--there was no acknowledgment of the delay until after we inquired about our order multiple times, and even then there was no real apology or effort to make things right. We had to ask for a refund ourselves before leaving, and never even got to try the pizza we'd heard good things about. Really disappointing experience. We won't be coming back. Visited April 24, 2026 read more

Brooklyn Bros. Pizzeria was an unplanned stop which turned out to be a great find. We just landed in Seattle and needed a quick bite on our way to Vancouver. We found this spot which was close to the highway and looked to be pretty fast casual. Finding it was easy as it sits on a corner of an old building that has lots of character. Parking was a lot across the street or street parking. Walking in, the place is pretty large with high ceilings and plenty of seating in two different areas. Customer service was great. The guy behind the counter handled the lines with ease and had no problem giving great suggestions. We showed up during happy hour which happened to have some awesome deals. What they claim to do here is authentic New York style pizza. This is far from New York but I gotta say, this was pretty damn close to the real thing. They sell pizza by the slice or whole in either a Sicilian (thick crust) or Napoletana (thin crust). They also have starters like salad, flatbreads, or breadsticks. If you aren't feeling a slice, you can also order a calzone. We weren't looking to get super full so we went with stuff off the happy hour menu which had things like a slice and a beer, or a couple of slices and a fountain drink, etc. I went with two slices and a fountain drink. If you go with a slice, they have premade pizzas on display and they just throw a slice in the oven. Even at home I always reheat pizza in the over to get that perfect crunch. I went with the Bowery (pepperoni, Italian sausage and roasted garlic), and the Hudson (Italian sausage, roasted red peppers, ricotta, and roasted garlic). The slices were large and they came out piping hot. I went in on the Bowery first. This was good. It had a nice crisp crust and the toppings were flavorful. I could've used a few more slices of the cupped pepperoni though. The Hudson was my favorite though. It had plenty of sausage but the addition of creamy ricotta was a nice touch. Overall, I will say this place definitely brought me back to having a slice in NYC recently. Of course nothing compares to having the real deal, but this was a close second. I would come back if in the area. read more

See all

Have been going to the (now closed) Mill Creek location for years, and occasionally to the Everett location. Came in to the Everett one and asked whether a particular pizza was vegetarian. They assured me it was, but when they brought it out, it had pepperoni in it. Was told a half salad was big enough to share, but when it arrived, it only filled about half the plate. Not really much bigger than a side salad, but priced much more. I told the server it was way smaller than what I had always gotten at Mill Creek, and that I had also gotten this at Everett recently and it was much larger. Server insisted they had not changed the serving size, but that was obviously not the case. We told them when we ordered that we wanted an extra plate to share the half salad (thinking it was as big as it used to be on all recent visits). They did not bring an extra plate, and we had to ask again. Pretty expensive for how small the salad was. Also, even though there were obviously two people ordering/at the table, they put both slices of pizza on one dinner plate, so we had to ask for another plate for that. Service was not good, and communication was obviously not good for our orders. Overpriced for what we got, incorrect information given about the ingredients on the pizza, and poor communication/service. I'm disappointed in what used to be a "go-to" place. I am now reluctant to go back. read more

Amazing pizza with a crispy thin crust. I recommend the Bowery due to the strong savory garlic flavor. Lunch special was $11.99 for two thin crust slices plus a soda. read more

Brooklyn Bros. Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Everett, Washington

See all

I'd say these guys set the bar when it comes to Snohomish county pizza. Great spot to grab a slice or a pie before a game, concert or before hitting a few bars. read more

Great food and service. We enjoy a nice crispy thin pizza. Great flavor. Order at the counter and wait for them to bring it out to you. Self service drinks. read more

See all

Best pizza in WA. Our go to for pizza. Yes yes yes. It can get crazy here before events at angel of the winds. But they move pretty quick.

This is my second time to Brooklyn Bros. pizza...and the vibe is just as cool as the first time. The pizza slices are large...and a little greasier than I remember. It's a great spot for a large group. Call ahead with the order for pies so you don't have to wait too long. read more

Love this place, probably the closest your gonna get to NY style pizza north of Seattle. Staff is helpful and quick. Restaurant is clean and basic, but that's what you want when your a busy pizza shop, grab a slice and move on. Good to grab a bite before heading into the arena across the street. read more

Brooklyn Bros. Pizzeria - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Everett, Washington

I usually go to the one in downtown Everett. I must say I do love their pizzas a bit on the pricy side so I use it as a treat for myself and the family. But in retrospect you get what you pay for. Again one of the best pizzas I've had. The staff is friendly and most of them are cheerful but all of them are so helpful when it comes to questions. The location is across from angel of the winds, they also have outdoor seating which i love using. Definitely would recommend! read more

As a New Yorker this is the closest pizza I can find to NY style. One of the staples on my life. The wings could be better, but they have a great HH. Don't tell anyone (more) people but it's the perfect pregame to the Silvertips. read more

This place has been dishing up New York style thin crust pizza for years. Always delicious! You can order by the slice or a whole pie. Absolutely love this place - some of the best pizza in the PNW!! read more

Brooklyn Bros. Pizzeria - Yummy! - Pizza Near Me - Everett, Washington

I hate the price that this place charges but my god is the food worth it. The service is impeccable minus the occasional new guy. The cannoli's and The Hudson pie are perfect in every capacity. Cannot make this up. The old school pizzeria ambiance is also welcoming. Everett lucked out having this place settle here. To. Die. For. read more

Was expecting the best pizza ever by the way people talk and it was very bland. Hard to find parking.

This is a great spot to grab a quick bite, before you go to a game or concert, across the street! People keep to themselves, which very much reminds me of New York! I liked their Pizzas, for a only a quick bite spot. read more

Pizza is great 8/10. Caesar salad was not good. Best pizza in Everett in my opinion. Fast as you always grab a slice to go.

Service was excellent. I was provided ice water while waiting. I opted not to purchase a drink after the steep price tag for my order was tallied up. I arrived shortly after the Mill Creek store opened. Ambiance: Brooklyn artifacts/photos were nice. Place was immaculately clean. Who ever closed last night did a good job. Ordered one slice of a three topping pizza and a calzone. To go. Wait time was 18 minutes. Food was hot and well packaged. The cost of a calzone and one slice was over 21.00. Expensive. The slice: crust was crispy. A noticeable crunch at every bite and while chewing. Sauce was rich but definitely not balanced: the garlic smothered it resulting in an inability to taste the other toppings. I thought maybe the slice had garlic on it. But I tasted the enclosed dipping sauce for the calzone. Same heavy on the garlic flavor. Also, I'm from the Brooklyn area and have never had a crunchy crust pie. Ever. Not thrilled with the slice at all. On the plus: slice size was generous. The cornicione, the raised part of a pizza slice, was defined and I could tell it had ample raise time. Crust flavor was good and I could fold the slice in my hand. It took a bit of doing. The dough was rigid. I checked the undercarriage and it looked perfectly cooked. The calzone: size was slightly smaller than I'm used to but the shape was spot on what you would experience in Brooklyn. The West Coast pizza communities have a calzone perversion - shaping it in various ways. It it unrecognizable as a calzone. This one was spot on. It was cooked perfectly. The cheeses were perfect. Once you've grown up on Polly O mozzarella you can tell the difference. Good flavor. However, any calzone I've had in NY/Brooklyn always included a couple slices of ham. Typically sweet. Not smoked. This calzone had no ham. One can typically order additional fillings. Not at this establishment. So pleasantly surprised at the flavor but disappointed about no ham. The garlic infused dipping sauce was overpowering. Typically a marinara sauce the screams fresh tomatoes and is slightly sweet is used to complement the cheeses. Again: way over the top with the garlic infused dipping sauce. I've been strongly encouraged by my East coast family and friends to voice a pattern with all pizza establishments I've patronized in Washington. That pattern is price. With no exception, the prices have been mind numbing. I know the cost of living here is high. But the prices being charged for pizza or what they call a calzone, is astronomical. People gotta make a living. I understand that. So I'll continue to scout out the pizza joints to do reviews but I'll render my own humble version at home. Do try the calzone. And have some marinara ready for dipping. read more

This was a good pizza, no doubt, but my reason for the low rating was the price-$36 for a small pizza with 3 toppings . Maybe I'm out of touch, but that seems expensive for a 14 inch pizza. read more

The pizza was nearly tasteless with little sauce and probably 25 tiny cup and curl pepperonis on the whole pie. If there was sauce on it, I could hardly taste it. The crust was airy and cracker-like. The beer selection on draft was good, but this pizza is too expensive to be this bland. If I didn't have a beer that I could taste with it, I would have almost thought I had COVID. The ambiance is non-existent with walls full of signatures, pics of New York, art of a clown holding a Chicago pizza box (?), no music playing and kids running next to my seat. Three stars for the beer and the super nice staff, who were the only saving grace to this place. read more

Brooklyn Bros. Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Everett, Washington

See all

Tried on vacation. Omg some of the best pizza I have ever had!! I need this pizza again! Tried the pepperoni with sausage (can't remember the name on menu). The sausage was delicious!! Wish there was more pepperoni -- next time I'll order extra! I can't wait to have this pizza again -- try it!! You won't be disappointed. read more

The pizza was good but nothing to "write" home about, especially for the price. The service was great, all the staff we had encounters with were great and quick. The restaurant can get a bit loud because of its high ceilings but that doesn't really influence my rating. The pizza was just missing the wow factor. read more

Ok pizza on top of being expensive bread sticks are all right and the Caesar salad was the best thing it's a good experience at least read more

Brooklyn Bros. Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Everett, Washington

We loved this place. Easy ordering at the counter, they give you a number and find a seat. Pizza came out quick and hot. We loved the pizza, great flavor sauce and cheese taste. read more

Brooklyn Bros. Pizzeria - Full Loaf of garlic bread. - Pizza Near Me - Everett, Washington

See all

It's been about a year but last time I was here, there was rat/mouse poop all over the dining room. I'll never go back!!! How this place stays open and passes health inspections is amazing. read more

Brooklyn Bros. Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Everett, Washington

See all

This place is packed...The line never goes down.... It is super crowded, and after trying their pie, I can see why... If you are from the east coast, this place nails it... The staff is very friendly, and the food s excellent... It is a casual place, and apparently they encourage you to write on the walls.... What is not to love about this place... I would phone ahead with my order, to speed things up read more