I was really excited to come to Broken Bat's new location with some friends. Overall I was generally pleased! They had fun, reasonably priced flights but weren't very accommodating to my gluten free needs. I ended up getting a seltzer and wasn't impressed. I had my friends try it too and they didn't love it. Overall the vibes and beer were great but skip the seltzer! Hopefully they expand their options after Covid! read more

Broken Bat Brewing Co - Menu and my friend's beer flight - Breweries Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

This is another great local brewery currently moving to a new location because they've grown so much. They have a lot of beers on tap and an ever rotating list. I'd recommend trying the cracker jack caramel stout or the harry cherry. I havent found a beer I absolutely love here but they keep things interesting and bring new flavors to their beers. They're also extremely dog friendly and even have events for dog owners to get discounts for bringing their pups in. Lots of other events are always going on too. Beware of parking though, its location in the third ward can make it a hassle. read more

The staff was extremely friendly with my dog (asking if they could bring him a treat and water) and they let me sample a few brews before settling on a delicious pineapple milkshake IPA. A bunch of TVs for watching while you sip. Wold definitely come back! read more

Broken Bat Brewing Co - Pineapple milkshake IPA - Breweries Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

Our first brewery visit in Milwaukee and probably our favorite! Very casual fun atmosphere. DELICIOUS beers! Super dog friendly both outdoor and indoor as well! Fun displays throughout too! Get some Stack'd takeout and park yourself down, order some beers and you can waste your day away! Chucky says thanks for welcoming him! And he can't wait for our next trip to Milwaukee to return! read more

See all

Being immediately greeted by dogs when I didn't even know dogs were allowed was the best surprise of all. If you couldn't guess by the name, all the tv's had baseball on. I love baseball so this was another pro on my list. On that note, I don't really have any cons to mention. Maybe a bigger selection of beers but even with what they had, there were plenty that I wanted to try that it kept my entertained anyways. The vibe seemed real nice, a good place to hang out, watch some sports with your friends, and drink some good beer! read more

Had a great time at Broken Bat! They have so many different beers to choose from--there's something for everyone! Obviously the dogs were the highlight and the baseball theme was fun. I definitely want to go back and rent out the wiffle ball field sometime, it looks like a blast. read more

Super cool brewery with good beers and service. I love all the baseball themed beer names and the bobbleheads. I had the Harry Cherry Hefeweisen. It was a good hefe with a nice tart cherry finish. I will definitely go back next time we are in Milwaukee. read more

Broken Bat Brewing Co - Breweries Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

Super super fun environment I am jealous of locals to be a part of their mug club with the bat glasses. Super committed to the theme I loved it read more

We were walking through the ward last night and saw a pop up sign for this brewery and decided to wander over to check it out. So glad we did! The ward has a lot of options for relaxing and drinking but none quite like this. It's downstairs on a lower level which made me feel like I was going into the Bat Cave (pun intended). But don't be fooled - this place is open, airy and the only bats are sport related. Since the only food options are snacks like popcorn they can be dog friendly and sure enough there was a pup hanging out last night. No brew for him. We ordered a sampler with the IPA, double IPA, coffee stout and imperial stout. Sampler rack was cool as you can see in pic. Looks like they've made some upgrades since some earlier reviews. The beers are solid. Nice job nailing the different styles. The IPA was my winner but they were all good. There were ten beers to choose from so I'll have to go back! Love the sports theme and all the brewers bobble heads. And the upgraded digital beer board behind the bar tells me these guys are serious about their products. I'm giving it a home run with 5 stars. read more

Broken Bat Brewing Co - Flight ready set go - Breweries Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

LOVED this place! So glad we wandered around the historic Third Ward in Milwaukee. Had they not had the sandwich board out on the street, we would have missed this gem! If you are any kind of baseball fan, THIS is the brewery FOR YOU! And, the beer selection is BIG LEAGUE, delicious, and affordable! I had a four beer flight of 755 (Nitro), Sky High (Scotch Ale), Climb the Wall (Belgian Style Farmhouse Ale), and Golden Sombrero (American Pilsner). BY FAR, BEST NITRO I have ever had! Smooth and delicious - JUST AWESOME! The atmosphere is EXCPETIONAL, and you are surrounded by baseball and GREAT beer. Check out all the names of their beers on the walls and the baseball art work used to characterize the beers. Definite BIG FLY to the deepest part of the park. Gets my STRONGEST recommendation as a Milwaukee MUST DO and TASTE. You'll be hard pressed to experience a No Hitter in here. All these beers are BIG HITS! read more

Broken Bat Brewing Co - Broken bat tap handles! - Breweries Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

New (relative) craft brewers in the third ward. Space is small but cool. Located downstairs in the basement. Baseball theme from name to decoration. Dog friendly and they have small and group tables. Brew kettles are right there. Beer flights (four 6 oz beers) are $12 and you have a choice of 10 beers. We tried the IPA, double IPA, coffee stout and imperial stout. All were quite good. Will definitely be back. read more

Broken Bat Brewing Co - Flight - Breweries Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

I've given them a couple tries. A couple beers I've tried were undrinkable (and I'm generally able to power through most beers). Had an Oktoberfest the last time, thinking that's as safe a choice as you can have, and it was watery. Last time in there, there were lots of fruit flies and the service was about as flat and impersonally bland as you could have. Just about everybody I know marvels at how this place is still in business. read more

There are so many breweries in Milwaukee, but Broken Bat definitely found their niche to stand out and be different. It's tucked away downstairs so you may not even see it if you walk by. It's pretty small, but you can either sit at the bar and watch any of the baseball games going on, sit at a high top table, or what we did - play free metal tip darts! I was nervous about their beer flavors, but they all ended up being really good. There are a lot of IPAs but I opted for the cherry Hefeweizen, my friend got their Mexican lager, and they have some rotating seasonals. My friend loved it so much, he joined the Broken Bat Mug Club. It's $100/year, you get a wooden baseball bat mug, $5 12 oz pours for all beers anytime, $1 off special bottle releases, a punch card with every 5th mug filled free, and more. I've never seen a beer rewards program before, more places should do this! read more

Good beer. Apparently they have indoor wiffle ball leagues which sounds like the coolest thing ever read more

Broken Bat Brewing Co - Breweries Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

Fabulous place!! I love that it's dog friendly and just so chill inside. They have a wide variety of beers and even a seltzer. You can also order your drinks on tap, or in cans. The staff was all extremely friendly and provided top notch service. They have many TVs which is great if you're trying to catch a game. It's super spacious inside with many different seating options. This is a great spot to go with a small or large group & bring your pups. Definitely going to be one of our new hangouts now that we have a dog! read more

Broken Bat Brewing Co - Flight - Breweries Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

A rare combination of the chill brewery atmosphere while having the plus sides of a sports bar including TV's all over, darts and pool. Perfect place for group events or just hanging out at the bar and watching a game. Great beer up and down the menu and other non-beer options as well read more

Good space, good beer and good people. We ventured into Broken Bat for the first time a few weeks ago after they were the beer sponsor at a charity event we participated in and were pleasantly surprised. The space is a unique underground area down Buffalo and has a subtle and not overwhelming baseball theme. Between our group we tried almost all of the beers and did not have one that disappointed. A particular favorite was the Double Play. They do not serve food but they do allow dogs and seem to be happy to see dogs there. The staff was really nice and after speaking with them for a few minutes we learned the bartenders were the owners. They were happy to talk about all of the different beers and give recommendations. Overall, even with all of the recent brewpubs opening in Milwaukee Broken Bat is a good unique choice. read more

Broken Bat Brewing Co - Bar - Breweries Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

We went here for a beer and check out the waffle ball scene. Not easy to find parking. But we persevered. Along with my beer I drank, I purchased a Big Red Machine 4 pack. Nice independent brewery. They were grilling brats outback, I hope to try on my next visit. read more

Such a fun brewery! We tried a couple beers and they were all excellent! Employees were helpful picking out brews and followed COVID procedures. Dogs are allowed inside as well! read more

Broken Bat Brewing Co - Pub Pass - Breweries Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

The unique "underground" location of one of Milwaukee's latest breweries is slightly small but very cool! We nabbed spots at the bar and were promptly served by the two owners while none other than the Brewers were on the tv, an obvious choice for a baseball-themed brewery. The best part of the whole theme coming together we're the bowls of in-shell peanuts tossed with a sprinkle of M&Ms - probably a pain in the ass to clean up but so worth it for customers. If I remember correctly, they had been open only a week, though in the planning processes, as many breweries are, for some time. The transition from homebrewing, or brewing on a different system than their current one could be the culprit behind less-than-great beer, but they're headed in the right direction and given time, I have hopes they'll iron the quality issues out and start putting out some tastier brews. read more

Broken Bat Brewing Co - While the quality suffered, they're headed in the right direction. I hope for better beer as they learn their system. - Breweries Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

See all

Dog friendly! As a couple that currently is dogless to we love coming here to see all the varieties of dogs that get to visit this brewery! Nice variety of brews to choose from too! Tasty!! read more

Awesome beer selection. It's a huge place!! Darts and batting cages! The service was good and the place was super clean!

This small basement brewery in the Third Ward is worth of going while in Milwaukee. There are a couple dozen or so beers on tap and you can purchase them in crowlers, growlers or cans. There is no food menu but you can bring your furry friends to the place. Oh and BTW, BYOBs - bring your own boardgames. read more

Broken Bat Brewing Co - Beer flight - Breweries Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

Great beer. Bar is located downstairs. No food options but you can have some delivered. read more

Broken Bat Brewing Co - Breweries Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

Nice place. Great beer and service. Collins is a great bartender. Tried a flight of beer and stayed for more.

Cool place to hang out. Beer was ok. I would come back. You can rent a wiffleball field for 150 an hour so bring friends and hit some dingers. read more

Love the new location and the beer! Super great baseball themed brewery.

Solid little brewery in the old third ward area. It's literally a stones throw from the new Milwaukee Ale House, so you can easily do both in one day, which is what we did. I got the ugly finer, straight chedd, and the corre corre, all good, plus I got a 4pack of the ugly finder to go. It's located in the lower level of the building just FYI when you arrive. Not a super big place, might need to stand, but didn't feel cramped, and we got served pretty quickly at the bar. Solid addition to the Milwaukee brewery scene. read more

I want to love this place. The location is great. It's in a basement, which is cool. But even after a few visits, I'm still firmly in like. It's a good place to meet up with friends after work. Their beer is decent. I've never had a beer I disliked, but then again, I've never had a beer I loved and that's really the bottom line for me. Disclaimer: I love Stout's. In my opinion, a great beer doesn't let light through it. Broken Bat doesn't currently deliver in that arena. They have plenty of beer for those of a lighter beer persuasion. In fact, my running club frequently stops in here pre- run and this place is perfect for that! read more

I enjoy most of the beers I've had here, and I enjoy they have a lot of selection. I love that the bar is so chill and that there are always dogs here! read more

Broken Bat Brewing Co - Sox Amber Ale - Breweries Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

First in for most, I love the "Paws on the Patio" events which are held several times a year. Dogs are welcome, and they are treated extra special. They are a craft beer/seltzer bar/brewery with a lot of character. So many beers to choose from, and the atmosphere is very charming. I highly recommend the "Ricky lager." Plenty of parking and room for large parties. Very reasonably priced. read more

I really, really wanted to like this place, but it just wasn't happening for me... THE SPACE - I will tell you that it is a cool little space - visually. Here's what's not great about it, it's really small and getting to the bar can be a challenge. The bar area is cramped, so you have to wiggly your way in for service. Patrons handing my beer back to me spilled my drinks...just great. Also, the brewery is underground - the first thing that hit me was the funky smell. Now I know that much of it was from the beer making process, but the fact that they also allow dogs into the small space really makes amplifies said funk to a musky wet dog direction. THE BEER - This is all subjective, but it was really mediocre. I can't say much about this, you either like it or you don't. I just don't. THE SERVICE - It was okay, didn't get much interaction with employees since the bar area was so cramped and no one was waiting tables. I wouldn't make it a point to come back here - there are too many great micros to experience in this town. read more

What a great brewery!! We loved all of the baseball themed beers and decor. The Harry Cherry was such a tasty fruit beer. The staff was great and friendly. It can get filled up really quick in there on a nice weekend, so try to go early! My husband tried a flight of beer and really enjoyed each one of them! Next time we are back in Milwaukee we will definitely be visiting again! The location near the heart of Milwaukee is excellent for city exploring. :) read more

Broken Bat Brewing Co - Beer menu. September 2018. - Breweries Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

I hate baseball, so this was never going to happen on my own recognizance, so thanks, Ben. I came here on a bachelor party, and what a groovy room. It's got a bit of an industrial feel with the brick walls and metal piping. The beers were great and the bartender was a pro. I can't imagine staying for even 10 minutes if it was packed or if a game was on, but on a rare Monday night bachelor party, when you know everyone there, and have full reign over the place: cool joint! read more

Excellent beer selection. Outstanding staff. Good place to have a beer and watch the game.

I visited Broken Bat for the first time on 2/11/22. I visit breweries as a hobby. The parking outside is somewhat sparse but I was lucky and caught another patron leaving. The place definitely has the industrial feel with the steel decor', but has some distinctiveness with the baseball theme. It did strike me (no pun intended) as very much like many other craft breweries I've visited with a nice variety but heavy on the trendy IPA's. My bartender was very kind and helped me pick my flight of four. Out of the four breweries I visited on this date, only Broken Bat & MobCraft provided me a free brewery sticker while the other two charged me a buck. I appreciate it more when offered freely. I thought the beers were good. None of them really jumped out as unique, but the pistachio stout was not something I've had before. Overall, I'd consider Broken Bat an essential visit for a brewery crawl in the Walker's Point area. read more

Broken Bat Brewing Co - Taproom decor. - Breweries Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

See all

Bartender was nice and conversational. Beer was okay, went with the 'Ugly Finder.' It was good, environment was chill. Giving two stars because the bartender would NOT stop with the aggressive coughing w/o wearing a mask. Why are you serving beer? GO Home, that's so nasty, selfish and senseless. Hope I don't catch COVID, maybe the dept of health needs to be involved. Shot my beer beer and skedaddled. Ugh!!! read more

A little hidden gem. They had a little street sign directing us here and it was a great place to grab a beer at the bar and rest after walking all over the third ward in the heat. I loved the theme of this brewery. Their beer was good too which I guess is the important part of this place. I had the corre corre and it was smooth. I like the hint of lime in this beer. They of course had baseball on the TV's and the atmosphere was cool. I would come back. read more

Broken Bat Brewing Co - Corre corre. Mexican lager with lime. - Breweries Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

See all

Was on a random venture from Chicago to Gary Indiana to Milwaukee all in 1 day and thought there'd be no better way to end the day with a few nice pints. Broken bat definitely sufficed for this occasion. Knowledgeable bartenders and a really solid East Coast IPA. I'm from CA and was a bit iffy on their west coast IPA. Hops were a bit off but all the other brews were solid. Cool layout on the ambiance too. I'll be back if I ever get back to good Ol' WAUKEE! read more

We really enjoyed our beers here tonight. We'd visited at the old, tiny location. They are SO friendly and happy to help you find something that works for you. Beautiful woodwork on the bar! Totally worth a visit! read more